Caste census without economic indicators is of little value, says Congress leader Sachin Pilot
Though the Socio-Economic and Education Survey was carried out in the previous term of Siddaramaiah as the CM, its findings were never officially released. However, earlier this year, certain portions of the report were leaked, triggering protests by Vokkaligas and Lingayats.
The party's articulation of this position comes at a time when its Karnataka unit is under pressure from the politically dominant Vokkaliga and Lingayat communities, who are upset over being 'undercounted' in a survey commissioned by Chief Minister Siddaramaiah in 2015.
New Delhi: The Congress Tuesday said a caste census that merely records caste identities would hold little value, stressing that the exercise should aim to assess people's living standards and the impact of government welfare schemes on their lives.
A cornered Congress has attempted to wriggle out of the situation by ordering a re-enumeration of castes in Karnataka within the next three months. And, that is why its latest underlining that a caste census must go beyond enumeration of caste identities is significant.
'The objective of the exercise is not just to get the name and the caste of a person, that I don't think has that much value. The real value is that you understand in what condition they are living, how successful the schemes have been so far, are the targeted budgets and policy programmes reaching the ones that we are intending for,' Congress general secretary Sachin Pilot said at a press conference at the party's new headquarters in Delhi's Kotla Marg.
The former Rajasthan deputy chief minister said Rahul Gandhi's pitch for a nation-wide caste census was always about carrying out an 'x-ray' of the country, rather than simply counting castes.
'When we said, we wanted a caste census, the objective was to know exactly in what conditions people of India are living, those who are being deprived, who are not in the mainstream, how much have they got education, how much access they have to government schemes and policy programs, in what economic condition are they living, what is an expanding, household incomes, all that is required for us to do better policy combination,' he said..
The idea, he added, is not just to collect data of an individual's caste or a household's caste.
'The objective is to know exactly in what condition these families are living and how we can better curate our policies to substantially help the livelihood of those people. Unless we have tangible data, no state government and no central government can actually do targeted interventions and that is what we wanted to do.'
On 30 April, the Centre had announced that caste enumeration would be included in the next population census. And on Monday, the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) issued a notification saying that the next census will be held in 2027.
While the Congress has questioned the absence of the term census in the notification, the Centre has dismissed the contention, pointing out that the MHA has already announced in multiple press statements that caste will be counted as part of the next exercise.
Pilot highlighted the issue even on Tuesday, adding that the allocation of Rs 570 crore for conducting census in the annual budget also raises questions on the Centre's intentions.
'Given the BJP government's track record of backtracking, use of distraction tactics in times of its failures and its affinity to hypocrisy, we won't be surprised if it quietly shelves the caste census once again. Also, while the census would cost about Rs 8,000 to Rs 10,000 crore, the government had allocated a meagre Rs 570 crore for the purpose, which clearly shows its intentions,' he alleged.
(Edited by Tony Rai)
Also Read: Manish Tewari on Congress's Narender Surrender jibe—'nature of politics, back-channel talks nothing new'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Indian Express
37 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
Replace India's national flag with a saffron flag: Veteran BJP leader N Sivarajan
PALAKKAD: Inviting widespread outrage, likely to escalate political debate in days to come, veteran BJP leader and former National Council member N Sivarajan made a controversial call to replace India's national flag with a saffron flag. The incident occurred during a public protest organised by the BJP at the Anchuvilakku Junction in Palakkad, where the party accused both the LDF and UDF of insulting 'Bharat Mata'. During the protest, Sivarajan, who is the BJP sitting councillor in Palakkad municipality, stated that political parties should be prohibited from using flags resembling the national tricolour. Targeting the Congress and NCP, he further said they should adopt distinct flags -- suggesting that the Congress would use a green flag. Sivarajan went on to say that Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi, who he alleged were ignorant of Indian history, could instead fly the Italian flag.
New Indian Express
37 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
'Power over principles will backfire,' warns ex-Gujarat minister Nanubhai as he slams BJP's changing culture
AHMEDABAD: Former Education Minister Nanubhai Vanani has launched a sharp attack on the BJP's internal culture, warning that 'gaining power by sidelining principles' could backfire. Despite the BJP's record-breaking win in the 2022 Gujarat Assembly elections with 156 seats and its grip over all 8 municipal corporations, Vanani has raised alarm. In a strongly worded letter, he questioned the means by which the party is securing power, saying people should not feel cheated after three decades of loyalty. His statement strikes at the heart of BJP's current political strategy in Gujarat. In a scathing seven-page letter titled 'The Very Formula That Led to Congress's Downfall Now Threatens the BJP Too,' Nanubhai Vanani delivers a blistering critique of his own party, warning that the BJP is treading the same self-destructive path once taken by the Congress. Senior BJP leader and former Education Minister Nanubhai Vanani has accused his own party of abandoning its ideological core in blind pursuit of power. 'The entire culture of the Bharatiya Janata Party has changed,' Vanani wrote, warning that the party is now driven by a ruthless mantra: "Jo Jeeta Wahi Sikandar." But, he asks, 'Where have these Sikandars come from? What's their ideology, what's their morality—does anyone even care anymore?' Vanani claims that the BJP is recruiting leaders with no connection to its values, thereby eroding its foundational ideology. 'This reckless induction is not just weakening us—it's destroying the very spirit that built this party,' he warned. He added that the BJP's growing tilt toward power-centric ideology is not only dangerous but suicidal. 'Power means nothing if it's gained by dumping principles. True power lies in winning with principles at the core,' he emphasized.
The Print
an hour ago
- The Print
Hope Israel, Iran stop attacking each other soon: Omar
Wondering on what basis Israel attacked Iran, he said, 'A few days ago, the US intelligence in-charge said before the Senate and Congress that Iran is not closer to getting a nuclear weapon. So, if America felt that a few days ago, then why did Israel attack Iran?' 'It is obvious that there is some politics behind it but we hope that this cycle stops sooner and the issues are resolved through dialogue,' he added. 'We can only hope and pray that the war stops. The situation is bad. This should not have happened,' Abdullah told reporters in central Kashmir's Ganderbal, his assembly constituency. Srinagar, Jun 21 (PTI) Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Omar Abdullah on Saturday expressed hope that Israel and Iran will soon stop attacking each other and resolve their issues through dialogue. Abdullah visited many areas in his assembly constituency and said it was his duty as the local MLA. 'The people of Ganderbal have sent me to represent them and serve them and I will try my best to meet their expectations. So, since I became the MLA, we have hastened the development progress here. 'Today, I inaugurated one project, a marriage hall and laid the foundation stone of a bridge, which was an old demand,' he said. Abdullah said when he sought votes from the people of Ganderbal, he had told them that he would serve them as an MLA and address their issues. 'I had told them I will not remain away for five years after taking their votes. Despite having the responsibility of the whole J-K, I have never forgotten that the people of Ganderbal did me a huge favour by electing me from here and that is why I did not leave this seat,' he said. Abdullah won the assembly polls from two seats - Ganderbal and Budgam. He vacated Budgam after being sworn-in as the chief minister. Asked about the upcoming annual Amarnath yatra, Abdullah said he was hopeful that yatris will come in large numbers to visit the Amarnath cave shrine. 'We hope they return safely as well. The responsibility of their security lies with the LG and Raj Bhavan, and I hope all the measure will be taken for their safety and security. Rest of the responsibilities - be it medical or infrastructure - we have fulfilled those,' he added. PTI SSB ZMN This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
