'He's going to be an epic failure': NFL legend calls Shedeur Sanders a fraud and warns he'll destroy the Browns
Merril Hoge delivers a sharp critique of Sheduer Sanders' NFL prospects (Getty Images)
Shedeur Sanders
' unexpected drop to the fifth round of the 2025 NFL Draft surprised many, but for former
Pittsburgh Steelers
running back
Merril Hoge
, it wasn't a shock. In a revealing radio interview just days before the draft, Hoge outlined his reasons for believing that the former Colorado quarterback might struggle to establish himself as a dependable NFL starter.
Merril Hoge questions Shedeur Sanders' readiness for NFL, cites "Mediocre" core skills
On April 23, during an interview on 102.5 WDVE in Pittsburgh, Merril Hoge recognized Sheuder Sanders as a capable college quarterback but argued that he didn't stand out beyond that level. While Sanders demonstrated some impressive plays in college, Hoge believed his fundamental quarterback abilities, like precision and decision-making, were only "mediocre."
'I think the best way to sum him up is, he's a really good college quarterback . His accuracy is good, his processing is good," Hoge said. "And when I say good, I use a scale from 1 to 10, so good is around a five."
Hoge took particular issue with Sanders' inflated 74% completion rate in 2024, attributing it to Colorado's tendency to favor short passes. He noted that more than a third of Sanders' throws (168 in total) were either behind or at the line of scrimmage. According to Hoge, this kind of statistic manipulation creates a misleading perception of a quarterback's effectiveness.
"Nobody threw more bubble screens than Shedeur Sanders when it mattered," he said."You're going to protect the kid. I get that from a coaching aspect. That's the skill set you're looking for .He ain't even close, he ain't even in the ballpark. ... There's some toughness to him I like, but how he moves, he ain't going to put fear in anybody."
Hoge's doubts didn't stop with Sanders' mechanics. He pointed to the quarterback's late-season slump at Colorado-specifically a poor showing against BYU in the Alamo Bowl-as another red flag. "He got worse as the year went on," Hoge said, comparing Sanders' bowl performance unfavorably to that of
Mitch Trubisky
.
Perhaps most damning of all was Hoge's warning to any team considering Sanders as a future franchise player: "He can't handle the expectations that are coming his way. He's going to be an epic failure and he's going set your organization back another two or three years."
In closing, Merril Hoge made it clear that he sees Shedeur Sanders as a risky investment for any NFL team. While Sanders may have name recognition and flashes of talent, Hoge believes his average skill set, reliance on short throws, and poor late-season performance raise serious red flags.
Also Read:
Did the Miami Dolphins just jeopardize their 2025 season by ignoring the cornerback position in the draft?
Hoge's blunt assessment that Sanders "can't handle the expectations" and could become an "epic failure" serves as a stark contrast to the hype surrounding the young quarterback. As Sanders begins his NFL journey, only time will tell if Hoge's warnings hold true or if Sanders can prove his critics wrong.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
YouTube's NFL coverage winning over Gen Z viewers, claims CEO Neal Mohan
Live Events (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel YouTube's NFL coverage is proving to be a hit with Gen Z viewers, according to CEO Neal Mohan . Speaking about the platform's growing role in sports streaming, Mohan said broadcasting NFL games on YouTube is helping the league connect with a younger, digital-first highlights, livestreams, and exclusive content tailored for mobile consumption, the NFL's presence on YouTube has become a key part of its outreach noted that Gen Z fans are engaging with the sport in new ways - through shorts, creator reactions, and interactive content - making YouTube an essential bridge between the league and its next generation of a recent conversation with Ankler Media founder Janice Min, Mohan said that the NFL's presence on YouTube enables games to exist alongside a wide array of creator-driven sports content - the very type of material that younger audiences actively seek out on the platform."We actually aged down the NFL's audience on our platform," claimed YouTube secured the rights to NFL Sunday Ticket , it didn't just make the service more accessible to those previously limited by DirecTV - it also created a gateway to a younger Sunday Ticket remains a premium subscription mainly appealing to die-hard fans, YouTube's broader platform reach offers the NFL a chance to engage new CEO further highlighted that the upcoming Week One matchup between the Chiefs and Chargers in Sao Paulo, Brazil, set to stream for free globally on September 5, marks a major milestone. By removing paywalls and broadcasting to a worldwide audience, the NFL hopes to draw in a fresh, younger fan base.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Alex Tuch's $59M deal update could end trade drama and lock him in long-term with Sabres
Sabres may seal the deal with Alex Tuch as $59 million extension update emerges (Getty Images) The Buffalo Sabres are approaching a crossroads with one of their key players—Alex Tuch. As the Syracuse-born winger enters the final season of his contract, the front office is staring down a complicated choice: invest in a long-term extension or explore trade options that could aid their ever-stalled rebuild. Alex Tuch's future with the Sabres gets clearer with $59M contract extension in the works Since being acquired from the Vegas Golden Knights, Alex Tuch has become a consistent force for Buffalo. His most recent campaign was a testament to that, tallying 36 goals and 31 assists. However, extending him won't come cheap. According to The Athletic, locking Tuch in for the long haul would likely require a seven-year commitment worth around $59.5 million—a deal that would stretch into his decline years. That's where the dilemma lies. The Sabres are not yet a team knocking on the door of championship contention. Committing such a hefty sum to a player nearing 30 only makes sense if Buffalo truly believes it will be a playoff threat in the next two to three seasons. Unfortunately, the franchise's long history of stop-and-start rebuilding offers little certainty in that regard. Tuch has at least made one part of the negotiation easier. He's been vocal about his desire to stay in upstate New York, giving the Sabres a leg up in talks. It's far more complicated when a player is already eyeing the exit. Still, the decision isn't just about desire—it's about direction. 'Another factor for Buffalo to consider is that there are very few teams selling right now, which could increase their return on Tuch, as some teams will be left empty-handed after the initial scramble of unrestricted free agency,' noted Josh Cybulski of Pro Hockey Rumors. He added, 'Buffalo could wait a bit after July 1 to assess the trade market and see if any moves pique their interest; if not, they could then consider an extension. ' With July 1 fast approaching, the Sabres must weigh short-term gains against long-term vision. A trade could accelerate their rebuild if the return is right. But letting go of a hometown star who wants to stay—especially one still producing—won't be easy. Buffalo's decision on Tuch could signal how much faith they still have in their current trajectory. Also Read: Florida turns into hockey heaven as Panthers throw another unforgettable Stanley Cup parade Follow all the live updates, scores, and highlights from the India vs England Test match here . Game On Season 1 kicks off with Sakshi Malik's inspiring story. Watch Episode 1 here
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Florida turns into hockey heaven as Panthers throw another unforgettable Stanley Cup parade
Panthers' victory parade returns to the beach (Getty Images) Sunshine, champagne, and sea air set the perfect stage for the Florida Panthers as they celebrated their second consecutive Stanley Cup championship with a massive beachfront parade in Fort Lauderdale. A crowd of nearly 400,000 filled the sand and streets along A1A to witness the triumphant return of the Panthers — and this time, under clear skies, unlike last year's rain-soaked celebration. Panthers go big with second Stanley Cup parade after securing NHL 's top prize again 'It's a little better day today than it was last year, but still, this is amazing,' said captain Aleksander Barkov, as he beamed in front of the crowd wearing a shirt featuring teammate Matthew Tkachuk smoking a cigar. The team paraded in style, perched atop double-decker buses and flanked by jubilant fans, many of whom waded into the Atlantic just to get a glimpse of the Cup. The rally at Fort Lauderdale Beach Park saw the Panthers fully embracing the moment, unapologetically flaunting their back-to-back glory. 'I would like to apologize to absolutely ... nobody because a double champ does whatever ... he wants,' said Tkachuk, drawing a massive roar from the crowd with a nod to UFC star Conor McGregor. Coach Paul Maurice kept things light and personal, again donning a custom shirt designed by his daughter—this time, featuring his cats Penny and Poppy wearing tiny crowns. He dubbed this 'the summer of love,' a message echoed by GM Bill Zito, who credited the players and their families for the unity and success: 'It's these players, these coaches … you wouldn't know who the superstar was or who the other guy was.' Fan chants echoed for forward Sam Bennett to be re-signed, prompting the Conn Smythe winner to close with a playful plea: 'Eight more years, please.' Brad Marchand, a key mid-season addition from Boston, soaked in the love and joked, 'I'm so happy that I don't have to play against these guys anymore.' Sam Reinhart, who missed last year's celebration due to a wedding, made sure he didn't skip this one. 'The only thing I've heard all day is how this is the best parade that's ever been had in South Florida,' he said, clearly impressed. As players danced with fans, hoisted the Cup high, and passed cigars around, the Panthers sent one clear message — winning never gets old, and neither does celebrating like kings under the Florida sun. Also Read: Panthers' Stanley Cup celebrations show no signs of slowing while looming offseason decisions stir up speculation Follow all the live updates, scores, and highlights from the India vs England Test match here . Game On Season 1 kicks off with Sakshi Malik's inspiring story. Watch Episode 1 here
