Judge Blocks Emotional Distress Evidence in Blake Lively's Case Against Justin Baldoni
Blake Lively's legal battle with Justin Baldoni has taken a sharp turn, as a federal judge has now ruled that she cannot move forward with her emotional distress claims. The decision follows a back-and-forth between both parties over Lively's refusal to release medical records.
Blake Lively's legal battle with Justin Baldoni took a significant turn when a federal judge ruled that her emotional distress claims cannot proceed and barred her from presenting related evidence at trial.
On Tuesday, Judge Lewis Liman ruled that her claims related to emotional distress would not move forward, after Lively's attorneys indicated they would be dropping them. The decision came in response to a motion from Baldoni's legal team, who had pushed the court to compel Lively to release private medical records, including therapy notes.
Judge Lewis Liman denied the motion to compel those records, citing Lively's intent to withdraw the related claims. He wrote, 'The motion to compel … is denied based on Plaintiff's representation that the relevant claims will be withdrawn.' However, the judge also made it clear that if the claims aren't formally dismissed, Lively won't be allowed to submit any evidence related to emotional distress.
The judge also addressed Blake Lively's attempt to have her claims dismissed without prejudice, saying, 'Lively's request that 'because the parties have agreed to dismiss Ms. Lively's tenth and eleventh causes of action…the Court exercise its inherent authority and authority under Rule 15 to dismiss them without prejudice' is denied without prejudice to renewal.' He further instructed both parties to either jointly 'stipulate to whether dismissal is with or without prejudice,' or have Lively submit a formal motion.
Although Justin Baldoni's lawyers did not respond to the ruling, Lively's attorneys, Esra Hudson and Mike Gottlieb, issued a pointed statement. They called Baldoni's motion 'utterly pointless.' They added that while the standalone emotional distress claims are being withdrawn, Lively still plans to seek emotional distress damages through other claims in the lawsuit, such as sexual harassment and retaliation. (via Variety)
Originally reported by Disheeta Maheshwari on ComingSoon.
The post Judge Blocks Emotional Distress Evidence in Blake Lively's Case Against Justin Baldoni appeared first on Mandatory.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
American Military News
11 hours ago
- American Military News
‘Stuff of nightmares': Alleged killer stalked lawmakers, stopped at 4 homes the night of killings
Federal charges filed Monday laid out the shocking scope of Vance Boelter's alleged plans to assassinate state lawmakers before he fled the Twin Cities, evading law enforcement for 43 hours before his arrest in a field near his rural home. Boelter, 57, of Green Isle, Minn., has been charged with six federal crimes, including stalking and murder, for the killing of Rep. Melissa Hortman and her husband, Mark, and the shooting of Sen. John Hoffman and his wife, Yvette. Acting U.S. Attorney for Minnesota Joe Thompson said those charges carry the potential for a death sentence. Law enforcement officers cross a farm field after searching a wooded area near where Vance Boelter has been apprehended on Sunday, June 15, 2025. (Jeff Wheeler/The Minnesota Star Tribune/TNS) 'It is no exaggeration to say that his crimes are the stuff of nightmares,' Thompson said. The 20-page federal complaint against Boelter provided the most detail yet about what happened Saturday morning through Sunday night, including that Boelter went to the homes of four Minnesota lawmakers. He also encountered law enforcement in two cities before fleeing Brooklyn Park and setting off the largest manhunt in state history. 'This was a political assassination,' Thompson said. 'Which is not a word we use very often here in the United States, let alone here in Minnesota. It's a chilling attack on our democracy, on our way of life. It's only the most recent example of political extremism in this country, and I hope it's a wake-up call for everyone that people can disagree without being evil.' One of the previously unknown lawmakers targeted, Sen. Ann Rest, DFL-New Hope, said in a statement Monday she was informed Boelter parked near her home early Saturday. Acting U.S. Attorney Joseph H. Thompson addresses the media regarding the Federal charges against Vance Boelter, who has been taken into custody on Sunday evening, during a press conference at the United States Courthouse in Minneapolis on Monday, June 16, 2025. (Elizabeth Flores/The Minnesota Star Tribune/TNS) Boelter is now federally charged with two counts of stalking Rep. Hortman and Sen. Hoffman using interstate facilities; two counts of murder for Melissa and Mark Hortman; and two counts of using a firearm to shoot the Hortmans and Hoffmans. On top of the federal charges, Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty said she intends to pursue first-degree state murder charges against Boelter in District Court. The federal complaint says Boelter used extensive planning to surveil his potential victims, dressed as a police officer and drove a police-style SUV to the homes of Hoffman, Hortman, Rest and a fourth lawmaker from Maple Grove, who was not named, with the intent to 'inflict fear, injure, and kill members of the Minnesota state legislature and their families.' It also shows that in the wake of the killings, Boelter texted his family, 'Dad went to war last night … I don't wanna say more because I don't wanna implicate anybody.' Shortly after that his wife received a text message that read, 'Words are not going to explain how sorry I am for this situation.' At a news conference Monday, Thompson noted that the list of names of political leaders spanned several different notebooks found in multiple locations. He also dispelled the notion of any 'Unabomber-style' manifesto, referencing Ted Kaczynski. The criminal complaint says that in the notebooks were 'names, and often home addresses, of numerous Minnesota public officials' including Hortman. It included a note that Hortman was married to her 'husband Mark,' that she had two children, and that she was in her 11th term in the Legislature. Boelter used several websites to search for addresses and personal information of legislators and purchased materials from Fleet Farm to carry out the shootings, including flashlights and decals to create fake license plates that read 'POLICE.' He also wore a silicone mask throughout the night. When he arrived at the Hoffmans' house, Boelter knocked and repeatedly shouted, 'This is the police. Open the door,' according to the complaint. When the Hoffmans opened the door, Boelter shined his flashlight in their faces, and allegedly told them there had been a shooting inside the house. He asked them if there were any guns present, according the complaint, and Hoffman said their guns were locked away. Yvette eventually realized that Boelter was wearing a mask, and the couple told Boelter they knew he was not an officer. Boelter responded by saying something along the lines of: 'This is a robbery,' the complaint says. Sen. Hoffman tried to push Boelter away from the front door and Boelter then 'shot Senator Hoffman repeatedly.' Yvette Hoffman tried to shut Boelter outside by closing the door, but he then shot her multiple times, the complaint says. Boelter then went to the home of another state legislator in Maple Grove who was out of town with family. As Boelter pounded on the door, a doorbell camera caught him saying, 'This is the police. Open this door. This is the police. We have a warrant.' He then traveled to New Hope toward Rest's home. By that point, law enforcement in the Twin Cities had been alerted that there could be threats on state politicians and police were engaging in proactive investigations. A New Hope officer dispatched to a home came upon a SUV that resembled a squad car. The complaint reads that the officer approached the SUV and saw a 'bald, white male, staring straight ahead. The officer tried to speak with that man, but he continued staring straight ahead and did not respond.' Thompson said he believes Boelter was wearing the silicone mask when the New Hope officer pulled up next to him. The officer then left to continue the wellness check. When the officer returned to the area where the SUV had been parked, it was gone. 'I am so grateful for the heroic work of the New Hope Police Department and its officers. Their quick action saved my life,' Rest said Monday. 'While I am thankful the suspect has been apprehended, I grieve for the loss of Melissa Hortman and her husband, Mark, and I am praying for the recovery of John and Yvette Hoffman.' Not long after that, the complaint reads, Brooklyn Park police encountered Boelter outside the Hortmans' home. He had a flashlight raised toward the house and as police arrived he fired several shots into the home before entering and killing Melissa and Mark Hortman and shooting and gravely injuring the family dog, Gilbert. Law enforcement officials said they are still investigating whether Boelter actively shot at police. 'This happened incredibly fast,' said Drew Evans, superintendent of the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension. 'What I can tell you is the police officers that were there on the scene, that while they were assessing the situation that gunfire erupted.' Bought e-bike, car After the slayings, video footage shows Boelter returning to a north Minneapolis house. A witness said he met Boelter at a bus stop at 7 a.m. Saturday at the intersection of 48th Avenue N. and Lyndale Avenue, less than a mile to the east of Boelter's Fremont Avenue apartment. He was holding two duffel bags, and asked to buy the witness' e-bike. The man agreed, and the two boarded a bus and traveled to the witness' house, where Boelter also asked to buy the man's Buick sedan, which was later abandoned miles away from Boelter's house in Green Isle. Boelter and the man went to a U.S. Bank branch in Robbinsdale, where Boelter withdrew $2,200, emptying the account, the complaint says. He gave the man 'about $900' for the e-bike and Buick. About 2:30 a.m. Sunday, police received word about someone riding an e-bike some 2 miles northeast of his family home in Green Isle but were unable to locate him. The abandoned Buick was found near where the e-bike was sighted. Inside it, police found a handwritten letter directed to the FBI. The letter was signed 'Dr. Vance Luther Boelter,' and included him admitting to being 'the shooter at large in Minnesota,' according to the charges. After being arrested late Sunday in a field in Sibley County, Boelter was booked into the Hennepin County jail just after 1 a.m. Monday. His bail was set at $5 million, but he is now in federal custody. Two criminal hearings Boelter appeared in person in U.S. District Court in St. Paul on Monday afternoon wearing a standard orange jumpsuit. A federal defender was appointed for him after U.S. Magistrate Judge John Docherty said he doubts Boelter's finances could cover attorney costs given the 'severity' of his charges. Docherty asked how he pronounced his name and Boelter said it is pronounced 'Belter.' 'The 'o' is silent,' Boelter said. As Assistant U.S. Attorney Bradley Endicott read the criminal charges, Boelter looked on, responding 'yes, sir' to most questions, leaning forward to speak into a microphone and projecting his voice throughout the courtroom. He told Docherty that he understands the charges against him and has read the criminal complaint. He said he owns his home and works part time, making 'maybe $540 per week,' and has an estimated $20,000 to $30,000 in his bank account. His next hearing was set for June 27. Boelter was initially charged by the Hennepin County Attorney's Office with two counts of second-degree murder and two counts of attempted second-degree murder. Assistant Hennepin County Attorney Judith Cole handled the bail review for the state charges and Judge Juan Hoyos granted a bench warrant with $5 million bail. No court date has been set for his next state appearance. Moriarty noted earlier in the day that a conviction on a first-degree murder charge in Minnesota carries a sentence of life in prison without parole. 'It is a frightening time we are living in,' Moriarty said. 'We will seek justice and accountability for the victims of all these heinous crimes. We cannot continue this way.' ___ © 2025 The Minnesota Star Tribune. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
Elle
12 hours ago
- Elle
Will There Be a ‘We Were Liars' Season 2?
Season 1 of We Were Liars, based on the E. Lockhart novel of the same name, just wrapped. The YA bestseller was adapted for screen by showrunners Julie Plec and Carina Adly MacKenzie into eight episodes, and the season finale seemed to be setting up more intrigue ahead. So, will there be a season 2? Here's what we know so far. Not yet. The second season just finished airing, and it may take a while for Prime Video to decide to renew. Plec and MacKenzie told The Wrap that they've had 'endless conversations' with the streamer on the topic. 'They are very supportive and just waiting on whatever data it is these algorithmic creators need to have before they write big check, so we're looking forward to the data working in our favor,' Plec said. 'We are, as usual, at the mercy of the robots,' MacKenzie added. While talking to Variety, MacKenzie said, 'The great thing about this show is that the first season has a satisfying, powerful ending. So I want people who generally don't tune in to the first season because they're afraid it's going to get canceled, to know that they're safe to watch this show, and if it doesn't get a second season, you've still got a whole story. But also, Emily wrote three books and we love this world. We love our cast. We'd love the opportunity that exists for more story, so we're hopeful that we'll get to come back and do more. But also, should this be a limited series, I think it's a beautiful story.' The show follows the teen members of the wealthy and elite Sinclair family, Cadence, Johnny, Mirren, and their friend Gat, across two summers. The first summer involves traumatic loss and the second summer sees Cadence dealing with the loss of her siblings and their ghosts' struggles to move on to the other side. Johnny ends the season still earthbound and seemingly tied to his mother, Carrie. That means a second season could center around their relationship and the older Sinclairs. In an interview with The Wrap, Julie Plec shared, 'The best gift that Emily Lockhart gave us as we were sitting down to write We Were Liars was she published Family of Liars, which was a prequel about the Sinclair sisters when they were teenagers. The book opens with Carrie telling the story of a very dark time and a very bad summer to her dead son.' 'We just wanted the audience to know that there's still more story to tell, and we're really looking forward to the opportunity to be able to do it,' she added. It's unclear if the released spirits would return, but season 1 starred Emily Alyn Lind, Esther McGregor, Joseph Zada, Shubham Maheshwari, and Mamie Gummer. This post will be updated.
San Francisco Chronicle
14 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
‘Your client does not own this concept': Bay Area filmmaker fires back at plagiarism accusations
With the high-stakes release of the horror film 'Together' looming, lawyers representing Bay Area filmmaker and actor Dave Franco and his wife and co-star Alison Brie are hitting back against a copyright infringement lawsuit over their buzzy Sundance Film Festival favorite. According to a letter sent to lawyers representing the production company of 'Better Half,' a 2023 film written and directed by Patrick Henry Phelan, attorney Nicolas Jampol asserts that 'Together,' written and directed by Michael Shanks and starring Brie and Franco, is 'not remotely similar.' Both films are about a couple who hook up then become fused together, though 'Better Half' is a romantic comedy, and 'Together,' due for release on July 30, is a body horror film. 'Your client does not own this concept,' Jampol wrote in the May 21 letter, which was obtained by Variety. 'Neither do our clients. It is an unprotectable idea, one that predates all of our clients and has been explored in many films, television shows and other fictional works.' The suit, filed May 13 in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles, called 'Together' a 'blatant rip-off' of 'Better Half,' complete with a Spice Girls reference and a 'near verbatim' reference to Plato's 'Symposium.' In addition, the plaintiff, StudioFest, alleges that the casting director of 'Better Half' sent the script to Franco and Brie's agents at WME in August 2020 with an offer to star, but were turned down. But in the letter, Jampol noted that Shanks registered a completed draft with the Writers Guild of America in 2019. He also wrote that the reference to the Spice Girls song '2 Become 1' was not surprising, and that the coincidence is unprotectable. In a response to Jampol's letter on Monday, June 9, plaintiffs' attorney Daniel Miller, said that defense 'borders on the ridiculous.' Aside from Franco and Brie, who is also a producer on the project, defendants listed in the suit include Shanks, William Morris Endeavor Entertainment — which represents Franco and Brie — and Neon, the distributor which acquired 'Together' for $17 million out of Sundance. Franco, 39, is the brother of actor James Franco and is an alum of Palo Alto High School. He married Brie, 42, in 2017, and they have co-starred in four movies.
