MLB weighs a salary cap as potential lockout looms in 2026
For decades, Major League Baseball has stood alone among the major U.S. sports leagues as the only one without a salary cap.
Team owners may test that dynamic at the end of next year.
MLB owners as well as Commissioner Rob Manfred's office have begun privately contemplating what a new league economic structure could look like as the league heads toward a new Collective Bargaining Agreement with players, according to people familiar with the matter. The league's current CBA expires on Dec. 1, 2026.
MLB officials have discussed adding both a salary cap and a salary floor, said the people, who asked not to be named because the discussions are private. The Major League Baseball Players Association, however, has long been against a salary cap, and the group says its position hasn't changed.
The result is a potential lockout in December of next year when the current CBA expires — one that appears increasingly likely given the opposing positions of both sides.
If MLB owners are ultimately successful in forcing through a salary cap, it would end decades of limitless spending that's led to increasingly disproportionate spending between teams in the league. Critics of the format say the variability results in a competitive imbalance that reduces fan enjoyment and retention of star players in small markets.
The remaining three major sports leagues in the U.S. — the National Football League, the National Hockey League and the National Basketball Association — all have salary caps. The NHL adopted its cap in 2005. The NFL introduced a cap in 1994, and the NBA has had one since 1984.
While MLB maintains a luxury tax and revenue sharing, there's no formal limit on what teams can spend on a roster.
Manfred addressed the issue of a salary cap last week on FS1′s 'The Herd.'
'We do hear a lot about it from fans, particularly in smaller markets,' said Manfred. 'But the reality is we're two years away from the end of the [bargaining] agreement. We're just not in a position where we are talking about or have made decisions about what's ahead in the next round of bargaining. I think that a lot of water is going to go over the dam before we need to deal with that issue.'
In the meantime, the delta in spending between MLB's highest spending teams and the lowest has reached an all-time high. This season, the New York Mets are spending $323 million on players. The Miami Marlins are paying just over $67 million. There are nine teams spending more than $200 million on players in 2025, and there are five spending less than $100 million, according to MLB calculations obtained by USA Today.
When including the league's luxury tax, the Los Angeles Dodgers will spend more than $500 million — a record amount — given the value of their contracts this year, which include deferred payments. The Mets will pay more than $400 million.
The large gaps are evidence of 'a massive disparity problem,' Manfred said in a New York Times article this week.
'I am really cognizant of it, and I'm sympathetic to fans in smaller markets who go into the season feeling like they don't have a chance in the world to win,' Manfred said. 'I think our game turns on fans having hope when you enter the season. I think it's a really important issue that we need to pay attention to.'
This isn't the first time MLB has considered installing a salary cap.
In 1994, a stalemate over spending led to an MLB strike and the cancellation of the World Series that year. Players successfully prevented a cap then, and nothing has changed, according to Tony Clark, the MLBPA president since 2013.
'We've always believed in as free a market system as possible, such that the individual player can realize his value against the backdrop of teams that are interested in his services,' Tony Clark, MLBPA president, told The Athletic in February. 'A cap is an artificial lever that is the ultimate salary restrictor, independent of where you are on the salary food chain.'
Both sides appear to be preparing for an impasse.
The MLBPA has a so-called 'war chest' of money to help non-star players afford a work stoppage, and it's prepared to use it as soon as December 2026, according to people familiar with the union's thinking. The money derives from licensing fees from baseball cards, video games and other merchandise.
The size of the war chest is unclear, but people close to the matter say it's larger than that of the last round of bargaining, when it was considered a record amount.
The union executive board voted in December to withhold 100% of 2024 licensing money to prepare for bargaining to replace the current labor contract, said the people familiar.
Diverging spending
While the concept of introducing a salary cap has consistently been a nonstarter with the players' union, there's some evidence suggesting reforming MLB's economics could be good for players.
The average MLB salary hasn't kept pace with the league's increase in revenue, which has grown at a rate of 4.1% per year in the past decade, according to Joel Litvin, former president of league operations for the NBA and a lecturer at Columbia University, who teaches a course called 'The Business of Professional Sports Leagues and Franchises.'
That's not the case in the NBA, NHL and NFL, which have a cap, said Litvin.
'Had salaries been tied to revenues (as they are in the other leagues), the players would have earned an additional $2.3 billion in salaries over that period,' Litvin wrote in a Sports Business Journal op-ed last month. His calculations conclude players' salaries have increased 3% per year over the past ten years.
'The best outcome — for both teams and players — would be a salary cap/revenue-sharing system, which would promote competitive meritocracy and eliminate economic risk faced by both players and teams of a revenue/salary imbalance,' wrote Litvin, who worked for the NBA from 1988 to 2015 and managed the NBA's salary cap for years.
While the MLBPA isn't against a salary floor, it views any restrictions on what a player could earn in a free market as unacceptable, according to people familiar with the matter.
Unrestricted spending has led to outsized deals in baseball, such as the Mets' 15-year, $765 million contract for Juan Soto this offseason — the largest contract in the history of American sports. The deal surpassed Shohei Ohtani's 10-year, $700 million contract signed in 2023, though Ohtani's $70 million per year remains tops in the U.S. on an annual basis.
Still, while the best MLB players benefit from the current rules, most of the league's players don't see the big bucks. This isn't all that different from any sport, where stars command the biggest contracts.
But that's where the concept of a salary floor could help tip the scales for the MLBPA. Small market clubs would be forced to pay higher salaries for their 26-man rosters.
Competitive balance
While the commissioner's office, owners and executives legally can't discuss the upcoming CBA publicly, talk in private of changing the rules has started to heat up. Executives across the league have hinted at a growing desire to address the problem — including, surprisingly, those that work for the Dodgers and Mets, the two teams who benefit most from the current league rules.
'I think greater parity would be a benefit to the game,' Dodgers CEO Stan Kasten told CNBC Sport just days after the Dodgers won the World Series last year. 'It doesn't help that our revenue per game is 10 times that of a team on the bottom. It really isn't good for anyone. We have revenue sharing in our league, so we hope to close that gap, but I think there are other ways to achieve that. We see a lot of examples in the other sports.'
Mets President of Baseball Operations David Stearns echoed Kasten's sentiments in a CNBC Sport interview earlier this year.
'I think there is a conversation that needs to occur, and it is ongoing, as to the importance to baseball closing some of those spending gaps,' Stearns said. 'I think it's primarily important because markets like Milwaukee, markets like Tampa — when you draft and develop, sign and develop a star, you should have the ability and the capability to really keep those stars in smaller markets. We've seen other sports figure out how to make that happen. Baseball has had a tougher time figuring out how to make that happen.'
While some sports fans may enjoy dynasties, more parity generally increases fan engagement — at least that's the case in the NBA, Commissioner Adam Silver told CNBC Sport in October.
'The data is absolutely crystal clear that the more competition you have, the more it drives interest in the league,' Silver said.
Eight out of the last 10 World Series champions have payrolls in the top 10 most expensive for that specific year. As the Wall Street Journal noted, since 1998, teams ranked in the top five in payroll have averaged 89 wins a season, while teams in the bottom five have averaged 74 wins.
Still, the randomness of the MLB playoffs has equalized the World Series winner. The league has had 16 different World Series champions since 1998, more than any other of the major U.S. sports leagues. Yet, just one team has won the World Series with a bottom 10 payroll since 1998 — the 2003 Florida Marlins, who ranked 21st in terms of spending.
The MLBPA views stingy owners as the principal problem in competitiveness rather than outsized spending from teams like the Mets, who haven't won a World Series since 1986, and Dodgers, who have won just two championships in the past 36 years.
The RSN problem
As the Dodgers' Kasten noted, part of what's causing spending discrepancies for MLB teams is local media revenue.
Even with nationally broadcast games, MLB teams have heavily relied on regional channels to house much of each team's games. While NBA and NHL also air games on these networks, a broader assortment of games are nationally available.
While the Dodgers make more than $300 million per year from their 25-year deal with Charter Communications (originally signed with Time Warner Cable in 2013), smaller market teams like the Marlins make about $50 million.
Those figures may decline as fewer people subscribe to the cable bundle and regional sports networks are increasingly tiered by pay-TV providers to more expensive packages, further diminishing subscriber numbers.
Main Street Sports, the largest portfolio of these regional networks, emerged from a lengthy bankruptcy earlier this year after renegotiating deals with teams. Some teams accepted lower fees, while others walked away from their networks for other options.
MLB's national media rights deals expire in 2028, and the league's goal is to sell more packages of games to both new and old media partners, similar to the NBA's recently inked $77 billion deals, people familiar with the matter have said. MLB also hopes to take back many of their local rights to sell them as new national packages, which would replace the current RSN-dominated model.
Industry bankers and consultants, however, are skeptical MLB could garner a blockbuster media rights deal akin to the NBA or NFL, even with a larger package of games. A salary cap could help MLB if it can't generate the same type of huge TV rights fees as the NBA and NFL.
MLB has recently struck deals with streamers — but they have yielded far less revenue. Roku pays $10 million a year for 18 games for its free ad-supported streaming Roku Channel, while Apple spends $85 million annually to stream 'Friday Night Baseball.' ESPN opted out of its $550 million-per-year deal with the MLB earlier this year because the sports media giant felt it was overpaying.
'Everyone knows that 2028 is going to be a reset,' said Shirin Malkani, co-chair of the sports industry group at Perkins Coie. 'The league will have a new collective bargaining agreement, and I do think they will try to get a salary cap. Without a salary cap, it's a system of haves and have-nots among the teams. Layer in the local media rights fee disparities and there can be a real disparity in terms of funding payroll.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
MLB roundup: Dodgers' Shohei Ohtani, Max Muncy too much for Nationals
June 23 - Max Muncy hit a grand slam in the sixth and a three-run homer in the seventh to help host Los Angeles rally for a 13-7 win against Washington in the rubber game of their three-game series on Sunday. The Dodgers' Shohei Ohtani had a three-run triple in the seventh, a two-run homer in the eighth and also made his second start on the mound since returning from a nearly two-year absence because of elbow surgery. He threw a scoreless first inning with two strikeouts. Nathaniel Lowe homered for the third time in the last two games for the Nationals, who had won two of three following an 11-game losing streak. Washington starter Michael Soroka took a no-hitter into the fifth inning before getting into trouble in the sixth. He allowed three runs and two hits in 5 1/3 innings, striking out a career-high 10 and walking two. Ben Casparius (6-1) allowed three runs and five hits in five innings of relief for Los Angeles. Yankees 4, Orioles 2 Jazz Chisholm Jr. hit a go-ahead two-run double with one out in the eighth inning and New York earned a series-clinching victory over visiting Baltimore. Chisholm had his seventh multi-hit game since returning from an oblique injury on June 3. He scored on an RBI single by DJ LeMahieu in the second on a play that knocked out Orioles catcher Maverick Handley and scored an insurance run in the eighth. Rookie starter Will Warren yielded two first-inning runs but pitched into the seventh for the Yankees. Ryan O'Hearn hit an RBI single and Colton Cowser hit an RBI double in the first inning, but Baltimore dropped its second straight after winning 14 of 20. Starter Dean Kremer allowed one run on five hits in 5 2/3 innings. Bryan Baker (2-3) gave up Chisholm's go-ahead hit and took the loss. Tigers 9, Rays 3 Wenceel Perez belted a two-run homer and drove in three runs and Parker Meadows hit a three-run blast to give Detroit a comfortable victory over host Tampa Bay. Spencer Torkelson and Riley Greene each scored twice for the Tigers, who avoided losing more than three consecutive games for the first time since dropping five straight July 28-Aug. 2, 2024. Before Perez's go-ahead blast in the seventh, the Rays' Junior Caminero tied the game in the fourth with his 379-foot homer to left field. It was his team-leading 19th blast of the season, the most by a Tampa Bay player before the All-Star break since Brandon Lowe hit 21 in 2021. White Sox 4, Blue Jays 2 Miguel Vargas hit the go-ahead two-run double in a three-run eighth and visiting Chicago defeated Toronto. Vargas had two hits to help the White Sox take the rubber match of the three-game series. Starter Adrian Houser finished with two runs allowed, seven hits and three walks with four strikeouts in 6 1/3 innings. Grant Taylor pitched around a single in the ninth to earn his first career save. Bo Bichette had two RBI singles and Vladimir Guerrero hit an RBI single for the Blue Jays, who finished a 3-3 homestand. In six innings, starter Chris Bassitt gave up one run, three hits and one walk with seven strikeouts. Marlins 5, Braves 3 Otto Lopez had two hits and a pair of RBIs and Kyle Stowers homered to help Miami post a rubber-game victory over visiting Atlanta. Xavier Edwards went 3-for-4 with an RBI and Sandy Alcantara (4-8) threw six innings of six-hit, three-run ball, while striking out four and walking two for the Marlins. Ronny Henriquez allowed Alex Verdugo's leadoff single in the ninth before getting Michael Harris II to ground into a double play and striking out Sean Murphy for his second save of the season. Miami also recorded its first series win over the Braves since September 2023. Brewers 9, Twins 8 Brice Turang hit a three-run homer, Rhys Hoskins hit a solo shot, and Milwaukee held on to edge Minnesota in Minneapolis. Hoskins also had an RBI double for the Brewers, who completed a three-game sweep and improved to a season-high eight games above .500. Christian Yelich went 2-for-5 with a double and an RBI to cap off a dominant series in which he drove in 10 runs in three games. Byron Buxton hit two solo home runs to lead the Twins at the plate. Ty France and Ryan Jeffers also homered for Minnesota, which lost for the ninth time in its past 10 games. Reds 4, Cardinals 1 Andrew Abbott was effective through seven innings, Matt McLain homered and visiting Cincinnati snapped a three-game losing streak with a win against St. Louis. Abbott (7-1) allowed one run on three hits and struck out three in his third quality start over his past five outings. Emilio Pagan tossed a perfect ninth for his 18th save. The Reds are the only team in the majors who have yet to be swept this season. Miles Mikolas (4-5) gave up three runs (two earned) on four hits and fanned six over five innings for the Cardinals, whose five-game winning streak ended. Pirates 8, Rangers 3 Tommy Pham had three hits, including two run-scoring doubles, to lead host Pittsburgh to a victory over Texas. Pham went 3-for-3 and drove in three runs while Spencer Horwitz had three hits and two RBIs and Ke'Bryan Hayes had two hits and two RBIs. Bryan Reynolds also had three hits as the Pirates totaled 15 overall to win for only the second time in their past eight games. Josh Jung had two RBIs and Sam Haggerty had two hits to lead the Rangers, who dropped their fourth game in their past six. Texas had taken the first two games of the weekend series. Mariners 14, Cubs 6 Cal Raleigh hit his major league-leading 31st home run and Donovan Solano drove in five runs to lead visiting Seattle past Chicago. The teams combined for nine home runs on a warm and windy day at Wrigley Field. Twenty-one home runs were hit in the three-game series. Solano and Dominic Canzone both had two home runs for the Mariners. Rockies 4, Diamondbacks 2 Mickey Moniak homered, Antonio Senzatela pitched solidly into the sixth inning and Colorado defeated Arizona in Denver. Senzatela (3-10) allowed a pair of runs over 5 1/3 innings to earn the win for the second straight start. Seth Halvorsen got the final three outs to pick up his sixth save. He was the last of five pitchers that held the Diamondbacks to five hits. Randal Grichuk had two hits and Josh Naylor scored both runs for Arizona on his 28th birthday. The Diamondbacks had their three-game winning streak snapped and managed just two runs after scoring 19 over the first two games of the series. Guardians 3, Athletics 0 Slade Cecconi tossed seven shutout innings as Cleveland blanked the Athletics in the rubber match of a three-game series in West Sacramento, Calif. Cecconi (3-3) allowed six hits with one walk and three strikeouts. Cade Smith and Tim Herrin combined for a scoreless eighth inning before Emmanuel Clase escaped a bases-loaded jam in the ninth to record his 18th save. The Athletics sandwiched a walk between a pair of singles to load the bases with one out in the ninth. Clase then struck out pinch hitter Max Muncy on three pitches before Lawrence Butler grounded out. Giants 9, Red Sox 5 Casey Schmitt, Mike Yastrzemski and Willy Adames hit home runs, Heliot Ramos collected four RBIs and host San Francisco outslugged Boston to take the three-game series. Completing his first set of games against his former team, designated hitter Rafael Devers contributed a hit, a walk and a run to the Giants' win. Powered by homers by Rob Refsnyder (his fifth), Romy Gonzalez (second) and Ceddanne Rafaela (eighth), the Red Sox took a 5-4 lead into the last of the seventh inning. The Giants scored four runs in the bottom of the stanza with the help of four hits, a sacrifice bunt and second baseman Gonzalez's throwing error that brought in the go-ahead run. Astros 8, Angels 7 Mauricio Dubon hit two home runs and drove in three runs and Jeremy Pena homered, doubled and scored twice to lead Houston past Los Angeles in the rubber game of their three-game series in Anaheim, Calif. It was the second multi-home run game of Dubon's career. Jake Meyers had two hits, two stolen bases, one run scored and an RBI, and Christian Walker doubled and had two hits and an RBI for the Astros, who won for the ninth time in the last 12 games. Ryan Gusto (5-3) picked up the win, allowing five runs on six hits over six innings while striking out seven without a walk. Josh Hader, despite allowing a leadoff homer to Zach Neto to open the bottom of the ninth, garnered his 19th save in 19 tries. Padres 3, Royals 2 Jose Iglesias' RBI infield single in the bottom of the ninth inning lifted host San Diego over Kansas City. Luis Arraez started the winning rally with a leadoff single off Daniel Lynch IV (3-2) and Xander Bogaerts lined a one-out double to left-center to push Arraez to third. The Royals inserted John Schneider to face Iglesias, but he slapped an 0-2 pitch up the middle. Shortstop Bobby Witt Jr. gloved it but his off-balance throw home wasn't in time. Robert Suarez (2-3) pitched a scoreless ninth for the win, getting help from his defense. Freddy Fermin ripped a two-out double to right-center after Drew Waters walked. But Waters was called out at home for running out of the baseline after missing the plate as he dove to avoid the tag of catcher Elias Diaz. Phillies 7, Mets 1 Jesus Luzardo held New York scoreless into the seventh inning and Edmundo Sosa hit a three-run homer as host Philadelphia cruised to victory. Luzardo (7-3) allowed only three hits in 6 2/3 innings for the Phillies, who won two of three against the Mets this weekend to move one game ahead of New York for first place in the National League East. The lefty Luzardo struck out seven and walked one as Philadelphia improved to 9-2 in its last 11 games. The Phillies had one big inning against Mets starter David Peterson (5-3), who was charged with five runs and six hits in four frames. Francisco Lindor hit a solo home run for New York, which has lost eight of its last nine games. --Field Level Media
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Kate Upton and MLB star husband Justin Verlander receive life-changing family news
MLB star Justin Verlander has welcomed his second baby with his wife, actress Kate Upton, according to a report. Upton, 33, gave birth to their son, Bellamy Brooks Verlander, on June 19, a representative for the supermodel told TMZ. Just one day later, Verlander, 42, was placed on paternity leave by the San Francisco Giants Friday to spend quality time with his wife and their new bundle of joy. The two-time World Series winner and Upton welcomed their first child - a daughter named Genevieve 'Vivi' Upton Verlander - in November 2018. The pitcher has been married to the glamorous Vogue cover model since 2017. The happy couple first crossed paths when working on the same commercial set for a Major League Baseball 2k12 video game in 2012. Verlander got down on one knee four years later and they tied the knot in a stunning Tuscan ceremony just a few days after the right-hander led the Astros to a World Series victory - his first with the franchise. The Other Woman star announced that she was expecting her first child less than a year after the couple tied the knot. Three days after celebrating their first wedding anniversary in November 2018, the couple welcomed Vivi to their family. Upton has previously revealed that their little girl is aware of her dad's fame on the mound. In 2023, Upton shared: 'She knows that he's a baseball player now. She goes to school part time in Houston, so she definitely knows that he plays baseball now.' Verlander made his MLB debut with the Detroit Tigers in 2005, before joining the Astros in 2017 going on to win two World Series titles in Houston. He had a fleeting stint with the New York Mets in 2023 before returning to Houston partway through the season. He joined the fourth team of his career - the Giants - ahead of the 2025 campaign, and has a 4.45 ERA and 47 strikeouts so far this season. Verlander will miss San Francisco's home series against the Boston Red Sox, which begins Friday night, after being put on paternity leave by the team. The earliest the pitcher could return is Tuesday, when the Giants host the Miami Marlins at Oracle Park. The MLB's paternity leave policy allows players to step away for up to three games, barring any issues requiring a longer leave. If a player requires a longer absence, the team can apply to have him join the restricted list or go on family medical leave. The Giants currently sit second in the National League West at 42-33 behind the Los Angeles Dodgers. Upton has been a regularly fixture at her husband's games, supporting him at ballparks across the country - including at Yankee Stadium when the Astros swept New York in the 2022 American League Championship Series. However, she has previously revealed that she wasn't aware how grueling the MLB's schedule was before realise chaotic her WAG lifestyle would be. 'Being a baseball wife is absolutely insane, like this schedule is wild, it's so long. I didn't know,' the 32-year-old said on the Chicks in the Office podcast in July 2024. 'I accidentally fell in love. I had no idea that there were this many games,' she went on.
Reuters
5 hours ago
- Reuters
Max Scherzer set to make Blue Jays return on Wednesday
June 23 - Future Hall of Fame pitcher Max Scherzer is set to make his return to the mound for Toronto on Wednesday when the Blue Jays play the middle game of a three-game set at the Cleveland Guardians. Manager John Schneider has officially listed Scherzer as the starter in that game. It will mark his first appearance since his Blue Jays debut versus Baltimore on March 29. "That's a huge, huge addition for us," Schneider said after Sunday's 4-2 loss to the Chicago White Sox. "That's Max Scherzer. I'll take that any day of the week." Scherzer signed a one-year, $15.5 million deal with Toronto in February. He only lasted three innings versus the Orioles in the third game of the season. He was initially placed on the 15-day injured list on March 30 with inflammation in his right thumb, but was eventually transferred to the 60-day IL. The 40-year-old has received two cortisone injections and was eligible to come off the list on May 29. He made two rehab starts for Triple-A Buffalo on June 13 and 18, fanning 12 batters and allowing two earned runs in 8 2/3 innings of work. He threw 75 pitches at Columbus on Wednesday and completed a bullpen session in Toronto on Sunday. "He's ready to go," Schneider said. "The thumb is a thing. It's a real thing. I think that getting to 75 pitches in his last start is a good thing and we just have to monitor it as we go. He knows his stuff is where it should be. I'm really, really excited to have him back." --Field Level Media
