Residents survey reveals ‘distrust'
Better communication, more genuine consultation and greater transparency are key lessons from a survey of Queenstown Lakes residents, councillors say.
"Stinging" and "sombre" were some of the adjectives they used at a council workshop yesterday to describe the results of the survey, which was released last week.
Conducted by an independent market research company earlier this year, the survey delivered some confronting results, such as only 17% of respondents thinking the council made decisions in the best interests of the district.
Council policy data analyst Nathan Brown said the results reflected a "general distrust and unhappiness" with the council, and a perception by residents they were not being listened to.
Deputy mayor Quentin Smith said trust in the council had taken a hit over the Wānaka Airport lease issue, and the trend had only worsened in the years since.
Cr Niki Gladding said staff tended to "manipulate" community engagement, either "conscious or subconsciously".
Staff bias had crept into consultation on such issues such as Project Manawa, Lakeview and outdoor dining fees.
Councillors were "constantly being denied information we need to make decisions", Cr Gladding said.
Cr Esther Whitehead said that the council needed to be more transparent and improve its communications.
She often read online comments by people who clearly did not know much about the issue they were concerned about.
Cr Cody Tucker said it was "frustrating" to read online comments by people he had known for many years, but who never contacted him directly about their concerns.
Cr Lisa Guy said some online criticism was "made up and personal", but there was plenty to improve on.
She gave the council's website an example of an "amateur hour" level of service.
"I hate searching our website — I can't find things."
Cr Gavin Bartlett said some of the community's frustration was due to a lack of understanding of how local government worked.
Some people thought it was easy to get things done and fix problems, and believed councillors were intent on pursuing personal agendas.
"Anyone who sits in a council meeting knows that's not the case."
Mayor Glyn Lewers said the council was dealing with an "all-encompassing" level of growth, but he would rather be mayor of a town that was growing than one that was not.
The survey results were a "baseline", and the council would take the next few months to absorb the lessons.
"I don't think we should be too hard on ourselves".
guy.williams@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
3 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Residents survey reveals ‘distrust'
Better communication, more genuine consultation and greater transparency are key lessons from a survey of Queenstown Lakes residents, councillors say. "Stinging" and "sombre" were some of the adjectives they used at a council workshop yesterday to describe the results of the survey, which was released last week. Conducted by an independent market research company earlier this year, the survey delivered some confronting results, such as only 17% of respondents thinking the council made decisions in the best interests of the district. Council policy data analyst Nathan Brown said the results reflected a "general distrust and unhappiness" with the council, and a perception by residents they were not being listened to. Deputy mayor Quentin Smith said trust in the council had taken a hit over the Wānaka Airport lease issue, and the trend had only worsened in the years since. Cr Niki Gladding said staff tended to "manipulate" community engagement, either "conscious or subconsciously". Staff bias had crept into consultation on such issues such as Project Manawa, Lakeview and outdoor dining fees. Councillors were "constantly being denied information we need to make decisions", Cr Gladding said. Cr Esther Whitehead said that the council needed to be more transparent and improve its communications. She often read online comments by people who clearly did not know much about the issue they were concerned about. Cr Cody Tucker said it was "frustrating" to read online comments by people he had known for many years, but who never contacted him directly about their concerns. Cr Lisa Guy said some online criticism was "made up and personal", but there was plenty to improve on. She gave the council's website an example of an "amateur hour" level of service. "I hate searching our website — I can't find things." Cr Gavin Bartlett said some of the community's frustration was due to a lack of understanding of how local government worked. Some people thought it was easy to get things done and fix problems, and believed councillors were intent on pursuing personal agendas. "Anyone who sits in a council meeting knows that's not the case." Mayor Glyn Lewers said the council was dealing with an "all-encompassing" level of growth, but he would rather be mayor of a town that was growing than one that was not. The survey results were a "baseline", and the council would take the next few months to absorb the lessons. "I don't think we should be too hard on ourselves".
Otago Daily Times
4 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Shop set for influx of half a million books
Hard To Find Books Dunedin manager Blaze Forbes peruses the aisles at the Dowling St second-hand bookshop. PHOTO: GERARD O'BRIEN Half a million books could be bound for Dunedin if the closure of a prominent second-hand bookshop goes ahead, its owner says. While the possible closure of Auckland-based Hard To Find Books had plunged its future into "total chaos", owner Warwick Jordan said he expected its Dunedin store would continue "business as usual". "If anything, it could boost it in the longer run if we end up coming down there." The Auckland bookshop's lease is scheduled to lapse at the end of February next year. Housed in a former convent, the building is owned by the Catholic Church, which decided not to renew the lease as it intended to sell it. The bookshop had occupied the building since 2018 but has had a presence in Auckland for more than 40 years. Mr Jordan said he had wanted the bookshop located somewhere it could stay forever as it was "just too much of a mission to move". "I thought that was the case with where we are. Turns out I was wrong." The contents of the Auckland store could fill an estimated 20 shipping containers — roughly half a million books, he said. It would cost $100,000 alone to move the books and, because he lived above the bookshop, Mr Jordan would also need to look for a new home. "I just don't want to have to go through this again. I'm getting old, but I have no retirement plan whatsoever." He did not believe there was another suitable building in Auckland to house the bookshop. Renting a larger premises was also out of the question. Another option he was looking at was relocating all of its stock down to Dunedin, but they were already "pushing it" for space. "We've got 30,000 square feet in Dunedin pretty much packed already. "We'd be bringing down about half a million books, but we've got over half a million in Dunedin already." While anywhere with enough space was open to consideration, it was "highly likely" the Dunedin store would become the sole retail outlet, Mr Jordan said. Whether they moved everything to Dunedin was a separate issue. Their Auckland stock would at the least end up being sold from out of storage units, which could still get shipped down to Dunedin anyway. He also floated the idea of storing the books in a woolshed at a rural property on the outskirts of Dunedin, or in Milton.
Otago Daily Times
13-06-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Cost hikes will not hit rates
Government-mandated KiwiSaver cost increases will not affect Invercargill City Council rates this year. In the May Budget Finance Minister Nicola Willis announced the default rate for employee and employer contributions would rise to 3.5% on April 1, 2026, and 4% on April 1, 2028. The scheme will also be extended to include 16 and 17-year-olds. At an extraordinary meeting yesterday councillors considered a resolution to fund the increased KiwiSaver cost, an estimated $61,000, by raising the projected 2025-26 rates rise from 7.11% to 7.19% . This would be included in the annual plan documents for adoption later this month. During the discussion of the resolution Cr Tom Campbell said throughout the year there were many times when budgeted costs changed. "There's going to be ups and downs — it's like a golf score where you get birdies and bogies." It was a "relatively small" amount of money. "My view would be, we should simply absorb this." Cr Ian Pottinger said the council should rate according to its costs and the projected rates rise should be increased. When the resolution was voted on, the vote was split and Mr Clark cast the deciding vote to defeat the motion. A new resolution agreeing to take the extra KiwiSaver costs out of increasing chief executive Michael Day's efficiency target also resulted in a split vote and Mr Clark's vote gave the motion the majority.
