Prafull Patel questions Singapore Airlines' silence on Air India plane crash

MUMBAI: Former union civil aviation minister and NCP leader Praful Patel has criticised Singapore Airlines for its silence on the Air India Dreamliner plane crash on June 12.
In a tweet on X (formerly Twitter), Patel said that in all the sorrow and din surrounding the crash, there remains a surprising silence - or perhaps ignorance - about the role of a substantial shareholder, and the entity responsible for maintaining a large number, if not all, of Air India's wide-body aircraft. 'Guess the name: Singapore Airlines. They seem to be in hiding. Let's not forget they have a say in management and a codeshare agreement with Air India,' he said.
Patel added that importantly, Campbell Wilson, the CEO of Air India, is a nominee of Singapore Airlines. He previously served as CEO of their low-cost subsidiary, Scoot Airlines. 'Why this deafening silence?' he asked.
Soon after his remarks, Singapore Airlines came out with a statement. Its spokesperson said, 'The Singapore Airlines (SIA) Group extends our deepest condolences to the families and loved ones of everyone affected by the devastating Air India flight AI171 accident. We have been in close contact with our partner Tata Sons and Air India, and continue to offer our full support and all necessary assistance to them during this difficult time.''
Patel took to X again to respond: 'After six days, today, Singapore Airlines finally offers condolences to the victims of the Air India Boeing 787 Dreamliner crash - and says it is 'offering all assistance' to the owners of Air India, Tata Sons. Why are you paying lip service today so late? The part owner of 25.1% with board representation and the CEO as its nominee says that owners, Tata Sons, are being offered all assistance?'
Last week, Patel had said that after three-and-a-half years of the takeover of Air India by the Tatas, the management still needs to fine-tune various aspects of running a world-class airline, including maintenance.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Time of India

34 minutes ago

• Time of India

Indian aviation ecosystem under the lens: DGCA orders 'comprehensive special audit'

DGCA NEW DELHI: Jolted by the tragic crashes of Air India flight 171 and multiple helicopters in Uttrakhand within the last one month, the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) has ordered a 'comprehensive special audit' of Indian aviation ecosystem. This covers scheduled, non-scheduled, and private airlines; maintenance, repair, and overhaul (MRO) organisations; approved training organisations (ATOs); flying schools; air navigation service provider; airport operators, and ground handling agencies (GHAs). The audit will focus on 'examining the safety management systems (SMS), operational practices, and regulatory adherence across all aviation domains.' It will also audit 'supporting elements such as technology providers, emergency response systems, supply chain networks, and regulatory coordination bodies.' Air safety expert Amit Singh said: 'DGCA has been auditing aviation since time immemorial. Wouldn't it be prudent to invite a third party to audit and why (have past) DGCA audits failed to reign in safety?' Same was the reaction of several others in the industry who have seen multiple audits, enhanced surveillances in the past. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 2025 Top Trending Local Enterprise Accounting Software [Click Here] Accounting ERP Click Here Undo Also, for several years, the frail financial health of many aviation ecosystem players — specially airlines — has been a key vulnerability and the resolution for this is beyond the DGCA's scope. 'Very often in the last 2-3 decades such weak players (many of who have now shut shop) have warned authorities they will shut down if forced to dot all Is and cross all Ts which will affect connectivity,' said industry insiders. "Hopefully the recent crashes will change things." The audit order issued by DGCA chief Faiz Ahmed Kidwai says: 'Traditionally, regulatory and safety oversight functions within Indian aviation have been conducted in silos, with different directorates performing inspections and audits specific to their respective domains. These activities include planned/unplanned surveillance inspections, random spot checks and ramp inspections, which primarily assess compliance and safety within individual aviation segments. ' 'In a significant paradigm shift, the comprehensive special audit is designed to transcend existing siloed assessments by evaluating the aviation ecosystem holistically…. The goal is to generate a 360-degree evaluation of the aviation ecosystem, reflecting both its strengths and areas needing improvement. These special audits will be over and above the regulatory audits carried out as per the annual surveillance programme,' Kidwai's order says. The special audits will be conducted by multidisciplinary teams led by a senior DGCA official (DDG/director) as the lead auditor, supported by specialists from flight standards, air safety, airworthiness, airspace & air navigation services, licensing, and aerodrome standards directorates. 'Whenever necessary, external experts from industry may be included to provide specialised insights. This diverse team composition ensures a comprehensive evaluation that leverages both regulatory expertise and industry-specific knowledge, fostering credible and actionable findings,' the order says. Once the audit is over, the findings will be shared with the audited entities. They, in turn, will need to submit a corrective action plan (CAP) within 15 days. 'DGCA will monitor CAP implementation through progress reviews and verification audits, ensuring effective resolution of findings…. Non-compliance with audit findings or failure to implement CAPs may result in progressive enforcement actions, including advisory guidance, formal warnings, operational restrictions, financial penalty, suspension, or revocation of licenses… Enforcement decisions will consider public safety, compliance history, and entity cooperation, ensuring fairness and proportionality/natural justice,' the order says.

Hindustan Times

an hour ago

• Hindustan Times

DGCA threatens to suspend Air India license over 'repeated violations'

The Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) has warned that it may suspend or withdraw Air India's license after ordering the airline to remove three staffers from crucial operational roles over 'repeated and serious violations' related to pilot duty scheduling and oversight. Earlier in the day, a Delhi-bound 787-8 Dreamliner was returned to its origin Hong Kong airport after a suspected technical issue.(X/@Aviationa2z) As reported by Hindustan Times earlier, DGCA ordered an immediate removal of Choorah Singh, divisional vice president of the Integrated Operations Control Centre (IOCC); Pinky Mittal, chief manager-DOPS, crew scheduling; and Payal Arora, crew scheduling-planning from all roles related to crew scheduling and rostering. The regulatory body cited 'systemic failures in crew scheduling, compliance monitoring, and internal accountability' for its swift action. In its June 20 enforcement order, the DGCA highlighted 'systemic errors', saying, 'Of particular concern is the absence of strict disciplinary measures against key officials directly responsible for these operational lapses. These officials have been involved in serious and repeated lapses.' The regulator issued stern warning that 'any future violation of crew scheduling norms, licensing, or flight time limitations detected in any post-audit or inspection, will attract strict enforcement action, including but not limited to penalties, license suspension, or withdrawal of operator permissions as applicable.' Air India has come under growing scrutiny after the June 12 crash of its London-bound Boeing 787 Dreamliner shortly after takeoff from Ahmedabad, killing 241 of the 242 people on board and at least 30 on the ground. The Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau is probing the crash. While the DGCA did not directly link its latest enforcement action to the crash, documents seen by HT suggest that the regulator is stepping up scrutiny of the airline. Air India responds Air India said it has complied with the DGCA directive and removed the three officials named in the order 'In the interim, the company's chief operations officer will provide direct oversight to the IOCC,' the airline said in a statement. 'Air India is committed to ensuring that there is total adherence to safety protocols and standard practices.'

The Print

3 hours ago

• The Print

Kanishka bombing: Canada police finally know who 'Mr X' was but name withheld citing privacy laws

On 23 June 1985, a mid-air bomb explosion on Air India Flight 182 off the coast of Ireland left all 329 people on board dead. En route from Montreal to Mumbai via London, the aircraft had Canadian citizens of Indian origin as the majority of its passengers. On Saturday, RCMP Assistant Commissioner David Teboul, while not identifying 'Mr X', confirmed his death during an event marking 40 years since the bombing, with dozens of relatives of the victims attending the memorial. New Delhi: The Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) has finally uncovered the identity of 'Mr X', a man involved in testing a bomb in Vancouver Island only weeks before the Kanishka bombing, but has not revealed it, citing Canadian privacy laws. For the longest time during the Kanishka bombing probe, investigators kept identifying one of the men behind the testing of the bomb as 'Mr X' because they could not pin down who he was. He reportedly died not very long ago without facing any charges, according to Canadian police. The revelation comes at a time when diplomatic relations between Canada and India have shown signs of recovery. Prime Minister Narendra Modi met his Canadian counterpart, Mark Carney, on the sidelines of the G7 summit in Kananaskis, Canada earlier this month. During the summit, India and Canada 'agreed to take calibrated and constructive steps to restore stability' in their relationship, starting with the 'early return of High Commissioners' to the each other's capitals. Bilateral ties had been under strain since former Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau accused India of killing Sikh separatist Hardeep Singh Nijjar in British Columbia last year. India had rejected the accusation, calling it 'absurd'. However, soon, there was a pullback in diplomatic ties between the two countries. India then suspended visas for Canadians, and both countries expelled each other's diplomats in a tit-for-tat move. In his address at the memorial Saturday, David Teboul said that after the acquittals of key Kanishka bombing suspects in 2005, investigators had continued to work the case in the hopes of resolving 'loose ends', eventually finding out the identity of the man, who helped test the type of bomb that brought down the AI flight 40 years ago. According to the RCMP, 'Mr X' travelled to Duncan, Vancouver Island, with the Kanishka bombing mastermind, Talwinder Singh Parmar, on 4 June, 1985. The two men joined Inderjit Singh Reyat, an electrician by profession, and went deep into a wooded area to test an improvised explosive device (IED). Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) agents reportedly surveilled the trio after they heard an explosion in the area but mistakenly believed the sound to be coming from a gunshot and could not accuse the three of any wrongdoing. Inderjit Singh Reyat, the only person ever convicted in the bombing, pleaded guilty to aiding in the construction of the bomb that exploded on AI-182 but claimed that he did not know the identity of 'Mr X'. During the trial, Reyat committed perjury, which led to a longer sentence. Reyat has since served his time in prison and is now out of jail. Talwinder Singh Parmar, the alleged mastermind of the bombing and founder of the banned Babbar Khalsa separatist group, was killed in a shootout with Punjab police in 1992. During the memorial, David Teboul noted that while the investigation had continued, 'there was very little realistic chance of seeing the matter go to another trial'. He added that the Kanishka bombing had been the 'largest act of terrorism' in the history of Canada. 'So we, RCMP, have an obligation to memorialise it and pay respect every year,' Teboul told the assembled gathering. A bomb in a suitcase set off mid-air in Air India Flight 182, killing 329 people, 307 passengers and 22 crew members. On board were 268 Canadian citizens, 27 British citizens, and 4 Indian citizens. The majority were of Indian ancestry. Soon after, a second bomb on another Air India flight exploded prematurely at Tokyo's Narita airport, killing two baggage handlers. (Edited by Madhurita Goswami) Also Read: 'Air India ki flight mat lo' — how Canadian neglect led up to Kanishka bombing 38 yrs ago