WRC finds in favour of dismissed employee who endured ‘deplorable' treatment from betting company
A service desk engineer dismissed by bookmaker Bar One Racing for alleged poor attendance and timekeeping was subject to 'deplorable' treatment by the company, the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) has found.
The company conducted a 'masterclass in how not to convene a disciplinary meeting' as it dealt with Liam Kyle, who initially worked on a part-time basis before being made permanent in October 2023, said WRC adjudication officer Pat Brady.
Mr Kyle, who said he believed he did good work for the company, was called to an initial meeting last September at which it was put to him he had been absent on 16 occasions.
He accepted there were absences but was not sure how many and had not considered it an issue until the meeting. A document stating the number as 16 was put to him and he was told that if he did not sign it, his employment could be terminated. He said he signed it under duress.
READ MORE
He said there were a couple of other meetings he considered to be informal and though the company said he was given a letter of warning, he said he did not recall seeing it and had certainly not been given a copy.
Mr Kyle did not initially realise he was the subject of disciplinary proceedings but was dismissed at a meeting in January. He said he found alternative work five weeks later.
In his decision on the case, Mr Brady described the conduct of the hearing into the matter as 'somewhat extraordinary' due to the company's attitude.
Represented by two members of its HR department, he said Bar One Racing failed to produce the relevant staff members as witnesses, did not make written submissions and demonstrated complete confusion with regard to the conduct of the meetings Mr Kyle was obliged to attend.
'The respondent did not apparently consider it necessary to submit any relevant documents in evidence from which I draw the obvious conclusions in respect of the burden of proof,' he said.
It was 'fatal' to the employer's case, he said, that Mr Kyle was not given a copy of the written warning 'if indeed it ever existed'.
'It seems probable that no such warning was administered on the date claimed and in any event, the complainant should have been given a copy of it formally,' Mr Brady said.
'It is rare these days to encounter such a complete repertoire of gross breaches of fair procedure and of a worker's rights.'
Based on Mr Kyle's earning of €540 per week, and the fact there was no ongoing loss due to him having found new work, he ordered that Bar One pay him €2,700 in compensation.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
29 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Fights recorded on doorbell camera and mobile phones culminated in man's death, murder trial told
A series of fights that ended with a man dying from a stab wound to the neck was recorded on CCTV, by neighbours using mobile phones and by a Ring doorbell, the Central Criminal Court has heard. Bernard Condon SC, for the Director of Public Prosecutions, on Friday told a jury they will view a 17-second CCTV clip of the moment when Joseph Lawlor (39) stabbed Michael Ryan (51) in the neck, cutting his carotid artery and causing his death. Mr Condon told the jury that both men had been drinking heavily together before the fight, which was the third physical altercation between them that night. Counsel said he expects it will be a straightforward task to find that Mr Lawlor inflicted the fatal wound, but it will be for the jury to determine Mr Lawlor's intention at the time of the killing. Mr Lawlor has pleaded not guilty to the murder of Michael Ryan at Hampton Wood Way, St Margaret's Road, Finglas, Dublin 11, on June 20th, 2024. READ MORE In his opening address this afternoon, Mr Condon told the jury that Mr Lawlor and Mr Ryan were drinking at the accused man's home in Hampton Wood Way from early in the day on Wednesday, June 19th, last year. The first physical altercation between them happened at about 8.30pm and was caught on CCTV covering the area outside Mr Lawlor's home and by a neighbour using his mobile phone. One witness will say that the 'younger man seemed to knock the older man to the ground' before gardaí intervened. Gardaí noted that they were intoxicated, but neither man wanted matters to go further, Mr Condon said. After gardaí had left, three more men joined Mr Lawlor and Mr Ryan at the house, before another fight broke out at about 9.30pm. One of the three men who had arrived appeared to be refereeing the fight, which was also recorded on CCTV and by neighbours using mobile phones, Mr Condon said. In the recordings, Mr Condon said Mr Lawlor can be heard calling Mr Ryan a 'rat' and saying, 'I'm going to stab out' before telling Mr Ryan: 'I love you too much, I'm not going to stab you, you're my friend.' Mr Lawlor got the better of Mr Ryan, counsel said, and Mr Ryan went to his car, where gardaí arrested him for being drunk in charge of a vehicle at about 9.50pm. Having been brought to a Garda station to be processed on that charge, Mr Ryan returned to Mr Lawlor's house shortly after midnight. A neighbour's Ring doorbell picked up Mr Ryan saying through a window of Mr Lawlor's home that he wanted his watch back. He also threatened to flick 'pineapples', which Mr Condon said is slang for grenades, through the window. About 20 minutes later, both men were again captured on CCTV on the street, where Mr Ryan can be seen carrying a bag. Mr Condon added: 'It seems Mr Lawlor is coming at him with quite a big knife and you will see a 17-second clip that shows Mr Ryan swinging a bag at Mr Lawlor and Mr Lawlor raising his knife-wielding hand and striking Mr Ryan on the neck with the knife.' His carotid artery cut, Mr Ryan died a quick death, Mr Condon said. Mr Condon told the jury that murder is an unlawful killing where the accused person intends to kill or cause serious injury. For murder, he said, the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that when he inflicted the fatal wound, the accused intended to kill or cause serious injury. The trial continues on Monday before Ms Justice Karen O'Connor and a jury of five women and seven men.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Nordic group mulls higher offer for Dalata as it buys more shares in Irish hotel chain
A Scandinavian consortium circling Dalata Hotel Group has signalled an interest in potentially making an improved offer for the business, after its €1.3 billion bid was rejected earlier this month. Oslo-based investment firm Eiendomsspar and Swedish hotel company Pandox, in which it owns an almost 25 per cent stake, said on Friday that they have bought 1.69 million shares in Dalata at €6.30 – marking a premium to the €6.05-a-share non-binding offer it had made for the company. 'Consequently, any firm intention to make an offer for Dalata by the consortium in accordance with Rule 2.7 of the Irish Takeover Rules, if made, will be at a price of not less than €6.30 per share,' the Nordic group said. 'There can be no certainty that any offer will be made. A further announcement will be made as appropriate. Any offer, if made, is likely to be solely in cash, although the consortium reserves the right to vary the form of consideration and/or introduce other forms of consideration.' READ MORE Eiendomsspar already owned an 8.8 per cent stake in Dalata before it made the bid approach. This latest share buying brings its stake in the Irish hotel group to 9.6 per cent. [ Dalata rejects surprise €1.3bn bid from Scandinavian consortium Opens in new window ] The property firm, which has a history of large investments in hotels, first emerged with a disclosable stake above 3 per cent in Dalata at the end of October. The company added to its stake the following month. But its chief executive, Sigurd Stray, sought to contain speculation at the time that it could amount to a strategic stake-build, telling The Irish Times he saw it as a 'financial investment' that would 'hopefully provide a fair return over time'. The early-June bid came as a surprise as the Pandox-Eiendomsspar consortium had not been involved in a formal sale process, managed by investment bank Rothschild, that has been going on in recent months. Dalata, which is led by chief executive Dermot Crowley, rejected that offer, saying it 'materially undervalues the group and its prospects'. [ Bidding war for Dalata Hotel Group hots up Opens in new window ] The board of Dalata, which floated on the stock market in 2014, hired investment bank Rothschild to carry out a strategic review of the business in March, following a sustained period of underperformance by the stock. Shares in Dalata jumped as much as 5.3 per cent to €6.53 on Friday afternoon, after the Pandox-Eiendomsspar consortium revealed its latest share purchase. The spike suggest that investors are holding out for a bid above the new floor that the consortium has set for a potential second tilt at the company.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Dublin airport operator warned over passenger cap breach
Dublin Airport operator DAA has been issued with an enforcement order by Fingal County Council for breaching the 32 million annual passenger limit, despite a High Court suspension of the cap. An Bord Pleanála imposed the limit on airport's capacity in 2007 as a condition of allowing it add a second terminal. The move was meant to allay fears over traffic jams on roads to and from the airport, which have since been upgraded. State company DAA applied to the council for permission to increase the cap to 36 million and 40 million in separate applications, but has yet to receive a decision from the planning authority. However, in April the High Court effectively suspended the passenger cap pending the outcome of a legal challenge relating to the limit taken last year by Irish airlines Ryanair and Aer Lingus, and Airlines for America, which represents US and Canadian carriers. READ MORE The cap was breached last year when 33.3 million passengers came through the airport. The council has now issued DAA with an enforcement notice which allows a two-year period to comply with the passenger capacity conditions. [ Aviation regulator drops measure from winter travel plan Opens in new window ] 'The two-year period provides an opportunity for DAA to progress their planning applications to increase passenger capacity at Dublin Airport or take such other steps as they consider appropriate to achieve compliance,' the council said. In response to complaints received that the conditions were breached in 2023 and 2024, the council's enforcement unit initiated a formal investigation to assess compliance. 'A warning letter was issued to DAA, providing them with an opportunity to respond, which they did,' the council said. 'Fingal County Council acknowledges the operational complexities presented. However, the information submitted by DAA does not constitute sufficient grounds to prevent further action. The investigation has determined that a breach of the relevant planning conditions has occurred and remains ongoing.' A DAA spokesman described the issuing of the enforcement notice as a 'sorry indictment' of the planning system. 'The fact that Fingal County Council is sending us an enforcement notice regarding 32 million passengers when passenger numbers will be north of 36 million this year and heading towards 40 million before the end of the decade is a sorry indictment of the mess that is the Irish planning system, particularly when it comes to the most vital piece of transport infrastructure on this island,' he said. DAA said that until the 'broken' system was overhauled the airport was effectively 'hamstrung' and unable to grow Ireland's connectivity. It has called for a complete scrapping of the passenger limit and for the airport to be classified as strategic infrastructure, placing relevant decisions in the hands of a national planning body and not a local authority. 'When it took up office, the Government committed to acting speedily to identify and implement a legislative solution that would remove the passenger cap from Dublin Airport,' the DAA spokesman said. 'The Minister has since also said he will bring forward legislation to solve the cap issue, dispel uncertainty and maintain connectivity for Ireland – and this can't happen quickly enough.' Minister for Transport Darragh O'Brien last month said he hoped forthcoming legislation could bring an end to the dispute.
