Shah's anti-English position harms India
Union Home Minister Amit Shah's denunciation of the English language is ill-conceived and uninformed, and will only work against the country's unity and development. Speaking at the launch of a book by a former civil servant in Delhi on Thursday, Shah said, ''The time is not far away for people speaking in English in the country to feel ashamed'. The prejudice against English is part of the ideology and politics of his party, and Shah has only given expression to it. He is right in saying that the languages of our country are the jewels of our culture, but wrong in dismissing the role of English as a linking and unifying language. He is also right in saying that we should take pride in our languages, but pride in one's own language need not translate into shame about another language. Languages are not zero sum games, and the knowledge of another language does not mean degradation or devaluation of the mother tongue. Languages gain by interaction. All Indian languages have enriched themselves from their interaction with English. .English not a shame but power: Rahul Gandhi hits back at Amit Shah's remarks, says discouraging it to deny opportunities .English is spoken by over 100 million people in the country, and the number exceeds the number of speakers of most other languages. It is the official language in many states. India is also said to have the second largest English-speaking population in the world. English has served as the official and link language for centuries in our country, which speaks richly diverse languages. It is difficult to imagine English losing its status in the near future, going by the people's attitude towards it. The usefulness and popularity of a language don't always depend on government policies. People's relationship with language is a sensitive matter and governments should handle it with care and caution. .Shah's tirade against English should also be seen in context of the efforts of the central government and the BJP to promote Hindi aggressively. This has resulted in apprehensions about domination of Hindi in non-Hindi states. English was the language of power in India during colonial times but after the British left, it serves as a link language, with an equal relationship with all languages of the country. The replacement of English would lead to its place being taken up by Hindi, which comes with political baggage. English is also India's window to the world in every respect, and closing that window would hurt and set the country back. Shah says India cannot be imagined with a foreign language. But the idea of India is not static--it has room for English, which is no longer considered a foreign language.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
19 minutes ago
- India Today
Bypoll results in 5 states today, BJP, AAP, Congress to battle it out
The results of the bypolls held in five seats across four states - Gujarat, Punjab, Kerala and Bengal - will be announced today. The counting will begin at 8 am, with trends emerging soon after. The bypolls were held on June 19 for two seats in Gujarat - Visavadar and Kadi assembly seats - and one each in Punjab (Ludhiana West), Bengal (Kaliganj), and Kerala (Nilambur).advertisementThe bypolls, considered a precursor to Assembly elections slated in some of the above-mentioned states, are crucial as both the BJP-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA) and the INDIA alliance have fielded BYPOLLSThe BJP is looking to take back the Visavadar assembly seat, which the party hasn't won since 2007. The seat has been vacant since 2023 after the then AAP legislator Bhupendra Bhayani resigned and went to the BJP's side. For this bypoll, the BJP has picked Kirit Patel, while the Congress and AAP has fielded Nitin Ranpariya and its ex-Gujarat President Gopal Italia, respectively. The Kadi seat, meanwhile, has been vacant since February owing to the death of BJP MLA Karsan Solanki. Coming under the Mehsana district, the constituency is reserved for Schedule Caste candidates. The BJP has fielded Rajendra Chavda from the constituency, while the Congress and the AAP opted for Ramesh Chavda and Jagdish Chavda, BYPOLLadvertisementThe Nilambur seat in Kerala is seen as a prestige battle for Congress's Priyanka Gandhi Vadra. The seat falls within her Wayanad constituency, and she had held a roadshow in the region ahead of the June 19 bypolls. The bye-election had to be conducted in the constituency after the switching of two-time MLA OV Anvar - earlier backed by the Left - to the Congress party. He contested the bypoll as an Left Democratic Front (LDF) has fielded M Swaraj for the crucial test, while the Congress-supported United Democratic Front (UDF) has fielded Aryadan Shoukath. The BJP has fielded Advocate Mohan George for the Nilambur BYPOLLIn Bengal's Kaliganj constituency, which falls under Nadia district, the bypoll was necessited due to the death of Trinamool Congress MLA Nasiruddin Ahamed in February. Now, his daughter, Alifa Ahamed, is hoping to retain the seat as the ruling party's candidate. The BJP has fielded Ashis Ghosh for the seat, while the Congress picked Kabil Uddin Shaikh who contested with the backing of the CPI(M).The Kaliganj bypoll is seen as a vital face-off between Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee's Trinamool and the BJP ahead of next year's Assembly elections, where the saffron party is hoping to dethrone the BYPOLLadvertisementThe Ludhiana West seat in Punjab fell vacant after sitting AAP MLA Gurpreet Bassi Gogi died of a self-inflicted bullet injury in January. The AAP, which has been striving to retain power in Punjab since the brutal loss in the Delhi Assembly elections, will aim to retain the seat. The BJP, meanwhile, hopes to wrest the seat will see a three-way battle among AAP's Sanjeev Arora, BJP's Jeewan Gupta, and Congress veteran Bharat Bhushan Ashu. Shiromani Akali Dal has fielded Parupkar Singh Ghuman as its candidate for the bypoll. IN THIS STORY#Kerala#West Bengal#Gujarat#Punjab#All India Trinamool Congress
India Today
19 minutes ago
- India Today
Did US use Indian airspace to strike Iran nuke sites? Government clarifies
India on Sunday dismissed as "fake" claims by certain social media handles that the US fighter jets used Indian airspace to launch strikes against US bombed three nuclear sites in Iran overnight, with President Donald Trump warning of additional strikes if Iran retaliates. advertisement'Several social media accounts have claimed that Indian Airspace was used by the United States to launch aircrafts against Iran during Operation #MidnightHammer. This claim is FAKE,' PIB Fact Check said in a post on X. 'Indian Airspace was NOT used by the United States during Operation #MidnightHammer,' said the fact check unit of the Press Information Bureau that functions under the Ministry of Information and said that the Joint Chiefs of Staff Chair Gen. Dan Caine had explained the route used by US aircraft during a press InMust Watch
India Today
19 minutes ago
- India Today
Bypoll Results 2025 Live: Counting of votes to begin at 8 am, security tightened at booths
Bypoll results 2025 Assembly Bypoll Result 2025 Live Updates: The counting of votes for bypolls in five assembly constituencies across four states, including two in Gujarat and one each in Bengal, Kerala and Punjab, will begin at 8 am. The bypolls were held on June 19, with the Nilambur constituency in Kerala recording the highest voter turnout at 73.26 per cent. The overall turnout went as high as 70 per cent. The by-elections in Kerala and Bengal are seen as precursor to the big assembly elections in both the states next year. In Bengal's Kaliganj, ruling Trinamool Congress is aiming to retain the seat, while the Nilambur seat in Kerala is seen as prestige battle for Priyanka Gandhi Vadra as it falls under her Wayanad constituency. Meanwhile, Arvind Kejriwal's AAP is striving to keep the Ludhiana West seat in Punjab, and the BJP is hoping to break its 18-year jinx and win Gujarat's Visavadar seat. The Kadi seat in Gujarat could reveal the Dalit community's voting patterns in the region. Stay tuned at as we bring to you all latest updates. ...Read More 0
