G7 Summit marks turning point in India-Canada relations, says former minister Ujjal Dosanjh
Vancouver [Canada], June 12 (ANI): As India cements its place as the world's fourth-largest economy, the global balance of power is shifting -- and Canada must take note, says Ujjal Dosanjh, former Canadian Minister of Health, senior lawyer, and vocal advocate against extremism.
Speaking in the wake of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's participation in the G7 summit, Dosanjh says this moment offers a much-needed opportunity to reset strained India-Canada relations, particularly due to long-standing tensions over Khalistan-linked extremism.
'India, even before it became the fourth-largest economy, was being recognised by leaders like Carney as indispensable on the global stage,' Dosanjh remarked, referring to Prime Minister Mark Carney, who assumed office earlier this year. 'Now that India has moved up in global rankings, it only strengthens the case for deeper cooperation.'
Dosanjh pointed out that G7 leaders are well aware of India's growing influence and are likely advising Canada not to let political disagreements override strategic and economic interests.
'Leaders know that even when they have issues with a country, they can't ignore its importance. They find ways to engage constructively -- and that's the approach Carney seems to be taking,' he said.
Prime Minister Carney's invitation to Prime Minister Modi drew protests from several Sikh separatist groups in Canada. But Dosanjh, a long-time critic of extremism, questioned the seriousness with which these groups should be taken, especially given their historical role in damaging Canada's global reputation.
'These elements did massive damage to Canada's image when they bombed Air India Flight 182 in 1985,' Dosanjh said, referencing the worst act of aviation terror before 9/11. 'That wasn't India's wound -- it was Canada's wound. Those were Canadian citizens who died.'
He also recalled the role of Khalistani militant Talwinder Singh Parmar, believed to be the mastermind of the Air India bombing. 'Parmar had earlier killed police officers in India and fled here. Indira Gandhi sought his extradition, but Canada didn't act, partly because there was no extradition treaty at the time. That failure had grave consequences.'
Dosanjh emphasised that Canada has allowed such extremist elements to penetrate mainstream politics. 'Former Prime Minister Stephen Harper rightly said we shouldn't tolerate separatists in our political parties -- especially those seeking to break up allied democracies. I've always believed that, and I suspect Carney privately does too,' he added.
India has sought the extradition of 26 fugitives, including several Khalistani extremists. On this issue, Dosanjh confirmed that there are signs of cooperation, although progress remains slow.
'I spoke with Mr. Verma, India's former High Commissioner to Canada, and he said publicly -- and to me privately -- that Canada has started moving on some of those cases,' he revealed. 'There is an extradition treaty in place. It now depends on the quality of the evidence provided, and on Canada's willingness to act on it.'
With both countries being democracies and promoting strategic autonomy in foreign policy, Dosanjh sees a natural alignment between India and Canada, especially on trade and global issues.
'Canada exports a lot of lentils and grains to India. I know someone personally in that business who's been suffering because of the diplomatic chill -- no trains are moving from his location,' he said. 'It's critical for both countries to stabilise relations not just for trade, but also to collaborate on global challenges as democratic allies.'
Dosanjh believes PM Modi's visit to the G7, hosted by Canada this year, is a promising step toward restoring ties. 'Mr. Carney signalled his intent to reset the relationship during his campaign. Inviting Modi to the G7 is the first concrete step in that direction,' he said.
While tensions remain, especially around the killing of separatist figure Hardeep Singh Nijjar, Dosanjh believes these should not prevent broader cooperation. 'Countries always have disputes. But responsible governments work on multiple tracks: you can address law enforcement matters on one track and continue dialogue on trade, people-to-people ties, and international cooperation on other tracks.'
On the recent attack on journalist Mocha Bezirgan in Vancouver -- where Khalistani supporters allegedly surrounded, threatened, and snatched his phone -- Dosanjh didn't mince words.
'Khalistanis have never shied away from violence. Air India was just the most dramatic example,' he said. 'Unless there are serious prosecutions, these incidents will continue. Canada has been slow to prosecute Khalistani violence, and that delay is hurting our society.'
He stressed that the problem is not just about India's security. 'It's in Canada's own interest to control this menace, for the peace and safety of Canadians. We must protect journalists, uphold free speech, and prosecute threats without fear or political calculations.'
The extradition of Pakistani national Muhammad Shahzeb Khan, accused of plotting an ISIS-inspired attack in New York, has raised further concerns about radicalisation in Canada. Dosanjh believes these fears are well-founded.
'Nearly 100 Canadians went to fight alongside ISIS. Some returned and were prosecuted, some are in jail. Canada is aware of the threat, but our responses are often too slow and reactive,' he said. 'The same lethargy we showed after Air India shouldn't be repeated with new threats whether from Islamist extremists or Khalistani groups.'
Dosanjh also pointed to Pakistan's long-standing role in fuelling the Khalistan movement -- a connection made more visible during recent protests in Vancouver where Pakistani flags were seen alongside Khalistani banners.
'This isn't new. In the 1970s, Jagjit Singh Chohan declared Khalistan in a U.S. newspaper after returning from Pakistan. That declaration was funded by Pakistani money, funnelled in part by the CIA. I met Chohan in Canada back then,' he recalled.
He warned that the ISI's hand remains visible today. 'Figures like Pannun are believed to be working with Pakistani handlers in the U.S. Indian officials know this. Many Canadian politicians, either gullible or ignorant, still look the other way. But now, with the Pakistani flag appearing openly in these rallies, the truth is harder to deny.'
Despite all the tensions and painful history, Dosanjh remains hopeful. 'This G7 summit, hosted by Canada, is a turning point. Prime Minister Carney has taken the first step by inviting Modi. Now it's time for sustained engagement, honest dialogue, and zero tolerance for those who threaten democracy in any form.'
He concludes with a clear message: 'Canada and India are both democracies. They may have their differences, but the shared values and the global stakes are too high to let those differences define the relationship.' (ANI)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Canada Standard
an hour ago
- Canada Standard
"PM Modi always likes to come to Odisha": CM Majhi on PM's declining invitation of Trump, citing prior commitment in Odisha
Bhubaneswar (Odisha) [India], June 21 (ANI): Reacting to Prime Minister Narendra Modi's remarks that he politely declined an invitation from US President Donald Trump, citing prior commitment in Odisha, Chief Minister Mohan Charan Majhi has said that the PM always likes to come to his state. 'He always likes to come to Odisha. He spoke to Donald Trump during the G7, and he invited the PM for a visit to America. PM Modi had already given us the program and told us he would come on June 20... He likes to come to Odisha, and he starts his programs with the chant of 'Jai Jagannath, '' Majhi told ANI. Speaking at an event in Bhubaneswar on Friday, PM Modi said that he had politely declined an invitation from US President Donald Trump to visit the United States on his way back from Canada after the G7 Summit, choosing instead to travel to Odisha -- the 'land of Lord Jagannath,' which he called more important. 'At a time when Odisha's BJP government is completing one year, the people of Odisha are preparing for the Lord Jagannath Rath Yatra. He is our 'prerna' inspiration and 'aaradhya' worship,' PM Modi said. 'Just two days ago, I was in Canada for the G7 summit. During that time, US President Donald Trump called me and invited me with great insistence. I told the President of America, Thank you for the invitation, but I need to go to the land of the Lord. So I politely declined his invitation. Your love has drawn me to the land of the Lord,' he said. Odisha Chief Minister Mohan Charan Majhi has said that his government aims to make the State a USD 500 billion economy by 2036, adding that the government would cooperate with the Centre to achieve the goal of Viksit Bharat. 'We will cooperate with the centre to achieve the goal of Viksit Bharat... Our GDP is more than the national average... We have prepared a vision document for 2036... We aim to make Odisha a USD 500 billion economy by 2036. A double-digit growth rate is required for this,' Majhi told ANI. Majhi commended Prime Minister Modi's leadership and highlighted contributions to the state's development. 'In January, PM Modi urged the investors to participate in the Utkarsh Odisha 2025 conclave. We received proposals worth Rs 17 lakh crores in just two days, which is a record. This happened because the investors trusted you. We are working to make Odisha the industrial hub of eastern India...,' he said. On Operation Sindoor, Majhi lauded Prime Minister Narendra Modi's leadership, stating, 'Under your leadership, the terrorist has been eliminated. Operation Sindoor was not just an operation; it was a symbol of the trust of mothers and sisters. With Operation Sindoor, India rises to a new role, one that does not bow. Earlier, people said, 'Modi hai toh mumkin hai'; now they say, 'Modi hai toh desh surakshit hai.' Under your leadership, development is touching new heights. In 11 years, all sectors have made progress, and India has become the world's fourth-largest economy.' PM Modi inaugurated and laid the foundation stone for multiple development projects worth over Rs 18,600 crore in Bhubaneswar. These projects will cover critical sectors, including drinking water, irrigation, agricultural infrastructure, health infrastructure, rural roads and bridges, sections of national highways, and a new railway line. (ANI)
Winnipeg Free Press
2 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Wildfires: climate change cause and effect
Opinion Do we believe what we see or see what we believe? This question is at the heart of humanity's willingness to act on climate change. In the wake of record wildfire damage in Canada in 2023, the hottest year on record for the Earth in 2024, and scientists warning we will breach any chance of keeping global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius by 2027, it is fair to wonder. Do our world leaders believe in more climate change action? The G7 summit just concluded in Kananaskis suggests not. The term 'climate change' did not appear once in any of their communiques, a sharp departure from past summits but perhaps a sign of the times. Times preoccupied with urgent global economic and military conflicts and a U.S. Trump administration that has banned the term. Wildland fires like this one near Pimicikamak Cree Nation earlier this year, aren't only increasing as a result of climate change. They add to it as well. But if 'seeing is believing', then the G7 did see something alarming about our changing climate: wildfires. They issued the Kananaskis Wildfire Charter, stating: 'These increasingly extreme wildfires are endangering lives, affecting human health, destroying homes and ecosystems, and costing governments and taxpayers billions of dollars each year.' Wildfires are Canada's most public of dirty climate secrets. When we think of our biggest greenhouse gas (GHG) polluters, we tend to focus on the oil and gas sector. Think again. Canada's record wildfires in 2023 burned more than 16 million hectares of land, an area as large as 30 Winnipegs put together. It generated an estimated 647 megatonnes of carbon according to the authoritative scientific journal Nature. That is almost as much as all of Canada emitted the year before (709 megatonnes), and three times as much as the oil and gas sector itself. Trees and forests are natural carbon sinks. They absorb carbon dioxide when they are alive and healthy. But they release CO2 when they burn. Hot and dry weather caused by a changing climate is causing earlier starts to the fire season. It is making our forests more combustible when fires start. Forest fires become larger in area and of longer duration with more carbon emissions released. But Canada, like most countries, does not count most carbon emissions from wildfires in its GHG inventory. This is for two reasons. First, because the United Nations' climate rules focus on what's called 'anthropogenic' or human-caused emissions and second, it is hard to distinguish between carbon released from planned or managed land use changes such as timber practices and urban sprawl, versus unplanned wildfires. The atmosphere begs to differ. It doesn't care about carbon rules or even sources. It cares about carbon accumulation. Climate impacts today are caused from yesterday's carbon emissions, not tomorrow's. And it's caused by everyone's emissions, not just ours. Canada is more exposed to this vicious circle than any other country, due to our northern latitude and higher rates of warming being experienced. There's a reason we are on track for our second-worst wildfire season ever with 3.9 million hectares already burning and over 120 fires officially 'out of control', according to the Canadian Interagency Forest Fire Centre. What's the solution? Sadly, nothing easy, fast, or cheap. The federal government is spending $3.2 billion to plant two billion new trees over the next ten years. So far, 160 million trees have been planted. When finished, though, it would absorb only about 12 megatonnes of carbon per year in 2050. Not nearly enough or soon enough. Could those or other 'climate dollars' be more usefully invested elsewhere? Just as the G7 signalled combatting wildfires is now a global concern, Canada's governments need to make it a truly national priority. If you want to reduce our carbon footprint then focus on the emissions doing the most damage. That means investing more, now, in expanding our firefighting capacity. Canada has an aging water bomber fleet with insufficient planes. Trained wildfire fighters are lacking, particularly Type 1 firefighters, the first responders. Wednesdays A weekly dispatch from the head of the Free Press newsroom. Improvements are in the works. PEI is doubling its complement of trained wildfire fighters which, when deployed elsewhere as they were last month, helps in Manitoba and Saskatchewan. More water bombers are on order for Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Ontario. But these will not be ready for several more fire seasons at least. If we are in the midst of a growing wildfire trend, as the past three years attest, then expect more damage and more carbon pollution in the meantime. Canada has been embroiled in a debate about the cost of reducing carbon emissions from industry, vehicles, and consumers. There's another cost. The cost of climate change impacts on people and communities (185,000 displaced last year) ravaged by more wildfires. Insurance costs from last year's fires were more than $1.2 billion, according to the Insurance Bureau of Canada. That's the choice. Pay now or pay later. Tackling wildfires is a 'two-fer'. It protects lives and livelihoods. And it helps keep carbon in the ground, not emit it into the atmosphere. It's a way for Canadas to reduce its global carbon footprint in a more meaningful way than one more taxpayer-funded boutique programs spooled out to garner positive headlines about 'acting on climate'. Raging wildfires across Canada are the clearest case yet of 'see it, believe it' that climate change is real and expensive. David McLaughlin is a former clerk of the executive council and cabinet secretary in the Manitoba government.
Winnipeg Free Press
2 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
AmericasAgForum2025 seeks co-operation on weighty issue of food security
Opinion OLDS, Alta. — The 'world's most pressing issues' outlined in documents for G7 leaders meeting in Kananaskis, Alta., week seem complicated, unsolvable and worsening. One of those leaders even left early, reportedly to deal with another war. Meanwhile, delegates attending a simultaneous meeting just up the road at Olds were saying — in a manner of speaking — 'hold my beer.' It was no coincidence the shadow summit organized by the Inter-American Institute for Co-operation on Agriculture with support from the International Fund for Agricultural Development took place on the same days in the same province as the G7 summit. Manuel Otero, director general of the Inter-American Institute for Cooperation on Agriculture, says agriculture must be part of any conversation about world security. Photo: Laura Rance 'The summit's agenda does not include discussions on agriculture or food security, despite the critical role these sectors play in the economic, social, and environmental development of the Americas,' says a communiqué promoting the event. 'This event will serve as a positive and inclusive space for dialogue, bringing together government officials, industry representatives, academics, development experts and students, to explore solutions that enhance agriculture, food security, sustainability, innovation and trade.' Peace and security? Global migration? Trade? Economic growth? Climate? Energy? Food security is at the core of these G7 issues. Likewise, agriculture is at the root of the solution. That point was highlighted repeatedly over the two-day event that attracted 150 delegates in person and several hundred listening online. 'Agriculture has to be an instrument of peace,' IICA director general Manuel Otero said in an interview on the opening day of the AmericasAgForum2025. 'In all of these issues, agriculture is at the centre of the solutions, so implicitly or explicitly G7 leaders have to discuss the role of agriculture.' IICA, which was founded in 1942, focuses on fostering rural and agricultural development among its 34 member states across the Americas. Otero told his audience the world faces a multidimensional challenge over the next 40 years. Meeting the growing demand for food will require addressing production shortfalls brought about by climate change while navigating the simultaneous crises of undernutrition and obesity. Agricultural policy 'is not just climate smart anymore, it has to be nutritionally smart, too,' he said. Otero called on world leaders to focus on policies that enable smallholder farmers to adopt new technologies that stabilize rural communities by keeping farmers on the land. A robust rural economy stabilizes cities, too. 'Every time a producer becomes a consumer, we face a problem,' Otero said, noting outward migration from rural areas creates unsustainable pressure on urban infrastructure and food systems. Farm leaders addressing the conference said politicians need to be reminded of the vital role food producers play in global security and geopolitical stability. They warned rural depopulation and the loss of youth will hamper the sector's ability to stay abreast of the world's future food needs. Kallie Wood, president and CEO of the newly launched National Circle for Indigenous Agriculture and Food, said rather than seeking new solutions and posturing over who will be the leaders, the focus should be on building relationships, trust and sharing ideas that are already working. Tuesdays A weekly look at politics close to home and around the world. 'We don't need to reinvent the wheel,' Wood said. 'There's ideologies and models that are working all around the world. I think we adopt one another's processes that are working. Nobody has to lead this, it's about outcome.' Canadian Federation of Agriculture president Keith Currie said farmers have a long history of working together to accomplish common goals. He said everyone benefits from rules-based trade and harmonized regulatory systems that give farmers access to the technological tools they need to succeed. But they need to be part of the conversation. 'Constantly we find ourselves, more so on the political side of things, being last to the table of the conversation, instead of being first to the table,' he said. 'I always like to remind people that the French Revolution was very romantic, talking about liberty, but … the French were hungry, there was a catastrophic failure that made people hungry,' said Jorge Esteve Recolons, president of Mexico's Consego Nacional Agropecuarario (National Agricultural Council). 'So, to have stable nations, we really need to take care of food security.' Laura Rance is executive editor, production content lead for Glacier FarmMedia. She can be reached at lrance@ Laura RanceColumnist Laura Rance is editorial director at Farm Business Communications. Read full biography Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
