University fees: A parental obligation or a student's burden?
This long-standing question has sparked many debates over the years.
For older generations, the answer was often clearer: tertiary education fees were typically paid by students, especially when pursuing university studies was less common.
However, with rising incomes and the perceived necessity of a university degree in today's society, the question of who foots the bill has gained prominence.
A recent Reddit post highlighted a startling reality for some. The user, a student accepted into medical school at both the National University of Singapore (NUS) and Nanyang Technological University (NTU), expressed exasperation over their parents' refusal to fund their university degree.
To compound the issue, the student's parents also expected financial support from their children upon retirement.
While such situations may not be the norm for many Singaporean families, this case raises a pertinent question: beyond mandatory education, are parents responsible for funding their child's tertiary studies, or should young adults bear the cost themselves?
The New Paper surveyed 60 students, aged 16 to 25, from various institutes of higher learning, including Junior Colleges, Polytechnics, the Institute of Technical Education (ITE), and Universities.
Most student respondents felt that parents should pay for their child's education in a survey conducted by The New Paper on financial responsibility. PHOTO: TNP
A significant 90.2 per cent of students surveyed believe funding a child's tertiary education is an inherent parental responsibility, viewing it more as a right than something to be earned.
A 19-year-old polytechnic student commented: "I think it's unfair not to pay. When bringing kids into the world, parents have the responsibility to raise them in a safe manner, both mentally and physically. Refusing to pay [for higher education] is not ensuring a good and safe environment for children."
Some respondents suggested that if parents are unable to fund their child's education, it could indicate poor family planning, thereby creating unnecessary stress for the child.
52.5 per cent of respondents felt that parents have the right to refuse to pay for their child's school fees. PHOTO: TNP
However, 52.5 per cent of respondents also believed parents have the right to refuse to pay their children's school fees.
They reasoned that valid circumstances might exist, such as a desire to teach independence.
One university student remarked: "It depends on their circumstances and their belief system; they might feel that their child should learn independence and stop relying so much on their parents."
60.7 per cent of respondents felt that it was acceptable for parents to ask for money from working children. PHOTO: TNP
Students also had varying responses when asked whether parents have the right to demand money from their children.
Most acknowledged that, within the context of Asian culture where filial piety is emphasised, it is reasonable for parents to seek financial support from their children upon retirement.
A 20-year-old university student said: "It only seems fair, given our society's values of filial piety. Children should also develop the habit of setting money aside to support their parents, especially after their parents retire."
Reciprocity appears to be a key driver: students felt that if parents had supported them financially throughout their schooling, it is natural for children to give back when they are able.
Mr Ignatius Gan, a 21-year-old university student, suggested that financial support for parents should stem from gratitude: "Asking for money from your child should be a healthy, two-way interaction. The parents ask, and the child is happy to give."
However, other respondents felt that when financial support becomes an expectation or demand, it crosses a line.
"It no longer makes it okay, especially if your parents expect you to 'return' the money they spent raising you. Then why have kids if they're just bank investments to you?" said Miss Genevive Tan, 21.
Ultimately, many students believe that once an adult child begins earning their own income, they should decide how to spend it.
Currently, the Maintenance of Parents Act in Singapore allows parents aged 60 and older, who are unable to support themselves, to claim financial maintenance from children who have the means to provide it.
However, a key point of contention, as some see it, is that while the Act enforces an obligation, true willingness to provide support often stems from reciprocity. Children may feel more inclined to support parents if they themselves felt supported throughout their childhood. Strained parent-child relationships can complicate this, as support given purely to avoid a lawsuit may not resolve underlying issues.
Perhaps the focus should be on mending estranged family relationships and tackling the root of emotional disconnects, rather than relying solely on legal mechanisms. Laws like the Maintenance of Parents Act provide a safety net, but they cannot legislate love, trust or mutual care.
In a society where both independence and interdependence are increasingly valued, the conversation around who pays - and who gives back - will continue to evolve.
If there is one takeaway, it is that financial responsibility within families is rarely just about money. It often involves the invisible emotional debts accumulated over time, and how each generation chooses to settle them.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Independent Singapore
2 days ago
- Independent Singapore
'Do Singaporeans think that giving money to the poor makes them lazy?' Redditor asks
Photo: Reddit screengrab/u/michuang74 SINGAPORE: When a local Reddit user asked if Singaporeans disapprove of giving money to the poor as it sends the wrong message, it sparked a lively discussion, with many commenters bringing up important points for and against such a scheme. In a post on r/askSingapore on Thursday (June 19), u/AjaxCooperwater wrote, ' Generally, do Singaporeans think it is a bad idea to give money to the poor because it encourages laziness and de-incentivises job hunting?' They added that they personally do not believe that giving money to the poor 'encourages any form of stereotype behaviour,' but genuinely wanted to know the reason behind such perspectives, asking also if anyone has personally seen such a case occurring. The post was somewhat similar to another one from u/AjaxCooperwater earlier this week, when they asked how Singaporeans feel about Universal Basic Income . 'If you see a very old lady or an old man who is handicapped with one leg or one arm, do you think that even if they try hard looking for a job, any boss would want them? So, try to give them some money whenever you come across them. Sometimes, due to dignity, they refuse to accept your money without you taking something from them, such as a packet of tissues or a lottery ticket. Just take it, and say thank you,' one wrote. 'Just help if you want and in a position of being able to afford to.. most importantly, from the heart. Even one word of kindness is a type of charity,' commented another. A Reddit user outlined the reasons why a person may be hesitant to give money to the poor, which have nothing to do with being encouraged to be lazy. People are afraid of getting scammed, or are concerned that the money they give will end up in the pockets of crime syndicates. Another reason is that people from neighbouring countries might end up coming to Singapore to beg. This is why they prefer for social workers to reach out to people in need instead. 'Meritocracy can drive us to be unkind and elitist. When we work hard and land a good education and job, we believe it's our hard work that led us to be successful, and those who are poor are poor because they did not work as hard as us. But reality is never as simple as that. Success requires connections, hard work, and luck. If you're born well off, it's easier to focus on your studies, easier to build good connections,' another observed. /TISG Read also: 'JB businesses will be happy' — Singaporeans debate pros and cons of Universal Basic Income
Independent Singapore
3 days ago
- Independent Singapore
‘I'm still her child and I have feelings too': Daughter says her mum favours siblings who give more money, even though she covers most family expenses
SINGAPORE: A 27-year-old Singaporean woman took to Reddit to express how painful it is to feel overlooked in her family simply because she gives her mother less money than her siblings. 'I know my mum doesn't favour me because I can't give her more or as much money as my siblings does. I have student loans to pay from when I studied in uni and also savings,' the woman wrote on the r/askSingapore forum on Thursday (Jun 19). 'To her, I have a higher pay so I should be able to give more but I'm not giving her more. She doesn't want to understand that I have financial responsibilities because she doesn't understand the concept and value of money after not working for 20 years. All she knows is that she'll get money if she asks for it and she better get it when she asks for it.' Still, the woman said she makes it a point to show up for the family whenever she can. She shared that she's usually the one footing the bill for family celebrations. 'I've always been the one who paid for everyone's birthday when we eat out. I paid for the bill for father's day, everyone's birthdays and sometimes even mine, and my parents' anniversary. I bought the cake and gifts,' she said. 'For mother's day, I split the bill with my younger brother to treat my entire family of 6 to dinner at Arab Street eating Mediterranean food. It costed us well over $350. ' 'I didn't mind paying first, but one of my brothers transferred me half, saying that we should at least split the bill because it was a lot. My mum didn't notice or cared that I paid first and eventually forked out half of the bill. She kept on bragging to her siblings and bringing up how thankful she was that my brother paid for mother's day. Just my brother and not me.' What cut even deeper was how her own birthday was handled. Initially, she had suggested a day trip to Johor Bahru, but changed her plans when she realised her youngest brother couldn't join due to a CCA camp. Wanting everyone to be involved, she chose to have a small celebration at home instead. Her only request was simple: to have three of her favourite dishes—chilli crab, prawn fritters, and mee soto—prepared for the occasion. But even that, she said, was met with dismissal. 'On the day of my birthday, my mother sent a message in the family group chat saying that she'll be making changes to the menu. She'll only be cooking chilli crab and the prawn fritters but not the mee soto even though I offered to help her cook and clean when it's my birthday.' 'She eventually said that she was lazy because it's just another day. I was in my room doing a bit of WFH (took half day off on my birthday which fell on a weekday) and just started crying because I felt so hurt for some reason.' At the end of her post, the woman shared that she had long accepted she was not the favourite child in the family. It was something she had gradually made peace with over the years. Even so, she admitted that moments like these still hurt more than she would like to admit. 'Sometimes it sucks,' she wrote. 'I'm 27 but I'm still her child and I have feelings too.' 'I hope you will have a wonderful 28th birthday next year.' Local users quickly flooded the comments with support, telling her she's not alone and that her feelings are completely valid. Some also tried to cheer her up. One user said, 'You matter too, and if there's no one that knows how to treat you like you matter, then let's start making yourself matter to yourself first. Great things will come to you. Please, please, please don't ever put yourself down just for another person's comfort.' Another wrote, 'Happy belated birthday. I am so sorry that you went through a sad 27th birthday. We can't choose our family, but we can choose how we feel. 'I am not my mum's favourite child either, so I don't focus on her. I focus on those that love me. Yes, she is your mum and your immediate family. You need to love her, but you also need to love yourself first. I hope one day you will be able to come to peace with this and not feel upset if such a situation happens again. I hope you will have a wonderful 28th birthday next year.' A third added, 'Things will get better, don't worry. You are a good daughter in the family. Unfortunately, you can't choose your mother. Try to talk things out between you two, if that doesn't work. Consider moving out and finding a partner. In time, your mum will appreciate you more when you are not living with her.' In other news, a man in his late 20s recently turned to social media to ask how much money someone should be making before they feel ready to start dating. Posting on the r/askSingapore subreddit, he shared that he had just landed a short traineeship in data analytics within the finance sector. However, he revealed that his current pay is only in the mid-S$2,000 range. Read more: Man earning S$2K a month asks: How much do you need to earn in Singapore before you're ready to date? Featured image by Depositphotos (for illustration purposes only)
AsiaOne
3 days ago
- AsiaOne
'I just wanted a piece of nostalgia': Hundreds turn up at adoption drive to collect remaining Yale-NUS books, Singapore News
PUBLISHED ON June 19, 2025 5:22 AM By Liv Hana Roberts Hundreds of book lovers turned up at NUS Library's book adoption and exchange drive on Saturday (June 14) to pick up some of the discarded books from Yale-NUS College. Held outside the NUS Central Library, members of the public were given access to about 2,000 books. After the controversy over the disposal of hundreds of books in May, Yale-NUS College decided to host a donation drive for students, staff and their guests that month which saw "overwhelming response". 'A piece of nostalgia' Over at NUS Central Library on June 14, AsiaOne noted hundreds of people, ranging from children to graduates to elderly, queuing up and collecting books. "I just wanted to grab a piece of nostalgia," Yip, who declined to give his full name, said as he waited in the middle of a snaking queue. The 60-year-old, who studied economics in NUS about 20 years ago, added he was interested in collecting books on social sciences, humanities and history, as well as books on communication. "Yale-NUS College is closed, so they are giving away books for free, so I think that's good." The infotech worker said he felt "sad" hearing the books were dumped. "I mean I love books so if you see books being dumped they could be put to better use, somebody could use it. There's still value." Another book lover, who wanted to be known only as Chow, said he was curious to see "who are the people who would come to pick up the books". The school principal said that even though he understands the reason behind the outcry, the 52 year-old hopes the public can understand that "there is a proper way for libraries to dispose of books". He added that when books are "outdated", libraries often have their own "processes" to dispose of them and that information is often not known or accessible to the public. Many fresh graduates were also spotted at the book donation drive. One graduate, who only wanted to be known as Ping, said she wanted to check out the books as they are otherwise expensive. Ping, who had picked up books on anthropology, women in Afghanistan and slavery in America said: "There's so many people who want (the books), then you dump for what?" Jaron Lua and Sharyl Chin, both 25, and NTU English Literature graduates, said they just wanted to make sure the books didn't go to waste. Like Ping, Sharyl also noted that academic books are expensive. "We thought we should try our luck to see if we can get anything useful or relevant for our postgraduate studies." Sharyl, who picked up 18th and 19th century literature like Gertrude Stein, Jane Austin-adjacent titles and books on women's activism, added: "I think it's great that they decided to do this because you can see the whole Singaporean community come together for books. "So for me it disproves the idea that people don't read anymore." Both of them felt that the book dumping incident could have been handled better. Jaron said: "I feel like they should have considered adoption as their first option as opposed to (dumping the books)." The graduate, who collected books on Shakespeare, Italian poet Giovanni Boccaccio and English poet and author Geoffrey Chaucer, said: "They still shredded like 500 plus books… It may not seem like a lot but it actually is." Good haul Yip thought the fair was a good way for NUS Libraries to show the public that they "made an error and were trying to make amends". Yip revealed he wasn't just collecting books for himself but also for his friends and wife, who also had an interest in humanities, specifically history. Sharyl added that the event was "a really good haul" and had a "really good spread" of books. AsiaOne has reached out to NUS Libraries for more information. [[nid:718972]] NUSYale-NUSBooksStudentsUniversitydonations This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.
