Exclusive: 'Every Day Is a Fight for Survival in Gaza" says Genocide Scholar Dr. Melanie O'Brien

In an exclusive interview, Dr. Melanie O'Brien, President of the International Association of Genocide Scholars (IAGS), provides critical insights into the ongoing humanitarian crisis in Gaza and the complex legal framework surrounding genocide prevention. Dr. O'Brien emphasises that understanding genocide requires a comprehensive historical perspective. "In genocide studies, we call genocide a process, not an event, and that's why we look beyond today, beyond yesterday, going back several years to see what has happened in terms of human rights abuses, and particularly persecution and discrimination of a particular targeted group," she explains.advertisement
The legal definition of genocide centers on specific intent, which Dr. O'Brien notes creates significant challenges in prosecution. "Genocide is defined as the destruction in whole or in part of a group... carried out through one of five different crimes including killing and causing serious bodily or mental harm," she states. "The intent to destroy a particular group is what makes genocide different and also quite difficult to prove in a court of law because you have to be able to prove that the perpetrators intended to destroy that people."Regarding the current situation in Gaza, Dr. O'Brien points to several concerning patterns. "We are seeing indiscriminate bombing, long-term indiscriminate bombing that is killing people, that is destroying livelihoods, that is destroying infrastructure, that is destroying healthcare facilities and healthcare workers," she observes. She particularly highlights the strategic use of humanitarian aid as a weapon: "Denial of humanitarian aid, including food, healthcare, and medicine, is leading to a high likelihood of death. Therefore, you have to say their intent must be to kill, to destroy, at least in part, the Palestinian people of Gaza."advertisementDr. O'Brien also discusses the psychological warfare tactics employed, noting that "Israeli military open firing on people queuing for food, resulting in deaths, is designed to create fear so that people don't even want to try and get food, because that is just another situation where they risk death."The scholar acknowledges the historical context whilst maintaining legal clarity: "The genocide convention came about in part as a result of the Holocaust... The Jewish people have an existential fear that someone will destroy their people because it happened to them." However, she firmly states that "even if Israel had a right to self-defense against an armed attack from Hamas, there is certainly no justification for the commission of genocide."Dr. O'Brien criticises the international community's response, particularly highlighting how "the Security Council system, with the veto power of the permanent five members including the United States, essentially prevents any action from being taken regarding this situation." She notes that while "there are arrest warrants that the International Criminal Court has issued against Benjamin Netanyahu and the former defense minister of Israel Yav Galant, waiting for implementation," meaningful enforcement remains elusive.The human cost remains paramount in Dr. O'Brien's analysis: "On the ground in Gaza, every individual is hoping they survive each day, not knowing where their food will come from or whether they will be bombed or shot at."Must Watch

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Hindustan Times

9 minutes ago

• Hindustan Times

US cities beef up security after Trump launched airstrikes on Iran

Major US cities are tightening security after President Donald Trump unleashed airstrikes on Iran, a direct military intervention that's deepened Washington's role in Israel's war with Tehran and raised concerns about potential retaliation. In Los Angeles, mayor Karen Bass said that officials in the second largest US city are closely monitoring the situation.(AFP/ representational) Iran early Sunday warned that the US attack, dubbed 'Operation Midnight Hammer' by the Pentagon, will trigger 'everlasting consequences' and said it 'reserves all options' to respond. Police in New York, Washington, DC, and Los Angeles have since increased patrols at religious institutions, diplomatic facilities and public spaces. Officials cited no credible threats at this time but highlighted the need for vigilance. In the capital, the Metropolitan Police Department said it's closely monitoring the events in Iran and is coordinating with local, state, and federal law enforcement partners to share information and monitor intelligence. The New York Police Department said it's deployed additional officers across the city and is coordinating with the US Department of Homeland Security and other federal agencies to monitor for any potential threats. Additional resources have been allocated to religious, cultural, and diplomatic sites across the city. The Greater New York area is home to the largest Jewish population outside of Israel, with about 1.4 million people. Since 2001, the NYPD and its federal partners have disrupted about 30 plots targeting the city, the department said. Officials said those efforts reflect a broad strategy that combines intelligence gathering, overseas partnerships and rapid response capabilities — tools they're now using to assess any fallout from the US strikes on Iran. The department's Intelligence Bureau operates an international liaison program with embedded personnel in 13 countries, including in Israel, where an officer is providing real-time assessments from the region. The NYPD also maintains a Sensitive Compartmented Information Facility, where meetings can take place without fear of listening devices. Three DHS intelligence analysts are assigned to the department, facilitating the flow of classified information and supporting joint threat analyses. Additional capabilities include a foreign linguist program with more than 1,200 registered speakers across 85 languages, and the Domain Awareness System, a real-time surveillance and analytics platform developed in partnership with Microsoft. In Los Angeles, Mayor Karen Bass said that officials in the second largest US city are closely monitoring the situation. 'Out of an abundance of caution, LAPD is stepping up patrols near places of worship, community gathering spaces and other sensitive sites,' Bass said. 'We will remain vigilant.'

Time of India

16 minutes ago

• Time of India

Strait of Hormuz Closure: What is Iran's next move as regime takes final call to close Strait of Hormuz as Yemen joins Iran in war against US and Israel? See if Russia may come to Iran's aid

Yemen Announces Military Involvement Iran Responds to Airstrikes Live Events Iran Accuses US of Legal Violations Will Strait of Hormuz Close? Iran Seeks Support from Russia FAQs Yemen has declared it will support Iran in its ongoing conflict with Israel and the United States. The announcement comes after US and Israeli airstrikes on Iranian targets. The situation has raised tensions in the Middle East and prompted global General Yahya Saree, spokesperson for the Yemeni Armed Forces, announced on social media that Yemen is now part of the war against Israel and the United States. He warned foreign ships to avoid Yemen's territorial statement followed a military message from the Yemeni Armed Forces. The message condemned attacks by Israel on Gaza, Lebanon, Syria and other countries. It claimed the US was supporting Israeli military operations and creating instability in the Iranian Foreign Ministry released a statement on Sunday. It strongly criticized the US for attacking Iranian nuclear facilities. These facilities are under international inspection by the IAEA . Iran called the strikes a violation of international law and statement also noted that the attacks happened during the tenth day of Israel's offensive against Iran. Iran reported that at least 400 people have died in the conflict so said the strikes violated the United Nations Charter and Security Council Resolution 2231. This resolution supports the 2015 Iran nuclear deal. Iran demanded that the UN and IAEA act immediately. It urged the UN Security Council to hold an emergency meeting. Iran also criticized the IAEA Director General. It claimed he was not impartial and helped enable the parliament has approved a measure to close the Strait of Hormuz. However, the final decision will come from Iran's Supreme National Security Council. This waterway handles about 20% of global oil and gas traffic. A commander said the closure will happen if Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi said he would visit Russia for talks with President Vladimir Putin. He mentioned the strategic partnership between the two countries. Russia has supported Iran's nuclear program and received Iranian drones for its conflict in Ukraine. Russia has also kept ties with joined the war to support Iran and oppose US and Israeli military actions in the region after recent airstrikes escalated may close the Strait of Hormuz if necessary, but the final decision lies with its Supreme National Security Council.

Hindustan Times

29 minutes ago

• Hindustan Times

India pledges to secure fuel supply amid Middle East turmoil

Jun 22, 2025 10:32 PM IST NEW DELHI, - India will take measures to safeguard domestic fuel supplies amid rising tensions in the Middle East following U.S. and Israeli attacks on Iran's nuclear sites, oil minister Hardeep Singh Puri said on Sunday. India pledges to secure fuel supply amid Middle East turmoil India, the world's third biggest oil importer and consumer, has diversified its crude import sources over the last few years, reducing its dependence on the Strait of Hormuz. It gets less than half of its average 4.8 million barrels per day of oil imports from the Middle East. "We have been closely monitoring the evolving geopolitical situation in the Middle East since the past two weeks... we have diversified our supplies in the past few years and a large volume of our supplies do not come through the Strait of Hormuz now," Puri said on social media platform X. Investors and energy markets have been on high alert since Israel launched airstrikes across Iran on June 13, fearing disruption to oil and gas flows out of the Middle East, particularly through the Strait of Hormuz. Iran has long used the threat of closing the Strait, through which around 20% of global oil and gas demand flows, as a way to ward off Western pressure which is now at its peak after Washington carried out strikes on Iranian nuclear sites. "Our Oil Marketing Companies have supplies of several weeks and continue to receive energy supplies from several routes. We will take all necessary steps to ensure stability of supplies of fuel to our citizens," Puri said. This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.