Anger in Cork as once-popular Cobh strand set to remain closed indefinitely due to lack of funds
A rocky strand around half a kilometre long between the Titanic Memorial Garden and Cuskinny Strand, Battery Strand was closed in June 2013 on public safety grounds following an inspection by an engineer involved with the Cobh Landslide Programme.
For generations the Battery Strand was a popular place for locals in the seaside Cork town to swim and bathe. The strand was accessible via a gate in the Memorial Garden's boundary wall, but that gate has been locked for the past dozen years.
The closure has been controversial, especially around summer-time each year. However, the local authority doesn't see much hope of getting funding to shore up the cliff.
Responding to a motion by Councillor Sinead Sheppard (Fine Gael) at this week's Cobh Municipal District meeting, Municipal District Officer Páraig Lynch said that there are no plans to reopen access while the current situation remains.
He said that the most likely solution to the issue would be to shore up the cliff face, which would have the effect of essentially covering the beach area, thus rendering it inaccessible. Mr Lynch added that while 50 to 70 metres of the cliff are owned by the local authority, the bulk of it is owned privately.
A 2020 report prepared for the Municipal District by the County Council's Coastal Management Section found that there was evidence of slippage along the cliff face and a medium to high risk of collapse. The report also stated that the works necessary to stabilise the cliff face wouldn't meet the criteria of the OPW's Minor Flood Mitigation Works and Coastal Protection Scheme.
Cobh Municipal District members were advised at that time that works to shore up the cliff could cost in the region of €500,000.
Speaking at this week's Cobh Municipal District meeting, Councillor Sheppard said the strand was "closed correctly but we need to raise it and to exhaust every avenue."
Councillor Cathal Rasmussen (Labour Party) said the decision to close the strand was on health and safety grounds and the cost involved in fixing it would be "huge." He added that "we've tried everything and made no progress." Councillor Anthony Barry (Fine Gael) said remediation would be "very costly" while Councillor Ger Curley (Independent Ireland) concluded that "it's probably not viable to be doing it."
However, local man Peter Kidney disputes the opinion of the local authority. A petition he set up in 2021 calling for access to the Battery Strand to be restored gained 1,317 signatures. Speaking to The Irish Independent, he queried whether all funding possibilities have been exhausted:
ADVERTISEMENT
Learn more
"Have the municipal authority made any application for funding to central government? Why spend €144 million on cleaning the water in the lower harbour if you deny people access to the amenity?"
He believes only a small portion of the strand is owned privately and the bulk is owned by Cork County Council and the municipal authority. He also thinks there's a safety risk to having access to the beach closed off.
"There is no other access to the strand for two miles so if a yacht or small boat is in trouble they can only be rescued from the water," Mr Kidney said.
In January 2023 the Crosshaven lifeboat had to beach itself to take onboard a man who had fallen on cliffs at the strand as paramedics and fire service personnel were unable to extract the patient by land.
Researchers at UCC are currently carrying out a study into coastal erosion in County Cork. For now, it looks like state funding won't be forthcoming to fix the Battery Strand. Councillor Rasmussen said: "We tried everything to get money, everything was shot down. It's very difficult, it was a great amenity and is a huge loss to the town."
He said the plans he saw for shoring up the cliff would require an L-shaped prop from the cliffside to the water. There's also the difficulty of access with everything needed for a shoring-up effort having to come in from the water side of the strand, he added.
Funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
Plan to build 70 houses and apartments in scenic Waterford seaside town denied
Fewer Harrington and Partners applied to the local authority on August 21, 2024, for the construction of Strandhill Phase 2 housing complex at Crobally Upper, Tramore, County Waterford. The applicant sought permission to build 70 residences, consisting of 14 two-storey, four-bed, semi-detached houses, 28 two-storey, three-bed, semi-detached houses, four two-storey, three-bed, terraced houses, two three-storey, dormer four-bed detached houses and one four-storey, split level apartment block. The apartment block was to house six two-bed duplexes and eight two-beds. The proposed development would have also included internal roadways to connect to Strandhill Phase 1, currently under construction, a new pedestrian access, new boundary treatments, landscaping, drainage and all associated site works. Submissions and observations were lodged by numerous local residents, expressing concerns about the development. One local resident expressed concerns about the 'biodiversity of the area and planet'. 'We are in a climate crisis and need all the plants, trees and shrubs to help with this. The original hedge on the racecourse road should never have been allowed to be taken out by the developers. We should be encouraging wildlife not destroying their habitats. 'I have issues with the possibility that the vast green open space bordering site B on the main Waterford road would be relinquished by Waterford City and County Council. 'This is a very attractive green space which adds to the character of the area, especially as it is visible to all who enter the town. It is a much needed green space and walking along this stretch gives the onlooker a sense of physical and mental wellbeing. 'If it was acquired by the developer… it would mean the removal of the beautiful 100mtr long griselinia hedge. This took years to mature and must not be removed. 'This green open space was the subject of a CPO by Waterford Council many years ago to assist with an infrastructure project. It would be an insult to the previous owners if this section was placed back in the hands of private ownership. 'It was acquired by the council for the benefit of the public and must remain so. I am unsure as to the regulations pertaining to CPOs but this would be a counterproductive move.' 'Tramore is growing rapidly with several ongoing housing developments and I understand the need for more housing, but developers must not be allowed interfere with public green spaces and hedges which are there for our wellbeing and the wellbeing of our natural habitat.' Another resident said the positioning of a four-storey block of 22 apartments on the main R675 Waterford to Tramore road in such a visually prominent location 'will greatly detract from the character of the area.' The apartments would alter 'the landscape and streetscape of Crobally Upper'. 'A prominent urban edge is not what is required on the entrance to Tramore and these apartments, if approved, would set a worrying precedent for future high rise developments. Tramore has a uniqueness that must not be jeopardised. The main entrance to our lovely town is not suitable for high rise apartment blocks.' They also raised concerns over health and safety issues, visual impact, fumes, overdevelopment, traffic, parking, and excessive noise levels, adding that 'the Creeslough incident in Donegal highlighted the dangers associated with apartment blocks positioned too close to a garage'. The council refused permission on Tuesday, June 17, citing two reasons. The council stated that it had regard for the location of the proposed development on a prominent site on the main road into Tramore town, the excessive level of cut and fill proposed at the site, in particular the levels of fill proposed, and the associated excessive differences in levels throughout the site. 'It is considered that, by reason of the design and layout of the proposed development and the poor relationship with the Waterford Road (R675), with insufficient contribution to the development of a new urban public realm, the proposed development would represent a substandard form of development creating a poor urban edge and streetscape which would also seriously detract from residential amenities in the area.' Furthermore, the proposed development would be contrary to policy objectives of the Waterford City and County Development Plan, 2022-2028, which seek to ensure all developments are of a high quality design with a focus on 'placemaking, cognisant of their context and need for variety, distinctiveness, focus on public realm and design'. Additionally, the planning authority was not satisfied that it had been demonstrated that it was technically feasible to the satisfaction of Uisce Éireann, as the water authority, to connect to the public water supply and the public foul sewer connections in the area. 'In the absence of the confirmation of feasibility with Uisce Eireann that connection to public water supply and foul sewer are feasible and acceptable, it is considered that the proposed development would be premature pending the confirmation of feasibility of connections to water supply and foul sewer to serve the proposed residential development. 'The proposed development would therefore be prejudicial to public health and contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area,' concluded the council.
RTÉ News
3 days ago
- RTÉ News
Call for more thatching courses to save 'uniquely Irish craft'
There has been a call for more thatching courses around Ireland in order to save the "uniquely Irish craft". Fine Gael Senator Manus Boyle said that thatching is at risk of dying unless investment into training is urgently made. He said that a Heritage Council course in thatching in conjunction with the Kilkenny and Carlow Education and Training Board saw great interest and that similar courses need to be extended around the country. "There are only ten master thatchers in the whole country," he said. "It's something we really need to get on top of very quickly. If anything happens to these ten people, the whole trade is going to die away. "I really want to see the young people take it up," Mr Boyle added. "Even if they don't use it as a trade, get the gift of knowing how to do it. "So that they can pass it on down through the years." Mr Boyle said he has a list of thirty names who would be interested in learning the skill in Donegal. "It's something I really believe in. It's part of our heritage," he said. The senator said he remembers his own grandfather's house being thatched and that it was a "week's work from the time you cut the rushes". "It's something that came up through my heritage and I would like to see it being kept alive and well for the generation to come," he said. "Originally, it was always passed down from father to sons, then my generation missed out." Mr Boyle said there are approximately 2,000 thatched buildings that need constant maintenance and a one-year waiting list for most repair jobs. "You're on a waiting list for the thatcher to come," he said. "This time of year would be very busy. "If we could only get another 20 from the whole country, just to keep the tradition alive so that it could be passed on to the next generation." Mr Boyle added that thatched houses are an important part of the Irish landscape that tourists "really love" to see them. "The Americans loved the thatched house," he said. "You'll always see the cars pulled up outside of the thatched house and them taking a photograph." 'Every village should have a thatcher' Meanwhile, Wexford thatcher Matt Whelan said that he cannot keep up with the amount of people who want to learn the skill from him. "I can't take them all. I am so busy," he said. "There are so many emails, so many people looking and it's heartbreaking." He believes that "every village should have a thatcher" for the craft to be kept alive. Mr Whelan grew up in a thatched house and completed a Fás course in Rosslare, Wexford 33 years ago. "They brought a master thatcher over and he taught the course," he said. "They had an 80% success rate." Mr Whelan runs the Irish School of Thatching in Kilmore Quay but said that Ireland lacks a "structure of teaching". He said that there is "no set technique" in Ireland and that he has heard some "horror stories" where people have "paid €20-40,000 and the roof is gone in a matter of three or four years". "There are different levels, especially in Ireland because we haven't recognised thatching as a craft," he said. "It has always been these bohemian characters that are thatching. Their techniques vary so much. "One guy might do a roof and it might only last three years. Another guy could do a roof and it might last 40 years." He said that becoming a master of the craft takes decades of practice. "That's a word given never taken," he said.
Irish Independent
07-06-2025
- Irish Independent
Anger in Cork as once-popular Cobh strand set to remain closed indefinitely due to lack of funds
A rocky strand around half a kilometre long between the Titanic Memorial Garden and Cuskinny Strand, Battery Strand was closed in June 2013 on public safety grounds following an inspection by an engineer involved with the Cobh Landslide Programme. For generations the Battery Strand was a popular place for locals in the seaside Cork town to swim and bathe. The strand was accessible via a gate in the Memorial Garden's boundary wall, but that gate has been locked for the past dozen years. The closure has been controversial, especially around summer-time each year. However, the local authority doesn't see much hope of getting funding to shore up the cliff. Responding to a motion by Councillor Sinead Sheppard (Fine Gael) at this week's Cobh Municipal District meeting, Municipal District Officer Páraig Lynch said that there are no plans to reopen access while the current situation remains. He said that the most likely solution to the issue would be to shore up the cliff face, which would have the effect of essentially covering the beach area, thus rendering it inaccessible. Mr Lynch added that while 50 to 70 metres of the cliff are owned by the local authority, the bulk of it is owned privately. A 2020 report prepared for the Municipal District by the County Council's Coastal Management Section found that there was evidence of slippage along the cliff face and a medium to high risk of collapse. The report also stated that the works necessary to stabilise the cliff face wouldn't meet the criteria of the OPW's Minor Flood Mitigation Works and Coastal Protection Scheme. Cobh Municipal District members were advised at that time that works to shore up the cliff could cost in the region of €500,000. Speaking at this week's Cobh Municipal District meeting, Councillor Sheppard said the strand was "closed correctly but we need to raise it and to exhaust every avenue." Councillor Cathal Rasmussen (Labour Party) said the decision to close the strand was on health and safety grounds and the cost involved in fixing it would be "huge." He added that "we've tried everything and made no progress." Councillor Anthony Barry (Fine Gael) said remediation would be "very costly" while Councillor Ger Curley (Independent Ireland) concluded that "it's probably not viable to be doing it." However, local man Peter Kidney disputes the opinion of the local authority. A petition he set up in 2021 calling for access to the Battery Strand to be restored gained 1,317 signatures. Speaking to The Irish Independent, he queried whether all funding possibilities have been exhausted: ADVERTISEMENT Learn more "Have the municipal authority made any application for funding to central government? Why spend €144 million on cleaning the water in the lower harbour if you deny people access to the amenity?" He believes only a small portion of the strand is owned privately and the bulk is owned by Cork County Council and the municipal authority. He also thinks there's a safety risk to having access to the beach closed off. "There is no other access to the strand for two miles so if a yacht or small boat is in trouble they can only be rescued from the water," Mr Kidney said. In January 2023 the Crosshaven lifeboat had to beach itself to take onboard a man who had fallen on cliffs at the strand as paramedics and fire service personnel were unable to extract the patient by land. Researchers at UCC are currently carrying out a study into coastal erosion in County Cork. For now, it looks like state funding won't be forthcoming to fix the Battery Strand. Councillor Rasmussen said: "We tried everything to get money, everything was shot down. It's very difficult, it was a great amenity and is a huge loss to the town." He said the plans he saw for shoring up the cliff would require an L-shaped prop from the cliffside to the water. There's also the difficulty of access with everything needed for a shoring-up effort having to come in from the water side of the strand, he added. Funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme.
