Council fined after Christmas tree worker's fall

A council workman tasked with erecting a Christmas tree in a town's market was badly hurt when the platform he was using toppled over with him inside, a court has heard.
James Lyth, 32, was using a scissor lift to straighten the 20ft (6m) high tree in Bury, Greater Manchester, on 21 November 2022.
Bury Metropolitan Borough Council, which admitted breaching health and safety laws, was fined £200,000 at Manchester Magistrates' Court on Wednesday.
Health and Safety Executive (HSE) inspector Leanne Ratcliffe said: "It is important for industry to understand the importance of a risk assessment and training when using elevated platforms."
The court heard the tree was being installed by a council subcontractor at Bury Market in time for the town's annual festivities.
Mr Lyth suffered concussion and severe injuries to the right-hand side of his body, including bruised ribs, when the platform fell.
He needed an operation on his leg and was left using a wheelchair and crutches after also sustaining a large cut to his leg.
The accident kept Mr Lyth off work for two months and he was subsequently only initially able to return on restricted hours and duties.
The subsequent HSE investigation found the council had failed to provide Mr Lyth with any training in the safe operation of the scissor lift.
It also failed to carry out a sufficient risk assessment.
The HSE said such preparatory work would have identified the dangers involved, as well as the need to ensure appropriate training.
The council admitted breaching Section 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974.
Ms Ratcliffe said: "This was a very serious incident.
"Access to these platforms should be limited to those trained and anyone who isn't trained shouldn't be allowed to use them.
"If this sort of work is not planned and controlled to a high degree, then there is a very high likelihood of a potentially fatal fall, or one resulting in very serious injury."
Listen to the best of BBC Radio Manchester on BBC Sounds and follow BBC Manchester on Facebook, X, and Instagram, and watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer
https://www.bury.gov.uk/

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

American Press

14-06-2025

• American Press

The Informer: Five killed in 1971 blast at chemical plant

1/3 Swipe or click to see more A fallen tank lies amid PPG blast debris on Dec. 23, 1971, as workers inspect damage at the plant. Sam Guillory / American Press Archives) 2/3 Swipe or click to see more The frame of the vinyl top of this convertable stands erect after an explosion at the PPG plant rocked employee cars in an adjacent parking lot. (Sam Guillory / American Press Archives) 3/3 Swipe or click to see more A worker uses a respirator while inspecting damage to the plant. (Sam Guillory / American Press Archives) Two days before Christmas in 1971, the unthinkable happened. Four men were killed instantly and another three were badly burned after an explosion ripped through the new solvents section of the Plate Glass Industries chemical plant. The explosion occurred at about 4:30 a.m. in the perchloroethylene and trichloroethylene unit, which manufactures solvents used for dry cleaning and degreasing, according to the Dec. 23, 1971, front page of the American Press. The unit had only been in operation 'a couple of days' when the explosion occurred, plant officials told the newspaper. A large area surrounding the complex was shaken by the blast. Residents in the Westlake area reported articles knocked from their shelves. 'When the explosion occurred, a distillation tower estimated to be about 100 feet in height toppled to the ground. The unit is located on the west side of Columbia Southern Road near the main entrance to the plant,' the newspaper reported. 'Metal parts of the unit weighing a ton or more were hurled more than a hundred yards from the center of the blast. The major force of the blast appeared to be in an easterly direction, directly toward the offices and the older units located across Columbia Southern Road.' A flash fire accompanied the blast, but was contained by plant employees on site. Several cars and trucks belonging to employees of the plant were damaged or destroyed by the explosion. The parking lot was located about 100 yards northeast of the destroyed unit. 'One car apparently exploded and went up in flames after its gasoline tank was struck by the hot metal,' the newspaper reported. 'The roof of a pickup truck was smashed flat by a portion of the unit which smashed into it. Windshields and windows in the cars were shattered or broken out.' Ceiling tile from offices across the road from the plant were also heavily damaged. Metal door frames were twisted and large windows were shattered. When a headcount of employees was conducted after the explosion, it was discovered that Lowell Laughlin was unaccounted for. 'Shortly before the explosion occurred, Laughlin climbed up a ladder to close a valve on a pipe through which chlorine was flowing,' manager A.T. Raetzsch told the American Press. The explosion occurred almost simultaneously with his closing the valve. 'Technical personnel at the plant stated that this could not have caused the explosion and, on the contrary, was a beneficial act in that the chlorine flow was cut out from the explosion area,' Raetzsch said. PPG employees, Boy Scouts, classmates of Laughlin's 1957 graduating class, a U.S. Army helicopter, and officers on horseback scoured the area around the plant in search of Laughlin — who they felt may have been dazed after the blast and suffering from amnesia-like symptoms. The search went on for 15 days before Laughlin's body was discovered in a drainage line. The discovery brought the death toll from the explosion to five.

Yahoo

13-06-2025

• Yahoo

East Nashville residents frustrated by recent car burglaries

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (WKRN) — Neighbors in East Nashville said they're sick of petty crime in their community. In the last four weeks, there have been more than 80 reports of vehicle break-ins or vehicle thefts in just one portion of East Nashville, according to 'We don't feel safe. We're frustrated,' Yoko Ono said. Within the last two weeks, Ono's car was broken into twice, with the suspects breaking the same window. Parent says crosswalk at East Nashville elementary school is becoming dangerous Neighbors caught the apparent suspects on camera and agreed they looked like young adults or teenagers. 'From 11 p.m. to 3 a.m., it's their witching hour where they get to go out and get crazy because I guess there's nothing better to do in this area,' Victoria Ochoa said. According to Ochoa, community members start to see a spike in crimes like this after schools get out. 'I've lived here almost three years now. We do see an uptick during Christmas, during spring break, during Thanksgiving holiday, and especially summer,' Ochoa said. Back in January, News 2 reported on dozens of car break-ins from East Nashville to Germantown. | READ MORE | In the last four weeks, there have been 81 reports of vehicle thefts or break-ins in and around Ochoa and Ono's neighborhood. Ono said it's not only an inconvenience to get her car fixed, but it's also a cost burden: 'Filing for the insurance claim and then probably my rate will go up. I'm trying to pay off debt, I'm trying to go to Japan to see family, and it's just been really hard to make those goals happen.' Now Ochoa and Ono have home surveillance cameras set up, so they're constantly watching the video feed. 'I got cameras literally that day…I got them delivered same day; we put them in that night. I said, 'This isn't happening again,'' Ochoa said. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Yahoo

12-06-2025

• Yahoo

Apprentice had 'lucky escape' after stairwell fall

An apprentice bricklayer was "lucky to escape serious injury" after a temporary stairwell cover collapsed, a health and safety watchdog has said. Charlie, 17, was working as a contractor for Taylor Wimpey on 450 new homes in Weston-super-Mare when he fell two metres to the ground along with about 20kg of concrete in August 2023. The housebuilder has been fined £800,000 following an investigation by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE), which said the incident could have been avoided had the right steps been taken. "The failures of Taylor Wimpey resulted in a young man at the very beginning of his career being injured", said HSE inspector Derek Mclauchlan. More news stories for Somerset Listen to the latest news for Somerset "Charlie was lucky those injuries were not far more serious," he said. The teenager, from Whitchurch in Bristol, sustained injuries to his fingers, hand, wrist and shoulder after a large area covered with a timber sheet caved in, the HSE said. He had been loading concrete blocks into stacks on 22 August 2023, one of which was on or near to a temporary stairwell covering. The area was covered with a timber sheet material laid over joists, but it collapsed, causing Charlie to fall around two metres with around 20kg of concrete blocks. An investigation by the HSE found the joists under the timber sheet should have been back propped. Taylor Wimpey UK Limited was also ordered to pay £6,240 in costs and a £2,000 victim surcharge after it pleaded guilty at North Somerset Magistrates' Court to breaching section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974. "Everyone working in construction has a responsibility to ensure people are safe", Mr Mclauchlan said. "Any work involving structural stability is potentially high risk and proper planning and implementation should be given. "Lessons should be learned." Follow BBC Somerset on Facebook and X. Send your story ideas to us on email or via WhatsApp on 0800 313 4630. Pupils injured by power cables at private school Head teacher apologises after pupils hurt in crush Boarding school exposed children to radioactive gas Health and Safety Executive