Crown seeks first-degree murder conviction against Calgary man in 'grotesque' killing of woman
Slain Calgary sex-trade worker Judy Maerz fought for her life before murder suspect Christopher Ward Dunlop killed her, a prosecutor suggested Friday.
Article content
In seeking a first-degree murder conviction against Dunlop, Crown prosecutor Greg Piper said the evidence points to no other conclusion.
Article content
Article content
Piper noted Maerz had defensive wounds on her hands and arms and Dunlop likely cut himself in the brutal attack in a northeast Calgary athletic park, which he described as a 'grotesque … overkilling.'
Article content
Article content
Blood found in the snow near Maerz's torched remains, initially thought to be hers, came back first as being male and a later DNA analysis determined it was Dunlop's.
Article content
Article content
'In the attack it turned into a fight, or a struggle,' Piper told Justice Colin Feasby.
Article content
'What we're asking you to find is Ms. Maerz fought for her life and in that process Mr. Dunlop was cut.'
Article content
The prosecutor said video footage of Dunlop at a pet store the afternoon of Feb. 15, 2023, the day before Maerz's body was found in the Deerfoot Athletic Park showed his right index finger was fine.
Article content
But CCTV surveillance from the following afternoon captured Dunlop with a blood-stained wrap around that same digit, Piper said.
Article content
He told Feasby the logical inference was the blood stain found near Maerz's body was Dunlop's and it was deposited during the killing.
Article content
Dunlop, who previously served the equivalent of a 13-year sentence for manslaughter in the 2009 killing of sex-trade worker Laura Furlan, faces Feb. 16, 2023, charges of murder and causing and indignity to a body for setting the victim's remains on fire.
Article content
Article content
Piper said scratches on Dunlop's arm noted after his March 1, arrest were also consistent with the victim fighting for her life.
Article content
'Male DNA was on her fingernails,' Piper said, noting not in sufficient quantity to create a scientific profile.
Article content
Piper also said CCTV footage entered into evidence during his and co-prosecutor Hyatt Mograbee's case should lead to the conclusion Dunlop picked up Maerz on the Forest Lawn stroll on 19th Avenue S.E. in his wife's Rav4 and took her to the park off 8th Avenue N.E.
Article content
He said while surveillance evidence can have its drawbacks 'it is an objective, silent, disproportionate observer.'
Article content
Among the pieces of video evidence introduced in the case was CCTV footage from a Peter Lougheed Centre parking lot where Dunlop's wife had parked her SUV.
Article content
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
3 hours ago
- Global News
Man acquitted after B.C. judge rules he ‘likely' slashed woman but Crown couldn't prove it
A man accused of slashing a woman in the face in an apparent stranger attack in Vancouver's Downtown Eastside has been acquitted, even though the judge ruled it was 'more likely than not' that he was the accused. In a ruling delivered Thursday, Provincial Court Judge G.M. Rideout concluded that while it was possible Shone Robert Selbie was the attacker caught on CCTV, the evidence wasn't good enough to prove it beyond a reasonable doubt. 'It wasn't me,' Selbie told Global News outside the court. 'That's why the judge found me innocent.' 'I look like the person in the video,' he added. Selibe, who turns 52 this year, had been charged with a single count of aggravated assault in Aug. 11, 2024 attack in the 400 block of Cordova Street that left a woman with a serious laceration on her cheek. Story continues below advertisement 1:53 Vancouver machete attacker sentenced CCTV footage captured from two social housing buildings on the block depicts a man hunched over and swaying and holding a box cutter in his hand. In the video, he can be seen putting a woman into a headlock, appearing to slash her face, and then casually walking away. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy The case hinged on the identity of the accused, and the Crown's ability to prove it. At trial, the Crown pointed to the CCTV images themselves, along with testimony from a Vancouver police officer who had interacted with Selbie twice that summer and identified him in court from the images. At trial, prosecutors argued Selbie had a distinctive face with prominent features, including crooked and pointy nose, high cheekbones, and sunken cheeks with deep-set eyes. On the stand, the officer further testified he was '100 per cent certain' Selbie was the person depicted in the CCTV images that had been compiled into a police information bulletin. Story continues below advertisement Selbie's defence argued the CCTV footage was of average quality, and never caught a clear full facial image of the attacker. It also noted that the officer had pointed to the attacker's Nike shoes as a distinctive identifying characteristic, but had incorrectly described the logo on them as black when it was actually white. 0:54 Vancouver police safety trailer vandalized in Downtown Eastside In acquitting Selbie, Rideout agreed the CCTV footage shows someone with a pointed nose, but acknowledged it never caught a full facial view of the suspect. 'Clearly there are some physical characteristics of the suspect in the CCTV footage consistent with the accused's appearance in court,' he ruled. 'I am unable to say with any confidence that the suspect in the CCTV footage is the accused before this court.' Story continues below advertisement The identifying officer, he added, does not have any special training in identification, and 'agreed in cross-examination that some of the characteristics he identifies as distinctive to the accused can also apply to other individuals.' Rideout noticed that in the CCTV footage, the suspect had a distinctive walk, a 'physical hunch-like walk consistent with drug addicts' known in the Downtown Eastside as the 'benzo gait.' The identifying officer, he said, never noticed anything distinctive about Selbie's gait in the two interactions he had with the accused that summer. 0:30 Vancouver police officer slashed with knife in Downtown Eastside Those interactions, together, lasted for about 45 minutes — not enough for his level of familiarity with Selbie to rise to the level of being 'so well acquainted' with him to make his identification 'certain and safe,' Rideout said. 'His recognition evidence is insufficiently reliable to assist the court in identifying the accused as the suspect in the identification bulletin,' Rideout ruled. Story continues below advertisement That led the judge to conclude that while Selbie was more likely than not the attacker, the Crown hadn't met the threshold of proof beyond a reasonable doubt. 'The inherent frailties of identification evidence are well known to the law and have been the subject of frequent judicial consideration and comment,' he said, quoting a legal precedent. 'We must, however, never regard these principles as trite. They are fundamental.'
Calgary Herald
7 hours ago
- Calgary Herald
Crown seeks first-degree murder conviction against Calgary man in 'grotesque' killing of woman
Slain Calgary sex-trade worker Judy Maerz fought for her life before murder suspect Christopher Ward Dunlop killed her, a prosecutor suggested Friday. Article content In seeking a first-degree murder conviction against Dunlop, Crown prosecutor Greg Piper said the evidence points to no other conclusion. Article content Article content Piper noted Maerz had defensive wounds on her hands and arms and Dunlop likely cut himself in the brutal attack in a northeast Calgary athletic park, which he described as a 'grotesque … overkilling.' Article content Article content Blood found in the snow near Maerz's torched remains, initially thought to be hers, came back first as being male and a later DNA analysis determined it was Dunlop's. Article content Article content 'In the attack it turned into a fight, or a struggle,' Piper told Justice Colin Feasby. Article content 'What we're asking you to find is Ms. Maerz fought for her life and in that process Mr. Dunlop was cut.' Article content The prosecutor said video footage of Dunlop at a pet store the afternoon of Feb. 15, 2023, the day before Maerz's body was found in the Deerfoot Athletic Park showed his right index finger was fine. Article content But CCTV surveillance from the following afternoon captured Dunlop with a blood-stained wrap around that same digit, Piper said. Article content He told Feasby the logical inference was the blood stain found near Maerz's body was Dunlop's and it was deposited during the killing. Article content Dunlop, who previously served the equivalent of a 13-year sentence for manslaughter in the 2009 killing of sex-trade worker Laura Furlan, faces Feb. 16, 2023, charges of murder and causing and indignity to a body for setting the victim's remains on fire. Article content Article content Piper said scratches on Dunlop's arm noted after his March 1, arrest were also consistent with the victim fighting for her life. Article content 'Male DNA was on her fingernails,' Piper said, noting not in sufficient quantity to create a scientific profile. Article content Piper also said CCTV footage entered into evidence during his and co-prosecutor Hyatt Mograbee's case should lead to the conclusion Dunlop picked up Maerz on the Forest Lawn stroll on 19th Avenue S.E. in his wife's Rav4 and took her to the park off 8th Avenue N.E. Article content He said while surveillance evidence can have its drawbacks 'it is an objective, silent, disproportionate observer.' Article content Among the pieces of video evidence introduced in the case was CCTV footage from a Peter Lougheed Centre parking lot where Dunlop's wife had parked her SUV. Article content
Ottawa Citizen
10 hours ago
- Ottawa Citizen
Lam sisters called family for help amid alleged abuse before killing their mother, court hears
Article content On the day of Kieu Lam's death, her son received a call from his sisters asking for help after days of escalating abuse, only for their mother to take the daughter's phone away, a jury heard Friday. The brothers are expected to testify next week when the defence begins its case. Article content Sisters Chau Kanh Lam and Hue Ai Lam are facing first-degree murder charges in the death of their mother, Kieu Lam, on Oct. 31, 2022. Article content Article content Article content Defence lawyer Ewan Lyttle, who is representing Chau, gave his opening statements to the jury Friday morning after the Crown closed its case against the Lam sisters. Article content Article content The jury heard how Kieu gave her daughters a life devoid of love, compassion and protection. Instead, Chau and Hue's life was filled with 'control, violence and cruelty,' Lyttle said. Article content 'Kieu Lam gave life to her daughters but Kieu Lam did not give her daughters a life.' Article content On Monday, the defence will begin presenting evidence and calling up witnesses, where Chau and Hue are expected to testify through a Vietnamese interpreter. Their older brothers are also expected to testify to their mother's alleged abusive nature throughout their lives. Article content The jury heard how the brothers witnessed the alleged abuse starting in the Lam sisters' early life in Vietnam, when they were beaten with straps, and continued at their home on Bowmount Street. Article content Article content One of the brothers will say that Kieu was ashamed of her daughters for not getting married and not being able to work at times, Lyttle said. When Hue developed Parkinson's disease and was unable to work, Kieu's abuse allegedly escalated further, as Hue was the family's main source of income. Article content Article content 'They feared for their safety and had to kill their mother to end a decades-long mental and physical campaign of violence,' Lyttle said. Article content The jury heard that Kieu made the 'whole family suffer' and one of the brothers had to physically prevent their mother from attacking his sisters, Chau and Hue. Article content 'Both brothers will tell you that their mother adhered to strict old-fashioned Vietnamese rules,' Lyttle said. In the culture they were raised in, he says no child would 'ever dare fight back.'
