Number of kids who died under Ontario's care network reaches new high
A total of 134 children died under the umbrella of Ontario's care network in 2023, according to new data, the highest number since the provincial government began consolidating and tracking the figures.
Internal data obtained by Global News using freedom of information laws summarizes and records the number of children who died in care, with an open social work file or a case that had closed within 12 months.
Over the three years, between 2020 and 2022, an average of 118 kids were recorded to have died. The number equated to roughly one child every three days.
Now, the most recent figures show the number has risen.
In 2023, there were 134 deaths for children under Ontario's care network, compared to 121 in 2022, 129 in 2021 and 104 in 2021.
Story continues below advertisement
The Ford government began tracking the data in its current configuration in 2020.
'It is very concerning,' Ontario Liberal MPP John Fraser told Global News. 'These children are our responsibility, our government's responsibility — that's what we do when someone comes into care, what we used to call a ward of the Crown. It's our duty to make sure that they're safe.'
The government data breaks down the ages of the 134 children who died and where they were in the system.
Among them, it shows 37 infants aged two months to one year associated with the care network died, along with 35 teenagers and 18 toddlers.
Only six of the deaths were for children actively in the care of an agency, and the vast majority — 92 — had an open child protection file. Other deaths related to children who had their child protection file closed within the past 12 months.
Get breaking National news
For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
The government did not respond to questions from Global News, nor did it acknowledge a request for an interview with Michael Parsa, Minister of Children, Community and Social Services.
Parsa previously called similar data a 'profound tragedy' and said his government would do 'everything we can' to ensure children have support. He did not provide a timeline or target to reduce the figures.
Story continues below advertisement
The government has been tracking the number of children who have died over the past four years. Global News
Fraser said the most concerning part of the data was the number of cases recorded where the cause of death remains unknown.
In 2023, 32 per cent of recorded deaths for children associated with care were unknown. Medical deaths were the next largest cause at 25 per cent, followed by accidental at 16 per cent.
While the number of unknown deaths is lower in previous years, roughly one-third of all deaths in 2020, 2021 and 2022 were listed as undetermined.
'How do we have such a high number of undetermined reasons?' Fraser said.
'That number seems really high, it's something you have to dive into and look at. You imagine that's someone's child, would that parent be satisfied with an undetermined conclusion? Well, these children, we've said their our children now as a government.'
Story continues below advertisement
The data captures all deaths, from accidents, suicides or homicides to medical situations. It includes times where neglect could be a factor, as well as situations like car accidents or medical episodes.
The government report said that 44 per cent of the deaths in 2022 and 2023 were investigated by Ontario's chief coroner.
1:27
Ontario minister quizzed on high number of deaths for kids associated with care
Irwin Elman, who worked as Ontario's advocate for children and youth before the office was dissolved in 2019, previously said tracking the data had already been difficult.
'There is a grey area of a number, but the bottom line for me, when I think about it, was the children,' he said last September.
'They're children who are being cared for, whose responsibility for their welfare was a system we created in Ontario… to make sure that they're loved, cared for, nurtured, have a good life.'
Story continues below advertisement
The government is in the midst of financially-focused audits of Ontario's children's aid societies.
That audit is not directly related to the deaths of children in care but instead reports of waste in the sector. When it announced them, the government pointed out that the number of kids living in care has declined, but the costs have increased.
The audits are pencilled in to be completed by the start of summer.
Fraser suggested an all-party approach should be taken to the issue of children dying under the care network — calling on the government to collaborate and strike a committee.
'Select committees are not always the solution to everything, but it's a start, it's a beginning,' he said. 'We've had them before, and they point governments in the right direction. I think it is reasonable to say this is too much, and we need to know why this is happening.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
a day ago
- Global News
Interior Health won't rule out pediatrics closure extension
What was supposed to be a six-week closure of the pediatric ward at Kelowna General Hospital (KGH) will likely extend beyond that. 'The service interruption itself is really stressful for parents but the uncertainty is even more frustrating,' said Gavin Dew, Conservative MLA for Kelowna-Mission. With the closure of the 10-bed unit now in its fourth week, Interior Health (IH) is still unable to say when it will reopen. In a statement to Global News, IH CEO Susan Brown stated, 'Interior Health leadership is fully committed to restoring full services and the entire team at Kelowna General Hospital are committed to addressing the current challenges and reopening the unit as quickly as possible.' Brown went on to say that reopening will happen as soon as it is safe and feasible but stopped short of providing a more concrete timeline other than stating, 'to build towards reopening, one new pediatrician is starting this summer with two more joining in September.' Story continues below advertisement 3:18 Kelowna General Hospital pediatric unit's troubled history The ward closed on May 26 so that the few pediatricians left working at the hospital would be available to cover critical services, such as high-risk deliveries. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Since the ward's closure, 14 young patients have needed a hospital admission and had to be transferred to other hospitals. Five of those patients were transferred to Royal Inland Hospital in Kamloops, nearly 170 km away. The other transfers involved hospitals in Vernon and Penticton. 'That's just not acceptable especially for how fast and big Kelowna is growing to not have that for people,' said Brent Watson, a Kelowna father of two young children. 'I just can't get my head wrapped around it.' Story continues below advertisement KGH doctors have gone public in recent weeks, claiming the current crisis is the result of an inadequate staffing model that often has one pediatrician on shift and makes it impossible to properly care for all the children needing their attention. However, they say the calls for change were ignored for years and prompted specialists to resign. Those resignations culminated in occasional service disruptions and now the lengthy pediatric ward closure. 'Now that they've started speaking out, they've started asking for better,' Dew said. 'I don't think this is going to stop until there's a really serious reset in the system.' That reset many doctors say has to in part involve dual pediatrician coverage 24/7. 2:01 Calls for Interior Health CEO to step down On Friday, Global News asked IH if it will commit to the change. Story continues below advertisement 'We have been moving to that split service delivery model for some time, with contracts, compensation and other solutions in place to support it, with the goal of having pediatricians assigned to both areas, one each at both the NICU and the pediatrics unit,' Brown stated. 'We remain committed to ensure all potential compensation strategies are in place to enable the additional capacity in the pediatrics unit and support a collaborative and sustainable model.' Brown is slated to retire in December. There have been calls from the BC Conservatives to fast-track the leadership transition in order for a new CEO to begin implementing long-term solutions to the crisis.
Global News
a day ago
- Global News
Pediatric ward closure at Kelowna hospital will likely extend beyond 6 weeks
What was supposed to be a six-week closure of the pediatric ward at Kelowna General Hospital (KGH) will likely extend beyond that. 'The service interruption itself is really stressful for parents but the uncertainty is even more frustrating,' said Gavin Dew, Conservative MLA for Kelowna-Mission. With the closure of the 10-bed unit now in its fourth week, Interior Health (IH) is still unable to say when it will reopen. In a statement to Global News, IH CEO Susan Brown stated, 'Interior Health leadership is fully committed to restoring full services and the entire team at Kelowna General Hospital are committed to addressing the current challenges and reopening the unit as quickly as possible.' Brown went on to say that reopening will happen as soon as it is safe and feasible but stopped short of providing a more concrete timeline other than stating, 'to build towards reopening, one new pediatrician is starting this summer with two more joining in September.' Story continues below advertisement 3:18 Kelowna General Hospital pediatric unit's troubled history The ward closed on May 26 so that the few pediatricians left working at the hospital would be available to cover critical services, such as high-risk deliveries. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Since the ward's closure, 14 young patients have needed a hospital admission and had to be transferred to other hospitals. Five of those patients were transferred to Royal Inland Hospital in Kamloops, nearly 170 km away. The other transfers involved hospitals in Vernon and Penticton. 'That's just not acceptable especially for how fast and big Kelowna is growing to not have that for people,' said Brent Watson, a Kelowna father of two young children. 'I just can't get my head wrapped around it.' Story continues below advertisement KGH doctors have gone public in recent weeks, claiming the current crisis is the result of an inadequate staffing model that often has one pediatrician on shift and makes it impossible to properly care for all the children needing their attention. However, they say the calls for change were ignored for years and prompted specialists to resign. Those resignations culminated in occasional service disruptions and now the lengthy pediatric ward closure. 'Now that they've started speaking out, they've started asking for better,' Dew said. 'I don't think this is going to stop until there's a really serious reset in the system.' That reset many doctors say has to in part involve dual pediatrician coverage 24/7. 2:01 Calls for Interior Health CEO to step down On Friday, Global News asked IH if it will commit to the change. Story continues below advertisement 'We have been moving to that split service delivery model for some time, with contracts, compensation and other solutions in place to support it, with the goal of having pediatricians assigned to both areas, one each at both the NICU and the pediatrics unit,' Brown stated. 'We remain committed to ensure all potential compensation strategies are in place to enable the additional capacity in the pediatrics unit and support a collaborative and sustainable model.' Brown is slated to retire in December. There have been calls from the BC Conservatives to fast-track the leadership transition in order for a new CEO to begin implementing long-term solutions to the crisis.
Global News
a day ago
- Global News
B.C. desperately needs a 2nd forensic psychiatric hospital, report finds
B.C. needs a second forensic psychiatric hospital to deal with a constant demand for beds, a new report has found. A forensic psychiatric hospital is a facility where people who have committed a crime or been involved with the law have been found not criminally responsible for their actions. Under Canadian law, a person is found not criminally responsible if a judge finds they committed a criminal act under the influence of mental illness and they cannot possess the capacity to understand that their behaviour was wrong. There is only one forensic psychiatric hospital in the province, located in Coquitlam and known as Colony Farm. The facility has 190 beds. The province also has six forensic clinics for people who have received a conditional discharge, where they do not have to attend Colony Farm but must take part in monitoring and ongoing treatments. Story continues below advertisement The annual report from the British Columbia Review Board states that the number of people found not criminally responsible remains the same as the previous year, which remains the highest it has been since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic. However, the number of accused people discharged by the board who have had their cases closed has decreased from pre-pandemic years. 'It is likely that the impact of dramatically reduced community-based services for forensic patients,' the report states. As a result, the board found that Colony Farm is under constant pressure as more new accused people are being admitted than are being discharged. Get weekly health news Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday. Sign up for weekly health newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'Of course, the Board cannot discharge patients when it is unsafe to do so,' the report states. 'Further, the Board regularly hears of accused persons who are in the community but are not complying with the Board's orders. In many cases, these accused ought to be returned to custody.' With limited beds available, the board said an obvious solution is a second forensic psychiatric hospital. 'The Board notes that Ontario has 11 forensic hospitals serving a population of 15.9 million. B.C., by contrast, has one forensic hospital serving a population of 5.6 million,' according to the report. Story continues below advertisement 4:14 B.C. premier comments on Vancouver Chinatown stabbings Colony Farm was thrust into the spotlight again after a man who was on an unescorted leave from there stabbed three people at a festival in Chinatown in 2023. Blair Evan Donnelly pleaded not guilty earlier this year in the stabbing case. However, this was not the first time he had been involved with the law. In 2006, Donnelly said God wanted him to kill his 16-year-old daughter, Stephanie, when they were living in Kitimat, B.C. According to court documents, on Nov. 23, 2006, Donnelly went to the kitchen and grabbed a knife, stabbing his daughter several times, first in the chest and then in the neck. After the attack, Donnelly went to the church and prayed, according to the documents. Story continues below advertisement On Jan. 23, 2008, a judge found Donnelly not criminally responsible due to mental disorder in the second-degree murder of his daughter. He was sent to Colony Farm. In 2009, Donnelly was before the courts again in Surrey. That file is currently sealed, but according to a 2011 report in the Vancouver Sun, the B.C. Review Board granted Donnelly unescorted leave and a violent incident involving a weapon took place. The story also said that in February 2009, Donnelly was granted unsupervised community visits up to 28 days in length. It was during one of these visits in October later that year that he stabbed a friend and was held criminally responsible for that incident. In 2023, then-Vancouver police Chief Const. Adam Palmer said Donnelly was out on a day pass when he allegedly stabbed three people in an unprovoked attack at the family event in Chinatown. Donnelly could go to trial later this year.
