Scroll Adda: ‘Secular forces fixate on footnotes, Hindutva gets how Indians deal with history'
Play
Few things seem more contested today than history. From politics to Bollywood, this once sleepy school subject dominates headlines.
In an extensive chat with Shoaib Daniyal on the Scroll Adda podcast, however, historian Manu Pillai contextualises this. People of every age think they are living through unique circumstances. But maybe it's not so different today as it was earlier.
That said, Pillai is clear that 'Hindutva has understood and weaponised how Indians deal with history' in a way that the left has not. 'Secular forces are fixated on a footnoted version of history,' he says. This makes it quite unappealing to people looking to history to construct an identity.
Where does that leave the historian? Pillai agrees that he never thought he'd be in such a contentious field when he first started out. But in the end, he sees it as the price of being in the public eye. Historians are people too. The idea that a pure or virtuous history is possible, he suggests, may itself be an idealised position.
Aryan Mahtta
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
17 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
First of 3 flights evacuating Indians from Iran's Mashhad lands in Delhi
The first of three chartered evacuation flights carrying Indian nationals from conflict-hit Iran arrived in Delhi late Friday night, following Iran's decision to ease airspace restrictions for the operation. Those on board had earlier been moved from Tehran to safer locations. Additional flights may be arranged in the coming days for others wanting to return to India, according to a senior Iranian diplomat. Those on board had earlier been moved from Tehran to safer locations. Additional flights may be arranged in the coming days for others wanting to return to India. (File)(Vipin Kumar/HT Photo) 'Iran's airspace is currently closed, but we're facilitating limited access for the safe evacuation of Indian nationals,' said Mohammad Javad Hosseini, deputy chief of mission at the Iranian embassy. Around 1,000 Indians, mostly students pursuing professional courses, were relocated from Tehran to Qom and then to Mashhad. These evacuees will be flown to Delhi on three Iranian-operated charter flights arranged by India, Hosseini said. Two more evacuation flights are set to arrive on Saturday. This evacuation is taking place as the Iran-Israel war enters its second week, following Israel's large-scale aerial offensive launched last week. Meanwhile, US President Donald Trump said he is considering joining Israel in the conflict and will make a decision within two weeks, leaving open the possibility of negotiations to end the hostilities. More evacuation flights to land on Saturday Sources familiar with the situation said that another flight is scheduled to bring back more Indian nationals who were earlier moved from Iran to Turkmenistan via a land route. This evacuation flight from Ashgabat is expected to arrive in New Delhi early Saturday morning. None of the evacuation flights are flying over Pakistani airspace. Hosseini noted that additional flights may be arranged in the coming days, including a possible one on Sunday, to help Indians wishing to return home. He added that the Iranian foreign ministry is coordinating closely with India's external affairs ministry and the Indian embassy in Tehran to ensure the safe evacuation of Indian citizens. 'We are arranging for the safe passage of Indians who want to [leave] via air or via road through third countries, or directly from Iran,' Hosseini said. A separate group of 110 Indian students, who had been relocated from Tehran to Qom and then taken to Armenia by land, reached Delhi on a flight from Yerevan on Thursday. At the time the hostilities began, triggered by Israeli airstrikes on Iranian military and nuclear sites over the weekend, there were around 10,000 Indians in Iran—many of them students. India has not issued any formal advisories urging its citizens to leave Iran or Israel, but it has asked nationals in both countries to remain alert and limit their movement. Indian authorities have also recommended that citizens move out of Tehran. Hosseini said that all Indian nationals in Iran are safe, except for a few who sustained injuries when an Israeli airstrike struck a student dormitory in Tehran over the weekend. (With inputs from Rezaul Laskar)
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Uddhav's rhetoric shows his desperation: Maha BJP chief
Nagpur: State BJP president Chandrashekhar Bawankule on Friday dismissed Shiv Sena (UBT) chief 's speech on the organisation's 59th foundation day as a "desperate outburst" reflective of his waning public support and growing fear of defeat. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Terming the address on Thursday a sign of "helplessness," Bawankule claimed Thackeray has abandoned Shiv Sena's core ideology and Marathi interests in a bid to retain political relevance. "Uddhav's speech was not a show of strength, but a cry of despair. When people stop believing in you, loud slogans become your last refuge," Bawankule said in a statement issued on social media. He accused the ex-CM of losing not just the party name and symbol, but also its founding values, including its association with Hindutva. Responding to Thackeray's repeated assertion that "Mumbai belongs to us," the state revenue minister questioned Sena (UBT)'s legacy in the megapolis. "What exactly did your administration do for the Marathi-speaking people of Mumbai during decades of control over the BMC? There was no progress in housing, water, education or healthcare," he said. —Vaibhav Ganjapure
Deccan Herald
2 hours ago
- Deccan Herald
Iran lifts airspace restrictions to evacuate 1,000 Indians
Mohammad Javad Hosseini, the deputy chief of mission at the Iranian embassy, said more evacuation flights could be operated in the coming days to bring back Indians if required.
