Scottish football needs to say no to newco and get 'robust' governance

Nor was there an outcry when it emerged the SPFL had issued a 'formal waiver' which will allow the newco to take the place of the oldco in League Two next season, albeit with a five point deduction.
It was a far cry from the outrage, anger and animosity which erupted far and wide when Rangers were forced, after HMRC were among those creditors who rejected a company voluntary arrangement, to go down the same road way back in 2012. The ill-feeling caused by that seismic event still lingers to this day.
The fact that Dumbarton are, despite their long and proud history, a part-time provincial outfit with a small fanbase who have long languished in the lower reaches of the senior league set-up is largely responsible for the lack of hysteria.
Read more:
The majority of their own supporters, who have grown increasingly concerned about the motives of their enigmatic owners Cognitive Capital in recent years, are probably firmly in favour of the drastic move.
Mario Laponte, the Canadian musician and entrepreneur who will own Dumbarton Football Club 1872 in its entirety, has publicly stated that he is not interested in using the land around the stadium for a lucrative property development. Hopes are high that 'Vintage', as he is known as a performer, will be an upgrade on what has gone before him.
Anyway, this is not the first time that Dumbarton have started again. They ceased playing in 1901 and returned to action 1905. Suggestions they were a new club were swiftly dismissed by the SFA and the Scottish Football Combination so they could be fast-tracked into their competitions. This sort of chicanery, then, has aye been.
Blair Nimmo, the experienced insolvency practitioner who was involved in the battles for survival which were waged by Airdrieonians, Hearts and Rangers during his professional career, was confident that Inverness Caledonian Thistle would bounce back in some capacity when the Highlanders went into administration in October last year.
'Virtually every club to go into administration in the past 20 years has survived in one form or another,' he said. 'Over the years, Rangers, Hibs, Hearts, Falkirk and Airdrie have all been bust. Gretna is probably the only one that didn't come back.'
(Image: Mark Scates - SNS Group) There should, however, perhaps be more concern expressed about the plight of this ancient institution than there has been. Going out of business and starting up again as an entirely new entity, as a phoenix club, should never be regarded as a convenient solution to a complex problem. Having watertight safeguards in place which ensure things don't get to that stage would be a far better plan.
That, of course, is far easier said than done. Rule 10.2, the so-called 'fit and proper' person test, in the SFA Articles of Association attempts to ensure that directors and owners are solvent, honest and competent. But there are ways to circumvent that process. Plus, perfectly reputable and well-meaning individuals can run into all kinds of issues once they become embroiled in the weird and wonderful world of soccer.
Suggestions that Scottish football should follow the lead which has been taken by England and introduce an independent regulator prompt howls of derision in boardrooms across the land whenever they are aired. Directors and chairmen feel is that it is difficult enough running a club and breaking even already without some interfering busybody poking their noses in. They want to retain control.
The cost involved in creating another level of bureaucracy also leaves many uneasy. Fraser Wishart, the chief executive of the professional footballers' union PFA Scotland, recently stressed that his organisation is against creating a regulator because it would drain the game of much-needed funds.
However, Wishart offered an important caveat to that statement. 'That's dependent on the governance model changing,' he said. Clubs governing clubs is, for him and many others, unhealthy and leads to myriad problems. There are several sensible administrators who agree and feel passionately the game in this country urgently needs to put the greater good first.
Read more:
Ian McMenemy, the former Stenhousemuir chairman who served on a number of SFA and SPFL committees, is one of them. 'We can't achieve change because of our own self-interest,' he has said. 'A regulator might be able to help us unlock that by having that independent voice that takes all that on board and allows us to get to a point that is absolutely better for us.'
Ian Maxwell, the SFA chief executive, told the health, social care and sport committee at Holyrood that governance procedures were 'robust' and 'fit for purpose' back in 2023.
Since then, both Dumbarton and Caledonian Thistle have been plunged into existential crises. The latter only came through it because of the benevolence of a wealthy local businessman who was prepared to plough in over £1m of his own personal fortune. Many other clubs teeter on the brink amid a challenging financial climate.
Whether Scotland should create an independent regulator is possibly a moot point. Maree Todd, the minister for drugs and alcohol policy and sport, refused to commit the government to creating one due to the exorbitant costs involved last year.
There have been round table discussions since. But seasoned observers of MSPs, who have been reluctant to involve themselves in the regulation of the support since the Offensive Behaviour at Football and Threatening Communications (Scotland) Act 2012 was repealed seven years ago, aren't holding their breath.
More, though, needs to be done than is currently the case or more, far more, Scottish clubs will be left staring into the abyss and facing the same difficult decision that Dumbarton have made.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The National

24 minutes ago

• The National

McCoist names the Celtic transfer that would 'hurt' Rangers

The Irish striker is out of favour at Brighton and Hove Albion after an unsuccessful loan spell at West Ham United last season. Ferguson burst onto the scene on the south coast in the 2022/23 campaign, across which he scored 10 goals in 25 games. Read more: His future is currently up in the air, and several pundits have mentioned Celtic as potential suitors. McCoist thinks Ferguson joining the Parkhead club would 'hurt' Rangers: "I'm a fan," he said [Scottish Sun]. "I want him to get fit. I really like Evan Ferguson, and I really want him to get fit and stay fit. "He can finish. Out of all the younger ones coming through, I thought Evan Ferguson was the one to watch. 'Obviously, he's got one or two injuries going on that have held him back a bit, but if he keeps himself fit, he will score goals anywhere. "The unfortunate thing for my mob [Rangers] is, he could come in and hurt us. Definitely. "It wouldn't surprise me at all. I'm a big fan." Shay Given, who spent time at Celtic as a teenager, thinks the striker would be a 'perfect' fit for the Scottish Premiership champions: "Evan just needs to find a home, if I'm being honest," he said last week. "Be it here [at Celtic] or somewhere else. He needs someone to say, 'You're my player.' "He went to West Ham for Graham Potter and you thought that was the perfect fit because Graham had him at Brighton. But then he didn't play so much at West Ham either. "Michail Antonio and someone else was injured, yet they played Jarrod Bowen and Mohammed Kudus - not Ferguson. What happens next for Evan? "I just think he needs to go, be it a loan for a season or some club buys him, and you build the team around him. I think he's a top player, I really do. "I did some Malaysian TV recently with Bobby Zamora and he goes into Brighton once a week and coaches the strikers. Bobby said Evan was the best finisher at the club. "Maybe because he burst onto the scene that everyone's been expecting so much so soon. But again, with young players, you need to have a bit of time. "I just feel he's ready now to burst onto the scene for a full season with somebody. For us, with Ireland, it would be great too. "I don't know if the finances would be to buy him, but if you said for a loan for the season, it would be perfect. But I'm not the financial power at Celtic or Newcastle, so I don't know!"

Daily Record

37 minutes ago

• Daily Record

Celtic misfit bids emotional farewell as reported transfer target Hayato Inamura opens scoring account with a belter

Defender Gustaf Lagerbielke has spent the season in the Eredivisie with FC Twente. Celtic misfit Gustaf Lagerbielke has penned an emotional FC Twente tribute after his loan with the Eredivisie side expired. The Swedish defender headed to the Netherlands on a season-long loan last summer and made 32 appearances in all competitions as Twente narrowly missed out on a place in Europe with a play-off defeat to AZ Alkmaar over two legs. ‌ There was some talk in the Netherlands that Twente were keen to sign the centre back on a permanent deal but that appears to have gone cold due to Lagerbielke - who the Hoops signed for around £3million from Swedish outfit Elfsborg back in 2023 - still having three years left on his contract at Celtic. ‌ Twente are however hoping to bring back fellow defender Robin Propper from city rivals Rangers after just one season in Glasgow. The Dutchman will however hold talks with new Ibrox boss Russell Martin to discuss his future next week. Ahead of his return to Lennoxtown for pre-season next month, Lagerbielke has officially said his goodbyes at Twente. His post on Instagram read: "From the first day I arrived in Enschede, I felt at home. "Every day I drove to the training field in Hengelo, I felt excitement. Every day I was with the team and the staff, I felt joy. "Every day I put on the Twente shirt, I felt proud. Every day I played for your supporters, I felt honoured. "And today I feel grateful. Grateful for all of you and for letting me be part of your family. Thank you." Elsewhere, reported Celtic target Hayato Inamura opened his account for J-League side Albirex Niigata in emphatic style. ‌ The left-sided defender only joined Albi last summer but has made 14 league appearances in Japan's top tier, with his side currently in the midst of a relegation battle. And while Albirex were on the end of another defeat at the hands of Avispa Fukuoka on Saturday, the 23-year-old did register his first goal for the club. ‌ Inamura showed his class to lash home an effort from inside the area and give his team a 1-0 lead after hosts Avispa had failed to clear a corner. However, a quickfire double from their opponents minutes later saw the scoreline reserved and while Albirex levelled things up again, Yuji Kitajima's goal on the stroke of the half-time whistle turned out to be the winner. You can get all the news you need on our dedicated Rangers and Celtic pages, and sign up to our newsletters to make sure you never miss a beat throughout the season. We're also on WhatsApp where we bring all the latest breaking news and transfer gossip directly to you phone. Join our Rangers community here and our Celtic community here.

Daily Record

an hour ago

• Daily Record

Russell Martin warned over Rangers mistake as Celtic flop tells him challenge could be 'over before it even starts'

The new Light Blues boss gets up and running in pre-season on Monday with a big Champions League tie on the horizon Russell Martin has been handed a 'over before it even starts' Rangers warning if he overplays at Ibrox. The new Light Blues gaffer is in position and gets on the grass with his players on Monday as they begin pre-season. ‌ The ex-Southampton boss will be going all out to implement his style and brand of football on his troops from the off with a huge Champions League clash with Panathinaikos on the horizon. ‌ Speaking on talkSPORT, former Celtic attacker Tony Cascarino spoke about the new man in the dugout at Ibrox. And he made his views very clear on his philosophy and principles. He said: 'I understand that you can stick to your principles and your ideas. But if you're playing for Rangers and you're getting beaten 3-0 against Celtic, you're overplaying and they're demanding that you go for blood - because they do, whether we like it or not - that's what the Old Firm derby's like and you have to be matching that. 'If you're playing tippy-tappy football and you're winning, you won't have a problem. I'm being a bit disrespectful saying tippy-tappy but basically I mean overplaying in dangerous areas. 'If they do that against Celtic and come off second best again, it will be over before it even starts, it really will.' It's all systems go at Ibrox with the players back at Auchenhowie tomorrow and the club holding an EGM. ‌ Fans are now desperate to see new faces with a host of names linked including Conor Coady and Max Aarons. Follow Record Sport on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram for all of the up-to-the minute breaking news, video and audio on the SPFL, the Scotland national team and beyond. You can get all the news you need on our dedicated Rangers and Celtic pages, and sign up to our newsletters to make sure you never miss a beat throughout the season. We're also WhatsApp where we bring all the latest breaking news and transfer gossip directly to you phone. Join our Rangers community here and our Celtic community here. Tune in to Hotline Live every Sunday to Thursday and have your say on the biggest issues in Scottish football and listen to Record Sport's newest podcast, Game On, every Friday for your sporting fix, all in bitesize chunks.