Stolen Generations survivor Kath Ryan reflects on her life after WA redress scheme announced

More than 60 years ago, Stolen Generations survivor Kath Ryan was pulled screaming from her mother in Western Australia's Gascoyne region.
WARNING: This story contains details that may be distressing for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander readers.
At just seven years old, she became one of thousands of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children in Australia taken from their families.
Years later, her own daughter was taken from her. But in the years since, she has reconnected with her family, graduated university and is proud to be a grandparent.
On Tuesday, the WA government announced Stolen Generations survivors would be eligible for payments of up to $85,000 as part of a landmark redress scheme.
It leaves just Queensland as the only state or territory without a compensation scheme for survivors.
Ms Ryan, a 72-year-old Yinggarda elder, was at the steps of WA's Parliament House when the announcement was made.
"It's wonderful. I cried when [Noongar traditional custodian] Jim Morrison told us," she said.
Ms Ryan was born in Carnarvon in 1953, her skin much lighter than her single mother's.
It put authorities on alert, with Ms Ryan's hardworking mother always on the move to evade welfare officials.
When they eventually caught up to her, she was powerless to act when a seven-year-old Ms Ryan was shoved into a paddy wagon and taken away.
"I was screaming and kicking and stuff like that. I saw my mum walking off and she didn't look back," she said.
"The penalty was back in the day if you kicked up and carried on, you would be thrown in jail."
Ms Ryan was placed in a Church of Christ mission in Carnarvon, where she spent her days carrying out domestic tasks and looking after the younger children.
When she was about 12 years old, she was sent to live with a family in the affluent Perth suburb of Cottesloe.
She said the prospect of going to a big city was exciting, and she went to a private school where she worked hard.
But she felt keenly the absence of her family and other children who looked like her.
During this time, she fell pregnant and was sent to a home for women and babies.
But as soon as her daughter was born, she was taken from Ms Ryan.
"I had no choice in the matter," she said.
Ms Ryan went on to have six other children, whom she vowed to keep close.
"No way was I going to let those other six go," she said.
Ms Ryan returned to Carnarvon in her 20s but received a shock when she was ostracised by her family.
"It's sort of like … as we say in our language, 'you've been living with Wadjela people, you've got to live that life now'," she said.
But she persisted in rebuilding a relationship with her mother, whom she only spent a combined nine years with before her death in her 90s.
As well as taking away precious time with her family, her experience as a Stolen Generations survivor also made Ms Ryan doubt her intellectual abilities.
It was not until a friend convinced her otherwise when she was in her mid-30s that she pursued a university education, graduating with a degree in community health.
Her granddaughter is now following in her footsteps and is pursuing a law degree.
"It makes me so proud," she said.
Now retired, Ms Ryan enjoys spending time with her grandchildren and other Stolen Generations survivors.
But she said she feels deeply the loss of other survivors who died before the announcement of redress this week.
"It was great to hear it, but a great sadness as well, because the Aboriginal people don't have a good life span. I'm fortunate, I never in my wildest dreams thought I'd reach 60, let alone 72," she said.
"For the unfortunate ones that have passed … it's a little bit too late."
For some time, Ms Ryan wanted to keep her story close out of feelings of shame.
But she said the time for silence had long passed.
"People need to know that these things happened," she said.
"With this truth-telling and stuff like that, hopefully we'll make a lot of people realise these things are true, they're not just made up."
The state government estimates there to be between 2,500 and 3,000 survivors of the Stolen Generations in WA.
Registrations for the redress scheme are expected to open later this year, with payments to follow towards the end of the year.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Advertiser

13 hours ago

• The Advertiser

Death in custody case under scrutiny as ministers meet

An Indigenous death in custody case is being closely watched by the federal government after a territory leader vigorously opposed an independent inquiry. Senator Malarndirri McCarthy said ahead of a meeting of the Joint Council on Closing the Gap in Darwin that deaths in custody had to end and the Commonwealth was deeply concerned about the issue. The federal minister for Indigenous Australians said there could be heated debate over deaths in custody and harsher youth crime laws as she met with state and territory counterparts and Coalition of Peaks members on Friday. The coalition represents more than 80 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander community bodies comprising about 800 organisations and is a formal partner with Australian governments on Closing the Gap. Friday's meeting follows the death in custody of Kumanjayi White on May 27 after being forcibly restrained by two plain clothes officers inside a supermarket in Alice Springs. Police allege the 24-year-old, who had a mental disability and was in care, was shoplifting and assaulted a security guard. Despite multiple calls for an independent inquiry, NT Chief Minister Lia Finocchiaro and acting police commissioner Martin Dole rejected the proposal, saying NT Police were the best to investigate the death. Senator McCarthy has been among those calling for an independent inquiry. When asked on Friday if the federal government might intervene and convene a national cabinet on the issue, she said "we are watching very closely". Prime Minister Anthony Albanese would be briefed on the Closing the Gap meeting and its debates on deaths in custody, high Indigenous incarceration rates and tougher youth crime laws, she said. Federal Attorney-General Michelle Rowland was also deeply concerned about deaths in custody and would discuss the issue at an upcoming meeting with state and territory counterparts, the senator said. Scott Wilson, the acting lead convenor of the Coalition of Peaks, said outcomes for Indigenous people were improved when Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander organisations were properly resourced. "On the issue of youth justice and child protection, our kids are harmed by the system that should protect them," he said. The coalition wants a national strategy to address the drivers of youth detention and high number of Indigenous children in out-of-home care. "That is poverty, unstable housing, racism and lack of access to services," Mr Wilson said. "Locking up 10-year-old kids isn't justice, it's a failure of policy and compassion." Deaths in custody and high incarceration rates were not accidents but outcomes of a system that needed deep systemic change, including eliminating racism in police, courts and corrections, he said. All states and territories have introduced crime crackdowns after spates of violence and lawlessness, largely involving young people. In Queensland, children as young as 10 will face adult jail time for a range of new offences after the state government in May passed its second tranche of controversial youth crime laws. The NT government recently passed tougher bail laws, which are expected to lead to a surge in the territory's prison population, including more Indigenous youth inmates. 13YARN 13 92 76 Lifeline 13 11 14 An Indigenous death in custody case is being closely watched by the federal government after a territory leader vigorously opposed an independent inquiry. Senator Malarndirri McCarthy said ahead of a meeting of the Joint Council on Closing the Gap in Darwin that deaths in custody had to end and the Commonwealth was deeply concerned about the issue. The federal minister for Indigenous Australians said there could be heated debate over deaths in custody and harsher youth crime laws as she met with state and territory counterparts and Coalition of Peaks members on Friday. The coalition represents more than 80 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander community bodies comprising about 800 organisations and is a formal partner with Australian governments on Closing the Gap. Friday's meeting follows the death in custody of Kumanjayi White on May 27 after being forcibly restrained by two plain clothes officers inside a supermarket in Alice Springs. Police allege the 24-year-old, who had a mental disability and was in care, was shoplifting and assaulted a security guard. Despite multiple calls for an independent inquiry, NT Chief Minister Lia Finocchiaro and acting police commissioner Martin Dole rejected the proposal, saying NT Police were the best to investigate the death. Senator McCarthy has been among those calling for an independent inquiry. When asked on Friday if the federal government might intervene and convene a national cabinet on the issue, she said "we are watching very closely". Prime Minister Anthony Albanese would be briefed on the Closing the Gap meeting and its debates on deaths in custody, high Indigenous incarceration rates and tougher youth crime laws, she said. Federal Attorney-General Michelle Rowland was also deeply concerned about deaths in custody and would discuss the issue at an upcoming meeting with state and territory counterparts, the senator said. Scott Wilson, the acting lead convenor of the Coalition of Peaks, said outcomes for Indigenous people were improved when Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander organisations were properly resourced. "On the issue of youth justice and child protection, our kids are harmed by the system that should protect them," he said. The coalition wants a national strategy to address the drivers of youth detention and high number of Indigenous children in out-of-home care. "That is poverty, unstable housing, racism and lack of access to services," Mr Wilson said. "Locking up 10-year-old kids isn't justice, it's a failure of policy and compassion." Deaths in custody and high incarceration rates were not accidents but outcomes of a system that needed deep systemic change, including eliminating racism in police, courts and corrections, he said. All states and territories have introduced crime crackdowns after spates of violence and lawlessness, largely involving young people. In Queensland, children as young as 10 will face adult jail time for a range of new offences after the state government in May passed its second tranche of controversial youth crime laws. The NT government recently passed tougher bail laws, which are expected to lead to a surge in the territory's prison population, including more Indigenous youth inmates. 13YARN 13 92 76 Lifeline 13 11 14 An Indigenous death in custody case is being closely watched by the federal government after a territory leader vigorously opposed an independent inquiry. Senator Malarndirri McCarthy said ahead of a meeting of the Joint Council on Closing the Gap in Darwin that deaths in custody had to end and the Commonwealth was deeply concerned about the issue. The federal minister for Indigenous Australians said there could be heated debate over deaths in custody and harsher youth crime laws as she met with state and territory counterparts and Coalition of Peaks members on Friday. The coalition represents more than 80 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander community bodies comprising about 800 organisations and is a formal partner with Australian governments on Closing the Gap. Friday's meeting follows the death in custody of Kumanjayi White on May 27 after being forcibly restrained by two plain clothes officers inside a supermarket in Alice Springs. Police allege the 24-year-old, who had a mental disability and was in care, was shoplifting and assaulted a security guard. Despite multiple calls for an independent inquiry, NT Chief Minister Lia Finocchiaro and acting police commissioner Martin Dole rejected the proposal, saying NT Police were the best to investigate the death. Senator McCarthy has been among those calling for an independent inquiry. When asked on Friday if the federal government might intervene and convene a national cabinet on the issue, she said "we are watching very closely". Prime Minister Anthony Albanese would be briefed on the Closing the Gap meeting and its debates on deaths in custody, high Indigenous incarceration rates and tougher youth crime laws, she said. Federal Attorney-General Michelle Rowland was also deeply concerned about deaths in custody and would discuss the issue at an upcoming meeting with state and territory counterparts, the senator said. Scott Wilson, the acting lead convenor of the Coalition of Peaks, said outcomes for Indigenous people were improved when Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander organisations were properly resourced. "On the issue of youth justice and child protection, our kids are harmed by the system that should protect them," he said. The coalition wants a national strategy to address the drivers of youth detention and high number of Indigenous children in out-of-home care. "That is poverty, unstable housing, racism and lack of access to services," Mr Wilson said. "Locking up 10-year-old kids isn't justice, it's a failure of policy and compassion." Deaths in custody and high incarceration rates were not accidents but outcomes of a system that needed deep systemic change, including eliminating racism in police, courts and corrections, he said. All states and territories have introduced crime crackdowns after spates of violence and lawlessness, largely involving young people. In Queensland, children as young as 10 will face adult jail time for a range of new offences after the state government in May passed its second tranche of controversial youth crime laws. The NT government recently passed tougher bail laws, which are expected to lead to a surge in the territory's prison population, including more Indigenous youth inmates. 13YARN 13 92 76 Lifeline 13 11 14 An Indigenous death in custody case is being closely watched by the federal government after a territory leader vigorously opposed an independent inquiry. Senator Malarndirri McCarthy said ahead of a meeting of the Joint Council on Closing the Gap in Darwin that deaths in custody had to end and the Commonwealth was deeply concerned about the issue. The federal minister for Indigenous Australians said there could be heated debate over deaths in custody and harsher youth crime laws as she met with state and territory counterparts and Coalition of Peaks members on Friday. The coalition represents more than 80 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander community bodies comprising about 800 organisations and is a formal partner with Australian governments on Closing the Gap. Friday's meeting follows the death in custody of Kumanjayi White on May 27 after being forcibly restrained by two plain clothes officers inside a supermarket in Alice Springs. Police allege the 24-year-old, who had a mental disability and was in care, was shoplifting and assaulted a security guard. Despite multiple calls for an independent inquiry, NT Chief Minister Lia Finocchiaro and acting police commissioner Martin Dole rejected the proposal, saying NT Police were the best to investigate the death. Senator McCarthy has been among those calling for an independent inquiry. When asked on Friday if the federal government might intervene and convene a national cabinet on the issue, she said "we are watching very closely". Prime Minister Anthony Albanese would be briefed on the Closing the Gap meeting and its debates on deaths in custody, high Indigenous incarceration rates and tougher youth crime laws, she said. Federal Attorney-General Michelle Rowland was also deeply concerned about deaths in custody and would discuss the issue at an upcoming meeting with state and territory counterparts, the senator said. Scott Wilson, the acting lead convenor of the Coalition of Peaks, said outcomes for Indigenous people were improved when Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander organisations were properly resourced. "On the issue of youth justice and child protection, our kids are harmed by the system that should protect them," he said. The coalition wants a national strategy to address the drivers of youth detention and high number of Indigenous children in out-of-home care. "That is poverty, unstable housing, racism and lack of access to services," Mr Wilson said. "Locking up 10-year-old kids isn't justice, it's a failure of policy and compassion." Deaths in custody and high incarceration rates were not accidents but outcomes of a system that needed deep systemic change, including eliminating racism in police, courts and corrections, he said. All states and territories have introduced crime crackdowns after spates of violence and lawlessness, largely involving young people. In Queensland, children as young as 10 will face adult jail time for a range of new offences after the state government in May passed its second tranche of controversial youth crime laws. The NT government recently passed tougher bail laws, which are expected to lead to a surge in the territory's prison population, including more Indigenous youth inmates. 13YARN 13 92 76 Lifeline 13 11 14

ABC News

17 hours ago

• ABC News

Murujuga traditional owners 'sidelined' in government's North West Shelf approval

A group of Murujuga traditional custodians is calling on the federal government to immediately release the conditions attached to its 40-year extension of Woodside's North West Shelf gas project. Federal Environment Minister Murray Watt waved through the approval three weeks ago, allowing Australia's largest oil and gas facility to continue operating in Western Australia's Pilbara region until 2070. Ngarluma woman Samantha Walker penned a letter to the government on Tuesday last week, gathering signatures from multiple traditional owners and elders with connections to the landscape. "Our people have not consented to the proposal," she wrote. Mr Watt gave Woodside 10 days to respond to the approval's "strict" conditions, which he indicated focused on the protection of ancient Aboriginal rock art. Last Friday, the gas giant breezed past that deadline and neither Woodside nor Mr Watt could confirm the date negotiations would be finalised when asked by the ABC. Ms Walker said she was "alarmed" that the right of reply was afforded solely to Woodside. "We understand there are statutory requirements, however, the approvals process has sidelined Murujuga Ngurrara-ngarli [Murujuga traditional owners]," she wrote. "They have a process with Woodside and the government, but they don't take into account our cultural processes, which we have as well, which is very saddening." Ms Walker repeated calls for Mr Watt to visit Murujuga — the Aboriginal name for the Burrup Peninsula — where Woodside's main processing plant is located, about 1,500 kilometres north of Perth. The area is home to some of the world's oldest known rock art, the preservation of which became a flashpoint amid the extension decision. The Murujuga Aboriginal Corporation (MAC) administers cultural matters involving the peninsula on behalf of five language groups: the Ngarluma, Mardudhunera, Yaburara, Yindjibarndi, and Wong-Goo-Tt-Oo peoples. The corporation was formed in 2006 and granted joint management of Murujuga National Park in exchange for extinguishing native title rights to land earmarked for industrial development. The chair of MAC, Peter Hicks, flew to Canberra this week to meet with Mr Watt. Mr Hicks said he was confident findings of a two-year rock art monitoring program, carried out by MAC and the WA government, showed the North West Shelf project was not currently harming the ancient petroglyphs. The rock art is central to the organisation's bid to have Murujuga listed by the United Nations as a World Heritage site. This goal was thrown into doubt by a UNESCO draft decision calling for the area's industrialisation to be halted, triggering protests from the federal government. While Ms Walker backed the embattled World Heritage push, she said more consultation on the North West Shelf project and its impact was needed. "Broader consultation means speaking with the whole community, all of the families, the connections who have a connection to the place," Ms Walker explained. "The minister needs to speak to us, according to our cultural protocols," she said. She argued that the violation of traditional owners' informed consent was grounds for a human rights complaint, and current economic arrangements between Woodside and traditional owners had become obsolete. "It is severely remiss of the Commonwealth to consider approving a major project while relying on an outdated agreement that is in urgent need of modernisation," Ms Walker said. Mr Watt did not respond to specific questions put to him by the ABC. Samantha Hepburn, a professor at Deakin Law School, said it was not typical for proponents to miss response deadlines, although this case was "unique" given its magnitude and the extent of public interest. Dr Hepburn believed Mr Watt possessed the legal discretion to make the conditions public and would be "justified" in doing so because the approval was so controversial. "We see a broad range of the community very, very concerned about the impact that this extension is likely to have and wanting to make sure that the conditions are capable of addressing those concerns," she said. The decision to extend the major gas project is currently facing court challenges on several fronts. Dr Hepburn said publicising the conditions would be a show of good faith ahead of federal environmental law reform, the subject of high-level talks hosted by Mr Watt on Thursday. "Showing a preparedness to be responsive to the concerns, I think, is a very, very important thing that the government has the opportunity to [do]," she said. Ms Walker said she had only received a response from WA Senator Dorinda Cox, who could not be reached for comment.

ABC News

19 hours ago

• ABC News

Roger Cook, Rita Saffioti deliver budget that aims to insulate WA economy from global shocks

For everything governments say about their priorities, budget papers reveal where their real intentions lie. WA Premier Roger Cook's first budget since being elected in his own right has a clear theme, and for the first time in a few years, it's not cost-of-living relief. Those immediate pressures, at least according to the budget papers, are largely in the rear-view mirror. Don't worry, the state's coffers are still overflowing with iron ore royalties, which have remained higher than expected, and huge GST payments from the Commonwealth. Cook and Treasurer Rita Saffioti's first post-election budget pays for the basics, then looks to use the rest to start re-shaping the state's economy. If it goes to plan, that will mean being less reliant on importing many products by manufacturing more locally, and diversifying what the state exports to the world. "If we don't explore these opportunities to value-add, to have more local manufacturing, then we will be filled with a lot of regret in 10 years' time," Saffioti told reporters yesterday. As you'd expect, industry is already singing the government's praises. "Just like Taylor Swift, the government's entered a new era," Chamber of Commerce and Industry chief economist Aaron Morey said. "It's moving from the roads era to the industrial era [with] significant funding in ports, water, energy — so critical to the future of the WA economy." It's a bold ambition, and one many have spent years calling for. It's also well-timed, according to the government, to see the state through the global shocks ahead. But, like everything in life, it comes at a cost. To be clear, the cost isn't as great as it might have been in other places, thanks to two of the WA budget's familiar friends: GST payments and iron ore royalties. Royalties have benefited from an iron ore price that has remained higher for longer than expected, although it is expected to fall over the years ahead. That would probably still leave the books in decent shape, but luckily for Saffioti, WA's GST take will also be rising. Together, those sources will continue to account for about a third of the state's revenue. Other states are continuing to battle deficits, and no doubt another year of seeing WA's surpluses towering over them from across the Nullarbor will be met with the usual complaints. But given Western Australia again rewarded Anthony Albanese for his deference to the state, it's unlikely he will be racing to change those arrangements, despite the significant cost to the Commonwealth budget. It gives the government financial power that many others could only dream of. That power is nothing new, of course, and especially since COVID has been focused on two areas: immediate cost-of-living relief and building the Metronet projects that helped Labor get elected in the first place. This budget effectively places both in the past. Only a portion of Metronet projects remain unfinished, and the government's headline cost-of-living measure — hundreds of dollars off households' electricity bills — has been scrapped. Instead, the bulk of the government's infrastructure spending — some 40 per cent, or $15.1 billion over the next four years — is being put towards power and water infrastructure and ports. Saffioti told parliament that infrastructure would enable private sector investment, which would help build a "fortress" around the state's economy, like the state did during the pandemic. "While not a worldwide pandemic, the global instability and volatility we now face means we must once again stand together to repel any economic threat," she said. But some West Australians will be left wondering if such a heavy focus on the future is slightly premature. The government argues economic pressures have eased, which is true, looking at key indicators. Inflation has cooled, and there are signs the rental market is stabilising, even if prices remain higher than many can afford. Saffioti said that meant the risk of global turmoil had overtaken the cost of living as the most pressing issue for the government. "We don't want WA to be collateral damage in global economic chaos," she told the ABC. But people are still doing it tough, with ShelterWA still reporting "overwhelming" demand for housing support services. "The question really has to be asked: where is the cost-of-living pressure relief, [with] the cost of water up, the cost of electricity up, the cost of emergency services levy up?" Opposition Leader Basil Zempilas said yesterday. The government's solutions are targeted, which helps with not fuelling inflation again, but means some miss out. The $337 million on offer for residential battery rebates and no-interest loans is great for those who own a home, and works into plans to develop a local battery manufacturing industry, but does nothing for renters or people without solar panels. Another round of the up-to-$250 student assistance payment would be welcome relief for families, but it means nothing for anyone without school-aged children. And capping public transport fares at one zone will save $196, but it isn't much good for people not near public transport, or who need to drive for their work. The bigger, structural relief the government is promising will take some time to come. More housing will be years away, given the long game of catch-up the construction sector is playing after a post-COVID population surge. Secure skilled local jobs will also take time to materialise as the government's money to grow local industries filters through boardrooms and into construction and jobs. And pressures on the health system look set to continue, with those on the front line having little hope that promised changes will make that big a difference. It won't be easy, even with time and money. Successive governments have tried to break WA's boom-and-bust cycle without any luck. And that global uncertainty Saffioti wants to protect the state against could arrive faster than her fortress. Luckily for the government, the next time voters will have a chance to pass judgement on their plans is in four years. By then, they should have a sense of whether that fortress has been built or crumbled under the weight of reality.