‘Great flavour, delicate tang': the best supermarket sourdough, tasted and rated by Thomasina Miers
I make sourdough every week at home, so I feel that I'm a good judge of the flavour and texture of this style of baking. Overall, I was pleasantly surprised with the quality of a handful of these loaves, which had good texture, good flavour and a nice crumb. It was, however, interesting to discover that none had to declare the salt content in their loaves, because this has a surprisingly large impact on overall flavour.
The Guardian's journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. Learn more.
None of the packaging for any of these breads, save for Wildfarmed, talked about pesticides and herbicide sprays, which is one of the things I ask about whenever I do buy bread these days – surely part of the point of spending more money is to know that the loaves are made from flour without that toxic load to it? It was great to see the supermarkets becoming more engaged in making better bread, too, and that Jason's and Wildfarmed have made it on to so many high-street shelves.
£2 for 450g at Ocado (44p/100g)£2 for 450g at Tesco (44p/100g)★★★★★
This delicious loaf looked the part and seemed to have real provenance behind it. It had a great taste that translated into a wonderful crumb for our fish fingers the following week.
£4 for 600g at Waitrose (67p/100g)★★★★★
By far the best-looking of the bunch. A great flavour, a delicate tang and a crumb that stayed fresh for several days, and made great breadcrumbs and bruschetta after that. Very good quality for the price.
£2.35 for 400g at Waitrose (59p/100g)★★★★☆
This bloomer had a nice, tangy sourdough flavour and a great shape, but with quite a dense crumb. A pretty good flavour overall, and it lasted well over three or four days.
£2 for 360g in store at Co-op (56p/100g)★★★★☆
A lovely looking loaf, which is apparently made from a 12-year-old starter. The flavour was OK and the texture good, with nice holes and air in the crumb.
£2.65 for 400g in store at M&S (66p/100g)★★★☆☆
This San Fran-style loaf had a nice open crumb and not a bad flavour compared with most of the supermarket ones. The light tang was present but faint (apparently it's made with a 30-year-old starter).
Sign up to The Filter
Get the best shopping advice from the Filter team straight to your inbox. The Guardian's journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link.
after newsletter promotion
£2.10 for 400g at Sainsbury's (53p/100g)★★★☆☆
Interestingly, this has some rye flour in it, to give it a hint of extra flavour, but it's quite a flat, square-looking loaf that's unappealing compared with some of the competition, and with quite a dense crumb, too. Not masses of flavour, either.
£1.89 for 400g in store at Aldi (47p/100g)★★★☆☆
This loaf had an impressive open texture and crumb, and was very nice looking. There were no ingredients listed on the back, but it definitely tasted like it wasn't a straight white loaf. Could have done with a little more salt, though.
£1.99 for 600g in store at Lidl (33p/100g)★★☆☆☆
A very uniform-looking loaf with a pretty solid texture. I really didn't love the flavour, though.
£2.10 for 400g at Tesco (53p/100g)★★☆☆☆
This loaf is described as 'tangy' and 'golden', but in practice, it was pretty solid with a dense crumb, had very little flavour and some kind of glossy egg wash that felt very unlike a typical sourdough.
£2.10 for 400g at Morrisons (53p/100g)★☆☆☆☆
I didn't love the look of this loaf and its shape, nor was I hugely impressed by its flavour. Overall, I didn't love it.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
2 hours ago
- The Sun
All the ways Love Island's Shaughna Phillips hid her HUGE baby bump while flaunting six-stone weight loss
THESE are all the ways Love Island's Shaughna Phillips hid her huge baby bump. The ITV2 personality flaunted her six-stone weight loss while keeping her pregnancy a secret. 8 8 8 Shaughna, 31, recently revealed that she was expecting her second child. This was after she made her happy news public on Instagram, shortly after stripping to her underwear and opening up on her six stone weight loss. However, she used various ways of hiding her growing abdomen in posts on social media over the last few months. In one video on her grid page, she promoted the Musera range on SHEIN. In the first part of the video, she covered up in a long silk pyjama top, before changing into various more glam two-piece outfit. Despite a hint of her midriff, she tried to conceal the majority of her bump using a gold clutch bag, which she held in front. The former reality personality also posted weight loss videos that were twinned with throwback videos to throw fans off the scent. A side by side comparison showed Shaughna looking unrecognisable from her former self in an orange two-piece swimsuit. Other photos on her Instagram page have showed her sporting baggy clothes, which included a yellow co-ord that completely covered her stomach. As her bump got bigger over recent days, she also posted more weight loss snaps in the form of head shot pictures to avoid revealing her whole body. Shaughna Phillips hits back at she's accused of using weight loss jabs after revealing 5 stone body transformation The TV star first rose to fame when she featured in Love Island 's sixth season, the first in Winter to be held in South Africa. She gave birth to her first child in 2023 and will now expand her brood, gushing her eldest will be the "best big sister." In addition to the reveal on Instagram, she has dished the detail on her expanding family and her due date. After the post which saw two of her pregnancy tests show positive - she explained to MirrorOnline: "We're so happy to announce we are adding to our little family," Adding: "Lucia is going to be the best big sister and is really excited to have a new baby brother or sister arrive later this year." 8 8 8 8
The Sun
3 hours ago
- The Sun
My fiance lost six stone on fat jabs but secret sex side effect forced me to take drastic action in the bedroom
CRAIG Cooper's relentless advances are met with an exhausted sigh from his fiancee Kayla Goodearl as she nestles deeper into the sofa cushions. 'Not tonight, please,' the mum-of-six groans, dodging his eager attempts. 5 5 But social media manager Craig's newfound ' Mounjaro Mojo ' — a turbocharged libido sparked by his astonishing six-stone weight loss — is relentless. The bedroom has become a battleground of desire versus exhaustion, where a temporary sex ban — initiated by stay-at-home mum Kayla, 35 — was the only thing standing between them and chaos. 'It had to be done, it was driving me crazy,' says Kayla, from Rochester, Kent. 'The weight-loss jabs had got him pumped up and he now has a superman libido. 'It was like he was taking daily doses of Viagra, so I had to put him on a sex ban so I could catch up with him. 'His new mojo was initially fun. 'But having to be a full-time mum to six kids, while having a super-active sex life became exhausting.' Before Craig, 42, started taking the Mounjaro jabs, the couple's sex life had dipped dramatically due to having two babies under two. 'Our youngest child is 14 months, and we also have a two-year-old daughter, so we're constantly running around, plus they are co-sleeping with us,' says Kayla, who also has four children of her own. 'They want mine and Craig's attention at all times, so our sex life took a nose dive. Weight Loss Jabs - Pros vs Cons 'We would have high hopes at the beginning of the day, but as the hours passed sex became the last thing on my mind.' When the pair first met back in January 2022, they enjoyed regular sex — but that soon felt like a long distance memory. She says: 'Before our two kids, I would say we had a healthy sex life and did it around once a week, maybe twice. "But having such young kids kept us busy, while also taking up most of our energy. 'Of course at the time, I would wish for it to be better as we would go weeks — sometimes even two months — without doing the deed, and that thought would always be at the back of my mind. 'I didn't want things to fizzle out, but naturally the kids took all my time up.' But when Craig began taking Mounjaro in December last year things quickly changed. The decision to start the jabs came after he reached 20st and, at 5ft 2in, had a BMI of 51.4, making him morbidly obese and at risk of type two diabetes and heart disease. 'I soon realised I needed to be careful of what I wished for,' she says. 'Since he has taken on Mounjaro, Craig's libido has the activation button on at all times. 'I COULDN'T KEEP UP' 'He asks for it morning, noon and night. But I've got six kids. 'Where does he think I find the time? "'At first I didn't think much of it, I thought it was more that he had this new-found confidence. 'It was exhilarating and it really did reignite the spark between us — it was like we were teenagers all over again. 'It could be anywhere in the house. 'In the laundry room, the bathroom or even the kitchen, you name it, he wanted it there. 'Sometimes we have guests over, or the kids are in the house and he wants a quickie. 'Don't get me wrong, I love his new body — and the attraction is certainly there but I couldn't keep up. 'I would never get anything done if I hadn't put the sex ban in place. 'Four months down the line, in March, I had no other option but to ban Craig from the bedroom and make him sleep on the sofa. 'I also felt that soon enough we were going to get caught by one of the kids.' 'Initially he was gobsmacked. 'Then he groaned that I didn't understand. His increased libido combined with his body going completely 'off script' put me off sex even more Kayla Goodearl 'I stood my ground and, he realised: happy wife, happy life. And I needed space.' A new study from Lloyds Pharmacy reveals that over three-quarters of people say their body image affects their sex drive, rising to 82 per cent for women. Interestingly, 30 per cent of respondents discussed how weight loss improved their libido, with an equal amount commenting on their improved confidence and self-esteem, as well as increased energy levels, and improved relationship dynamics. Dr Tom Curtis, Clinical Head of Obesity at weight-loss programme Voy, says that it's not uncommon for patients taking weight-loss medications such as Mounjaro to report an increase in their sex drive. 'It's usually as a result of the weight loss itself rather than a direct effect of the medication,' he explains. 'Significant weight loss can have a powerful effect on confidence, self-image, and energy levels, all of which can reignite desire and intimacy. 'Biologically, there are also benefits. 'In men, weight loss can improve testosterone levels and blood flow. 'In women, it can help rebalance hormones such as oestrogen and insulin, which may improve mood and sexual responsiveness.' More typical side effects include nausea, vomiting, constipation, diarrhoea, stomach upset, heartburn and even hair loss. 'Craig had a tsunami of side effects, from Mounjaro moodiness, to constipation, farting, diarrhoea and bad breath,' Kayla explains. 'His increased libido combined with his body going completely 'off script' put me off sex even more. 5 Craig says: 'The jab has the same effect on me as taking Viagra - I used it once as a laugh and it was great. 'Imagine wanting sex constantly but everything is preventing it. 'At times I wanted to cry but I just had to laugh. 'I couldn't even get a snog from the missus. 'The jabs got me all pumped up and Kayla had had enough, so I understand it can get tiring for her. 'No one tells you about the secret Viagra-like effect of the jabs. 'I was hot to trot but Kayla was not.' A new study published in Andrologia, a research journal focusing on male infertility and sexual disorders, has confirmed that weight loss, particularly in obese or overweight individuals using weight-loss jabs, leads to improved erectile function. This is attributed to better cardiovascular health, reduced inflammation, and increased testosterone levels. This finding comes despite some men reporting erectile dysfunction while using these jabs. Craig pays £160 a month for his private prescription, and noticed changes in his weight in the first week, he lost five inches around his belly. Now, six months in, he has lost more than a third of his body weight and tips the scales at 14st 8lb. As well as a change to their sex life, Kayla has also noticed the family's food bill halved to £100 a week and Craig seems more focused. She says: 'That is also another plus from the jabs. 'I used to send Craig to the shops for milk, eggs and nappies and he'd come back with chocolate, crisps and unhealthy snacks and forget the milk and nappies. 'Now his memory is amazing, and he only eats salads and healthy lean meats.' He says: 'I feel amazing having lost more than a third of my body weight. 'I have more energy, I am no longer vague, and feel sexier than I ever have.' Craig isn't sure how long his 'Mounjaro Mojo' side effect will last for, but the pair are now learning to live with it — and last month, the sex ban was lifted. Kayla felt energised enough to get back into the bedroom, and the bonking had begun again — up to six times a week. She says: 'I have gone from zero to a hero between the sheets.' 'I did miss sleeping with him,' Kayla says. 'I fancy my new-look Craig more than ever. 'It's tiring, but it's been a huge reboot to our sex life and who would want to let that go? 'If I am in the mood, five to six times a week is great. 'But half a dozen kids at home means we have to plan when to have sex. 'So, when the school run is over and the little ones are napping, we enjoy a quickie.' Craig adds: 'The best thing is I have my mojo back. 'Our sex life is better than ever. 'From no sex to sex six times a week. 'It's so great I may need a lie down.'
The Sun
5 hours ago
- The Sun
Helen Skelton sells off one of her homes she shares with ex husband amid Gethin Jones romance
HELEN Skelton has apparently sold off one of her homes that she shared with ex husband, Richie Myler. This comes as she continues to become close to her BBC Morning Live co-star Gethin Jones. 9 9 9 9 The former Blue Peter face previously announced her split from rugby league ace in April 2022 as she revealed he left the family home. Just four months after Helen gave birth to her third child Elsie, he walked out of their nine-year marriage. The duo turned two adjacent houses into a lavish eight bedroom dream home just months before their relationship came to an end. However, the property was put on the market for £1.8million just weeks after the split. The MailOnline reported that Helen hoped to make £500,000 from the sale. Now, the publication reports that the former couple have divided up their properties once again, amid her new romance. They sold the first home they bought in January 2020 for half a million pounds, despite the fact it was listed at nearly £900,000. It is described as a 'link detached house' with four bedrooms that was given a modern makeover by the pair. This was after the duo moved into the period house, which reported to have been sold, subject to contract. Other features include a modern open-plan kitchen and living room that contain exposed beams and vaulted ceilings. Gethin Jones and Helen Skelton's romance heats up as they're seen at spa The spacious room - which comes with a log burner - has plentiful access to south facing gardens. On the ground floor, other rooms include a snug, a dining room for guests and a bedroom with its own ensuite toilet. The two bedrooms on the first floor provide ample space, as the master suite has its own ensuite bathroom and large dressing area. Outdoors, the property boasts a heated swimming pool as well as an annexe with its own bathroom, which could serve as either a guest house or a 'summer entertainment space' The outlet also reports that the couple still own a second property they bought in 2021 for £635,000. This comes after we reported that the relationship of Helen, 41, relationship with co-star Gethin, 47, continued to heat up in recent weeks as they grew ever closer off screen. The duo were spotted looking loved up as they headed to a country club and spa. He reportedly took his alleged new partner to a wellness venue near his home as he surprised onlookers with their flirty antics. An insider told The Sun: "Gethin and Helen were all over each other. "They are clearly super comfortable with each other and it wasn't just like two friends hanging out." Our mole added: "Helen was really laughing and smiling as they spent time together before heading off in the late afternoon." 9 9 9 9 9
