Iran-Israel conflict: Donald Trump's caution on joining Israel airstrikes rooted in fears of creating 'another Libya'
President Donald Trump's recent hesitation to authorise military strikes against Iran's nuclear facilities is rooted in a deep-seated concern: the risk of plunging Iran into chaos reminiscent of Libya's collapse after the 2011 NATO intervention.
As per a New York Post report citing multiple administration insiders, Trump has repeatedly cited the North African nation's descent into anarchy as a cautionary tale, shaping his approach to the escalating crisis with Iran.
The Libya precedent: A decade of anarchy
Libya's trajectory after the fall of Muammar Gaddafi stands as a stark warning in Trump's mind, as per the report.
In 2011, following a NATO-led bombing campaign—supported by the United States—the long-standing dictator was overthrown.
Rather than ushering in stability, Gaddafi's ouster triggered a prolonged period of civil war, political fragmentation, and violence. The country has since splintered into rival governments and militias, with no unified authority and ongoing conflict between factions based in Tripoli and the east.
Trump's frequent references to Libya are twofold, sources said: first, the chaos that ensued after Gaddafi's removal; second, the way the intervention complicated future negotiations with other adversarial states, such as North Korea and Iran.
"He doesn't want it to turn into Libya," one insider said, underscoring Trump's reluctance to repeat what he sees as a costly and destabilising precedent.
A two-week breather
In the wake of Israel's recent preemptive airstrikes on Iranian nuclear sites, Trump has opted to delay any US involvement for up to two weeks.
White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt confirmed the president's wait-and-see approach, citing the "substantial chance of negotiations" with Iran that may or may not materialize in the near future.
Iran's foreign minister is expected to meet with European counterparts in Geneva, while Trump's special envoy continues backchannel communications. The administration's posture is one of cautious patience, with Trump reportedly weighing input from advisors, international leaders, and the American public.
Limited strikes, not regime change
As per the New York Post report, sources close to the administration indicate that Trump's preferred military option, if any, would be tightly focused: limited airstrikes targeting Iran's nuclear facilities at Fordow and Natanz using 30,000-pound "bunker buster" bombs —munitions that Israel's air force cannot deliver.
The goal would be to neutralise Iran's nuclear capabilities without toppling Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khamenei or triggering a broader conflict.
'Libya was a much more extended kind of bombing commitment, and it ended up being regime change,' one source noted, contrasting it with Trump's current thinking. 'If the regime falls [in Iran], then it's not on Trump, because that's not the goal of his very limited strike'.
The president's reluctance to pursue regime change is also informed by the fear that a successor to Khamenei could be even more dangerous, and by a desire not to get entangled in the question of who governs Iran—a stance that resonates with his political base.
Trump's caution is further shaped by the broader regional context. The Middle East is littered with examples—Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Yemen—where US interventions have led to protracted instability and civil war.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
21 minutes ago
- Time of India
Iran Urges India To Condemn Israel Attack, Hopes Pakistan Won't Side With US In Gaza Conflict
/ Jun 20, 2025, 05:37PM IST Iranian Deputy Chief of Mission in India, Mohammad Javad Hosseini, has called upon India to openly condemn Israel over its military actions in Gaza. Labeling India the "voice of the Global South," Hosseini said countries that support peace must coordinate to pressure Israel and halt the aggression. 'They must first condemn Israel,' he insisted. When asked about reports of Pakistan potentially aiding US interests in the region following its Army Chief's recent US visit, Hosseini added, 'I hope Pakistan will not go for that one and will stand with Iran against Israeli aggression.' The statement signals mounting unease in West Asia as the Israel-Gaza conflict continues to spiral, drawing in global powers and regional rivals. Will India take a stand? And where does Pakistan really stand in this geopolitical tug-of-war?#iranindiastatement #israelgazawar #pakistanusnexus #indiaglobalsouth #iranpakistanalliance #middleeastcrisis #iranisraelconflict #modigazaposition #indiairanrelations #iranuspakistan #toi #toibharat #bharat #breakingnews #indianews
The Print
23 minutes ago
- The Print
Shinde & Thackeray revive Shiv Sena's classic ‘Marathi manus, sons of soil' pitch ahead of BMC polls
Meanwhile, Maharashtra Deputy Chief Minister Shinde, addressing party workers at NSCI Dome in Mumbai's Worli, hit back saying the Marathi population was compelled to go out of Mumbai because of 'those who are only remembering the Marathi manus now.' Speaking at the Shanmukhananda auditorium in Sion, Mumbai, Thackeray who heads the Shiv Sena (UBT) indicated once again that he is open to reuniting with his estranged brother Raj Thackeray, for the civic body polls without putting it in as many words. He said he is willing to 'do whatever the people of Maharashtra want' to protect the interests of Mumbai, Marathi and Maharashtra. Mumbai: Celebrating Shiv Sena's foundation day Thursday, both Eknath Shinde and Uddhav Thackeray sounded the battle cry for Mumbai's civic body, each returning to the party's roots—the Marathi manus, son of the soil. 'It is because you couldn't do anything, Mumbai's Marathi manus were driven out of Mumbai to places like Nalasopara, Badlapur, Vasai, Virar. This is your sin. Over the past 20 years, who ruled Mumbai? Everyone knows,' Shinde said, speaking at the event. Thackeray at his rally said, 'These people don't want Marathi people to come together, that's why they are paying frequent visits.' Thackeray was indirectly taunting Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis and Deputy CM Shinde who have had meetings with Raj Thackeray, who heads the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS), ever since talks about the two Thackeray cousins reuniting picked up steam. 'Whether it (the alliance with Raj Thackeray) will happen or not, we will see. You shouldn't bother about it,' added Uddhav Thackeray further alleged that the ruling Mahayuti does not want the Shiv Sena (UBT) to come to power in the Mumbai civic body so that it can continue to protect the interests of the Adani Group. 'You don't have money to give for the Ladki Bahin scheme, for state transport buses, but in Dharavi, stamp duty has been waived for the Adani Group. Where did you get that money from? Everything is free for Adani,' Thackeray said. The Adani Group is redeveloping the Dharavi slum cluster. 'This is not just our fight. In 1960, martyrs shed their blood to ensure we get Mumbai. We will not let that go to waste and let anyone finish the importance of Mumbai,' Thackeray added. Elections to all local bodies in Maharashtra are expected to be held late this year. The Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC), which the undivided Shiv Sena had ruled for 25 years till 2022, will also go to polls. The term of the general body lapsed in March 2022 and fresh elections are yet to be held. The Shiv Sena split in June 2022. The battle for the Mumbai civic body is a high-stakes one—for several reasons. The BJP has been aggressively trying to wrest control of the country's richest municipal corporation from the Thackerays, while the Shinde-led Sena is on a mission to prove itself the real Shiv Sena and show that the Thackeray brand's supposed appeal in Mumbai is a thing of the past. For the Shiv Sena (UBT), winning Mumbai is key to the immediate survival of his party especially after its debilitating defeat in the state assembly polls. Hitting back at Uddhav, Shinde said the Shiv Sena (UBT) was looking at Mumbai as a golden goose. 'Their heart is in the coffers of Mumbai. Those who stayed in power (in the Mumbai civic body) for so many years and broke the city's treasury are now remembering Mumbai…Mumbai will continue to stay with Maharashtra. Nobody can break Mumbai from Maharashtra,' Shinde said. The BJP is currently in an alliance—Mahayuti—with the Shinde-led Shiv Sena and the Ajit Pawar-led Nationalist Congress Party (NCP), ruling the Maharashtra government. Leaders from the BJP, as well as the Shinde-led Shiv Sena, have informally said that while the three parties will decide whether to have an alliance for each local body poll separately depending on the desires of the ground cadre in that region, the Mahayuti is most likely to fight the BMC election together. On Thursday, Shinde was less than subtle about his ambition of dislodging the Thackerays from the BMC. His party members presented him with a small replica of the BMC headquarters, saying the Mahayuti will rule this edifice post-election. The Deputy CM, at his event, paid tribute to former CM Manohar Joshi, known to have his fair share of differences with Uddhav. Shinde also felicitated Joshi's son, Unmesh, during his party's celebration of Shiv Sena's foundation day. Also read: 4 dead, 32 injured in bridge collapse over Indrayani River near Pune, 10-15 people feared swept away 'Come on, kill me'—Uddhav Thackeray Galvanising the crowd in front of him, Thackeray Thursday borrowed a dialogue from a 1990 Nana Patekar-starrer film, Prahar. 'I am standing here. Come on, kill me,' he urged the BJP and Shinde. 'But, when you come, bring an ambulance along since you will come walking, but will have to go back injured.' Shinde, who delivered his speech at the NSCI dome well after Thackeray had wrapped up his speech, said, 'How can we kill someone who is already dead? People of the state have already finished them in the assembly polls.' The Shiv Sena (UBT) won just 20 of the 288 assembly seats in the Maharashtra assembly election last year, while the Shinde-led Shiv Sena won 57 seats. 'I will share a little math with you,' Shinde told his party workers, elaborating how the undivided Shiv Sena's strike rate was 22 percent in 2014, 45 percent in 2019, and in 2024, while Shinde's party contested 80 seats, winning 57, the Shiv Sena (UNT) contested 85, winning just 20. 'This means their strike rate was just 23 percent. They did not get even one-third the votes that our Shiv Sena got,' Shinde said The Deputy CM said his party will contest the upcoming local body polls as an alliance with Mahayuti partners, but said that the details will be shared at a later stage. Shinde, however, stayed away from commenting on a possible Raj-Uddhav alliance. Hindi imposition Speaking at Shanmukhananda, Thackeray dove into the debate over the Modi government's proposed three-language policy and the Maharashtra government's decision to make Hindi a compulsory third language for students in all Marathi- and English-medium schools starting from the first standard. As per the state's government resolution, Hindi will be the default choice for the third language unless 20 students or more come together and demand a different third language. Speaking on the issue, Thackeray said it was a ploy to divide the state's population. 'They created a divide among Hindus over caste and now they want to divide Marathi vs non-Marathi so that we will fight among us. They want to divert attention from the real news,' Thackeray said. 'They want to impose Hindi, we won't let it be imposed. We are not against Hindi, but I will not allow compulsory Hindi in primary education,' Thackeray said, asking whether Hindi has been imposed in Gujarat. His estranged cousin, Raj Thackeray, has also raised strong opposition to making Hindi compulsory for primary schools as a default third language. (Edited by Zinnia Ray Chaudhuri) Also read: Rakhi gift before polls, now strain on coffers, how Mahayuti's Ladki Bahin scheme has undergone a squeeze
India.com
24 minutes ago
- India.com
Iran-Israel war: Can US' GBU-57 bunker buster destroy Iran's underground Fordow nuclear site? Experts make stunning claim, say Trump is unsure of...
Trump is unsure whether the GBU-57 bunker buster can take out Iran's Fordow nuclear site. (File) Iran-Israel war: US President Donald Trump has threatened to join its ally Israel in its war against Iran, demanding an 'unconditional surrender' from Tehran, and even threatening to assassinate Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khamenei. However, beyond the war rhetoric, Trump remains undecided on whether to commit the United States to a war in the Middle East which it may not be able to pull out of for at least 5-10 years, especially since the US President remains skeptical about whether its lethal bunker buster bombs have the capability to destroy Iran's underground Fordow nuclear facility. Trump unsure about bunker buster's ability to destroy Fordow site According to defense experts, Donald Trump is unsure whether even the GBU-57 Massive Ordnance Penetrator (MOP) bunker buster, aka the 'mother of all bombs', would be able to destroy the Fordow Fuel Enrichment Plant, which is basically buried beneath a gigantic mountain, and is protected by multiple units of Russian-made S-300 air defense systems. As per media reports, Trump has told defense officials that the US would be justified in attacking Iran only if the bunker buster bomb is guaranteed to destroy the uranium enrichment facility at Fordow. The US President was told that the gargantuan 30,000lbs (13.6 tonne) GBU-57 bunker buster would destroy the Fordow facility, but Trump remains unconvinced, and as such has not yet given the green light for America to join the Israel-Iran war. Additionally, experts believe that Trump is also looking at the possibility of Iran coming to the table for a 'deal' due to fear of US involvement in the Iran-Israel war. US would need tactical nukes to take out Fordow? The GBU-57, aka the bunker buster bomb, is a 30,000 pound bomb which is dropped using the US' B2 stealth bombers, and while its capable of taking out any other hardened underground facility, the Fordow site is unique as it has been specially built to withstand US' capabilities, particularly its ultra-heavy bunker buster bombs. The Fordow Fuel Enrichment Plant is a hardened, ultra-secure nuclear facility built deep beneath a mountain, and surrounded by tall peaks on all sides. The mountainous terrain renders even the most advanced cruise missiles ineffective, and the site is protected by a large number of air defense systems concentrated in a small region, making it almost impossible for any missile or drone to go through. US defense officials believe that only a tactical nuclear weapon would be able to completely destroy the Fordow nuclear facility, but Trump is not in favor of using nukes to attack the site. Quoting people familiar with the matter, The Guardian reported that Israeli intelligence estimates that the Fordow nuclear plant, which is built under a mountain near the Qom city, could be up to 90 meters deep. To reach such a depth, the US would have to have to weaken the ground with conventional bombs and then drop a tactical nuclear bomb from a B2 bomber to wipe out the entire facility. However, Donald Trump, at least for now, is not in favor of using the nuclear option, the report said.
