Heads roll at SBCA over heritage building's demolition
Sindh Chief Secretary Asif Haider Shah has ordered the registration of FIRs against two officials of the Sindh Building Control Authority (SBCA) and the owner of Kharas House, a protected heritage property in Clifton, following its illegal demolition during the Eid holidays.
The move came after an inquiry report by the Karachi commissioner, which held the demolition of the colonial-era structure - located at Plot No FT-4/14, Bath Island Road - unlawful and revealed a premeditated attempt by SBCA officials and the property owner, Dhummai Cowasjee Kanja, to bypass regulatory oversight.
The chief secretary had ordered the inquiry on April 24. Its findings have triggered a wave of disciplinary actions: SBCA Director General Ishaq Khuhro has been issued a show-cause notice, while SBCA Director Ashfaq Hussain Khokhar and Deputy Director Agha Kashif have been suspended by the Local Government Department. The Services and Administration Department has suspended Pirah Mangi, Deputy Director (Heritage) at the Culture, Tourism and Archives Department.
According to the report, the SBCA's Technical Committee on Dangerous Buildings started the demolition process on January 4, 2024, without input from professional bodies such as the Pakistan Council of Architects and Town Planners (PCATP) and the Association of Builders and Developers (ABAD). Despite acknowledging that Kharas House appeared to be a heritage structure, the SBCA granted demolition permission on October 18, 2024, without seeking mandatory heritage status verification from the culture department.
Perhaps most troubling, the demolition was timed to coincide with the Eid holidays - when government oversight would be minimal. The report stated that it was the deputy commissioner for District South, not the SBCA or culture department, who first took action to halt the demolition.
The inquiry also uncovered attempts by SBCA to retroactively cover up its role: demolition notices were issued only after work had begun, and no timely communication was made with the assistant commissioner to prevent the damage. Terming the case a "clear example of misconduct and manipulation," the report has recommended criminal proceedings against the SBCA officials involved as well as the property owner.
The entire matter was also brought to the knowledge of the Chief Minister Sindh, who reviewed the findings of the inquiry and fully endorsed the actions taken against the responsible officers. The Chief Minister expressed grave concern over the unlawful demolition of a protected heritage site and emphasized the need for strict accountability and reiterated the government's firm stance on the protection of Sindh's cultural heritage.
Chief Secretary Asif Hyder Shah has also instructed the Culture Department to immediately begin a citywide survey and mapping of all declared heritage buildings in Karachi. The Chief Secretary also directed that disciplinary proceedings be initiated against the Deputy Director (Heritage), Culture, Tourism, Antiquities & Archives Department, under the applicable Efficiency and Discipline (E&D) Rules, for failure to discharge duties and prevent the illegal demolition. The Chief Secretary emphasized that any individual found involved in endangering or destroying the cultural heritage of Sindh would face severe legal and administrative consequences.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
12-06-2025
- Express Tribune
Six drowned picnickers' corpses retrieved
The bodies of six members of two families who had drowned in in the Indus and Jhelum rivers have been found. In Bhakkar, a family outing to the Indus river ended in tragedy when a 21-year-old woman drowned along with her two young cousins. According to local officials, a six-year-old girl slipped into the river, after which her 13-year-old sister jumped in to save her. Seeing both girls drowning, their 21-year-old cousin also leapt into the river to rescue them. However, the strong current swept all three into deeper water. Upon hearing the screams for help from Lal Shah, the husband of the woman, local residents began a search and retrieved the bodies from the river after about half an hour. Bhakkar District Police Officer Shehzad Rafiq Awan told The Express Tribune that the deceased woman had been married 15 days earlier and was visiting a relative, Syed Taqqi Shah, in Jhok Jando, along with her husband, from the nearby town of Behal. Due to the river's proximity, they had gone for sightseeing at the Basti Mian Khan dyke with the two young cousins. The funeral of the woman was held in Kathanwalla and of Taqi Shah's daughters in Jhok Jando. The DPO explained that the incident had occurred during daytime and the water was seven to eight feet deep at the spot where the six-year-old girl had drowned. Her 13-year-old sister and newlywed cousin jumped into the same dangerous area in an attempt to save her, resulting in all three losing their lives. As the area descended into gloom over the tragedy, the official emphasised the importance of avoiding to take young children to the riversides. He suggested that even adults should prefer alternative locations for recreation. Meanwhile, the bodies of three members of a family from Kot Lashkari Khan in Sahiwal district were retrieved from River Jhelum. The family had gone to the river for recreation on the third day of Eid. A woman was taking selfies near the river when she slipped into the water. Her sister attempted to rescue her. Eventually, four family members were swept away while trying to save each other from drowning. Local residents managed to save one young man, Zeeshan Anwar. Sarfaraz Raja, his wife Nida and sister-in-law Nazia Sajjad drowned in the river. Their bodies were found seven kilometres downstream 20 hours later. The bodies were retrieved by local divers and teams from Rescue 1122.
Business Recorder
12-06-2025
- Business Recorder
Babar's plea against harassment by FIA: Urgent hearing to take place today
ISLAMABAD: The Islamabad High Court (IHC) fixed for urgent hearing today (Thursday), a petition filed by ex-senator Farhatullah Babar against alleged harassment by the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA). The petition was filed Wednesday under Article 199 of the Constitution by advocates, Imaan Mazari and Hadi Ali Chattha against the Ministry of Interior and the FIA and others as respondents, 'Seeking intervention of Court against the unlawful, illegal, arbitrary and mala fide conduct in continuously harassing the petitioner through repeated issuance of ambiguous and illegal notices and summons, in what is an illegal fishing expedition/roving enquiry by the FIA in violation of laws and principles of natural justice.' The petition said that the FIA enquiry was initiated on March 25 on the complaint of a private citizen, unknown to him, living in Morgah, Rawalpindi alleging 'suspected corruption, tax evasion and illicit asset accumulation' and he appeared before the FIA on March 28 a day before Eid holidays. No copy of the complaint was provided to him. Interestingly, on 11 April 2025, a detailed questionnaire of 12 questions was slammed at him through WhatsApp, directing him to answer them all by 7 April 2025, four days prior to receiving it. The questions delved deep into the past, requiring collecting information from multiple offices within and outside the country. Despite this, the petitioners provided answers to all the questions. Instead of acknowledging the answers provided to the questionnaire, the FIA then asked the petitioner on May 27 to explain the source of properties which it claimed to have received from the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) when he served as senator and also explain some banking transactions, within five days. The petitioner rejected the alleged transactions of Rs1,500,000 in his account on 3 April 2025 and another alleged transaction of Rs3 million on 5 July 2025 (almost a month away in the future). Thereupon, the petitioner was then directed to appear in person, the petition said. Just when the petitioner prepared replies to these questions, the FIA sent him another notice by WhatsApp, asking him to appear in person, disregarding the previous notice to send written replies. A day before Eid on June 6, Farhatullah Babar uploaded on X (formerly Twitter) extracts from his replies to the FIA and said; 'Two days ago, FIA regurgitated questions already replied to by me on May 12. One Q alleged transaction of 3 M on 5-7-25 (still a month away). Just when replies were being readied, the FIA WhatsApped to appear in person next day (June 5) on eve of Eid holidays. I couldn't appear in person and sent this reply.' Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
10-06-2025
- Express Tribune
Newlyweds commit suicide on railway track
A newlywed couple committed suicide by jumping in front of a train after not receiving money for their honeymoon. Police handed over the bodies to the families after completing legal procedures. Police said Sajid, a 34-year-old power loom worker and resident of 202 Rab Bhaiwala Adeel Town in the jurisdiction of Millat Town Police Station, had married Razia about two and a half months ago. The couple had planned to go to Naran for their honeymoon after Eid. Sajid asked his elder brothers, Fahad and Zahid, for money, but they were unable to arrange any funds. Early Tuesday morning, Sajid left home with his 30-year-old wife, Razia Bibi, and went to the Bhaiwala railway crossing near Chairman Stop. He called his brother Zahid and told him, "I am going to commit suicide with my wife. Come and collect our bodies." After the phone call, Sajid and his wife lay down on the railway tracks. At that moment, the Badr Express train heading from Lahore to Karachi arrived and both husband and wife committed suicide by coming under the train. They died on the spot as their heads were severed from their bodies. Upon seeing the bodies on the railway track, Sajid's elder brother Zahid reached the site and, with the help of passersby, collected their remains. Passersby informed the police. Millat Town police arrived at the scene and, after completing legal formalities, handed the bodies over to the family. Police said the deceased worked at a power loom and had married Razia Bibi two and a half months ago. The couple took their own lives after becoming disheartened when Sajid's brothers could not provide the money they had requested for the honeymoon. Neighbours said that just 15 days after the marriage, the couple was forced to live separately by their families.
