Sanctuary by Marina Warner review – the power of stories in an age of migration
Marina Warner begins this dazzlingly protean book with a distinctly mundane memory. It is the 1950s, she is a young teen, and the highlight of her week is going to the Saturday morning 'flicks' with a neighbour's slightly older daughter. One particular movie scene has stayed with her: it involves a man dressed in a vaguely historical costume who is fleeing for his life. Face contorted with terror, he makes it as far as the door of a cathedral, whereupon he knocks loudly and cries 'Sanctuary!' The door opens a crack, the man slides inside, and the Saturday morning audience breaths a collective sigh of relief. Even if the plot points remain hazy – is Robin Hood somehow involved? – the underlying principle needs no explaining. The fugitive has invoked the ancient right by gaining entrance to a designated sacred space. As long as he stays put his pursuers can't touch him.
From these hyper-local beginnings, Warner sets out to explore and expand what 'sanctuary' means in an age when millions are on the move around the world, chased out of their homes by environmental disaster, economic collapse, war and political oppression.
It is in these grim circumstances that she proposes a new concept of sanctuary, one built not from bricks and mortar or even tents and blankets, but by tales and their telling. Over the past 50 years of her distinguished career as a cultural historian, Warner has immersed herself in liminal literature, tracing the way that fairytales, playground chants, lullabies, fables, patter and ditties manage to evade the censor, slip under the radar, and slide into conversations without attracting too much attention. Now she suggests putting these folk forms to work, using them to build bridges and forge connections between arrivants (a term she prefers to 'migrants') and their often hostile hosts.
It is at this point that sceptics might ask how Warner's proposed 'commons of wonder', filled with stories of myth and magic, can possibly help with the practical needs of displaced people more likely to be worried about clean water, healthcare, a job and, above all, the legal right to remain.
This is a challenge that she knows well and has spent her career confronting. Her earliest books on the Virgin Mary (1976), Joan of Arc (1981) and, especially, female statuary (the magnificent Monuments and Maidens, 1985), all made the case for allegorical forms having a powerful conditioning effect on the way that people understand and experience their own lives. She got critical flak for it, as well as a great deal of praise. Decades on she shows no signs of being abashed, insisting as strongly as ever that storytelling can function as a 'binding agent' between strangers, creating spaces for concepts of justice and coexistence to develop. As back-up she deploys the British anthropologist Alfred Gell's useful phrase 'art as agency' to underscore her belief that telling stories has real-world consequences.
This won't be enough to convince everyone, yet even the most literal-minded critic must admire Warner's commitment to making things happen. In 2015 she won the prestigious Holberg prize and used her £380,000 winnings to help set up Stories in Transit, a project designed to facilitate the exchange of stories between the young people, mostly men, who daily arrive in Sicily from the Middle East, the Maghreb, Bangladesh, Pakistan and the eastern Mediterranean. What might emerge, Warner wanted to know, if these travellers and their tales were encouraged to mix and mingle?
Din from Guinea, where civil strife has destroyed his family, arrived in Sicily after a two-year trek by foot across the Sahara followed by a journey across the Mediterranean in a boat. During a Stories in Transit workshop he tells a traditional tale from home called The Huntsman, the King's Son and the Enchanted Deer, a spirited mashup of politics and magic, comedy and sorrow, with one tale nestled inside another in the manner of One Thousand and One Nights. What strikes the comparatist in Warner is the way that this Guinean tale echoes animal stories from both the medieval Arab world and the even older Aesop's Fables. Still, it is not where a story has come from that concerns her so much as where it is going. Over the course of several sessions, The Huntsman, the King's Son and the Enchanted Deer develops into a promenade piece, complete with puppetry, song and animated film. From here another arrivant, this time from Gambia, takes the spirit of Din's story and turns it into something quite distinct, a comic parable with music called One for You and One for Me.
Sceptics once again might worry that this privileging of fantastical and shape-shifting narratives strikes the wrong note in a world where truth has become slippery and facts are optional. But Warner is ready for them, pointing out that the world in which the arrivants live is already fictional. Rhetorically marshalled into 'hordes' or 'swarms', these 'aliens' are routinely denigrated as 'scroungers' and even 'criminals'. The official maps that tell them where they have come from and where they should go are also imaginary, continually redrawn in the wake of colonial and nationalistic carve-ups that frequently take little account of linguistic, cultural and ethnic affinities.
There is another reason Warner feels strongly about encouraging the arrivants to play fast and loose with the materials to hand. At every stage in their hazardous journey they have been required to narrate their life stories to officials in particular ways if they are to be allowed to proceed to the next stage in their search for sanctuary. The dates must be right, the dangers consistent, and motives must be pure, involving escape from tyranny rather than desire for a better job. To deviate from the first telling of an account is to risk deportation. As a result, suggests Warner, in an exquisitely attuned reading of the situation, arrivants are sealed into versions of themselves that take no account of their changing feelings and experience. It is in this context that making up stories becomes vital in ensuring a form of survival that is as psychically healthy as it is physically safe.
Sanctuary: Ways of Telling, Ways of Dwelling by Marina Warner is published by William Collins (£22). To support the Guardian buy a copy at guardianbookshop.com. Delivery charges may apply.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
32 minutes ago
- Times
Time for change: watches that are worn anywhere but the wrist
While most watches today are worn on the wrist, originally they came in the shape of fobs — attached to a waistcoat or uniform by a chain or ribbon — or were hung on pins. Later they were put on wrist straps for convenience, a style that was common after the First World War. Now makers are relegating the telling of time to a secondary function. 'We're seeing watches evolve into expressions of personal style as consumers seek more distinctive accessories,' explains Ben Staniforth, of the pre-owned luxury timepiece retailer Watchfinder & Co. 'Worn on lapels as pendants or integrated into couture, they reflect a trend where fashion meets functionality.' This article contains affiliate links that can earn us revenue Arsham Droplet watch, £76,000, If evidence is needed that this is entering mainstream culture, the actress Jenna Ortega rocking up at A$AP Rocky's Met Gala afterparty last month with an antique men's pocket watch by Heuer (known today as Tag Heuer) from c 1914 dangling from her tuxedo bodysuit should be proof enough. And the high echelons of watchmaking have cottoned on to this trend for self-expression too. Hermès debuted its Maillon Libre brooch watch in April. This gem of a timepiece can be pinned to a lapel or sleeve, or worn around the neck with a leather cord — and is a frontrunner for design ingenuity. Despite its established place in the serious fashion sphere, Chanel also knows how to have fun with its designs. The new Kiss Me necklace appropriately takes the form of the brand's cult lipstick. If that wasn't charmant enough, it slides open to reveal a hidden watch dial. Kiss Me necklace in yellow gold, golden beryls, rhodolites, onyx and diamonds, POA, Sixtie sautoir watch in rose gold, white opals and diamonds, POA, Also restringing its pearls is Piaget, which has taken inspiration from its archival necklace watches from the Sixties: the Sixtie sautoir has a lozenge watch dial as its focal point in a masterful melding of high jewellery and horology. And Hublot's long-standing collaboration with leading artists resulted in the release of a timepiece that sent ripples through the watch world last year. Designed by the visual artist Daniel Arsham, the Droplet is tethered to a chain and cased in sapphire glass, offering a clear view of the moving mechanical parts within. This cute kidney bean of a timepiece is as far removed from your grandad's gold pocket watch as you can get. Van Cleef & Arpels is a dab hand with watches that combine complex engineering with stellar gem setting. At first glance, its padlock-shaped Cadenas might look like a heavy-duty bracelet, but take a closer look and you'll find an angled watch dial set among a dazzling mix of gold, diamonds and sapphires. Panthère hinged bangle watch in yellow gold, lacquer, onyx and diamonds, POA, Sundial watch in steel, £128, Cartier is another high jeweller and watchmaker that excels at combining precious materials with covert details. Its new Panthère has Duchess of Windsor glamour in spades with its big-cat hinged bangle: cast in solid gold and set with precious stones, it also fits in a watch dial, revealed by turning your wrist a few degrees. But the most novel creation is by the young, dynamic German brand Nomos Glashütte. Its sundial watch, which can be worn as a ring or around your neck, has a machined hole that lets a beam of sunlight fall on the engraved numbers to tell the hours. It's useless at night, but it will certainly be a talking point during working hours.
Times
32 minutes ago
- Times
Reversible jewellery: designs that dazzle front and back
'The back should look as good as the front.' That's the first lesson instilled in goldsmiths at the world's most prestigious jewellery houses. It's a natural extension then to create pieces that are entirely reversible — a welcome feat at a time when gold prices are eye-wateringly high. This article contains affiliate links that can earn us revenue Rush Hour necklace in yellow and white gold and diamond, POA, Jessica McCormack's new Rush Hour collection features a sculptural wavy torque with a diamond nestled in one of its curves. The piece can be worn with the yellow-gold side facing out or flipped to reveal the white gold, so you can match it to your outfit. Chanel's Sport collection brings the same versatility to rings that pivot from a statement round-cut diamond to a more discreet enamel design on the back. Dior too embraces the concept with the latest additions to its Rose des Vents line: bracelets and necklaces whose spinning charms reveal a diamond-centred compass rose or a gently domed gemstone in hues including delicate pink opal, vivid malachite and sky-blue turquoise. Rose des Vents earring, necklace and ring in yellow gold, pink gold, white gold, platinum, diamonds, malachite, lapis lazuli, tiger's eye, pink opal, turquoise, mother-of-pearl, onyx and red ceramic lacquer, all POA, Reversibility also takes centre stage at Pomellato in the new Pom Pom Dot collection, inspired by a vintage piece. 'The discovery of a button motif in a necklace from 1974 in our archives was the starting point,' says Pomellato's creative director, Vincenzo Castaldo. 'However, we added playfulness by creating a double-sided button. Pom Pom Dot allows the wearer to flip the button to the plain gold or gem-set side,' he adds. Pom Pom Dot comprises earrings, rings and bracelets with button-shaped pendants in malachite, turquoise, mother-of-pearl and diamonds. With a satisfying click, each piece swivels to reveal a different face in rose gold. Gouette Question Mark necklace in white gold, green tourmaline, rock crystal and diamonds, POA, In India, the belief that the back of a jewel should be as beautiful as the front is rooted in a philosophy that considers beauty and craftsmanship as pathways to spiritual completeness. This applies particularly to bridal jewellery, where the hidden decoration on the reverse is seen as a metaphor for the bride's inner beauty. Honouring this tradition, Sabyasachi's opulent necklaces — no matter how lavishly set with diamonds on the front — are enamelled on the back with motifs of lotuses, peacocks and parrots. The technique, known as meenakari, was introduced during the Mogul era and originally helped protect the metal from corrosion. Cartier Le Voyage Recommencé High Jewellery necklace in white gold, diamonds, rock crystal and coloured lacquer, POA, Cartier's historic ties to India, which have inspired some of the maison's most innovative creations — including its flamboyant Tutti Frutti style — also informed a recent high jewellery necklace with two strikingly different sides. The front embodies art deco minimalism, with a cascade of rock-crystal drops interspersed with diamonds that shimmer in luminous white. But turn the piece over and it reveals a hidden explosion of colour as saturated magenta and deep blue enamel form an abstract pattern that's totally concealed when viewed from the front. Boucheron has also added a surprise to the back of its iconic Point d'Interrogation, or Question Mark, necklace. First unveiled at the 1889 Exposition Universelle in Paris, this sinuous, clasp-free jewel, designed to be swung around the neck with a single hand, earned Frédéric Boucheron the prestigious Grand Prix. More recently the house reimagined the design with three distinctive variations, one with rubellites, another with green tourmalines and a third with deep blue tanzanites. On the reverse, each sparkles with diamonds on rock crystal. Never has the concept of 'buy one, get one free' resulted in something so stylish. Main picture: Pom Pom Dot ring in rose gold, malachite, diamonds and mother-of-pearl, £3,950,
Times
an hour ago
- Times
Look sharp — the return of jewellery pins
Male adornment is in vogue again — at recent red carpet events, pins have been spotted on many an A-list lapel. Their roots lie in the jabot pin, with which men secured a lace ruffle to the front of their shirts in the 17th and 18th centuries. During the early art deco period of the Twenties, they would be revived by jewellery houses such as Cartier, which also took inspiration from the turban pins of its newly acquired Indian royal clientele. Rock crystal, onyx and carved emerald beads characterised these creations with a decorative element set at each end. Today, the British jeweller Glenn Spiro's first unisex collection includes a series of seven pins using materials such as ebony, horn and (west African) Baoulé gold mixed with antique diamonds. Boucheron has looked to its archive for the arrow motif, whose design naturally fits a pin's construction, here morphing from brooch to single earring. And Dior has gone punk — its take comes in the form of the humble safety pin strung with charms in new iterations from the maison's Rose des Vents collection — while Chaumet's diamond-set signature bee sits at one end of a gold pin, with a single cell of honeycomb in the shape of a hexagonal diamond at the other. 1. Flèche single stud earring in white gold and diamonds, £15,300, 2. Nomoli Deco tie pin in yellow gold, diamonds and ceramic, £6,500, 3. Harlequin pin in yellow gold, silver, rubies and sapphires, £1,595, 4. Materials of the Old World Tribal brooch in yellow gold, diamond, horn and ebony, POA, 5. Tasaki x Fiona Krüger Chaos lapel pin in white gold and black South Sea pearl, £8,100, 6. Charms brooch in yellow and pink gold, diamonds and ornamental stones, £6,600, 7. Forces of Nature Fortitude lapel pin in titanium and diamonds, POA, 8. Bee My Love brooch in yellow gold and diamonds, £13,500, 9. Belle Époque stick pin in yellow gold, turquoise, pearls and rubies, £1,250, 10. Fleur de Pavot Bud brooch in gold plate and rock crystal, £280,
