Plans stalled for data centre in Mayo
Contentious plans to proceed with a data centre in Co Mayo opposed by international best-selling author, Sally Rooney have been stalled.
This follows a third party appeal lodged with An Bord Pleanala against Mayo County Council's decision to grant planning permission last month to Mayo Data Hub Ltd for a data centre at Mullafarry and Tawnaghmore Upper, Killala.
One of the objectors to the data centre, Colin Doyle from Station Rd, Ennis, Co Clare has lodged the third party appeal.
The data centre for a site, located 1.8km to the south of Killala and 10.5km to the north of Ballina, will require 50MW average electrical power to operate.
A planning report lodged with the application by John Spain Associates states that proposed development "will attract complementary technology-based companies within the ICT sector and complementary industries to the west of Ireland which will provide for higher paying jobs and activate the local economy".
The Spain planning report also states that the electricity grid in the west of Ireland is currently unconstrained with sufficient capacity to accommodate the required connection for the data centre.
The report states that the project "was in fact situated in this part of Ireland after consultation with Eirgrid because this location is outside grid constrained areas and in a region with a surplus of renewable power".
In his original objection with the Council, Mr Doyle stated that his main concern was indirect greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) generated by the data centre and the resulting impact on climate.
In her own objection to the centre, Sally Rooney told the Council that "I urge you in the strongest possible terms to refuse planning permission for this wasteful, unnecessary and environmentally toxic proposal".
Ms Rooney said that she was making this submission "as a resident of County Mayo and a concerned citizen."
The Normal People and Intermezzo author said: "Climate change represents an immediate and unprecedented threat to our way of life here in Mayo and to the future of human life around the world".
She said: "Unless we act now to stop runaway overheating, children born today are likely to witness a catastrophic breakdown of global civilisation."
Ms Rooney said that in 2023, "private corporate data centres accounted for 21% of Ireland's total electricity usage – more than all urban households combined".
Ms Rooney said: "The truth is that these data centres exist largely to support online advertising. Some estimates suggest that online ads account for 50% of internet data usage; others put the figure between 60% and 80%.
She added: "Whatever the specific figure, online advertising is extremely energy-intensive and is increasing in scale all the time, requiring more data centres, more energy, and more fossil fuels.
Ms Rooney said: "Advertising, needless to say, is pointless. It adds no value to the real economy. It does not improve the overall quality of life for anyone. It is an utter waste of resources. At the best of times, this seems a shame; at a time of urgent global crisis, it is a catastrophe."
Ms Rooney argued that "wasteful consumption of electricity is a disaster. Not only does it drive energy prices upward for ordinary consumers; it also increases the total demand for energy and thus the total demand for fossil fuels"
Ms Rooney said that as the applicants have conceded that the project will result in the emission of more carbon dioxide" into our already overheated atmosphere".
She said: "This additional atmospheric carbon will contribute to climate change not only here in County Mayo, but everywhere on the earth, as part of the catastrophic planetary crisis that is global warming."
Ms Rooney further contended that 'Carbon credits' and 'offsetting programmes' deployed by operators of data centres "act only as a smokescreen for corporations that want to emit greenhouse gases into the atmosphere for profit".
She said: "These gases have already been responsible for the deaths of thousands of innocent people, and in the coming years we can be confident they will claim the lives of thousands more. No complicated EU policy instrument can wave that fact away."
In her six page submission, Ms Rooney further stated that "Not only would this proposed data centre represent a wasteful use of precious and limited electricity; it could also endanger that vital resource for other users, including hospitals and homes."
A decision is due on the appeal in September.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
a day ago
- RTÉ News
Laois County Council gives green light for Electric Picnic 2025
Laois County Council has given the green light for the largest ever Electric Picnic festival to take place. The Council has granted the licence to EP Republic Ltd to stage the festival where 80,000 are to attend each day to see the likes of Hozier, Chappell Roan and Becky Hill perform. Last month, Becky Hill was named as the final headliner and joined Sam Fender, Fatboy Slim, and Kings of Leon on the roster. The 80,000 for the 2025 EP - which is expected to cost between €25m to €30m to stage - is a 5,000 increase on the 75,000 tickets that were sold for the 2024 event. EP Republic lodged its licence application in March and the Council has granted the licence for the multistage live music and arts event at Stradbally Hall, Stradbally Estate, subject to 51 conditions. The Council had received a number of submissions calling on the EP promoters to support local businesses. In one of six submissions made to the Council on EP Republic Ltd's application, David Walsh Kemmis of Ballykilcavan Brewing Company, said: "With a view to supporting small local businesses, I would like to see the Council enforce a planning condition that the festival organisers must provide access to the festival for food and drink suppliers based in Laois, even if their product is in competition with a sponsor of the festival". However, in its 29 page planner's report into the licence application, the Council stated that submissions received relate to a number of issues relating to the event supporting locally produced produce and particularly the nearby Ballykilcavan Brewing Company. The report stated that "this matter is outside of the remit of the Local Authority and therefore cannot be dealt with in the Event Licence. The decision to allow or not the Ballykilcavan Brewing Company or any corporate entity to trade at the event is a commercial decision for the promoter." CEO of Electric Picnic, Melvin Benn, said last month that the cost of staging this year's Electric Picnic will be between €25m to €30m. In an interview, Mr Benn said Electric Picnic provides an enormous economic boost to the local economy. He said that every year, EP has "an awful lot of local businesses and local traders that sell at the festival". Mr Benn gave the example of Laois Taste which is a collection of local producers which sell their produce at the Electric Picnic He said that "we work very closely with local traders and I choose the ones that I work with. It is not up to the local authority to say who we work with. We have the freedom to choose who we work with and we exercise that freedom". Tickets for the 2025 EP event went on sale on August 21st last and sold out within hours without any act confirmed at the time. This year's event returns to the traditional last weekend of August where it will run from Thursday, August 28 to Sunday, August 31. The first Electric Picnic was staged on Saturday, September 4 2004 when around 10,000 people attended.
Irish Independent
2 days ago
- Irish Independent
Site in Mayo town identified as suitable for large housing project
This was revealed at a meeting of the Joint Committee on Housing, Local Government and Heritage. The six-hector site is currently zoned for infrastructure and utility. A report estimates that the cost of development and infrastructure will be between €68,750,000 and €86,450,000. Dearbhla Lawson, the director of planning services for the Land Development Agency (LDA) outlined details about the site. Ms Lawson added that 'there may be other sites the local authority has [but], this [site] has been shortlisted out of a longer process. There's probably more infill sites [in Ballina] and I'm very happy to take that forward with the local authority'. Senator Mark Duffy welcomed the site identified by the LDA, calling it 'promising' and asked the agency to work with him on other sites across Mayo. He proposed the Ballina Mineral Water site located in the town centre. This area had previously been put through a compulsory purchase order by Mayo County Council for a new Tesco supermarket however, the proposal never came to fruition. 'In terms of acreage it's quite small, it's about 4-5 acres,' said the Fine Gael representative. 'While the site might not be the most attractive size, in terms of scale [it] can have a huge impact in being the catalyst for the regeneration of our town' he added. John Coleman the CEO of the LDA, made clear that the main focus for development had previously been in city areas, but he confirmed that 'we will be looking at opportunities in Mayo going forward'. Senator Duffy made the point that while he understood the thought process behind the focus on cities, he recognized there are 'financial impediments that make it more cost effective if we target towns over the 10,000 population that can help to unlock a lot of the housing challenges, because this is a crisis that faces every community'. The type of housing that would be built on the utility site in Ballina is unknown, however the lack of social housing and affordable homes is a Mayo-wide issue, an estimated target of 708 homes are needed under the current Mayo County Development Plan 2022-2028. ADVERTISEMENT Learn more Councillor Peter Flynn, the chair of Mayo County Council's Strategic Policy Committee on Housing, has said he welcomes 'any intervention that will accelerate the delivery of housing in Mayo, particularly for large scale affordable housing schemes'. Speaking to the Irish Independent, Cllr Flynn said, 'The delivery of large-scale affordable houses and apartments is critical to any solution and the demographic of the working poor is a group that needs to be the focus of any initiative particularly in an era of almost full employment,' "For too long Mayo County Council has failed to deliver in this area and their delivery in relation to Social Housing can be described at best as average. We have seen the extraordinary increase in working people who don't qualify for any Government or Council supports becoming homeless and the needs of these people must be urgently addressed,' "I would welcome the LDA getting involved in Mayo towns if they particularly focus on affordable housing in suitable locations' he added. The LDA report was prepared and submitted under Section 52 of the Land Development Agency Act 2021.
Irish Independent
2 days ago
- Irish Independent
Sligo council ‘not adequately funded' to buy second hand homes
He also stated that the €3 million allocated to County Sligo was already committed for the purchase, fees and costs of refurbishment works committed to under the programme in 2024. 'In fact, the €3 million allocation is not adequate to cover the cost of the commitments we entered into last year. "Sligo's current commitment is €3,111,135. So not only have we no funding to address social housing needs as part of the Second Hand Social Housing acquisitions programme for 2025, that fact is that the €3 million we have been allocated is insufficient to allow us complete commitments which the Department of Housing actually approved in 2024. "This Council has also been told by the Department that, other that the €3 million allocated to us, no further funding will be made available to Sligo this year. 'I have to say that I find this shocking and unacceptable, particularly given the fact that we are in the midst of a housing crisis,' Cllr Bree told the monthly meeting of the council. He outlined how In March the Government and Minister for Housing announced €325 million in funding to address social housing needs as part of the Second Hand Social Housing acquisitions programme for 2025. 'The Minister said the 2025 second-hand acquisitions programme would facilitate the purchase of second-hand homes for Tenant-in-Situ Acquisitions. Families with children, older people or those with disabilities were to be prioritised under the tenant-in-situ scheme, however no household was excluded we were told. 'The Minister said local authorities could target the funding and he said the government was committed to the second-hand acquisitions programme and tenant-in-situ acquisition stream given its important role in the prevention of homelessness. "Government TDs in this constituency said they were delighted to see the tenant in situ scheme so well-funded for 2025. They said it would provide opportunities for long term renters to stay in their home with the local authority as their landlord for the long term. "Everyone in this chamber is aware that the crisis is causing huge distress, anxiety and despair to people here in Sligo and in communities across the country. The tenant-in-situ programme helped to alleviate the stress for a number of households in recent years. ADVERTISEMENT "However, Sligo County Council can no longer implement the scheme as the Government is not providing the necessary funding. "I am therefore appealing to the government supporters in this Council and more so to the three Government TDs in this constituency to make the necessary representations to the government and Minister for Housing so as to ensure that adequate funding is provided this year to allow this Council to fulfil its obligations under the Second Hand Social Housing acquisitions programme for 2025. A motion from Cllr Bree calling on the Minister and the Government to increase the funding allocation to Sligo County Council as a matter of urgency so as to allow it to acquire second hand houses for priority cases including people with a disability and older persons requiring urgent housing responses was unanimously adopted.
