Doctors' shortage: Punjab govt introduces bond policy for MBBS, BDS students
Patiala: In a move aimed at addressing shortage of doctors in government health institutions, the Punjab government has introduced a new bond policy for students enrolling in MBBS and BDS courses in state-run medical and dental colleges.
The policy, which will come into effect from the academic session 2025-26, mandates that students either serve in government healthcare facilities for two years after completing their degrees or pay a bond of ₹20 lakh.
The policy also applies to students admitted under the 'All-India quota', but their mandatory service period will be limited to one year.
'A service bond of ₹20,00,000 shall be applicable to students admitted under both state and All India quotas. The duration of the bond is one year for All India Quota students and two years for state quota students. The service period may be extended at the discretion of the government,' according to an order from the Punjab medical education department.
The government has stated that the new policy is designed to encourage MBBS graduates to join government service and help fill vacancies in rural and underserved areas, which are particularly affected by the shortage. Currently, around 1,962 posts of general medical officers (GMO) remain vacant out of 3,847 sanctioned posts.
While the policy targets the issue of doctor shortages, it highlights the broader problem in the state's medical infrastructure. Punjab has only four government medical colleges, which provide approximately 40% of the MBBS seats, while six private medical colleges account for the remaining 60%.
The state government had previously promised to establish 16 new government medical colleges over the course of its five-year tenure, but no new colleges have been built so far.
Govt defends policy
Health and medical education minister Dr Balbir Singh defended the policy, emphasising the need for more doctors, particularly in rural areas. 'Punjab needs doctors, especially in rural regions. We have been advertising for positions, but many MBBS graduates leave the government sector after just a few months. This bond policy will ensure that graduates serve for at least two years. They are studying with taxpayer money and it is their responsibility to contribute to society,' he said.
Medical associations, students oppose move
The policy has faced criticism from medical student associations and doctors' groups. The Medical Student Association (MSA), Punjab, strongly condemned the bond system, calling it a form of 'bonded labour' that would discourage high-ranking students from pursuing MBBS in Punjab's government colleges.
Dr Mehtab Bal, a member of the Resident Doctors Association (RDA) in Patiala, said: 'The government has failed to attract MBBS doctors to the public sector. Now, they are punishing deserving students, especially those from economically weaker backgrounds. This feels like an extortion tactic.'
The Punjab Civil Medical Services Association (PCMSA) also voiced its objections. Dr Nidhi Sharma Ahluwalia, spokesperson of the PCMSA, said: 'The MBBS course already has a mandatory one-year internship. Asking students to serve two additional years in government hospitals is unfair. The government should focus on improving recruitment processes and the working environment to address the doctor shortage.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
3 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Medical students protest bond policy, fee hike in Punjab
Amid widespread unrest over a recent hike in tuition fees and the introduction of a controversial bond policy, the Medical Student Association (MSA), Punjab, met with medical education minister Dr Balbir Singh at Government Medical College, Amritsar, on Friday to register their protest. Amid widespread unrest over a recent hike in tuition fees and the introduction of a controversial bond policy, the Medical Student Association (MSA), Punjab, met with medical education minister Dr Balbir Singh at Government Medical College, Amritsar, on Friday to register their protest. (Getty Images/iStockphoto/ Representational image) The student delegation submitted a memorandum demanding immediate withdrawal of the corrigendum issued by the Punjab government on June 13, 2025. The corrigendum, which implements a 5% annual fee increase and formalises a compulsory service bond, has triggered protests across the state's medical institutions. 'With fees soaring to ₹ 2.49 lakh annually for government quota students and ₹ 14.94 lakh for private management quota, we are left to survive on a ₹ 15,000 stipend — the lowest in the region,' said Dr Archit Bawa of the MSA. 'If a fee hike is justified annually, why doesn't the stipend increase by the same logic?' Calling the policy 'insensitive and unjust,' students argued it would make medical education inaccessible for students from low-income families. Many pointed out that while the state government takes pride in the success of government school students in NEET-UG, a large number may not be able to afford an MBBS seat even in government colleges due to the revised fee structure. Despite 474 students from government schools clearing NEET-UG this year, financial hurdles now threaten their future. A student from Bathinda's meritorious school who scored 564 marks, and another from Abohar who scored 493, are both eligible for government seats but may not be able to join due to the steep costs. Their fathers work as a tailor and a daily wage labourer, respectively. According to the revised structure, a student would need to spend nearly ₹ 10 lakh over the course of an MBBS degree in a government college. When hostel and mess charges are included, the total climbs to ₹ 13–14 lakh. In contrast, tuition fees in neighboring states remain significantly lower — around ₹ 3.19 lakh in Himachal Pradesh and ₹ 4.5 lakh in Haryana for government colleges. A government school teacher, speaking on condition of anonymity, revealed that several meritorious students have opted for medical colleges outside Punjab under the all-India quota due to the more affordable fee structure. Meanwhile, a senior official from the Punjab medical education department defended the move, calling the 5% hike a 'routine annual revision' initiated during the previous government's tenure in 2020. 'We didn't introduce a new hike this year — it's a continuation of existing policy,' the official claimed. However, student bodies like the MSA and Resident Doctors' Association (RDA) continue to question the logic. 'If quality education is the aim, financial sustainability must also include fair stipends and equitable access,' said Dr. Mehtab Bal of RDA Patiala. Responding to the protests, Dr Balbir Singh assured the students that their concerns would be taken into serious consideration. He reiterated that the government is committed to providing subsidized, quality medical education while acknowledging the need to strike a balance between cost and accessibility.
Indian Express
13 hours ago
- Indian Express
MBBS students, kin struggle to cope with trauma and uncertain future
Beset with anxiety, parents and family members of the MBBS students of Ahmedabad's BJ Medical College and Hospital, where the London-bound Air India plane plunged into moments after taking off on June 12, are a worried lot even as many students continue to struggle with their classes suspended and no information on their resumption. The mobile phones damaged in the crash, offering limited communication, is only adding to the woes on both sides. 'I would try and convince my parents that I am fine through daily video calls but they continued to worry about my safety. Finally, I asked my elder brother to visit me in Ahmedabad. He came by train, stayed with me for a day but returned a little worried,' a third-year student from Uttar Pradesh, who was among the first rescuers to reach out to the juniors, told The Indian Express on the condition of anonymity. In the absence of the classes, the MBBS undergraduate students based in Gujarat have returned home while those from outside the state have stayed back in the college hostels hoping things will normalise soon. Since most of the undergraduate students are still trying to come to terms with the accident, the exams, according to other students, are expected to be postponed. 'After days of sleeplessness, I was able to sleep last night. But my son is still unable to sleep. He was awake the whole night telling me that he cannot sleep as he sees the crash incident again and again,' Shilaben, mother of first-year MBBS student at BJ Medical College and Hospital, Jit Bhuriya, told this paper. Most of these undergraduate students lost their mobile phones, which were damaged in the crash, restricting their access to multiple things. Jit Bhuriya along with his friends had gone to the Atulyam hostel mess for lunch on June 12 when the AI 171 flight crashed into it and the ceiling collapsed on them burying them under the debris. Initially admitted at Civil Hospital Asarwa, Jit was shifted to a private hospital in Dahod and discharged on June 18. 'There is no information about the classes or exams yet,' Jit said. Another second-year student, Ritesh Kumar from Bihar, residing in Atulyam 12 hostel for undergraduate MBBS students who lost his mobile phone in the crash is in touch with a limited number of contacts now. 'After staying for a night in the hostel following my discharge from the hospital on 14, I came back home on repeated insistence of my family,' he tells this paper. Another first-year student, Akshat Jaiswal, who sustained a fracture in his leg, has returned to his home in Uttar Pradesh's Ayodhya. His phone was also damaged in the crash. Pratham Kolcha from Mehsana with his three second-year batchmates, including his roommate, were on their way to the mess for lunch when they were engulfed by the flames of the burning fuel. All three with burn injuries are admitted at a private hospital in Ahmedabad. Family members of Kolcha, the first child in the family about to fulfill his medical dream, are concerned about his future. 'There is no intimation yet… it would be better if the classes and exams are extended,' Jagdishbhai Kolcha, an employee in ONGC Mehsana, who has been staying in Ahmedabad since June 12, told this paper. Pratham's two batchmates, who were injured along with him, are Surat resident Nikunj and Brijesh from Panchmahal. Second-year student and Anand resident Nikul Chaudhary, who is undergoing treatment at a private hospital in Ahmedabad said 'under trauma' he is 'not thinking about anything at the moment' but hoping things will get better at the earliest.
New Indian Express
13 hours ago
- New Indian Express
Two Bhopal doctors anxiously await return of children stranded in war-hit Iran
BHOPAL: Two senior Unani medicine doctors in Bhopal are waiting with bated breath for the safe return of their children, both medical students, who are stranded in war-ravaged Iran. Dr Ehsan Azmi, a medical officer at Bhopal's Government HSZH Unani Medical College, is anxious for the safe return of his daughter Areej Ehsan, a second-year (fourth semester) MBBS student. Equally concerned is Dr Shahid Khan, a medical officer at Unani Shifakhana-Bhopal, whose son Mohd Haris Khan is in the eighth semester (fourth year) of the same course. Both Areej and Mohd Haris are pursuing their MBBS at Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences in Tehran. 'Before Monday, my daughter said it seemed they were surviving in the jaws of death and destruction. But from Monday, the Indian Embassy in Tehran started working on a war footing to rescue the Indian students via the Indian Medical Students Association in the Iranian capital. We were particularly concerned about the safety of children, as there are reports that some of the nuclear scientists who were killed in the barrage of Israeli strikes, were actually from the Shahid Beheshti University only,' Dr Azmi told TNIE on Friday. Originally from Azamgarh district in eastern Uttar Pradesh, Dr Azmi added, 'We had a slight sigh of relief when we came to know about the students, including my daughter, having been shifted by the Indian Embassy from war-ravaged Tehran to Qom city (around 160 km from Tehran) on June 15."
