Fix system and give Wales fair funding
Wales does not get its "fair share of rail funding" and the system must be "fixed", said a former Labour minister responsible for transport.
Plans for a £6.6bn Oxford-Cambridge rail line were previously classified as an England-only project, which means Wales could have been entitled to more money.
But the Treasury announced there was a "publishing error" in a 2020 document and it should have been classified as an England and Wales project.
Lee Waters, the Labour MS for Llanelli said the "cock-up" highlights the broader issue of how "unclear" and in need of reform the funding system is.
Anger as Oxford rail line classed as England and Wales project
Why does Wales not receive money from HS2?
Rail plan reclassified, denying Wales funding - MP
Rail in Wales is not devolved, which means funding is determined through the UK government using the Barnett formula.
Speaking to BBC Radio Wales Breakfast on Monday, Waters said: "Is it cockup, is it a conspiracy? Who knows - almost always a cockup in my experience."
But he said "it speaks to the broader truth" that "the system needs fixing".
He said: "We have not had our fair share of funding, the formula does not work to our advantage.
"It is not clear how the formula works and therefore we don't trust when things like this pop up."
Waters said only a few weeks ago the Welsh government "had to dip into our own coffers" to pay for the national insurance costs, which should be covered by the UK government as per a Treasury agreement.
"We need to reform the Barnett formula," Waters said.
"We need to have the UK treasury acting as a UK treasury for the whole of the UK, not just for whoever happens to be in government in England at the time."
He added that this is not "a party issue" because "this happened under the last government, it's happening under this government".
He said it is "the government machine" which must be "changed and fixed".
He said he is "confident" his London colleagues are ensuring Wales gets more funding, but is "less confident" they are trying to reform the Barnett formula.
He said part of the issue is there "is not a Wales pot of money for rail, we have to fight our corner in the England and Wales pot".
Waters said: "There's a UK Labour manifesto commitment to create a Wales fund for schemes so there can be transparency."
But he said he is "nervous" about "wholesale devolution of rail without the extra funding", because it comes with the responsibility of repair work.
He said: "You can argue we should get the extra funding, but it's back to 'do we trust the UK funding arrangements to do that?'"
The UK government previously said the "error" over the Oxford-Cambridge line classification "will be amended when an update is published at the spending review".
The HM Treasury has been approached for comment.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
27 minutes ago
- Yahoo
The once-booming Black Country factory that's been turned into swanky apartments
Wind the clock back 100 years and this place would have been a booming factory turning out top end bicycles and motorcycles. The tall-brick building on Paul Street, overlooking Wolverhampton's ring road, was once part of Sunbeamland. The area was named after the cluster of factories that rose up as part of the Sunbeam motorcycle works. READ MORE: The now-booming microbar in the middle of a housing estate that residents objected to Get breaking news on BirminghamLive WhatsApp, click the link to join John Marston set up the company on Paul Street, close to Wolverhampton city centre, in 1887. For the next 50 years, the city's famed bicycles and motorcycles were manufactured here until closure in 1937. The Sunbeam Factory, which was built in the early 1900s, still stands today with the company's name adorned on its walls. Industrial use continued there until 1990 before the building fell into disrepair for around 25 years. However it was snapped up by developers for £7.5million and planning permission was given for the conversion of 171 luxury apartments in 2022. Now apartments have gone on sale offering a "modern and lavish living experience" - but you'll have to fork out more than the UK average if you want to live at the former Sunbeam Factory. Latest statistics put the average rent price of a two-bedroom apartment at £1,124 per month in the United Kingdom. However if you'd like to live at the Sunbeam Factory, estate agents are asking for £1,600 per month. But residents will benefit from a fully-equipped gymnasium, co-working rooms and lounge areas, a barista bar and landscaped gardens to unwind and enjoy nature. In addition, apartments come with air conditioning, a 55-inch Sky Glass TV with ultimate package and kitted out rooms. An advert for the property on Rightmove said: "Introducing Sunbeam Apartments, where elegance meets comfort for a truly luxurious living experience. "Each apartment is equipped with top-of-the-line amenities to ensure a modern and lavish living experience. "A range of studios, one-bedrooms, and two-bedroom apartments, designed to offer modern living at its finest. "Each residence at Sunbeam Apartments boasts stylish interiors and state-of-the-art amenities, ensuring a superior standard of comfort and convenience."
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
University of Reading looking for residents to join steering group
The University of Reading is looking for two local residents to join its community engagement steering group. The group, launched two years ago, is chaired by Vice-Chancellor Professor Robert Van de Noort. It meets three times a year to provide strategic oversight of the university's community engagement activities. Professor Van de Noort said: "A key part of our university strategy is to be engaged with our local community. "This means working in partnership with local residents to understand how we as a university can best serve our community." The outgoing members, Andrea Malcolm and Hiral Patel, have helped to make the university campuses more accessible to all community groups during their two-year membership. They have also been instrumental in launching the community champions network. Andrea said: "I wanted to make a positive difference where I live. "Being part of the steering group allowed me to support community-focused events and projects that promote partnership, awareness, and local opportunities." Hiral added: "I joined the steering group to strengthen the partnership between local communities and the university, motivated by my deep connection to both." The university is inviting expressions of interest for the role by Friday, June 27. No previous experience of being part of a steering group or working with the university is required, but strong local connections, a good understanding of the area, and a passion for community engagement are essential. The appointments will last for the 2025/26 academic year, with the possibility of extension, and travel expenses will be paid.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
'We're not getting enough people through the door': Village pub closes
A village pub has closed less than a year after being taken under new management. Ben's at The Legion in Blackrod posted on social media that it had closed with "immediate effect" this week. The former Heroes of Blackrod, on Manchester Road, was taken over by husband and wife Ben and Nikki Haydock in October 2024. The post states: "It's with great regret that we have to announce that Bens at The Legion has closed permanently with immediate effect. More: 'Lovely' pub that's opened in former home of Coronation Street's Rovers Return More: Bolton restaurant to be closed for the day - as 9,000 staff prepare to party More: Closed town centre bar hopes for 'light at the end of the tunnel' with new venue "We've ploughed a ridiculous amount of time, effort and money into the venue but unfortunately, we're just not getting enough people through the door for the business to be viable. (Image: Ben Haydock) "We would like to say a huge thank you to all our staff for their hard work and dedication and also express my gratitude to all of our customers for your support during our brief stay. "If you got a taste for our ale you're more than welcome to visit us at Ben's Tap & Bottle Shop where we also have a great selection of craft cans and even more on our website (Image: Ben's Brewery) "To be frank it doesn't feel great to be yet another of the growing numbers of pubs closing but we'll dust ourselves down and crack on. "Thank you for some good memories Blackrod and all the best for the future." The building was formerly the Blackrod Royal British Legion Club before closing its doors in August 2012. The family's microbrewery, Ben's Tap and Bottle Shop, remains open in Chorley town centre. The Bolton News attempted to contact the pub's management, but they had no further comment to make. In 2024, close to 300 pubs closed down across England and Wales — a rate of around six per week — according to the latest figures from the British Beer and Pub Association (BBPA). The association, which represents more than 20,000 establishments, revealed that 289 pubs shut over the past year, leading to the loss of over 4,500 jobs.
