America is showing us football in its final dictator form – we can't afford to look away
Should we give it a miss? Is it best to stay away from next summer's Trump-Infantino US World Cup? Depending on your politics the answer may be a resounding no or a bemused shrug. Some will see pure drive-by entertainment. Why would anyone want to boycott a month-long end-of-days Grand Soccer Parade staged by two of the world's most cinematic egomaniacs?
But it is a question that has been asked, and will be asked a lot more in the next year. Those who intend to travel will need to answer it by action or omission. Would it be better for dissenting media and discomfited football fans to simply no-platform this event?
The picture is at least clearer now. After a week of the new steroid-fed Club World Cup we know what this thing will feel like and who it will benefit. There is no mystery with these events now, no sense of politics lurking coyly out of sight.
Under Gianni Infantino Fifa has become a kind of mobile propaganda agency for indulgent regimes, right out in front twirling its pompoms, hitching its leotard, twerking along at the front of the parade like an unholy Uncle Sam.
So we had the grisly sight this week of Donald Trump not just borrowing football's light, but wrestling it on to his lap and ruffling its hair, burbling like a random hot-button word generator about women and trans people, while Juventus players gawped in the background.
We have the spectacle of both club and international football hijacked as a personal vanity platform for Infantino, the dictator's fluffer, the man who sold the world not once but twice. Infantino's status as a wildly over-promoted administrator has always had an operatic quality. But there is something far more sinister in his political over-reach, out there nodding along at the latest Oval Office freak-off, helping to legitimise each divisive statement, each casual erasure of process.
STAR POWER: Inter Miami's Lionel Messi reacts after scoring during the Club World Cup group A soccer match between Inter Miami and FC Porto in Atlanta, Thursday, June 19, 2025. (AP Photo/Mike Stewart)
Nobody gave Fifa a mandate to behave like this. Its mission is to promote and regulate. And yet here it is acting as a commercial disruptor in its own sport and as a lickspittle to the powerful, disregarding the human rights fluff and political neutrality enshrined in its 'statutes', offering zero transparency or accountability.
To date Infantino's only public interface in the US is a 'fireside chat', AKA approved PR interview, at the Dick's Sporting Goods stage in New York. There he is, up there on the Stage of Dick's, mouthing platitudes to pre-programmed questions, high on his own power supply, the newly acquired Gianni glow-up eyebrows arched in a patina of inauthenticity. They say celebrity is a mask that eats into the face. Take a look at what football can do to you.
And so far this tournament has presented the full grotesquery in store. What is the Club World Cup like on the ground? Pretty much the same as it is on the screen given this event is invisible in physical form beyond the stadiums.
The key takeaway is confirmation of the weirdly jackboot, cult-like nature of the Infantino-shaped universe. Even the optics are trying to tell you something, all black holes, hard surfaces, gold, power-flash.
Why does Fifa have its own vast lighted branding on the pitch like a global super-corporation or a military dictatorship? What is the Club World Cup logo supposed to represent, with its weird angular lines, the void at its heart? An obscure Stalinist plug socket? Darth Vader's space fighter? Not to mention the bizarre obsession with that shapeless and indefinable trophy, present on the big screen in every ground in weird scrolling closeup, one minute a Sauron's eye, the next some kind of finger-snapping torture instrument, with its secret draws full of ectoplasm, a dead crow, the personal effects of Pol Pot.
Mainly there is the very openly manipulative nature of the spectacle, football in its final dictator form, with a sense of utter disdain for its captive consumer-subjects. Yes, they will literally put up with anything if we pipe it into their smartphones. So here is beauty, love, colour, connection, the things you're hard-wired to respond to, cattle-prodded into your nervous system for the benefit of assorted interests. Here is football reimagined as a kind of mass online pornography. Fifa even calls its media website Fifahub.
With all this in mind some have suggested a World Cup and US boycott is the correct and logical response, not least in two recent articles published in these pages. The organisation Human Rights Watch has carried a warning about the implications of staging the tournament under the Trump regime. Guardian readers and social media voices have asked the same question from all sides of discourse.
The hostile versions of this: if you don't like it then just don't come, we don't want you anyway [expletives deleted]. If you were worried about us in Qatar, western imperialist, why are you going to the US? And from the liberal left a concern that to report on sport is also to condone a regime that sends deportation officers to games, imposes travel bans on Fifa members and is edging towards another remote war.
THE COMPANY YOU KEEP: President Donald Trump signs a FIFA soccer ball as Qatar's Emir Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad Al Thani and FIFA President Gianni Infantino looks on at the Lusail Palace, Wednesday, May 14, 2025, in Doha, Qatar, as they marked the passing of World Cup hosting duties from Qatar, which held it in 2022, to the United States, which is hosting in 2026. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)
And all the while marches football around in a headlock, snapping its underwear elastic, saying thanks, Gianni, for the distracting firework show.
This is not a normal situation. So why normalise it? Why give it legitimising light and heat? And yet, one week into the World Cup's rehearsal dinner, the only logical response is: you just have to go. Not only would a boycott serve no practical purpose; it would be counterproductive, an act of compliance for a regime that will happily operate without an opposing voice on the stage.
There are two structural reasons for this. And a third that relates to the United States itself, or at least to the idea of the United States, to its possibilities, which are not defined by Trump, by the latest military action, or by Infantino.
Most obviously, if you leave the stage you abandon the argument to the other person. Dissent remains a useful commodity. However pointless, ineffective and landlocked the process of pointing out the flaws and contradictions may have become, it is necessary to keep doing so. Qatar 2022 was a dictator show that simply sailed above the criticisms. But someone, however minor, has to make them, to offer at least some kind of counter-view.
No-platforming an autocrat's show makes no sense on a basic level. These people would prefer you weren't there in any case. Whereas in reality the people platforming and enabling Trump and Infantino are not journalists trying to give another version of events, but the people who keep voting them into power, friendly dictators, subservient football associations and client media who will be present whatever happens.
Fifa and its Saudi-backed broadcast partner Dazn are glossing up an army of in-house influencers and content-wanglers to generate a wall of approving noise. Is it healthy if these are the only voices at the show? Shouting into a void may have little effect. But you still have to shout.
Second, football does still have a value that steps outside the normal rules of show and spectacle. This is why it is coveted, courted and used like a weapon. Last week these pages carnied a logical, entirely legitimate wider view, written by two academics from City University New York, which concluded that a boycott was not just an option but 'necessary'.
At the same time, the article defined the football World Cup as something that basically has no value, 'spectacles of recreation designed to distract people from their day-to-day lives, cultural and political branding opportunities for their hosts. For authoritarians, they have long been used as a tool to distract from or launder stains of human rights violations and corruption.' Which is definitely true. But it also reads like a vision of sport defined by the most joyless version of AI invented. Under this version of events no World Cup or Olympics would have taken place, because they are essentially worthless, home only to malevolent actors, lacking any notion of colour, human spirt, joy, art, beauty or connection.
Who knows, maybe this is accurate now. It is undeniably true that the idea of football as a collective people's game is fairly absurd. Fans of football clubs struggle with this state of cognitive dissonance on a daily basis, the contrast of legacy identity and hard commercial reality. Liverpool are a community club owned by a US hedge fund. Manchester City see themselves as outsiders and underdogs, and are also owned by the Abu Dhabi royal family. Football is the enemy these days.
But both sides of this are important, because without that emotional connection, without the act of faith that enables the warm, human part, everything becomes diminished, all our institutions toxic shells. To give up is to abandon sport for ever to the dictators and the sales people, to say, yeah, this just belongs to you now. No-platforming something that still means connection and culture and history. Are we ready for that yet? There will be another version of the present at some point.
The final point is about the US, a deeply divided and unhappy place right now, and a much-derided host nation, not least by members of its own populace. What has it been like here? The evidence is that an actual World Cup is going to be very hard to negotiate, spread over vast spaces, with baffling travel times, unreliable infrastructure, and a 24-hour attention industry that is already busy gorging on every other spectacle available to the human race.
The US has a reputation for peerless razzmatazz around public events. And while this is undeniably true with cultural spectacles it invented – rock'n'roll, presidential races, galactic shopping malls, enormous food, rural tornadoes, its own continental-scale sports – the US's version of other people's specialities, from cheese to professional football, can seem a little mannered.
But the fact remains the actual games have been quite good. There has been a European-flavoured focus on tickets and empty seats. But 25,000 people on a weekday to watch Chelsea in an ill-defined game is decent evidence of willingness to stage this thing and develop the market.
The dismay at 3,500 turning up to Mamelodi Sundowns v Ulsan HD in Orlando overlooks the upside, the fact that 3,500 people actually turned up to Mamelodi Sundowns v Ulsan HD in Orlando. Sundowns get 9,000-odd even at home. How many of their South African fans can afford to travel for this? Fifa, which uses its faux-benevolence cleverly, will point out an African team received $2m (£1.7m) for winning that game. Do we want to develop something or not?
BUYING IN: Flamengo's Wallace Yan celebrates after scoring during the Club World Cup Group D soccer match between Flamengo and Chelsea in Philadelphia, Friday, June 20, 2025. (AP Photo/Derik Hamilton)
A wider point is that football here is a game beloved of immigrant populations. There is a different kind of warmth, often among people without a platform or the means to make it to the matches so far. The waiter who adores Cristiano Ronaldo. The taxi driver who wants to talk for 40 minutes about Chelsea's wastefulness with academy players. The cop who loves the Colombian national team and is desperate for his son to see them in the flesh.
As for the US itself, it still feels like false equivalence to state that this is now an actual dictatorship, a lost land, a place that doesn't deserve this show because of its flaws and structural violence. This has always been a pretty brutal nation, human life as a constant pressure wave, mainlining heat and light into your veins, but also always taking a bite.
The opening week in Miami captured this feeling, football's most hungrily transactional event staged on a sunken green peninsula, a place where the sea seems to be punching holes in the land, but which is still constantly throbbing with life and warmth and beautiful things.
There is a nostalgic attachment to the idea of the US for people of a certain age, 20th-century holdovers, brought up on its flaws and imperialism, but also its culture and brilliance. But for the visitor America does seem in a worse state than it did 20 years ago. There is an unhappiness, a more obvious underclass, a sense of neglected parts and surfaces. All the things that were supposed to be good – cars, plenitude, markets, voting, empowerment, civil rights, cultural unity, all the Cokes being good and all the Cokes being the same – seem to have gone bad.
But this is also a democracy with an elected leader, albeit one with a lust for executive power and some sinister tendencies. Mainly the US seems to have a massive self-loathing problem. Perhaps you can say it is correct in this, that Trump is enacting actual harms. But Trump is also a symptom of that alienation and perceived decline. He's an algorithm-driven apparition. Say his name enough times and this cartoon will appear. America remains a great, messy, dangerous, flawed idea of a place. What else is the world currently offering?
This is in any case where football will now live for the next year, an unquestioning supplicant in the form of its own autocratic leader. The game is not an indestructible product. It can be stretched thin and ruined by greed, is already at war with itself in many key places. It will at some point be necessary to pay the ferryman, even as the US is packed away a year from now and the sails set at Fifa House for all corners of the globe and then Saudi Arabia. However stormy the prospects, it is not quite the moment to abandon this ship for good.
The Guardian
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
‘I'm crazy… I'll beat the s*** out of you' – Heated moment furious Inter star Acerbi threatens to fight PSG fan
INTER MILAN star Francesco Acerbi threatened to fight a Paris Saint-Germain fan during a meet and greet in the US. The Italian veteran, 37, is in Seattle with the Serie A giants for the Club World Cup. 3 Francesco Acerbi got angry during a meet and greet in the US Credit: X 3 Bradley Barcola sent Acerbi to the ground during the Champions League final During a fan meet and greet, Acerbi was cheekily reminded of the moment Speaking via a translator, the centre-back was fuming with the supporter. The translator sternly warned the fan: "You must be serious with him." Acerbi then let rip in Italian, blasting: "I'm serious. Don't make fun of me - I don't like it… I'm crazy, I'll beat the s*** out of you." READ MORE IN FOOTBALL The Inter are looking to bounce back quickly from their Champions League mauling as they compete in the Club World Cup. The Italian giants are playing under new manager Cristian Chivu, with Simone Inzaghi having Most read in Football Inter drew their opener 1-1 vs Monterrey, with Acerbi playing the full 90 minutes. BEST ONLINE CASINOS - TOP SITES IN THE UK 3 Acerbi was back in action in the Club World Cup earlier this week Credit: Getty The defender was playing in his first match since the Champions League final, having turned down an Italy call-up. Acerbi missed games against Norway and Moldova, as he felt "disrespected" by boss Luciano Spalletti, who has since resigned. The 34-cap star wrote on Instagram: "It's not a decision I have taken lightly. However, I believe that in light of recent events the conditions aren't there today for me to go forward with serenity. "I demand respect. If that respect is lacking from those who should lead the group, I prefer to step aside. "I won't stay where I'm no longer truly wanted and it's clear I'm not part of the coach's project." Spalletti subsequently resigned following an awful 3-0 defeat in Norway, with Gennaro Gattuso taking over. Inter return to action this evening, as they face Japanese side Urawa Reds in Seattle. They will then conclude their group stage campaign by taking on Club World Cup 2025 Guide SOME of the world's biggest clubs are in action at this summer's Club World Cup in the United States! Chelsea, Paris Saint-Germain, Real Madrid, Man City, and Inter Miami are among the 32 teams taking part in the tournament, which runs from June 14 to July 13. The likes of Lionel Messi, Kylian Mbappe, Erling Haaland, Ousmane Dembele, Cole Palmer and Harry Kane are showcasing their skills to packed crowds across the US. INFO Everything you need to know about the Club World Cup LATEST NEWS & FEATURES Club World Cup top scorers
The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Man Utd target Victor Osimhen suffered tragic loss of mum and sold sachets of water on streets before breakthrough
VICTOR OSIMHEN is the man of the moment. His name, which means 'God is good' in his local Edo dialect, is fitting for someone whose journey reflects faith, grit and perseverance. 8 Osimhen shot to fame at the FIFA U-17 tournament in Chile with 10 goals Credit: Shutterstock Editorial 8 Osimhen at the extreme right with his Nigeria U-17 team in 2015 Credit: Nigerian U17 National Football team 8 Osimhen always wanted to play in the Premier League as a child Credit: INSTAGRAM Osimhen could soon be heading to Manchester United as Talks with Viktor Gyokeres collapsed after the striker was not happy with the Red Devils' offer and now wants to move to United are still in need of a striker and will now The move would cap a remarkable rise for the Napoli striker, who spent last season READ MORE IN FOOTBALL The Nigerian began life selling sachets of water on the streets of Lagos to survive. Watching him play today you can feel that hunger, a drive forged in the hustle of one of the world's toughest cities. For years his WhatsApp profile photo carried the words: 'Focus, hustle, and believe.' It's a mindset he still lives by. Even as global interest in him soars, Osimhen remains grounded in the values that shaped him into a world-class striker. Most read in Football His first coach, Chinedu Ogbenna, told SunSport in an exclusive interview from his base in Nigeria about how it all started for the striker Ogbenna said: 'I lived in the same compound where Victor was born. 'His father was a friend. I literally witnessed his first days on earth. 8 Osimhen with his sister while on holiday in Nigeria Credit: INSTAGRAM 'The house was a shared compound filled with kids. Even as a toddler, Victor would cry uncontrollably if the ball was taken from him. 'He could barely kick but he just needed the ball near him. That's where his love for football began. 'Life was hard, he lost his mother before he turned one. That's the kind of start he had, it tells you everything you need to know about his journey.' Breakout moment in Chile Osimhen first grabbed international attention when he won the Golden Boot at the FIFA U-17 World Cup in Chile in 2015. Nigeria had only narrowly qualified after finishing fourth in the African Championship. Team media officer Morakinyo Abodunrin told SunSport how he witnessed first hand the growth of the man who will now become one of the best in the world. Sports DESK EP17_9_16 _AP_V3 He said: 'He wasn't the finished product when he joined, but something shifted in Chile. 'He asked the team manager for Nike boots and promised to score goals in them. I didn't even think we had any but he insisted. 'True to his word he dominated the tournament in those boots, scoring 10 goals and helping us lift the trophy.' His pace, power, and clinical finishing stood out but it was his mental toughness that truly separated him. 8 Osimhen goes back home to inspire the next generation when on holidays Credit: INSTAGRAM Losing his mother early and watching his father struggle without work gave him a resilience beyond his years. Osimhen opened up to He said: 'I lost my mom in October, I do not even remember the year. "I was small. Three months later, my father lost his job. It was very hard for our family. 'My brother sold sports newspapers, my sister, oranges in the street and me, bottled water in Lagos in the middle of the traffic. "We have to survive so we stick together. 'In the evening, we were all together and we gathered the money on the table. "We gave everything to our big sister and she made food and organized everything. 'Part of my life has been a struggle to survive. But that's all I am today in the end. It's hard to classify all that but each event has created my personality.' The tough beginnings have given him the resourcefulness to survive through the harder times in his career. Former He said: 'You know how we Africans are with our mothers and he didn't have his so I think he channeled that void. 'To be honest when he first came to us for trial I didn't see much in him in the first set of games he played. 'But one of my assistants said, 'Coach, that boy in green could have something.' So I gave him another shot in the second game. 'That's when it clicked, tall, strong in the air, quick feet, and raw hunger. You could tell he could go far. 'Normally when someone is that tall you don't expect them to be that good with their feet but he had it all.' 8 It was at Lille that the world started to take note of the Nigerian Credit: AP:Associated Press German setback Following his U-17 triumph, Osimhen signed for Germany . But he played just 14 games without scoring, overshadowed by experienced forwards like Mario Gomez and Divock Origi . He was loaned to Belgian side Charleroi, where he found his form, scoring 20 goals in one season. Speaking to The Nationonline, he said:'I wasn't shaken by the criticism at Wolfsburg. I believed in myself. 'Moving to Belgium proved that difficult times can be blessings in disguise. "Many Nigerians had come to Belgium before me and succeeded. I'm proud to be among them.' A star at Lille Charleroi exercised their option to buy him for just £3million, but that same summer, Lille swooped in, using funds from He made an immediate impact, scoring twice on his debut and later finding the net against Then-Chelsea manager Frank Lampard was full of praise after watching him closely for the first time: 'He's a striker with everything, fast, strong, and technically sound. 'I'd watched clips before the game, but seeing him live was different. He's impressive and his story is inspiring.' Osimhen finished as Lille's top scorer with 18 goals across all competitions attracting attention from Europe's elite. He chose 8 He was the star man as Napoli won a historic Serie A title Credit: Getty Superstardom in Naples In 2020, Napoli signed Osimhen for a club-record £70million making him the most expensive African player in history. After two solid seasons, he exploded in 2022/23. He had missed AFCON with a facial injury and had to wear a mask which prompted the Italian media to dub him the 'Masked Assassin'. Osimhen scored 26 goals in 32 league games as he led Napoli to their first Serie A title in 33 years. He also broke George Weah's record to become the league's top-scoring African ever and won the Capocannoniere as Serie A's top scorer. In 2023, he placed 8th in the Ballon d'Or the first Nigerian ever in the top 10. But even at the height of success, tragedy struck again when his father, his biggest supporter, passed away during the COVID-19 pandemic. A fallout with Napoli followed, derailing a dream move to Chelsea . From being the club's icon he suddenly found himself sidelined, training alone, staring down six months without football. 8 Osimhan has continued his goalscoring form in Turkey Credit: Getty King of Istanbul Then Turkey . He scored 26 goals in 30 games leading Galatasaray to the league title. Since the transfer window opened he's turned down four offers from Saudi clubs including one that was offering wages of £40million-a-year. Where he goes next remains uncertain but one thing is clear, Victor Osimhen has fought through unimaginable odds. He didn't just climb the ladder, he built it one step at a time. He's earned his place among the best strikers in the world.
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Kane helps Bayern restore a little European pride with win over Boca
Bayern Munich reignited the flickering flame of European honour at the Club World Cup, battling through a tense, fiery showdown to claim a hard-fought 2-1 victory over Boca Juniors and storm into the last 16 on Friday. Backed by a roaring sea of blue-and-yellow clad fans who turned the Hard Rock Stadium into a noisy outpost of their "Bombonera", Boca Juniors fought fiercely, but Bayern's resilience shone through in the closing stages. After Harry Kane gave the German champions an early lead, Boca equalised through Miguel Merentiel, only for Michael Olise to score a late winner that lifted Bayern to the top of Group C on six points, two ahead of Benfica. Boca, on one point, remain in contention as they face amateurs Auckland City in the last round of matches while Bayern will take on Benfica. The win marked a welcome rebound for European sides, who have faced a tough run at the tournament with Porto, Paris St Germain and Chelsea all suffering recent defeats. In a thrilling second half, Boca made Bayern fight for every ball in a match brimming with tension and bite In a thunderous atmosphere, the German side made a bright start and thought they had taken the lead when Olise's in-swinging corner flew directly into the net, only for VAR to spot a foul on Boca's goalkeeper. The pressure eventually told in the 18th minute when Harry Kane latched onto a loose clearance and toe-poked a composed finish into the bottom corner after Konrad Laimer's cross from the right for his first goal in the tournament after drawing a blank in his team's 10-0 demolition of Auckland City. Serge Gnabry scrambled the ball across the face of goal minutes later, but Kingsley Coman somehow failed to connect with what would have been a simple tap-in. Manuel Neuer had little to do in the first half, though he was called into action to make two smart saves from Kevin Zenon as Boca refused to back down. The Argentine side pressed higher after the break, showing typical grit and tenacity in the duels and slightly unsettling Bayern with their relentless aggression. Spurred on by deafening chants from their travelling support, Boca clawed their way back into the contest, forcing several anxious moments in the German defence as tempers flared and challenges flew in. In the 66th minute, Olise was harassed off the ball by three Boca players and Merentiel was fed in down the right and kept his composure to skip past Josip Stanisic before firing a shot past Neuer, sending the crowd into rapture as the whole stadium trembled. Bayern's composure eventually told as Olise bent one into the bottom corner after being set up by Kane six minutes from time. Reuters
