Kenya's pact of silence with its military is breaking
When the Kenyan government blocked the public screening of a BBC documentary investigating the military's role in the killing of protesters, it was about more than censorship. It was about protecting a decades-old pact – a silent agreement between the military, the state, the media, and the public: the army stays out of overt politics, and in return, no one looks too closely at what it's doing.
That pact is now under threat, and the backlash has been ferocious.
Government-aligned MPs have accused the BBC of inciting instability, calling for the broadcaster to be banned from operating in Kenya. Social media campaigns have been launched under hashtags like #BBCforChaos, framing journalism as sabotage. But what is really being defended is not national security, it's the manicured silence that has kept Kenya's military above scrutiny.
This decades-long silence has been carefully cultivated since independence. Two failed military coups, in 1971 and 1982, and the terrible records of military regimes across the continent, instilled a lasting fear of soldiers as political actors. To avoid future insurrections, successive governments kept the army well-watered and fed in their barracks and out of the headlines. In return, the public – and especially the media – looked away.
No see, no coup.
But behind the scenes, the Kenya Defence Forces (KDF) were growing in strength. Throughout the 1990s and 2000s, they expanded their capabilities, acquired new hardware, and cultivated a myth of discipline and professionalism.
The invasion of Somalia in 2011 brought the KDF out of the shadows. Now centre stage, the military took up the banner of patriotic warriors fighting terrorism and instilling discipline into the famously corrupt civilian public service. In the following decade, the administration of President Uhuru Kenyatta appointed retired and serving military personnel, including the then-defence forces chief, to a variety of civilian governance roles. But as the military's power and visibility expanded, there was little expanded public oversight and scrutiny.
This is despite the very public failures that came in the aftermath of the ill-advised invasion which shattered the myth of integrity and competence. The invasion itself, launched to great media fanfare, was soon bogged down. After a yearlong slog to the Somali port of Kismayo, Kenyan troops were almost immediately implicated in a smuggling racket, trafficking sugar and charcoal out in collusion with al-Shabab, the very enemy they were sent to fight. In 2016, at least 140 soldiers were killed in a single al-Shabab attack on the KDF base in El Adde – Kenya's deadliest battlefield loss.
Back home, things weren't going much better. The invasion inspired a wave of terrorism. The KDF's bungled and criminal response to the 2013 attack on the Westgate mall in downtown Nairobi which killed 68 people, badly exposed it. Soldiers systematically robbed the mall while pretending to battle terrorists. Less than two years later, the military was back in the news, having again bungled the response to an attack on the Garissa University College, which left 147 people dead.
Throughout all this, the military responded with silence and spin. There was no public inquiry. No reckoning. No accountability. Similarly, there were few calls for accountability when the KDF grabbed a chunk of Lenana Road, a major Nairobi thoroughfare, to expand its headquarters, or when its top brass were implicated in attempts to influence the 2022 presidential election. None of these incidents sparked serious media investigation or political debate about the military's role.
Kenya's mainstream media have largely internalised the terms of the pact. Defence reporters rarely publish anything critical of the army. Many function more as conduits for military press statements than as independent journalists. The KDF, in effect, enjoys a veto over how it is portrayed.
That's what makes the BBC documentary so dangerous – not because it poses a real threat to stability, but because it disrupts the performance of silence. It challenges the idea that the military is untouchable, and that truth about its conduct must be suppressed for the greater good.
But a viable democracy cannot be built on fear. Kenya cannot thrive while shielding one of its most powerful institutions from public accountability. If journalists are vilified for telling the truth, and if media houses censor themselves to stay in favour with generals, then the line between civilian rule and military impunity is already dangerously thin.
The real threat to national security is not the BBC. It is the refusal to confront the army's failures and abuses – and the willingness of so many to stay silent in the face of them.
Kenya must break the pact. The military must be accountable not just to its commanders, but to the people. And journalism must be free to expose the truth, even when it makes the people with guns uncomfortable.
The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera's editorial stance.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Qatar Tribune
5 days ago
- Qatar Tribune
Lebanon's energy sector on the cusp of transformation, says minister Joe Sadd
Tribune News Network Doha Lebanon's new Minister of Energy and Water, Joe Saddi, outlined steps on how to rebuild his country's faltering economy and energy industry during a candid and forward-looking conversation in the latest episode of the Al-Attiyah Foundation podcast. In a wide-ranging interview,Saddi, a former Chair of Strategy & Middle East and a veteran of major regional privatisation efforts, outlined Lebanon's pressing energy challenges and the ambitious steps being taken to rebuild a fractured system. Speaking with host Nawied Jabarkhyl, the minister emphasised the need for institutional reform, transparency, and private-sector engagement to unlock investment and stabilise electricity supply. 'Lebanon has endured one of the most severe peacetime economic crises globally,'Saddi said. 'But for the first time since 2019, we have a glimmer of hope. There's a path, a tough path, but nevertheless there is path that if we follow, we should be able to get through the thick of it.'At the heart of this transformation is the country's electricity sector, which has long suffered from decades of underinvestment, regulatory stagnation, and chronic described the absence of new power plant development over the last 15 years as a critical failure, compounded by ineffective governance. 'Tens of billions of dollars were spent without a single new plant being built,' he stated. To rebuild credibility,Saddi is reviving long-dormant legislation, most notably Law 462, passed in 2002 but never implemented. This law calls for the unbundling of generation, transmission, and distribution, and the creation of an independent Electricity Regulatory Authority. He has prioritised the Authority's establishment, receiving over 340 applications for its five positions in a matter of weeks signaling renewed public trust in energy sector reform. The minister also spoke of major infrastructure upgrades, including the construction of at least one new power plant and modernisation of the national transmission grid, envisioning financing these initiatives through international and domestic private partnerships. Renewables are also central to Lebanon's energy highlighted the untapped potential of solar energy and the pivotal role of regulatory reform in enabling utility-scale projects. 'The next step is scaling up with large, grid-integrated projects,' he said. Natural gas will also play a critical role in the energy transition. He confirmed efforts to secure floating storage and regasification units (FSRUs) and re-engage with regional pipeline infrastructure, while continuing exploration partnerships with companies such as TotalEnergies and QatarEnergy. Asked why investors should place faith in Lebanon now,Saddi pointed to a change in mindset: 'Lebanon is back in a sense. The trust in the current government is the highest that it has been for the last 30 or 40 years in Lebanon. The wave of reform that is coming is inescapable; there is no other path that is open to the Lebanese. One of the first things I said when I took this role is that politics must be removed from the electricity sector which has been plagued be political dealings.'
Qatar Tribune
14-06-2025
- Qatar Tribune
Egypt delays opening of grand museum
CairocTypeface:> Egypt on Saturday announced delaying the long-awaited opening of a grand antiquity museum near the Giza Pyramids, which was scheduled for next month, citing regional tensions amid ongoing war between Israel and Iran, state media reported. Egyptian Prime Minister Mostafa Madbouly said the opening, which was originally scheduled for July 3, would be postponed until the last quarter of this year. The state-run newspaper Al-Ahram quoted Madbouly as saying the postponement of the event aims to provide an 'appropriate atmosphere' for the opening of the Grand Egyptian Museum (GEM), and the new date would be set soon. GEM, deemed the world's largest museum of the ancient Egyptian civilization, showcases thousands of artefacts, including the full legendary collection of Tutankhamun featuring the king boy's iconic mask. Despite the delay, GEM will remain open to visitors as part of its ongoing soft opening, Al-Ahram Online reported. (DPA)
Qatar Tribune
07-06-2025
- Qatar Tribune
Yemen's Al Qaeda leader threatens Trump, Musk over Israel's war on Gaza
The leader of Al Qaeda's Yemen branch has targeted US President Donald Trump and tech billionaire Elon Musk over United States backing for Israel's ongoing war on the Gaza Strip and its besieged Palestinian population. 'There are no red lines after what happened and is happening to our people in Gaza,' said Saad bin Atef Al Awlaki in a half-hour video message that was spread online on Saturday by supporters of Al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP), the Yemeni branch of the armed group. 'Reciprocity is legitimate,' he said. The message featured images of Trump and Musk, US Vice President JD Vance, Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Secretary of Defence Pete Hegseth, as well as logos of Musk's businesses – including electric carmaker Tesla. Born in 2009 from the merger of Al Qaeda's Yemeni and Saudi factions, AQAP is completely distinct from Yemen's Houthi rebel group, which controls most of the country and agreed to a ceasefire with the US earlier this month. AQAP grew and developed amid the chaos of Yemen's war, which has pitted the Houthis against a Saudi-led coalition backing the government since 2015. (Agencies)
