German court dismisses climate case against RWE
German court dismisses climate case against RWE (Photo: AP)
In a decision that has been ten years in the making, judges in the western German city of Hamm have thrown out the case of a Peruvian farmer seeking damages from energy giant RWE for the risk of flooding connected to melting glaciers.
Delivering its verdict in the David versus Goliath case, judges said the damage to Saul Luciano Lluiya's property from a potential glacier flood was not high enough. They ruled out an appeal.
But in a legal first, the court did rule that companies can be held liable for the impacts of their emissions.
Lluiya's lawyer Roda Verheyen said that although the court had not recognised the risk to her client's home, the verdict was a "milestone" that would "give a tailwind to climate lawsuits against fossil fuel companies."
"For the first time in history, a high court in Europe has ruled that large emitters can be held responsible for the consequences of their greenhouse gas emissions," she added.
The environmental NGO Germanwatch, which has supported the plaintiff throughout the long legal proceedings, said the ruling marked "a great success."
"The court's decision, which at first glance sounds like a defeat due to the dismissal of the case, is actually a historic landmark ruling that can be invoked by those affected in many places around the world," the nonprofit said in a statement.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Lodha Élanor: 3-bed starting at ₹2.18 Cr+
LODHA® ÉLANOR
Book Now
Undo
"This is because there are very similar legal requirements in numerous other countries, such as the UK, the Netherlands, the USA and Japan."
A long road of litigation
It is almost a decade since Saul Luciano Lluiya first filed a lawsuit against German energy giant RWE, calling on the company to pay its fair share to protect his home in Peru.
Lliuya's town of Huaraz is located in the west of the country, in a valley below the Palcacocha mountain lake.
As greenhouse gas emissions have caused global temperatures to rise, glaciers in the region have been melting.
Water in the lake above Lluiya's home has increased more than fourfold since 2003 alone, leading experts to warn of an increased risk of flooding, with potentially dire consequences for the region. They say if large blocks of ice were to break off the glacier and fall into the lake, it could trigger meter-high flooding in lower-lying urban areas.
Lliuya has been suing RWE under a German neighborhood law, which works to protect residents from disturbances resulting from the actions of their neighbors — for example, from tree roots causing damage from an adjacent property. His initial lawsuit was rejected in 2015 by a court in Essen, the western German city where the energy company is headquartered.
But in 2017, a higher court in the nearby city of Hamm granted an appeal.
In March this year, judges at that court heard evidence over whether Lliuya's house was really in jeopardy and whether RWE can be held responsible.
"I feel a great responsibility," Lliuya said ahead of this year's hearings. For him, the case is about fighting climate change and the melting of glaciers and "holding those who have caused the damage to account."
The Peruvian farmer was calling on RWE to cover a pro rata percentage of the estimated costs to build flood defenses to protect the village from the rising lake water.
This would equate to around €17,000 ($19,000).
RWE, which is not active in Peru, says it has always complied with national legal regulations and has repeatedly questioned why it has been singled out.
In a statement to DW earlier this year, the multinational said "if there were such a claim under German law, every car driver could also be held liable. We consider this to be legally inadmissible and the wrong approach from a socio-political point of view."
Corporate responsibility for global emissions?
As an energy powerhouse with a history of largely using coal to generate electricity, RWE is one of Europe's biggest polluters. A 2023 analysis found the company to be responsible for just under 0.4% of global emissions — more than twice that of Greece.
In ruling the case as admissible in an earlier hearing, experts saw the court as effectively recognizing the transboundary effects of climate change — even if the damage occurs thousands of kilometers away.
"Some of the arguments made in the case are of course transferable, even if not directly applicable in any other jurisdiction," said Petra Minnerop, a professor of international law at Durham University.
"And this is what we see in litigation generally that litigants have tried to transfer the arguments and also learn from the court outcomes and then provided improved evidence and the adjusted legal argument," she added.
Could it still set a precedent?
Speaking ahead of Wednesday's decision. Noah Walker-Crawford, a research fellow at the London-based Grantham Research Institute on Climate Change and the Environment, said the case set an important precedent, adding that there were likely to be "repercussions around the world."
Since the proceedings began, Walker-Crawford says around 40 cases have sprung up challenging big companies over their responsibility for climate change in countries such as Belgium, Indonesia and the United States.
"There has been insufficient political progress on climate change over the past decades, especially at an international level and especially in terms of loss and damage, in terms of the devastating impacts that communities are facing around the world and that's why we're seeing more and more that communities are turning to the courts, really out of desperation," Walker-Crawford explained.
However, other experts doubt the impact it could have.
"It's something that will probably provide orientation for other courts or will be cited as something that's quite powerful and courageous and it could encourage other courts to follow [...]but if doesn't necessarily allow us to predict how other jurisdictions will rule on it," said Minnerop.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
With World Bk support, Jhansi set to develop into dedicated peanut cluster
1 2 Lucknow: Under the UP AGREES project, supported by the World Bank, the state govt is in the process of developing Jhansi as a dedicated peanut cluster. This initiative includes all seven districts of Bundelkhand: Jhansi, Jalaun, Lalitpur, Mahoba, Hamirpur, Banda, and Chitrakoot. The cluster-based model is expected to enhance exports and ensure better returns for farmers through improved pricing. Nationally, Gujarat leads peanut production with a 47% share, followed by Rajasthan (16%) and Tamil Nadu (10%). In UP, Bundelkhand is the primary peanut-producing region, with Jhansi at the forefront. Other key districts include Banda, Hamirpur, Mahoba, Lalitpur, Mainpuri, Hardoi, Etawah, Farrukhabad, Kannauj, Aligarh, Kasganj, Auraiya, Kanpur Dehat, Badaun, Etah, Unnao, Lucknow, Kanpur Nagar, and Shravasti. During 2013–2016, India's average yield was 1,542 kg per hectare, while UP's yield was only 809 kg per hectare—a shortfall of 733 kg. Tamil Nadu, by contrast, led with a productivity of 2,679 kg per hectare. "This gap highlighted UP's untapped potential. Through improved agricultural practices, adoption of high-yield varieties, and timely crop protection measures, UP has since raised its yield above the previous national average, currently reaching approximately 1,688 kg per hectare," a state govt spokesperson said. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Here's The Average Price of Gutter Protection For 2500 Sq Ft House LeafFilter Gutter Protection Learn More Undo To ensure fair prices and incentivize farmers, the govt is also procuring peanuts at the Minimum Support Price (MSP), currently set at Rs 6,783 per quintal. Procurement is facilitated by NAFED in districts like Mainpuri, Hardoi, and Etawah, and by NCCF in Farrukhabad, Kannauj, Aligarh, Kasganj, Auraiya, Kanpur Dehat, Badaun, Etah, Unnao, Lucknow, Kanpur Nagar, and Shravasti. Given their nutritional value, economic potential, and adaptability, peanuts have become a key focus area in UP's agricultural strategy, strengthening farmer incomes and positioning the state for greater self-reliance and export readiness. According to the ministry of agriculture and farmers welfare's directorate of economics and statistics, during 2013–2016, Uttar Pradesh accounted for just 2% of India's total peanut cultivation area, contributing approximately 1 million tonnes to the national production of around 7.9 million tonnes. But in the last seven years UP's share in peanut cultivation has more than doubled to 4.7% of the national production. Most of this growth has occurred in Bundelkhand and adjoining districts.
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
Less than 100 days to go, Kumartuli readies Durga idols for foreign shores
1 2 Kolkata: The festive fervour of Durga Puja may still be a little over three months away, but the idol makers' enclave in Kumartuli is already abuzz with activity. The artisans are racing against time, giving finishing touches to several idols — not for local pujas, but to meet the international demand. Several batches of idols have already been shipped to United States (US), the United Kingdom (UK), Canada, and Australia, among other countries where the Bengali diaspora organises Durga Puja celebrations. According to the Kumartuli Mritshilpi Sanskritik Samity, more than 200 idols have already been sent abroad this season, and dozens more are at various stages of completion. The first idol was dispatched as early as Jan this year, to Sydney. "This year, I have already dispatched five large idols to various cities in the US and the UK," said Bikash Pal, an idol maker. "It takes time to pack the idols securely and get the necessary customs clearances. The shipping itself can take weeks, so we begin much earlier," he added. Some idols are sent by air, too. Mintu Pal, another artisan, has dispatched several idols to Canada, Germany, France, Poland, and Italy. "The price starts from Rs 1 lakh . by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Florida New Policy For Senior Drivers The Quote General Learn More Undo This is excluding the expenses for packaging and travel," said Pal, who was busy giving finishing touches to an idol. Potters admit that the number of orders has increased over the past decade. "Earlier, we would only get a handful of overseas orders. Now, the international orders come months in advance," said Koushik Ghosh, who dispatched an idol to Sydney in Jan. The increasing number of orders has not only changed the production timeline but also the economic dynamics of Kumartuli. Artisans say that overseas clients are often willing to pay more as the idols have to be customised. The increased income has led to more stable employment for workers and assistants, who previously relied only on seasonal work. However, the international orders also come with specific challenges. "We have to follow strict guidelines for height, weight, and materials due to shipping constraints," explained Bikash Pal, adding that some idols need to be assembled on-site. Preparations for local pandals have also begun. Full-scale activity for Kolkata-based pujas is expected to pick up by first week of July.
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
Haryana set to emerge as a major force in logistics and supply chain: CM
1 2 3 Kurukshetra: Haryana is set to become a major force in India's logistics and supply chain sector, chief minister Nayab Singh Saini announced during the inauguration of the Inland Container Depot (ICD) and the PM Gati Shakti Cargo Terminal at Dhirpur in Kurukshetra. Describing the terminal as a transformative milestone, the CM emphasised its potential to drive prosperity among farmers, entrepreneurs, and traders while creating new employment opportunities for the youth. Highlighting the state's growing appeal for global investors, Saini lauded the Saraf Group from Dubai for investing in the region. "This investment reflects strong confidence in Haryana's pro-business environment and represents the deepening economic ties between India and the UAE," said Saini. The state-of-the-art terminal, spread across 18 acres, offers integrated facilities such as customs clearance, warehousing, and cold storage under one roof — amenities once exclusive to metros like Delhi and Mumbai. The CM said such infrastructure would significantly boost the ease of doing business and open up new avenues for investment in Haryana. The project is a key part of the PM Gati Shakti National Master Plan, aimed at building holistic infrastructure. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Perdagangkan CFD Emas dengan Broker Tepercaya IC Markets Mendaftar Undo Saini stressed that the terminal was not just a logistics hub for Haryana but also a strategic gateway benefiting neighbouring states like Punjab, Himachal Pradesh, and Uttarakhand. "This is a shining example of integrated infrastructure development and our commitment to making India a developed nation under Prime Minister Narendra Modi's vision," he said. The Saraf Group is also operating a Multimodal Logistics Park on 115 acres in Palwal, while developing a transshipment hub on 30 acres in Rewari, further reinforcing the state's growing logistics network. Saini attributed the progress to the vision of former CM Manohar Lal, who endorsed the project during a visit to Dubai. "This ICD project is a seal of approval on our simple yet powerful economic and logistics policies," he said. The CM also highlighted the role of Haryana's department of foreign cooperation, which was supporting businesses and facilitating skilled manpower for global markets. The terminal is expected to reduce logistics costs by 20-30% and significantly cut down delivery time. This will increase the credibility and global demand for Haryana's products. "As transportation, packaging, and logistics services grow, it will also generate thousands of job opportunities for our youth," Saini remarked. Calling Dhirpur depot a "Gateway to Global Trade", the CM urged the young entrepreneurs to take full advantage of this facility and contribute to making Haryana India's top export hub. The inauguration ceremony was attended by several dignitaries, including former minister Subhash Sudha, Saraf Group vice-chairman Sharafuddin Saraf, ,chairman Salah Saraf, Kurukshetra deputy commissioner Neha Singh, SP Nitish Aggarwal, and other prominent persons and officials. MSID:: 121994160 413 |
