Who Is on RFK, Jr.'s New Vaccine Panel—And What Will They Do?
An emergency-room doctor, critics of COVID-19 vaccines and an obstetrician who advises a supplement company are among the advisers handpicked by vaccine sceptic Robert F. Kennedy Jr, the head of the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), to provide advice on vaccines to the federal government.
Kennedy announced his new roster for the influential Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) on 11 June — just two days after he fired all 17 of its previous members and accused the ACIP of 'malevolent malpractice'. The ACIP advises US public-health officials as to who should receive approved vaccines, and when. Those recommendations are then often used to guide whether public and private health-insurance programmes will pay for the shots.
Kennedy has pledged that the ACIP will re-evaluate the vaccine 'schedule' for children — the list of which vaccines children should get and when they should get them. This week's shakeup of the committee is 'a major step towards restoring public trust in vaccines,' Kennedy said in a post on the social media platform, X.
On supporting science journalism
If you're enjoying this article, consider supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By purchasing a subscription you are helping to ensure the future of impactful stories about the discoveries and ideas shaping our world today.
Several of the new ACIP members have expressed public support for vaccines. But a number of them have also expressed scepticism; one serves on the board of an anti-vaccination organization, and a second has been a prominent sceptic of the COVID-19 vaccines on social media. As first reported by the biomedical news outlet STAT, Kennedy included four of the new committee members in the dedication to his 2021 book The Real Anthony Fauci: Bill Gates, Big Pharma, and the Global War on Democracy and Public Health.
'This is a disaster for public health,' says Adam Ratner, a paediatric infectious diseases physician in New York City. 'It has the potential to set us back decades.' The HHS did not respond to a request for comment before publication.
Far-reaching implications
Infectious-disease specialists worry about the implications of the ACIP potentially voting to recommend fewer vaccines or fewer doses than are currently advised. Paul Offit, an infectious-diseases paediatrician at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia and co-inventor of a rotavirus vaccine who served on the ACIP from 1998 to 2003, says insurers don't have to cover vaccines that aren't recommended by the ACIP. And 'doctors or pharmacists who give vaccines may feel that they would be liable for giving that vaccine', he adds.
Even those who can pay for vaccines out of pocket might find them harder to get without an ACIP recommendation, says Arthur Reingold, an epidemiologist at the University of California, Berkeley, because overall demand for the shots will decrease. That, in turn, could lead some pharmacies to stop stocking them.
Offit notes that at the ACIP's next meeting, which starts 25 June, the panel will decide whether to recommend vaccines for COVID-19, the human papillomavirus, meningococcal disease and RSV. 'These are established vaccines, and we're voting on them?' Offit says. 'The entire childhood and adult immunisation schedule is on the table.'
Kennedy has criticized the ACIP for what he says are rampant conflicts of interest among its members. On 12 June, the biopharma news outlet Endpoints News reported that two newly named ACIP members, Robert Malone and Martin Kulldorff, have received payment for serving as expert witnesses in lawsuits against pharmaceutical company Merck over two of its vaccines. Malone said on X that this work ended six years ago.
Kennedy has also said that past committee members did not demand what he considers to be adequate safety trials with control groups that received a placebo, before recommending vaccines.
But many of the vaccine studies included placebo controls, Ratner says, unless it was unethical to conduct the trial with one. And Reingold, who has served on the ACIP in the past, says that the committee has strict policies regarding conflicts of interest and that committee members must recuse themselves from any vote that might pose a conflict. 'The issue of potential conflicts of interest has been radically overblown and unfairly called into question the objectivity of this panel,' he says.
Offit says several independent groups have reviewed previous ACIP members and found no conflicts of interest. 'Now, the conflict of interest is real because these folks are indebted to RFK Jr, who just gave them this position,' he says.
Vetting process
Researchers are also concerned about the loss of expertise. The committee's new lineup is 'disturbing', says Nancy Bennett, a public-health specialist at the University of Rochester Medical Center in New York.
In the past, members were nominated and then vetted by staff at the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) before being sent to the head of the CDC and, finally, the head of the HHS for approval. Bennett says the vetting process sometimes took years. 'The ACIP was meant to be composed of people with deep expertise in the area,' Ratner says. 'That's what we have lost.'
Joseph Hibbeln
Hibbeln is a psychiatrist and neuroscientist who once worked at the US National Institutes of Health. His recent papers have focused on the connection between nutrition and various disorders, including mental-health conditions, and his LinkedIn profile states that twenty-first-century diets are contributing to 'inadequate brain nutrients and are likely contributing to the high burden of mental illnesses worldwide'. A search of PubMed, a database of biomedical papers, did not turn up any papers he has authored about vaccines or infectious disease. He did not respond to a request for comment.
Martin Kulldorff
Kulldorff is a Swedish epidemiologist and senior scholar at the Brownstone Institute, a think tank based in West Hartford, Connecticut, that formed 'to provide an independent voice for personal liberty' and to oppose lockdown policies instituted by public officials during the COVID-19 pandemic. Along with Jayanta Bhattacharya, the current head of the US National Institutes of Health, Kulldorff wrote the Great Barrington Declaration in 2020, which advocated against COVID-19 lockdowns except for vulnerable populations, and drew much pushback from the medical community.
Last year, Kulldorff wrote in City Journal that he was fired from Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts, for refusing a COVID-19 vaccine even though he already had immunity from being infected. He also wrote that 'vaccines are a vital medical invention, allowing people to obtain immunity without the risk that comes from getting sick,' but suggested that trials of COVID-19 vaccines early in the pandemic were not properly designed. Kulldorff did not respond to Nature 's request for comment.
Retsef Levi
Levi is a professor of operations management at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in Cambridge. He has published several papers on COVID-19, including one expressing concerns about side effects of the COVID-19 vaccines. In a post on social-media platform X in 2023, Levi said, 'The evidence is mounting and indisputable that MRNA vaccines cause serious harm including death, especially among young people. We have to stop giving them immediately!' Levi did not respond to a request for comment.
Robert Malone
Malone is a physician and scientist whose research contributed to the development of mRNA vaccines. He maintains that he has not received the credit he deserves for his role, but in a 2023 video, he said the mRNA vaccines for COVID-19 would damage children's organs and had no benefit to children.
He also promoted ivermectin, an anti-parasite medication, as a treatment for COVID-19; mounting evidence shows that it has no effect. Malone declined to comment but said in an e-mailed statement that he will do his 'best to serve with unbiased objectivity and rigor'.
Cody Meissner
Meissner studies paediatrics at the Dartmouth Geisel School of Medicine in Lebanon, New Hampshire, and has served on multiple federal committees on vaccines. He was a member of the ACIP from 2008 to 2012. He has emphasized the importance of COVID-19 vaccines, saying in 2021 that 'it's important that the main message we transmit is that we've got to get everyone two doses.' In 2021, he co-authored a newspaper commentary opposing mask mandates for children, and he has expressed scepticism about the benefits of repeated COVID-19 booster shots for children. He did not respond to a request for comment.
James Pagano
Pagano, now retired, has worked as an emergency medicine physician and emergency-room medical director. Kennedy described him as a 'strong advocate for evidence-based medicine'. He has published two fiction books about hospital physicians and in 2014 wrote a blog post questioning whether climate change is real. His public record on vaccines is thin. He did not respond to a request for comment.
Vicky Pebsworth
Pebsworth is a nurse, health-care administrator and health-policy analyst who has been a voting member of an FDA advisory committee on vaccines. She's also a volunteer at the National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC), a non-profit organization that highlights vaccine risks and informs about 'biological mechanisms involved in vaccine injury and death'. Her NVIC profile says that her interest on vaccine safety started after her son experienced 'long-term health problems following receipt of seven live viruses and killed bacterial vaccines administered during his 15-month well-baby visit'. Pebsworth was part of a working group for the FDA's National Vaccine Advisory Committee that monitored post-marketing vaccine safety and potential risks. In 2020, she told an FDA committee that the NVIC's position was that 'using coercion and sanctions to persuade adults to take an experimental vaccine, or give it to their children, is unethical and unlawful,' as first reported by CBS. She did not respond to a request for comment.
Michael Ross
Ross is an obstetrician and chief medical officer at Manta Pharma, an implantable device company in Maryland. He has been a board member and adviser for nearly a dozen pharmaceutical and medical-device companies, including LarreaRx, which distributes an herbal supplement. Ross was a presidential appointee on a CDC committee for preventing breast and cervical cancer, and a professor at George Washington University for 46 years. His LinkedIn profile lists his specialties as 'Contact lenses, International Business, Healthcare and pharmaceutical executive management, pharmaceutical consulting.' He did not respond to a request for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
29 minutes ago
- Fox News
One Whistleblower's Fight Against Big Pharma
About one million Americans live with Multiple Sclerosis, and nearly 10,000 new cases are diagnosed every year. While scientific advances have aimed to slow MS's progression, whistleblower Lisa Pratta argues the real threat may lie within the pharmaceutical industry itself. A former drug sales rep turned U.S. Department of Justice informant, Lisa Pratta, exposed widespread corruption, including bribing doctors to prescribe drugs for profit. Now an outspoken activist, Lisa describes how she believes Big Pharma exploits the vulnerable in pursuit of revenue. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit
New York Times
5 hours ago
- New York Times
‘I Feel Like I've Been Lied To': When a Measles Outbreak Hits Home
He was a chiropractor by training, but in a remote part of West Texas with limited medical care, Kiley Timmons had become a first stop for whatever hurt. Ear infections. Labor pains. Oil workers who arrived with broken ribs and farmers with bulging discs. For more than a decade, Kiley, 48, had seen 20 patients each day at his small clinic located between a church and a gas station in Brownfield, population 8,500. He treated what he could, referred others to physicians and prayed over the rest. It wasn't until early this spring that he started to notice something unfamiliar coming through the door: aches that lingered, fevers that wouldn't break, discolored patches of skin that didn't make sense. At first, he blamed it on a bad flu season, but the symptoms stuck around and then multiplied. By late March, a third of his patients were telling him about relatives who couldn't breathe. And then Kiley started coughing, too. His wife, Carrollyn, had recently tested positive for Covid, but her symptoms eased as Kiley's intensified. He went to a doctor at the beginning of April for a viral panel, but every result came back negative. The doctor decided to test for the remote possibility of measles, since there was a large outbreak spreading through a Mennonite community 40 miles away, but Kiley was vaccinated. 'I feel like I'm dying,' Kiley texted a friend. He couldn't hold down food or water. He had already lost 10 pounds. His chest went numb, and his arms began to tingle. His oxygen was dropping dangerously low when he finally got the results. 'Positive for measles,' he wrote to his sister, in mid-April. 'Just miserable. I can't believe this.' Twenty-five years after measles was officially declared eliminated from the United States, this spring marked a harrowing time of rediscovery. A cluster of cases that began at a Mennonite church in West Texas expanded into one of the largest outbreaks in a generation, spreading through communities with declining vaccination rates as three people died and dozens more were hospitalized from Mexico to North Dakota. Public health officials tracked about 1,200 confirmed cases and countless exposures across more than 30 states. People who were contagious with measles boarded domestic flights, shopped at Walmart, played tuba in a town parade and toured the Mall of America. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Chicago Tribune
15 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
US measles count now tops 1,200 cases, and Iowa announces an outbreak
The U.S. logged fewer than 20 measles cases this week, though Iowa announced the state's first outbreak Thursday and Georgia confirmed its second Wednesday. There have been 1,214 confirmed measles cases this year, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said Friday. Health officials in Texas, where the nation's biggest outbreak raged during the late winter and spring, confirmed six cases in the last week. There are three other major outbreaks in North America. The longest, in Ontario, Canada, has resulted in 2,179 cases from mid-October through June 17. The province logged its first death June 5 in a baby who got congenital measles but also had other preexisting conditions. Another outbreak in Alberta, Canada, has sickened 996 as of Thursday. And the Mexican state of Chihuahua had 2,335 measles cases and four deaths as of Friday, according to data from the state health ministry. Other U.S. states with active outbreaks — which the CDC defines as three or more related cases — include Arizona, Colorado, Illinois, Kansas, Montana, New Mexico, North Dakota and Oklahoma. In the U.S., two elementary school-aged children in the epicenter in West Texas and an adult in New Mexico have died of measles this year. All were unvaccinated. Measles vaccination rates drop after COVID-19 pandemic in counties across the USMeasles is caused by a highly contagious virus that's airborne and spreads easily when an infected person breathes, sneezes or coughs. It is preventable through vaccines and has been considered eliminated from the U.S. since 2000. There are a total of 750 cases across 35 counties, most of them in West Texas, state health officials said Tuesday. Throughout the outbreak, 97 people have been hospitalized. State health officials estimated less than 1% of cases — fewer than 10 — are actively infectious. Fifty-five percent of Texas' cases are in Gaines County, where the virus started spreading in a close-knit, undervaccinated Mennonite community. The county has had 413 cases since late January — just under 2% of its residents. The April 3 death in Texas was an 8-year-old child, according to Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Local health officials said the child did not have underlying health conditions and died of 'what the child's doctor described as measles pulmonary failure.' A unvaccinated child with no underlying conditions died of measles in Texas in late February; Kennedy said the child was 6. New Mexico held steady Friday with a total of 81 cases. Seven people have been hospitalized since the outbreak started. Most of the state's cases are in Lea County. Sandoval County near Albuquerque has six cases, Eddy County has three, Doña Ana County has two. Chaves, Curry and San Juan counties have one each. An unvaccinated adult died of measles-related illness March 6. The person did not seek medical care. Oklahoma added one case Friday for a total of 17 confirmed and three probable cases. The state health department is not releasing which counties have cases. Arizona has four cases in Navajo County. They are linked to a single source, the county health department said June 9. All four were unvaccinated and had a history of recent international travel. Colorado has seen a total of 16 measles cases in 2025, which includes one outbreak of 10 related cases. The outbreak is linked to a Turkish Airlines flight that landed at Denver International Airport in mid-May. Four of the people were on the flight with the first case — an out-of-state traveler not included in the state count — while five got measles from exposure in the airport and one elsewhere. Health officials are also tracking an unrelated case in a Boulder County resident. The person was fully vaccinated but had 'recently traveled to Europe, where there are a large number of measles cases,' the state health department said. Other counties that have seen measles this year include Archuleta and Pueblo. Georgia has an outbreak of three cases in metro Atlanta, with the most recent infection confirmed Wednesday. The state has confirmed six total cases in 2025. The remaining three are part of an unrelated outbreak from January. Illinois health officials confirmed a four-case outbreak on May 5 in the far southern part of the state. It grew to eight cases as of June 6, but no new cases were reported in the following weeks, according to the Illinois Department of Public Health. The state's other two cases so far this year were in Cook County, and are unrelated to the southern Illinois outbreak. Illinois unveils online tool showing measles vaccination rates by schoolIowa has had six total measles cases in 2025. Four are part of an outbreak in eastern Johnson County, among members of the same household. County health officials said the people are isolating at home, so they don't expect additional spread. Kansas has a total of 79 cases across 11 counties in the southwestern part of the state, with three hospitalizations. All but three of the cases are connected, and most are in Gray County. Montana had 22 measles cases as of Friday. Fourteen were in Gallatin County, which is where the first cases showed up — Montana's first in 35 years. Flathead and Yellowstone counties had two cases each, and Hill County had four cases. There are outbreaks in neighboring North Dakota and the Canadian provinces of Alberta, British Columbia and Saskatchewan. North Dakota, which hadn't seen measles since 2011, was up to 34 cases as of June 6, but has held steady since. Two of the people have been hospitalized. All of the people with confirmed cases were not vaccinated. There were 16 cases in Williams County in western North Dakota on the Montana border. On the eastern side of the state, there were 10 cases in Grand Forks County and seven cases in Cass County. Burke County, in northwest North Dakota on the border of Saskatchewan, Canada, had one case. Measles cases also have been reported this year in Alaska, Arkansas, California, District of Columbia, Florida, Hawaii, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, New Jersey, New York, Rhode Island, South Dakota, Vermont, Virginia and Washington. Health officials declared earlier outbreaks in Indiana, Michigan, Ohio and Pennsylvania over after six weeks of no new cases. Tennessee's outbreak also appears to be over. Cases and outbreaks in the U.S. are frequently traced to someone who caught the disease abroad. The CDC said in May that more than twice as many measles have come from outside of the U.S. compared to May of last year. Most of those are in unvaccinated Americans returning home. In 2019, the U.S. saw 1,274 cases and almost lost its status of having eliminated measles. The best way to avoid measles is to get the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine. The first shot is recommended for children between 12 and 15 months old and the second between 4 and 6 years old. Getting another MMR shot as an adult is harmless if there are concerns about waning immunity, the CDC says. People who have documentation of receiving a live measles vaccine in the 1960s don't need to be revaccinated, but people who were immunized before 1968 with an ineffective vaccine made from 'killed' virus should be revaccinated with at least one dose, the agency said. People who have documentation that they had measles are immune and those born before 1957 generally don't need the shots because so many children got measles back then that they have 'presumptive immunity.' Measles has a harder time spreading through communities with high vaccination rates — above 95% — due to 'herd immunity.' But childhood vaccination rates have declined nationwide since the pandemic and more parents are claiming religious or personal conscience waivers to exempt their kids from required shots. Measles first infects the respiratory tract, then spreads throughout the body, causing a high fever, runny nose, cough, red, watery eyes and a rash. The rash generally appears three to five days after the first symptoms, beginning as flat red spots on the face and then spreading downward to the neck, trunk, arms, legs and feet. When the rash appears, the fever may spike over 104 degrees Fahrenheit, according to the CDC. Most kids will recover from measles, but infection can lead to dangerous complications such as pneumonia, blindness, brain swelling and death. There's no specific treatment for measles, so doctors generally try to alleviate symptoms, prevent complications and keep patients comfortable.
