Reassessing South Africa's diplomatic missions: balancing budget cuts and economic growth
In the midst of budget pressures, calls have been made by political parties to close some South African diplomatic missions across the world. This has been done previously by the Department of International Relations and Cooperation (DIRCO).
The danger of such a blunt approach is that in pursuit of saving a few million in a budget of R2.6 trillion, we may actually do more harm than good to our fundamental task of stimulating economic growth and creating decent jobs. Is there a need to reconfigure and reposition our diplomatic presence? Without a doubt. This should be done in a way that attracts investment and boosts export opportunities and tourism for our economy.
Politicians are correct to demand savings across our diplomatic missions. Many of the buildings are too large and expensive. More affordable ones should be secured.
Should many of our diplomats spend less time at cocktail functions? Without a doubt. All departments should seek consistently to reduce wastage and improve efficiency, especially in the context of fiscal constraints and the need to ensure allocations to protect the poor, invest in critical infrastructure, and stimulate growth are prioritised.
What we need to avoid is a rush to close diplomatic missions in pursuit of saving money today but foregoing future investments and trade opportunities. Years of blunt budget cuts have shown the real dangers and unintended consequences of decapacitating the state.
The dangers of this will arise when South Africans are stranded overseas without access to an embassy to help them or issue an emergency passport, or South Africa being caught unaware of trade or political disputes at great cost to local industries.
SARS has shown a path to capacitating the state by investing in its personnel, management, infrastructure, and capacity, and whilst there is a bill to be paid today, society reaps the rewards with a growing economy in the future, thus ensuring the state has the revenue needed to fund the public services society depends upon.
A more nuanced approach is needed that balances short-term savings with long-term investments. Embassies, like all other state organs, need to be shaken up from time to time. Such a reconfiguration is overdue, but it requires a long-term vision coupled with greater efficiency.
Closing embassies saves money today, but it also denies greater trade and investment in the future. In the past few years, amongst others, we have closed our missions in Chicago, the financial hub of the American Midwest, and Finland, a relatively small nation, but also home to Nokia and other key start-ups, and one with deep historic ties to South Africa and the region.
Does squeezing DIRCO's relatively modest budget and compelling the closure of missions help boost investment from Chicago or open greater export opportunities to Finland? Likely not. What we should support DIRCO to do, with the support of key departments, e.g. Home Affairs, Tourism, Higher Education and Training, and most critically Trade, Industry and Competition, is to support a repivoting of our missions' mandates and provide them the tools to attract badly needed investment, export opportunities, and tourism.
Our missions need to have strong political heads who can ensure our bilateral relations with our host countries are healthy and alert government to issues needing interventions long before they arise. The turbulence in our relations with the US is a case in point.
The other key mandate of our missions must be to boost trade and investment. All missions must be required to meet set targets annually and be provided with the necessary technical support to achieve this, including from key economic sectors. The recent announcement by the Minister for Trade, Industry and Competition, Mr. Parks Tau, that DTIC currently does not have any trade attaches at our missions, must be an alarm bell and a dire warning about the dangers of recklessly cutting key departments' budgets.
The point of deploying strong trade attaches is to unlock trade and investment opportunities and tackle blockages to South African exports. This fundamental task is very difficult if we do not have skilled people in place to do so. DIRCO's recent deployment of a senior agricultural attaché to our embassy in the US is a welcome intervention to resolving long-simmering agricultural trade issues.
Tourism is a major growth sector and employer with over 800 000 jobs and with massive untapped potential. Despite the best efforts of the Department of Tourism over the years, we still have much greater space to unlock its potential. This requires supporting our embassies with the necessary technical support to boost tourism arrivals, including opening more direct flights from key tourism markets.
Home Affairs' investments in staff, filling critical vacancies, enabling online visa applications, and digitising operations is key to boosting tourism as we will never be able to have an embassy in every single corner of the world.
Embassies should be tasked to identify international education opportunities for young South Africans. This will not only boost their own career and earning potential but bring the skills the economy needs to grow. This is exactly why China, under Deng Xiao Ping, sent thousands of students to study in the US, Europe, and Japan in the 1970s.
The recent de facto enslavement of South Africans desperate for work in Myanmar is a reminder of why we need to have a presence across the world. Similarly, for our own tourists whose passports may be stolen and thus stranded and unable to travel. In a globalised era where organised crime has no borders, our law enforcement and security organs need to have access to their peers to be able to protect South Africa from such activities.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
2 hours ago
- IOL News
Celebrating educated young black farmers
Lizzy Nyathi is a member of the youth network ACTIVATE! Change Drivers who used a seedling donation by the network to plant a business that has grown its fruits and influence in many communities, and as a supplier to many retail stores. Lisima Farming Project employs four permanent staff who work at the farm and four seasonal labourers. Her story may not have drawn the attention of the Oval Office on 21 May; however, her commitment to sustainable farming and developing the next generation of young African farmers is adding to the good South African story of the immeasurable role of agriculture Lizzy Nyathi is a member of the youth network ACTIVATE! Change Drivers who used a seedling donation by the network to plant a business that has grown its fruits and influence in many communities, and as a supplier to many retail stores. An educated black female farmer, she is from Mpumalanga and the director of the Lisima farming project (Lisima Trading and project) that is based in the Bushbuckridge Municipality, in a small village called Welverdiend. Educated and passionate about sustainable farming Lizzy holds a degree in agricultural management from the University of Limpopo. For Lizzy, the idea to farm was born during her years as a student, and it grew its legs when she began to facilitate agricultural programs that focused on plant production and horticulture. Through her friends and family's support, she managed to raise funds to the sum of R50,000 to start crop farming. In 2023, she cleared 1ha (hectare) out of 3 and fenced it and started producing from it and ultimately made her first sale in August 2023 to Lebamba Hoedspruit. Nearly two years later, Lizzy has never looked back and recounts both challenges and opportunities that farming has brought her way. Some of her achievements include being a local crop supplier at Spar, Makhoma, Roots, Boxer, Lebamba, Street vendors, community members and several game lodges. Farming requires you to innovate As a small-scale farmer, Lizzy reflects on the challenges of having sufficient resources to meet the demands and make a profit. 'Sometimes our crops get affected when there are seasonal changes, but I kept it up throughout the whole year. With me now supplying the game lodges, I had to consider planting special crops and herbs. I then realised we, as small-scale farmers, incurred so many losses in our production due to an unplanned production system', Nyathi. 'We also tend to have more losses of products like tomatoes because they have a short shelf life. I came up with a way of preserving it for a different function. Now we are happy to say we also produce sun-dried tomatoes, pepper sauce and basil pesto, which we supply to many game lodges, and we also make spices from the herbs we plant on the farm. Some of these dried herbs are used on our processed products', she adds elated. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading Zamayirha Peter is an Advocacy Communications Specialist with over eight (8) years of experience in multimedia journalism and communications. Image: Supplied Giving back to those in need Lizzy's approach to farming has been multifaceted and comprised of dynamic interventions to get to her bottom line. Lisima Farming Project not only focuses on growing crops and livestock but also provides a space to teach the next generation of farmers and gives back to the communities that support the business through their social investment project. 'Some of our products are allocated to those in need. We go into households that are without food, and schools that cater for minor kids, such as creches, and we have a program in the community that annually gives Christmas hampers to the needy households on Christmas Day', Nyathi. For Lizzy, farming does not begin and end with what you plant, but with your impact at the community level. 'As a business, we comply with the South African Good Agricultural Practices (SAGAP) standard, and we are HACCP (Hazard Analysis & Critical Control Point) certified', Nyathi. 'For us, farming is not just about production, but we also ensure that we produce food that is healthy to consume, we minimise the use of agrochemicals, and in any way possible, we avoid them altogether', she adds.
Eyewitness News
2 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Growing calls for SA to lead the UN in drafting a new Human Rights Treaty
JOHANNESBURG - There are growing calls for South Africa to take a lead role in shaping a new United Nations (UN) treaty on crimes against humanity including apartheid. Human rights groups, including international organisation Madre, are urging government to contribute to the drafting process. The calls come after a two-day dialogue co-hosted by the Nelson Mandela foundation, bringing together lawyers, feminists, and civil society to address the legacy of apartheid and other global atrocities. International lawyer Wendy Isaack said existing laws don't go far enough. "International human rights law is not enough because it does not enable individual prosecution of those that should be held accountable for the crime of apartheid which means inhumane acts committed in the context of an institutionalized regime of systematic oppression and domination on the basis of race, and these acts include murder, torture and assassinations that were committed by apartheid era security forces and agents of the state in South Africa," said Isaack. She said the treaty should be broadly applicable to crimes worldwide. "These matters because when we think of apartheid as a domineering system, as a regime that oppressed black people in SA we also bear in mind that when international law is being developed, this law must also be applicable to other contexts, and at the top of our list are the Israeli apartheid policies and practices in occupied Palestinian territory. And the South African government made this very submission in the international court of justice in the 2014 advisory opinion proceedings," said Isaack. South Africa has previously made similar submissions at the International Court of Justice.
IOL News
3 hours ago
- IOL News
The implications of Shivambu's political move for South Africa's left
On Thursday, Floyd Shivambu, the former Secretary General of the uMkhonto weSizwe Party (MKP), announced a national consultative process aimed at gauging South Africans' interest in forming a new political party. This initiative comes on the heels of his recent removal as secretary general, signalling a potential shift in the political landscape as South Africa approaches the 2026 local government elections. Shivambu's announcement, although framed as a quest for broader public engagement, raises questions about the true intent behind his national roadshow. It is difficult to ignore the parallels with historical precedents, especially when one considers the various political figures who have pursued similar consultations over the years, from the Roelf Meyer and Bantu Holomisa duo to, more recently, Songezo Zibi's Rise Mzansi. Historically, none of these forums have concluded without eventually forming a new party. They often resemble more of a fundraising initiative before elections rather than a genuine effort to gauge public sentiment.
