Businesses ‘locked' out of key to success unless Minnesota lawmakers act
The Brief
A 2023 state law banned lead in a lot of products including toys, jewelry, cosmetics, and keys. It took effect in Jan. 2024, but the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency isn't enforcing it until this coming July.
Key makers and retailers say there aren't viable alternatives at this point. MPCA says some companies have alternatives, but they're recommending the legislature delay enforcement for three years.
Bills eliminating the ban on keys are making their way to conference committees for votes, so stakeholders are rallying for change.
ST. PAUL, Minn. (FOX 9) - The keys in your pocket are already illegal to replace in Minnesota.
Enforcement coming soon
The state isn't really enforcing a new law yet, but it will start as of July, and a lot of small businesses are hoping to unlock a change before lawmakers go home.
A 2023 law banned the sale of lead in products like jewelry, toys and cosmetics.The ban included keys, but the people who make keys say there's no way to do it without a little lead.
"Approximately 75% of all products that we stock have become prohibited for sale," said Rob Justen of Doyle Security Products.
Lead is the key to staying in business for Justen's business.
But a Minnesota law could lock them out soon.
"It really does make it illegal to sell or replace the very keys that Minnesotans use every day, your house keys, your car keys, your apartment key, your boat key," said Bruce Nustad of the Minnesota Retailers Association.
Urgency arriving
The law banning new lead keys took effect in January 2024, but the sense of urgency is new for retailers and security companies.
"[The Minnesota Pollution Control Agency] has been gracious in its enforcement," Nustad said. "The issue of sort of pending doom hasn't risen until just now."
A bipartisan group of lawmakers is trying to take keys out of the ban and their changes are bolted to bills still moving in the legislature's final week.
Compromising on keys
Key makers say there's no viable alternative to make functioning keys, but they're open to lead limits like California implemented back in 2001.
"Going back to the California standard would legalize every key that's in your pocket today," Justen said.
The Minnesota Pollution Control Agency is saying some companies are already using alternatives, but they're also recommending a three-year delay in enforcement to give these businesses a chance to catch up with new technology.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
Bike tour to border ordeal: Minnesota man flees Iran as tensions rise
The Brief A Minnesota man biking across Europe and Asia barely gets out of Iran. He details he was in a sketchy room during an exit interview with Iranian officials where he felt there was a 50% chance of never walking out. He had to leave Tehran and head to Azerbaijan. MINNEAPOLIS (FOX 9) - A Minnesota man barely gets out of Iran, as he puts it, he had a 50% chance of never walking out. This is stemming from the Israel-Iran conflict. His tour guide even said he could no longer protect him. What we know Ian Andersen started biking across Europe and Asia in February. He got to Iran on June 2, but his journey took a dangerous turn when Israel launched its airstrikes on Iran. "We're not going to Tehran after all. The situation is too dangerous," said Andersen in an Instagram video. That's the moment Andersen realized he had to change his biking plans from Tehran and head to Azerbaijan. "There's likely police blockages into the city and out of the city. I would truly be arrested," said Anderson. He posted the video on social media from a Saturday vlog, and it has been viewed more than a million times. What they're saying FOX 9 spoke to Andersen Wednesday after he was safe and sound. In his words, things got dicey when he had to do exit interviews. The first interview went fine. But then the second one. "They hold me into like a, like an army barracks with a couple of Europeans, Portuguese nationals," said Andersen. Andersen couldn't document that part of his travels, but he describes his feeling when he was in that room being interviewed. "This really sketchy room where, like, Okay, I've got like, a 50% chance of never walking out of here," said Anderson. Big picture view After this experience, Andersen expresses his empathy for everyone he met in Iran who are caught up in this conflict. "It makes, really, makes me think about all the people that can't leave, though it's like, I'm lucky to be here, out of here. But yeah, normal, everyday Iranians and Israelis who don't have the same good fortune, just stuck in the in the fallout of this, this whole thing," said Anderson. What's next: Andersen already biked from Alaska to Argentina nine years ago. His final destination is Japan, and he hopes to get there by Christmas.
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
Commentary: Minnesota's myth of exceptionalism
The assassination and attempted assassination of two Minnesota legislators should shatter, once and for all, the myth of Minnesota exceptionalism. The reality is that Minnesota has become a microcosm of the polarization and political tensions plaguing the United States today. It is, in effect, two states — separate and, if not unequal, at least very different. The myth of Minnesota exceptionalism runs deep. Minnesotans often celebrate what they believe is the uniqueness of their culture. This sentiment can be traced back to one of Minnesota's most famous writers, Sinclair Lewis, who satirized local boosterism through the character of George Babbitt. It lives on in the 1973 Time magazine cover featuring then-Gov. Wendell Anderson with the proclamation 'The Good Life in Minnesota.' Or in the pastoral image of Garrison Keillor's 'Prairie Home Companion,' with its portrait of a place 'where all the women are strong, all the men are good looking, and all the children are above average.' Minnesota is known for its legacy of progressive Democratic politicians — Hubert Humphrey, Walter Mondale, Eugene McCarthy, and Paul Wellstone. The political scientist Daniel Elazar famously described the state as having a 'moralistic political culture' rooted in volunteerism and civic engagement. Minnesota consistently ranks among the highest in the nation in voter turnout, per capita income, and high school graduation rates. It is also the land of 'Minnesota Nice,' a concept suggesting decency and civility in public life. Yet beneath the surface of this Minnesota Nice lies another reality. The murder of George Floyd five years ago should have laid that bare. Minnesota has some of the worst racial disparities in the country. While white students thrive, graduation rates, college matriculation, and standardized test scores for students of color are among the nation's worst. Racial gaps persist in housing, employment, and the criminal justice system. Politically and geographically, Minnesota is deeply divided. Though often labeled a reliably Democratic state — having last voted Republican for president in 1972 — Donald Trump came close to winning in both 2016 and 2024. The state legislature is nearly evenly split: The state Senate has 34 Democrats and 33 Republicans, and before Melissa Hortman was assassinated, the lower house had 67 Democrats and 67 Republicans. Minnesota is one of just three states with a divided legislature, as political trifectas dominate much of the rest of the country. As I've argued for years, Minnesota is a political swing state. Sharp partisan divides exist between regions, with only about a dozen of the state's 87 counties consistently voting Democratic. Drive just 20 miles from where Hortman was assassinated, and the political terrain shifts rapidly. In 2024, one might see yard signs flip from Harris to Trump in a single stretch of highway. Geography divides us, but so too does culture. The same moralistic spirit that once defined Minnesota's politics now fuels passionate polarization. In 2022, Democrats briefly held a narrow trifecta and enacted a sweeping agenda that national Democrats could only dream of — codifying abortion rights in ways more expansive than Roe v. Wade. Despite being broadly pro-choice, the state also contains strongholds of intense opposition to reproductive rights. If this description of Minnesota sounds a lot like the United States more broadly, it is because it is. Minnesota is both unique and yet fully enmeshed in the same political, cultural, and ideological battles gripping the nation. It reflects the breakdown of political consensus and the rising temperature of our public discourse. The political assassinations in Minnesota were the first in its history. And yet, many friends, neighbors, and observers across the state and country still think — like the title of another Sinclair Lewis novel — that 'It Can't Happen Here.' But it did. And it can. In a state long thought exceptional, we must now ask: What does this tell us about the degeneration of political discourse in America today? _____ Schultz is a Hamline University distinguished professor of political science and legal studies in Saint Paul, Minn. _____
Axios
3 days ago
- Axios
Minnesota students own the national speech and debate tournament
More than 200 Minnesota students have a chance this week to prove again why the state is a hotbed for high school speech and debate. The big picture: They're among the 6,300 competitors at this week's National Speech & Debate Tournament in Des Moines. Since 2000, Minnesotans have won the tournament's main events more times (43) than competitors from any other state, including Texas (38), California (37) and Florida (35). 🎙️ Kyle's thought bubble: Their success came after proving themselves at Twin Cities tournaments, which — as a former Minnesota speech kid and now a part-time coach, I can attest — are some of the toughest local competitions in the U.S. Every time I watch these competitors, and hear the strength in their voices, I know our future is in good hands. How it works: At nationals, 12 main categories of competition fall under the umbrellas of "speech" or "debate." In debate events, competitors verbally spar over morals and values, current events or policy plans or in mock sessions of a legislature. In "public address" speech events, competitors deliver persuasive or informative speeches. In one event, high schoolers have 30 minutes to prepare a seven-minute oration on questions like: "Will Syria be able to establish a stable government anytime soon?" "Interpretation" events look more like competitive acting, featuring humorous or dramatic monologues or a scene with a partner. Case in point: White Bear Lake's Sanyu Mwassa and Mariam Elias-Danjuma won the championship in 2024 for their "duo interpretation" about how white audiences demand Black artists to perform pain. By the numbers: Apple Valley remains the region's most venerable speech power, producing more champions (16) than any other U.S. high school since 1931. The next closest to that mark anywhere in the U.S.? Eagan, which is tied for second place with 10 speech and debate titles. Eastview is not far behind them with eight. What we're watching: Minnesota has produced 40 main event finalists since 2022 — and four of those competitors are back this year for another run at the stage. The returning finalists: Apple Valley's Aniya Bostick and Isaiah Craig, Eastview's Sahiti Atluri and Moorhead's Eleanor Culloton. The intrigue: Some of our future leaders in politics and culture are probably in Des Moines right now. Four of the nine current U.S. Supreme Court justices are speech and debate alums — and Neil Gorsuch is a former national champion. A young Oprah did speech. So did Paul Rudd, Jason Sudeikis, Hasan Minhaj and Stephen Colbert. The actor Josh Gad (Olaf in "Frozen"!) gave one of the most memorable speeches in the history of the national tournament.
