Scottish clubs set to push for football alcohol ban lift
The moves comes after St Johnstone chairman Adam Webb branded the current legislation 'discriminatory' and 'offensive.'
St Johnstone are one of a number of clubs pursuing applications to establish pre-match fan zones next season.
And the Scottish football authorities hope the widespread implementation of controlled zones selling alcohol to fans in supervised conditions will persuade Holyrood to relax a ban introduced as a response to disorder between Rangers and Celtic fans at the 1980 Scottish Cup final.
Read more:
First Minister John Swinney recently warned that the government were 'not sympathetic' to the idea of reviewing the legislation. Privately, however, senior figures inside Hampden believe that stance could change after next year's Scottish parliamentary elections. Successful fan zones up and down the country, they believe, can hope to accelerate the process.
St Johnstone chairman Webb told Herald Sport: 'We intend to have a fan zone operating before our games and if you do that for a season and there are no reports to the police of any problems then it should be able to be expanded,.
'We need to take gradual steps and adopt a logical, rational approach instead of the current one size fits all.
'The situation is unique to Scottish football and the 'one size fits all' attitude is so unfair. It makes no sense.
'We understand that there has been violence at certain games and certain clubs and that the police probably ought to have a role in whether or how alcohol can be sold at certain games. I get that.
'But when Saints are playing clubs where there is no real history of animosity in the Championship and we still can't have an open situation where people who want to drink can have a beer then that makes no sense.
'Where there is a game where violence might be anticipated, then conditions will be placed upon alcohol sales. We understand that, but I think it's time to take it forward and review this.
'You look at other sports in Scotland enjoy carte blanche to sell alcohol, like rugby.
'That would anger me as a Scottish football fan and I would be lobbying my political parties and if they heard that from enough fans, loudly enough, then maybe the law would change and we wouldn't have to be sneaking around the edges on this.
'The ban is discriminatory, it's offensive and it makes all football fans out to be hooligans And that's just not true.
'There are clubs and games where there would be no problem at all and this law has to go.
'I'm okay with gradual change, but we can't just take no for an answer forever.'
Mindful of the divisive nature of the debate, Webb believes fan zones are a logical starting point.
'Let's make sure everyone feels comfortable about it. In the Premiership there is obviously more sensitivity and concern, but you could still have some test policies, some test program, that could be tried out over a season. New things could be tried.'
While the SPFL and SFA have continued to quietly lobby the Scottish Government on the issue, their cause was undermined by various instances of crowd disorder towards the end of the season.
Scenes in Glasgow city centre were followed by a bottle being thrown on the pitch during the Rangers-Celtic game at Ibrox, while Aberdeen defender Jack McKenzie was struck on the face by the back of a seat thrown from the stand during a game against Dundee United.
In a statement yesterday the SPFL revealed that notices of complaints have now been raised against Aberdeen, Celtic and Partick Thistle over incidents which occurred at the end of the season.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
4 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
UWS lecturers to be balloted on strike action over job cuts
The university, which has campuses in Paisley, Ayr, Dumfries, Hamilton and London, had a deficit of £14.4m in 2023/24 and is expected to post an £8.4m deficit for the current financial year. The EIS union is looking to secure a guarantee that there will be no compulsory redundancies as part of the process, with a consultative ballot showing support for strike action if that guarantee is not made. Read More: The union said it has held "unproductive discussions with university management" over the changes and the announcement of job cuts. It has now announced that its members will be balloted on a strike, opening on Monday, June 23, and to close at 12:00 PM on Tuesday, July 22. Garry Ross, EIS National Officer for Higher Education, condemned the university's approach, stating, "It is deeply regrettable that the University of the West of Scotland has chosen to make this large number of job cuts and pushed staff to the point of balloting for strike action. The proposed redundancies are a short-sighted and a damaging strategy that will have a devastating impact on the livelihoods of dedicated staff, many of whom have worked at UWS for years. "Furthermore, it will inevitably lead to a decline in the academic provision, research capacity, and overall student experience at the university. We urge UWS to step back from this path and engage meaningfully with the EIS ULA (University Lecturers Alliance) to secure a no compulsory redundancy guarantee. "The EIS ULA branch at UWS has a strong mandate from its members to move to this statutory ballot, with a previous consultative ballot showing overwhelming support for strike action if a no compulsory redundancy guarantee was not secured. "Members are resolute in their commitment to protect jobs and ensure the continued excellence of UWS as a vital institution within the Scottish higher education landscape. "The EIS ULA calls upon UWS management to reconsider its position on any planned redundancies and enter into negotiations aimed at achieving a fair and equitable resolution to their dispute that safeguards jobs and protects the future of the university. "The union remains committed to finding a negotiated settlement but is determined to win the ballot and will not hesitate to take industrial action if necessary to defend its members and the integrity of academic provision at the University of the West of Scotland." A UWS spokesperson said: "Our organisational change project is designed to put our university finances on a more sustainable footing, to enable an even better student experience and enhanced graduate outcomes. "In common with the rest of the higher education sector across the UK, the university is operating in a very challenging financial environment exacerbated by external factors that have driven a significant change in the size and shape of our student population, and the associated funding."
The Herald Scotland
5 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Naismith on Rangers' 'hostile' UCL trip and key Martin aim
A trip to face the Athens-based side was one of Naismith's most memorable as a Rangers player for all the right and wrong reasons. "That was one of the most hostile places ever," he said. "It was on the run to the UEFA Cup Final. I remember, even from the warm-up, Gate 13, where the tunnel is. That's where the Ultras are. Naively, I was laughing and joking, coming out for the warm-up. But the next minute, there were glass bottles, coins, all sorts getting launched at us. Every time you went near the tunnel, you had to sprint in and sprint out. It was really hostile, that's my biggest memory of it. The night turned out to be really good for us, with Nacho [Novo] coming on and scoring to make it 1-1. It was a brilliant environment to play in, but very hostile. Read more: "You can talk about an atmosphere but until you're in it and experience it, it's just words. When you do experience it, it's a case of what way are you going? Are you intimidated or do you think this is good? That's the real root of whether you're going to be a success at Rangers or Celtic. It's about mentality. Do you go into that environment and think I'm up for that, I like a bit of this - or do you say, don't give me the ball because I'm scared? If it's the latter, you won't be a success." In drawing Panathinaikos, Rangers missed out on facing Servette of Switzerland and Norwegian champions Brann. "When you look at the teams they could have got, it's definitely the toughest opposition," added Naismith. "On top of that, you've had a takeover, a new manager and a squad rebuild that needs to happen. But as important as Champions League and European success is, if they missed out on this one but made the next 10, that's proper success. You have to understand where Rangers are at. "It's tough for any team competing in Europe. That's the toughest part, how early it is. The Old Firm have both been put out in early rounds in the past. You can train as much as you want and have friendlies - but you can't replicate that intensity of competitive football. It's going to be really difficult." New head coach Russell Martin has yet to dip his hand in European management. His possession-based, attack-minded approach could well set the heather alight in Scotland, although in the Premier League with Southampton, it failed to bear fruit. Ange Postecoglou was criticised for his refusal to switch it up on the European scene while at Celtic and Martin might face similar reproval should he remain stubborn on the continent. Regardless, his systematic style will be beneficial for his squad, according to Naismith. "It definitely makes things easier as a player when the manager has a clear, definite way of playing. "Players want simplicity in terms of their role. The style can be complex but as long as the player can understand it simply, it makes it easier. Russ' style is one that players will enjoy. The players who will find it most challenging are defenders. Because he'll ask them to do certain things and be in certain positions that can be uncomfortable. There will be a higher risk because if you're not in the right position it can be really costly. But every other player will be rubbing their hands because it's so enjoyable. "It's the way you wanted to play football growing up. He's worked on it for five years and has been successful. At every club, he's made them a better team and improved players. The proof of that is the sale of players he's worked with. They've moved on for a profit compared to when he brought them in." As well as playing alongside Martin at Norwich City, Naismith lined up with Max Aarons, who is set to become the new gaffer's first signing, all going well. "Max has got really good attributes. He's a modern-day full-back. He's not the tallest but very comfortable on the ball, quick and dynamic both going forward and defensively. "Probably the biggest thing I remember about Max is his attitude with sport. As a young player he was so deceptive to learn and get better and be better. That's why he got into a good Norwich team in the Championship and into the Premier League and eventually Barca come and ask him for you. That tells you a lot about him. "His career has maybe stumbled recently but he's definitely somebody with a high potential. He's got good experience and he's played at a really good level against some top players. I think he'd be a good signing. I think he's somebody who would raise the quality of the squad. If we go back to the previous remit, he's probably been signing young players and developing them. I think he's somebody who comes in and challenges right away." While getting his squad in a sufficient enough state to contest crucial European qualifiers is first up on Martin's Rangers agenda, Naismith thinks getting the club back to the top of the pile in Scotland must be his overarching target. In years gone by, the Govan side's ability to stumble against Scottish Premiership cannon-fodder yet pull off shock results against European teams of a considerable pedigree has been impressive. "I think success domestically has to be the first aim," admits Naismith. "It's not as clear cut as saying it's one over the other - because Rangers can have both. "But what won't be accepted is what's happened in previous years where it's been: 'Oh we've done well in Europe but we're 10 or 15 points behind in the league'. That just won't wash. That's what has to change. Rangers have to beat the other teams in the league. If you look at the points they dropped against teams from the mid-to-low end of the table, it was unacceptable. That's how the gap goes from being four points - where there is still pressure on the team at the top - to that big a gap where it becomes easy and the team at the top can cruise."
The Herald Scotland
5 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Steven Naismith bangs drum for Shankland to Rangers move
Naismith worked with Shankland at Tynecastle and thinks he would fit seamlessly into life in Govan and could play a similar role for Russell Martin as Kris Boyd did under the great Walter Smith. "In one respect, I'm surprised [Rangers haven't made a move for Shankland]," he said. "I'm surprised because I think he's as safe a bet as you're going to get to scoring goals in Scotland. I think what goes against him is probably his mobility and people looking at him. But for me, he's a really intelligent player now. Read more: "He's a good link between midfield and attack as well as a goal scorer. The other dynamic which I think would probably come into any thought of signing him is his age. "He's somebody who's probably seen in and around his prime. I've seen it with Kris Boyd at Rangers, who was probably similar in terms of their goal return. Walter Smith never played him in Europe and never played him in Old Firms. "But Walter Smith was a manager with loads of experience and knew how to handle him. Now I'm not saying Shanks is like-for-like but those are the kind of challenges that you have to think [about]. "I know in one respect it's on a free transfer. But I'm sure Shanks will definitely have some offers because for two seasons he's been unbelievable. "He's really intelligent. Where he picks positions up, his touch. He's got a real finesse about his touch. And then he's got that calmness in the final third that makes him different. "So, I definitely think he could fit in. He fits a lot of the criteria." Shankland has scored 40 goals in his previous two seasons at Hearts. Currently out of contract, it remains to be seen where his future lies. The centre-forward is more than familiar with Rangers and having a key core of players who understand the club, its values, and the unrelenting demand for success, is crucial, according to Naismith. "If you look at the most successful Celtic and Rangers teams, they've had a core group of British players, players that have grown up with an affiliation," he added. "You cannot underestimate how valuable that is. And that's not just guys that start every week. That's guys within the squad that will do anything to be part of the squad. And they might just be coming in as squad players, but a lot of the guys grab the opportunity and take it."
