Giles Martin on AI plans: 'It's like saying you can burgle my house unless I ask you not to'

Giles Martin on AI plans: 'It's like saying you can burgle my house unless I ask you not to'
Producer Giles Martin has said plans to allow AI firms to use artists' work without permission, unless creators opt out, is like criminals being given free rein to burgle houses unless they are specifically told not to.
Martin, who is the son of Beatles producer George Martin and worked with Sir Paul McCartney on the Get Back documentary series and the 2023 Beatles track Now And Then, spoke to Sky News at a UK Music protest at Westminster coinciding with a parliamentary debate on the issue.
Under the plans, an exemption to copyright would be created for training artificial intelligence (AI), so tech firms would not need a licence to use copyrighted material - rather, creators would need to opt out to prevent their work from being used.
Creatives say if anything it should be opt-in rather than out, and are calling on the government to scrap the proposals and stop AI developers "stealing" their work "without payment or permission".
ADVERTISEMENT
"If you create something unique it should be unique to you," says Martin. "It shouldn't be able to be harvested and then used by other people. Or if it is, it should be with your permission... it shouldn't be up to governments or big tech."
Sir Elton John and Simon Cowell are among the celebrities who have backed a campaign opposing the proposals, and Sir Paul has also spoken out against them.
"This is about young artists," says Martin. "If a young Paul McCartney at the age of 20 or 22 wrote Yesterday, now... big tech would almost be able to harvest that song and use it for their own means. It doesn't make any sense, this ruling of opting out - where essentially it's like saying, 'you can burgle my house unless I ask you not to'."
'I'm not anti-AI - it's a question of permission'
The Beatles' track Now And Then was written and recorded by John Lennon in New York in the late 1970s, and AI was used to extract his vocals for the 2023 release. The Get Back documentary also used audio restoration technology, allowing music and vocals to be isolated.
ADVERTISEMENT
"I'm not anti [AI], I'm not saying we should go back to writing on scribes," Martin said. "But I do think that it's a question of artist's permission."
Using AI to "excavate" Lennon's voice was with the permission of the late singer's estate, he said, and is "different from me getting a 3D printer to make a John Lennon".
He added: "The idea of, for example, whoever your favourite artist is - the future is, you get home from work and they'll sing you a song, especially designed for you, by that artist, by that voice. And it'll make you feel better because AI will know how you're feeling at that time. That's maybe a reality. Whoever that artist is, they should probably have a say in that voice."
Read more:
Authors 'absolutely sick' to discover books in 'shadow library'
AI tool could be game-changer in battle against Alzheimer's
Crispin Hunt, of 1990s band The Longpigs, who also attended the protest, said "all technology needs some kind of oversight".
ADVERTISEMENT
"If you remove the ability for the world to make a living out of creativity, or if you devalue creativity to such an extent that that it becomes a hobby and worthless to do, then humanity in life will be far less rich because it's art and culture that makes life richer," he said. "And that's why the companies want it for free."
The Data (Use and Access) Bill primarily covers data-sharing agreements, but transparency safeguards were removed at committee stage.
Critics say changes need to be made to ensure that companies training generative AI models disclose whether work by a human creator has been used and protect creatives under existing copyright rules.
In February, more than 1,000 artists and musicians including Kate Bush, Damon Albarn, Sam Fender and Annie Lennox released a silent album in protest at the proposed changes.
At that time, a government spokesperson said the UK's current rules were "holding back the creative industries, media and AI sector from realising their full potential - and that cannot continue".
The spokesperson said they were consulting on proposals that better protect the "interests of both AI developers and right holders" and to deliver a solution "which allows both to thrive".

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Yahoo

an hour ago

• Yahoo

Google AI is worse at Pokemon than I was when I was 5 – taking 800 hours to beat the Elite 4 and having a breakdown when its HP got low

When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission. If you're someone who thinks AI is almost ready to take over the world, I have some good or bad (depending on your stance on things) news for you: Google's Gemini 2.5 Pro took over 800 hours to beat the 29-year-old children's game Pokemon Blue. There's a Twitch account called Gemini_Plays_Pokemon, a pale imitation of the incredible Twitch Plays Pokemon account that started this trend. First things first: how long did it take the AI to actually complete the game? Well, it was a staggering 813 hours. I feel like you could hit buttons randomly and beat the game faster than that. After some tweaks by the creator of this Twitch channel, the AI managed to halve its time to a still outrageous 406.5 hours. That is actually dead on half the time, which is interesting mathematically but still far too long to beat a game you can win with an overleveled Venusaur. Additionally, as spotted by our friends at PC Gamer, Google DeepMind reported on the Twitch account, and something unusual happens whenever its Pokemon get low on health or power points (PP). Whenever one or both of these conditions are met, "model performance appears to correlate with a qualitatively observable degradation in the model's reasoning capability – for instance, completely forgetting to use the pathfinder tool in stretches of gameplay while this condition persists." This, combined with the AI mistakenly thinking it was playing FireRed and LeafGreen and would need to find the Tea to progress, are part of the reasons it took so long to finish. Honestly, AI just isn't very good at playing Pokemon. Someone else made Claude Plays Pokemon, and that AI spent hours trying to get out of Cerulean city because it kept jumping down a ledge to talk to an NPC it had already spoken to dozens of times. So, these AIs aren't able to beat a game that we could when we barely knew our times tables. Let's not worry about them taking our jobs any time soon. In the meantime, check out the best Pokemon games of all time.

Yahoo

9 hours ago

• Yahoo

Legendary '60s Musician Brings Out Beloved Actor for 'Beyond Awesome' Surprise Duet

Legendary '60s Musician Brings Out Beloved Actor for 'Beyond Awesome' Surprise Duet originally appeared on Parade. and just teamed up for the crossover that fans never knew they needed when the Grease alum joined the former Beatle onstage for a "beyond awesome" surprise performance. As seen in a clip uploaded to the actor's Instagram account, Travolta joined forces with Starr and his All-Starr Band to sing "With A Little Help From My Friends" during his Clearwater, Fla., concert on the evening of Saturday, June 21. Alongside the upbeat clip, Travolta included a photo with Starr backstage, with the Look Who's Talking star smiling excitedly while the musician threw a peace sign at the camera. "Ringo Starr was part of the soundtrack of my life. It meant a lot to me to sing with him and his all star band tonight," Travolta wrote of his brief time performing as part of what fans dubbed the "dream team." "Great song from The Beatles Sgt. Pepper album," he added. View this post on Instagram A post shared by John Travolta (@johntravolta) Fans were shocked by Travolta's cameo, with one jealous follower writing knowingly, "That must have been an amazing show! ❤️." "This is beyond awesome. The Dream Team! 😍❤️👏," another praised, with others gushing over the "Incredible," "So cool! 🙌❤️" and "Sensacional....👏👏👏" moment. "Billy Shears and Danny Zuko the crossover we didn't know we needed to have ❤️," one commenter said happily. "Both of you were the soundtrack of my life," another admitted. "So, so talented! ❤️." "👏👏👏What a privilege to be with him !!!" someone else surmised, adding a reference to the "Iconic music figures of a great era." "Lucky you!!!" someone else agreed, hyping up the actor living his '60s Musician Brings Out Beloved Actor for 'Beyond Awesome' Surprise Duet first appeared on Parade on Jun 22, 2025 This story was originally reported by Parade on Jun 22, 2025, where it first appeared.

Washington Post

12 hours ago

• Washington Post

AI is transforming Indian call centers. What does it mean for workers?

GURGAON, India — For three years, Kartikeya Kumar hesitated before picking up the phone, anticipating another difficult conversation with another frustrated customer. The call center agent, now 29, had tried everything to eliminate what a colleague called the 'Indian-ism' in his accent. He mimicked the dialogue from Marvel movies and belted out songs by Metallica and Pink Floyd. Relief finally arrived in the form of artificial intelligence.