North Sea collision: foul play, technical fault or human error?
The collision between two large shipping vessels in the North Sea raises significant questions about how such an event could occur – and what its effect might be. Here we set out what we know so far.
A US-chartered oil tanker, Stena Immaculate, was anchored in the North Sea about 13 miles off the coast of Yorkshire, when it was struck by a container ship, the Solong, just before 10am UK time on Monday.
The Solong was travelling at a speed of 16 knots when it collided with the tanker, causing a 'massive fireball' as both vessels scrambled to evacuate.
The Stena Immaculate was carrying 220,000 barrels of jet fuel in 16 segregated cargo tanks, according to the US maritime firm Crowley, which manages the tanker. At least one cargo tank carrying Jet A-1 fuel was ruptured and leaked into the North Sea, it said.
The Solong was initially reported to have been carrying containers of the highly toxic chemical sodium cyanide – but the vessel's owner, the German firm Ernst Russ, later said none of the toxin was on board.
The Solong's master, a 59-year-old Russian national, was arrested on Tuesday on suspicion of gross negligence manslaughter, as Humberside police began a criminal investigation. His nationality was confirmed by Ernst Russ, which said the Solong's crew were a mix of Russians and Filipinos.
The main focus of the investigations is how two modern ships, fitted with advanced radar technology, could collide in seemingly calm weather conditions.
A White House official reportedly told a US news outlet that it was unable to rule out foul play, amplifying speculation that the Stena Immaculate may have been targeted deliberately as it was carrying cargo for the US military.
This theory was downplayed by the UK on Tuesday, as initial investigations have found no evidence to suggest such a motive. The UK transport minister Mike Kane told MPs it was clear 'something did go terribly wrong' but added: 'Whether there was a foul play I think is speculation. There is no evidence to suggest that at the moment.'
Maritime traffic data showed the Solong travelling directly towards the Stena Immaculate without changing course before the vessels collided.
Andy Teasdale, a marine safety adviser to the Institute of Marine Engineering, Science and Technology, said the tracking data showed 'something was potentially amiss' on the Solong, which was sailing under a Portuguese flag.
Central to understanding this would be recovering the voyage data recorders from both vessels. Often referred to as the shipping equivalent of an aeroplane's 'black box', VDRs hold data on a vessel's speed, depth under keel, radio communications, bridge audio and radar data.
Teasdale said all those rescued would be interviewed and given precautionary drug and alcohol tests.
Dr Seyedvahid Vakili, of the University of Southampton, said at this stage it was 'difficult to determine the main cause of the collision' but that in most cases 'human factors play a significant role'.
Jin Wang, a professor of marine technology at Liverpool John Moores University, said human error was likely to have 'played a significant role', adding: 'It seems improbable that all of the factors leading to the collision of this nature could have occurred simultaneously without human error.'
One theory is that the Stena Immaculate may have been 'radar silent' at the time for security reasons given its sensitive cargo, said Tiago Alves, a professor at Cardiff University's School of Earth and Environmental Sciences.
This would have made it undetectable on the screens of nearby vessels, which may not have triggered the appropriate alarms on the Solong. However, it would have been visible to the naked eye from a distance.
Alves said: 'The oil tanker was seemingly under a military mission and might have been found, unexpectedly, anchored in an area that is not common for ships to moor. The tanker is now visible on vesselfinder.com [a ship tracking website], but it may have also been radar silent at the time of the collision for security reasons. Only a thorough investigation will reach a final conclusion on what happened.'
Another theory is that the Solong's autopilot function failed. Martyn Boyers, the chief executive of the port of Grimsby East, near the site of the collision, said he suspected the Solong had been on autopilot: 'If it's been put on autopilot and there's no one on the bridge, which could happen, then it'd just go straight on.'
Jet fuels are toxic to marine life, said the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration: 'Aquatic organisms that come in direct contact with naturally dispersed and entrained jet fuel in the water column may be killed.'
However, experts were optimistic that the highly volatile fuel spilled on Monday would have burned or evaporated quickly. Bacteria may also degrade the relatively small hydrocarbons found in the fuel, according to Mark Sephton, professor of organic geochemistry at Imperial College London.
The thicker bunker oil used to power the ships could be more problematic. Persistent oils such as marine diesel can smother marine habitats, affecting the ability of wildlife to regulate their body temperature, which could kill them, said Dr Alex Lukyanov, of the University of Reading.
The ships collided just east of the Yorkshire coast and Humber estuary, an ecosystem of 'immense biological, cultural and economic importance' said Dr Tom Webb, a lecturer in marine ecology at the University of Sheffield.
'Wading birds and waterfowl gather in large numbers as they move between wintering and breeding grounds, while soon Yorkshire's iconic seabirds will be coming inshore to breed at sites like the world famous Brampton cliffs,' Webb said.
Marine protected areas on the coast close to the collision site include Flamborough Head and Holderness offshore marine conservation zone – rich habitats supporting marine wildlife, including fish, bivalves, crabs and birds. Farther out to sea is the Southern North Sea special area of conservation, important for harbour porpoises.
Dr Leslie Mabon, a senior lecturer in environmental systems at the Open University, said: 'It's close to nesting season, so puffins, gannets, kittiwakes among others could be flying around the area and could be exposed to oil or petrol. Similarly, there are dolphins and seals.
'This is also a rich fishing environment, with the Grimsby fishing port nearby, and there could be economic consequences if fishing has to be stopped or scaled back.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
4 hours ago
- The Guardian
Blasts heard in Isfahan as US strikes Iranian nuclear sites
Blasts were heard in Isfahan after the US said it bombed three Iranian nuclear facilities at Fordow, Natanz and Isfahan. Explosions in the direction of the Isfahan site could be heard in a social media video, with at least one fiery ball illuminating the night sky as smoke rose into the air
Daily Mirror
12 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Disturbing text sent by former Olympic athlete before he hid her body underwater
Kathleen McLean was keen to give her marriage another try, but there was a final argument with Ingolf Tuerk that would seal her fate underwater, weighed down with rocks in her pocket After finding love later in life, Kathleen McLean and Dr Ingolf Tuerk were newlyweds living in a $2.4 million home in Dover, Massachusetts, with some of their children. The couple had met on an online dating app in November 2017 and had married two years later at a drive-thru wedding chapel in Las Vegas. Tuerk was a renowned urologist who specialised in robotic surgery. He was chief of urology at St Elizabeth's Medical Center and highly respected in his field. German born Tuerk, who had the nickname Harry, was charismatic and would turn up to work on his Harley-Davidson. He was also competitive and had once been a member of the East German Olympic decathlon team in the 1980s, but he quit in favour of studying medicine at university. Kathleen, 45, was Tuerk's third wife and they both had children from previous relationships – Tuerk had two and Kathleen had three. Kathleen ran Birch Tree Energy and Healing, an alternative healing service, and was passionate about helping people. Couple in crisis By 2020, the couple were already in crisis. Tuerk's career was in chaos after he was accused of falsely billing the government for surgeries that never happened. He agreed to pay £150,000 as part of a settlement and stopped working at the hospital. Tuerk and Kathleen's marriage was also strained. A few weeks after their Vegas wedding, Tuerk had gone to see a divorce lawyer, seemingly regretting their decision to marry. He would later say he was drunk and didn't really remember the wedding. When Kathleen found out from seeing it on his phone, she was devastated. They were having arguments and the arguments were escalating. In February, Kathleen went to the police and asked for a restraining order. She claimed that Tuerk was physically abusive and she'd grown afraid of him. There had been an incident when she was working on a school project with her daughter and Tuerk had started an argument. He'd allegedly said, 'I'm the f*****g king of this castle – you are only a guest,' before leaning in to cut off a piece of her hair. As she'd reached up to try to stop him, the scissors cut her hand. Kathleen started divorce proceedings and Tuerk was forced to move out of the house. But by May, to everyone's surprise, he had moved back in and Kathleen asked for the restraining order to be lifted. They were going to give their marriage another chance. They even arranged a prenuptial agreement that put Kathleen's name on the deeds of the house. Four days after moving back in, on 14 May, the couple had an evening meal with Kathleen's children and shared some drinks, but in the morning, Kathleen and Tuerk had gone. Soon the police were being contacted. Kathleen's ex – the father of her children –said she was missing. A friend of Tuerk also called the police to say that Tuerk had sent him a disturbing text the evening before that said, 'I am sorry brother, but she is a vindictive devil. She played us all. I am really sorry brother, but she manipulated us all. Love you, Harry.' Investigators tracked Tuerk down to a local hotel where he had self-inflicted wounds to his wrists. There was a syringe in the room so they administered Narcanto reverse the effects of any suspected overdose. After a check at the hospital, Tuerk confessed that he had 'gone too far' and that Kathleen was dead. Tuerk directed the police to a local pond, where they found Kathleen's body in the water, weighed down with rocks in her trousers. Tuerk said he had killed her in self-defence during a drunken argument after she'd attacked him. He was charged with murder but pleaded not guilty. The scandal of the surgeon's arrest spread quickly and Kathleen's death was devastating for all who knew her. The trial was scheduled four times over five years, which sparked fury among her loved ones. Finally, in April this year, Tuerk was in court facing a jury. He took the stand and wept heavily as he described what happened on the day of Kathleen's death. He said they'd been drinking and Kathleen had seen a text on his phone from another woman and had been angry. They had taken the argument upstairs so they wouldn't upset her three children. He said Kathleen had grabbed him and smashed a glass over his head, which made him 'snap' and he put his hands around her neck. 'She just flailed around,' he said. 'We fell to the floor together, in sync. When I came out of my blackout, that's where we were – she was not responsive.' Tuerk said he'd begged his wife to wake up. When she didn't, he alleged that he had put her on the bed and attempted CPR. When it hadn't worked, he put her body in the car and drove to a nearby pond. After putting her body in the water, she floated to the surface and he realised he needed to weigh her down. 'I walked through the yard and tried tolook for something that may, you know,bring her down,' he testified. He found rocks and put them in the pockets of her defence said he'd'panicked' and the death wasn't premeditated. Tuerk said he'd hidden the body because he didn't want her children to find her remains. Afterwards, he had attempted to take his own life. The defence also made claims that Kathleen had been trying to gain control of Tuerk's money and assets, and that's why she had taken him back. The prosecution agreed it had been about money – but said Tuerk had killed Kathleen because he was worried about losing his wealth and his house in his third divorce, thanks to their prenuptial agreement. All Kathleen had wanted was to give her husband one last chance and establish stability for her children. Treated like 'trash' They said that Tuerk hadn't been in danger of Kathleen and he'd disposed of her body 'like a piece of trash'. They said he hadn't snapped in the heat of the moment and instead had been 'cool, calm and collected'. If it had been an accident, why hadn't he dialled 911, they asked. Tuerk, now 63, was found not guilty of murder by the jury, but guilty of voluntary manslaughter. Kathleen's family were extremely disappointed and said they didn't feel that she had got justice – especially after waiting for five years. In May, Tuerk was sentenced. Kathleen's family said the way she had been described in court was wrong. 'She was vibrant and full of life. She always had a smile, she was calm. She had more patience than anyone I know,' her sister Beth Melanson said. Kathleen's children spoke of their grief while Tuerk apologised for the pain he'd caused. He was sentenced to 12 to 16 years in prison with credit for time served.
Daily Mirror
a day ago
- Daily Mirror
Schumacher's 11-year health mystery - 'conscious moments and secret treatments'
Legendary Formula One racing driver Michael Schumacher suffered life-changing injuries during a skiing accident 11 years ago and tragically hasn't been seen since It has been more than a decade since Michael Schumacher suffered a tragic accident that changed his life forever. The Formula 1 legend hasn't been seen by the public since, and now his close friend and former boss, Flavio Briatore, has shared an emotional update on his condition. Schumacher suffered a severe brain injury after a skiing accident in December 2013 and his wife, Corrina, has kept details of his treatment incredibly private. Briatore, who brought Schumacher to Benetton and helped him win two world titles, is among the few who have visited the German since his accident. Speaking to Italian newspapers, Corriere della Serra, he said: "If I close my eyes, I see him smiling after a victory. I prefer to remember him like that rather than him just lying on a bed. Corinna [Schumacher's wife] and I talk often, though." Last year, it was reported that the family was taking action to protect Michael's privacy around his current health condition, fighting an ongoing blackmail trial involving Michael's ex-bodyguard. Markus Fritsche had been accused of attempting to extort a £12m blackmail fee from the F1 icon's family. Markus Fritsche, who worked with Schumacher until about 2021, was accused of aiding and abetting blackmail of the family, using hundreds of private photos, videos and the driver's medical notes. Fritsche had threatened to release 1,500 images, 200 videos and extensive personal medical notes about his former boss, all the information was contained on four USB sticks and two hard drives that Fritsche had taken from the Schumacher home after being told to leave their employment. He then enlisted the help of long-term friend Yilmaz Tozturkan and his IT expert son, Lins. The plot eventually fell apart and the three men have since faced punishment. In February 2025, Fritsche was sentenced to two years in jail after being convicted of attempting to blackmail. His associate Tozturkan, who is already in jail for an unrelated crime, has been given a further three years despite suggestions from the Schumacher family that he was deserving of five. Lins was handed a six-month suspended sentence. Since that fateful day in the French Alps during Christmas 2013, the Formula One legend has been under full time care with very few visits from anyone. The driver had been skiing with his family before he went off-piste and lost control. The 56-year-old hit a boulder and suffered serious damage to his head, with his helmet saving his life. Following the incident on December 29, the seven-time world champion was left fighting for his life and was placed in a medically induced coma. In April 2014, his agent revealed that he had 'conscious moments' and two months later, Schumacher was back at his Swiss home by Lake Geneva under the care of his family. But ever since, the star has hidden away from the public while health updates have been few and far between. Here, we take a look at his decade-long health battle... When the crash happened, Schumacher's helmet absorbed much of the force, but the severity of the impact cracked the shell and fractured his skull, leading to a brain injury. He was quickly transported to hospital by air ambulance and medics carried out two life-saving surgeries to reduce pressure on the brain. At the time, it was confirmed that the star was fighting for his life and was in critical condition. It wasn't until April 2014 that the family released their next statement, in which they said Schumacher had shown 'moments of consciousness and awakening'. The following summer, it was confirmed that Schumacher was out of the coma and was moved to a rehabilitation facility before returning home to his family. Late in 2014, fellow former racing driver Philippe Streiff said Michael was paralysed and used a wheelchair - although it's unclear if this is still the case. Philippe, a good friend of Michael's who also uses a wheelchair after a racing accident, said: "He is getting better but everything is relative. It's very difficult. He can't speak. "Like me, he is in a wheelchair paralysed. He has memory problems and speech problems." And ex-Ferrari boss Jean Todt said that his miraculous survival was the result of Corinna's steely determination - but that it had come at a price. He told Bild: 'I've spent a lot of time with Corinna since Michael had his serious skiing accident on December 29, 2013. She is a great woman and runs the family. She hadn't expected that. It happened suddenly and she had no choice. But she does it very well. I trust her, she trusts me. Thanks to the work of his doctors and the cooperation of Corinna, who wanted him to survive, he survived - but with consequences." The exact nature of the 'consequences' is largely unknown. Corinna has described her husband as 'different', while son Mick - who has followed in his father's footsteps into F1 - said Michael's illness means he's unable to communicate. In 2019, he was widely reported to have undergone stem cell treatment in a bid to regenerate his nervous system. Le Parisien reported he was admitted for transfusions of inflammation-reducing stem cells, and also quoted an unnamed nurse who claimed Schumacher had shown signs of recovery. "Yes he is in my service," the nurse revealed. "And I can assure you that he is conscious." However, the racer is believed to have developed muscle atrophy and osteoporosis after being bed-bound. 'Close relatives' reportedly spoke with the French magazine 'Paris Match' ahead of his 50th birthday in January 2019. The magazine quoted one as saying: "When you put him in his wheelchair facing the beautiful panorama of the mountains overlooking the lake, Michael sometimes cries." Addressing the family's new way of life, Jean Todt explained that they are living 'differently' in the wake of the accident. He told "For me, it is a privilege to be close in the family with Michael, with Corinna, with Mick and Gina. Their life changed on December 29, 2013. They have to live everything differently. The important thing is the closeness of friends. And Keep Fighting, their foundation." In September 2020, he said he had seen Michael that week, who was "fighting." Later that month it was reported that Schumacher had been spending more time in Majorca. Elisabetta Gregoraci, ex-wife of former F1 team boss Flavio Briarote, was quoted in Spanish press saying: "Michael doesn't speak, he communicates with his eyes. Only three people can visit him and I know who they are." On the Italian version of Big Brother the brunette added, in comments echoed by Spanish press: 'They moved to Spain and his wife has set up a hospital in that house.' Despite the global outpouring of grief, Corinna has sworn those around her husband to secrecy over his condition to maintain his dignity. Only those trusted have been granted access to see the star, with the house under strict security protocols. But in 2021, Corinna gave a rare insight into her husband's health on Netflix documentary SCHUMACHER, admitting she desperately longs for the partner she had before the accident. "I miss Michael every day. But it's not just me who misses him. It's the children, the family, his father, everyone around him," she said. "Everybody misses Michael, but Michael is here - different, but here. He still shows me how strong he is every day." Confirming that he lives at the family home in Switzerland, she said the fight continues to help Michael get better, but insisted she wanted to keep his trials and tribulations private. She continued: "We live together at home. We do therapy. We do everything we can to make Michael better and to make sure he's comfortable. And to simply make him feel our family, our bond. And no matter what, I will do everything I can. "We all will. We're trying to carry on as a family, the way Michael liked it and still does. And we are getting on with our lives. It's very important to me that he can continue to enjoy his private life as much as possible. Michael always protected us, and now we are protecting Michael." Since his surgeries, little to no information has been shared about the procedures the star may have had. His son, Mick, 23, raced for Haas before becoming a reserve for Mercedes, and has given few interviews but has said his biggest heartbreak is that he can't discuss the sport with his father. He said: "Since the accident, of course, these experiences, these moments that I believe many people have with their parents, are no longer present or to a lesser extent. And in my view, that is a little unfair. "I think me and dad, we would understand each other in a different way now. Simply because we speak a similar language – the language of motor sport – and that we would have a lot more to talk about. And that is where my head is most of the time. Thinking that would be so cool… I would give up everything just for that." Meanwhile, it was reported that Schumacher's family were planning to start a 'new life' in Majorca in a £27 million villa which will be used over winter, according to German magazine Die Bunte. Schumacher and wife Corinna's new pad is said to have been previously owned by Real Madrid boss Florentino Perez. The property - which provides beautiful sea views down the Majorcan coast - is kitted out with two luxurious swimming pools, as well as a helipad and all the medical facilities needed for his recovery. As well as the villa, the Schumachers are said to have also purchased the surrounding land - which currently houses olive trees and dilapidated buildings. The land is reported to have cost an eye-watering £2.3 million. However if the first decade is anything to go by, fans are unlikely to know much about Schumacher's whereabouts or evolving health in the upcoming years. In November, the family's lawyer, Felix Damm, explained why his close circle have chosen to remain silent on the matter. "It has always been a matter of protecting private information," he reportedly told the Mail. "We also considered whether a final announcement about Michael's state of health could be the right way to go about it. But that wouldn't have been the end of it and there would have had to be permanently updated 'water level reports," he explained. Although his close friend Todt has shared a glimmer of hope, adding: "I hope the world will be able to see him again. That is what he and his family are working towards."
