Government ‘all talk but no action' on disability assessment backlog, says activist
Disability activist
Cara Darmody
(14) has accused the Government of being 'all talk but no action' after meeting Taoiseach
Micheál Martin
on Wednesday morning.
The secondary school pupil from Co Tipperary started a 50-hour picket outside Leinster House on Tuesday, calling on the Government to address the large number of children awaiting an assessment for a disability or autism for six months or longer.
More than 15,000 children are waiting for an assessment of need, but the
HSE
estimates the number will grow to 25,000 by the end of this year.
Just over 24 hours into her protest, Cara said the Government has not committed to any of the main asks of her campaign, which include its declaration of the assessment of need backlog as a national emergency for children.
READ MORE
'It's the same as usual. He [Mr Martin] didn't really agree to follow on with any of the asks. He's a lovely guy and I don't doubt his sincerity but it went exactly how I expected it to go. All talk but very little action.
'I don't think that things have changed and I don't think that things are going to change anytime soon. I'm going to keep trying my best to get change.'
Despite feeling there has been little progress, Cara said she is confident that she 'can win this issue, especially with the Opposition backing me up last night'.
On Tuesday evening the Dáil debated a motion put down by Sinn Féin demanding that the Government takes emergency action.
[
Government to change law in bid to speed up autism and disability assessments
Opens in new window
]
Speaking during the debate, Mr Martin said the issue was not one of resources but one of capacity: 'I think we have to facilitate more recruitment of therapists from overseas, and I think the regulatory body needs to be flexible in that regard.'
'I am in the process of establishing the first ever disability unit within the Department of Taoiseach to troubleshoot and to co-ordinate across all Government departments the provision of services for people with disabilities,' he said. 'The need is increasing all of the time.'
[
It's a strange day in the Dáil when a schoolgirl makes the Government squirm with embarrassment
Opens in new window
]
Cara's father, Mark Darmody, was with her for the meeting with Mr Martin at 9am on Wednesday.
'We've had lots of these meetings before,' said Mr Darmody. 'He had lots of plans, he listened to us, he took on board an awful lot of stuff including setting up a taskforce and all that. But we just didn't leave feeling that he was going to do something urgent.'
Referencing Mr Martin's comments on recruitment, Mr Darmody said: 'He has great plans to recruit and all this stuff but it's going to take years to do that. If that happens, children are destined to remain rotting on waiting lists. You might love to know what number before they would declare it a national crisis.
'Unfortunately for him, the numbers are only going one way, so if those numbers hit 25,000 at Christmas I think he's in big trouble.'
Asked how the first half of her 50-hour protest has felt, Cara said: 'It has been a long 24 hours.
'I only got around six hours of sleep last night, and that's really bad because I get 10 hours of sleep every night. My dad didn't get any sleep, he was shaking this morning. I'm just over half way through but I'm determined to keep fighting.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Dublin Airport will eventually exceed 40 million passengers a year, Minister for Transport predicts
Imposing annual passenger caps on Dublin Airport will be 'arbitrary' as even the 40 million cap being sought by airport operator DAA will be surpassed within a short period, Minister for Transport Darragh O'Brien says. The cap of 32 million passengers a year, which has been in place since 2008, was breached in 2023 and 2024. Mr O'Brien said the number of passengers passing through the airport was likely to exceed 36 million this year. He said it was a clear aim in the Programme for Government to end the restriction on passenger numbers. READ MORE 'I want to see the cap in Dublin Airport removed. I think any artificial stifling of growth within Dublin Airport, it would be counterproductive for the country,' he said. Last week, Fingal County Council, which is the local authority with responsibility for the airport, issued an enforcement notice that gave DAA a two-year period to comply with the planning conditions imposed by An Bord Pleanála in 2008. However, there is a High Court-imposed stay pending the outcome of proceedings taking by a number of airlines against the cap. Mr O'Brien said that stay was likely to remain until the second half of next year. He said the Government was now working on a new National Aviation Policy to address the issues of the volume of traffic around the State's main airport hub. He said a key ruling by An Bord Pleanála on night flights at the airport – expected within weeks – would be critical. At present no flights are allowed to take off from or land on the north runway between 11pm and 7am. The night-time movements of aircraft in the airport are restricted to 65 overall. DAA has applied for those restrictions to be eased and there is expectation that aircraft will be allowed on the north runway between 6am and midnight daily. This change has been strongly opposed by residents living in St Margaret's and The Ward, two communities located at the perimeter of the airport. Mr O'Brien, a TD for the constituency, said he was very conscious of the concerns of those communities and the challenges they faced. 'I've been at pains to say to DAA to operate under the good neighbour principle,' he said. He said some people in the St Margaret's area were in effect living right beside the runway. He said the airport should improve its voluntary purchase package as the impact was significant on a small number of households. 'They can't be forgotten,' he said. However, Mr O'Brien said the airport needed to expand and that included passenger numbers. He said if decision on night flights was in favour of expanding the hours then that would help passenger numbers grow. 'A total of 3 per cent of GDP comes from activity around the airport campus. It's a critical driver for economic growth, and supports about 20,000 jobs directly and about 130,000 indirect jobs.' He said basing numbers on forward projections over 10 years the number of passengers would exceed 40 million each year before then. 'One should ask the question, if DAA applies for a passenger cap of 40 million how long will that last? Is that cap going to be [surpassed]? Therefore should you have an arbitrary cap?' Mr O'Brien also said he had consulted Attorney General Rossa Fanning and may bring forward legislation to prevent what he sees as overly restrictive limits. He said the cap was put in 2008 as a response to inadequate transport infrastructure at the airport. He said the situation had changed since then, with a change in terms of roads, public transport and access.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Hospital endoscopy procedures are increasingly being done at weekends
The proportion of medical tests known as scopes conducted at weekends has increased significantly over the past 15 years, but there is a notable variation between hospitals, figures suggest. These procedures are carried out using endoscopes, which are long, thin, flexible tubes with a camera and light source at the end to see the inside of the body. The figures revealed that 2 per cent of scopes were carried out on Saturday or Sunday in 2010. By last year, this figure had increased to 13 per cent. But the figures, which were released in response to a parliamentary question from Sinn Féin health spokesman David Cullinane, highlighted a significant variation between hospitals. READ MORE Cavan General Hospital had the highest proportion of weekend scopes, with 49 per cent of such procedures being completed at weekends. Drogheda Hospital had the second highest at 46 per cent, followed by Cork University Hospital at 36 per cent. Mallow and Nenagh hospitals did none, while Waterford and Dublin's Connolly hospitals conducted 1 per cent of scopes at the weekend. The health service has been seeking to move away from a Monday-to-Friday daytime working week and to increase the number of procedures conducted at the weekend and evenings. An HSE spokeswoman said there were 'many reasons' weekend activity varied from site to site such as 'availability of capital infrastructure and staff, seasonal factors or some of these could be targeted initiatives that the sites carry out to reduce the waiting lists'. A spokeswoman for the Department of Health said the Government was 'committed' to providing a seven-day health service for the public, which will 'make better use of our infrastructure if we extend the working day and working week and spread out the staff to fully maximise our physical assets'. She said there was variance across hospitals in relation to productivity and to specialisms within sites. Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill will be making this information publicly available shortly, the spokeswoman said. There has been a focus on weekend working in the health service in recent weeks after a 2022 internal report from CHI, which has not been published but has been leaked extensively, noted a consultant in a Dublin children's hospital was referring patients to Saturday clinics that were funded by the National Treatment Purchase Fund (NTPF) to reduce long waiting lists . The consultant was seeing twice as many patients at the Saturday clinic, for which he received additional money, than during his weekday equivalent, the report said. This has created concerns about 'insourcing' through the NTPF – where hospitals and their staff receive additional payments for providing treatment to patients waiting longest for care outside of core working hours or at weekends. Mr Cullinane said there were three 'critical areas' that required answers following the release of these figures: whether conflicts of interest were being managed; if there was a 'perverse incentive' for insourcing; and if productivity during Monday to Friday was sufficient. 'For some hospitals, doing the work at weekends makes sense. Some people find it easier to get through planned procedures at the weekend,' he said. 'But this would raise concerns around productivity Monday to Friday. The whole point of the new consultant contract is to get more productivity across the six days. The variation between hospitals needs to be explained. 'The NTPF should be about balancing waiting lists, if it's being used as another income stream then we would have concerns about that. That's something we need answers on.' Representatives from the HSE, NTPF and CHI are all due to appear before Oireachtas committees next month to discuss waiting lists and the use of funding to tackle them.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Ireland is becoming a country of moderate drinkers and voracious cocaine users
A major generational shift has occurred in Irish society without much fanfare. Alcohol consumption in Ireland has collapsed. A report commissioned by the Drinks Industry Group of Ireland published this month showed the average alcohol consumption per adult in Ireland fell 4.5 per cent in 2024 compared with 2023. The story over the course of two decades is much more profound. Since 2001, alcohol consumption per adult in Ireland fell by 34.3 per cent. Today, people in Ireland are drinking at average European levels (a good argument for reducing excise taxes). The Health Research Board 's 2024 report on alcohol showed Ireland is no longer a high alcohol consumption country by European Union or OECD standards. This is a remarkable shift, great news for public health and will have a positive knock-on effect for decades to come. The reasons suggested for this can come off as anecdotal or vague, but like any behavioural shift, there tend to be multiple factors at once. What we do know is that this is a trend led by younger generations, who are less likely to reach for the bottle compared with their older siblings and parents. The data consistently show this. A report by Red C in April – part of broader polling across 39 countries – showed that 21 per cent of 18- to 24-year olds drink often, compared with 31 per cent of all adults, and 48 per cent of older men. READ MORE Under-25s are more health conscious and therefore more mindful of the damage alcohol and hangovers cause to the body and mind. Alcohol is also as expensive as it has ever been in Ireland. Student life has changed due to the housing and rental crisis, with fewer students living independently as Ireland has regressed to a context more like to the early 20th century, with people living with their parents well into adulthood. Those in their teens and 20s are also more attuned to their mental and emotional wellbeing, and less likely than Generation X adults to hit the bottle to dissociate under the guise of 'relaxing' or reducing stress. There is less peer pressure among younger people to drink compared with the social culture older generations fostered within their peer groups, and less judgment around sobriety. The trend of alcohol-free months can also reduce people's consumption in the short and medium term, and sometimes embed lifelong moderation. Ultimately, younger people are more grown up and responsible when it comes to alcohol. For all the progress made around alcohol, there is a major youth public-health issue regarding cocaine use. This is not being addressed in anything approaching something effective All of this speaks to a sense of maturity, confidence and capacity to be grounded enough and able to exert at least some kind of self-control that was absent among older generations. What has also been happening is that more people are using therapy and other resources to address their mental health needs. According to the most recent St Patrick's Mental Health Stigma and Attitudes Survey, in 2024, 66 per cent of people who were experiencing mental health difficulties sought treatment, an increase of 10 per cent from 2023. A movement from self-medicating to self-care is a sign of collective emotional growth. It demonstrates a capacity for self-reflection and self-examination, as well as a reduction in stigma around seeking help for mental health challenges. But there is something else happening alongside the decline in alcohol consumption, and that's the rise in cocaine use. A 2023 United Nations report showed that Ireland is, remarkably, the joint-fourth highest consumer of cocaine globally. [ Cocaine cited as main drug in almost two-fifths of cases needing treatment Opens in new window ] Demographically, this is a younger person's issue. Among 15 to 34-year-olds, Ireland has the distinction of being home to the biggest consumers of cocaine in Europe. In 2024, the median age for those seeking treatment for powder cocaine use was 32 years old. Thirty-nine per cent were in employment, compared with 7 per cent of crack cocaine users in treatment. Heroin and opioid users in treatment skew older, with an average age of 45, in tune with the 'greying' of heroin and opioid users in Ireland, which has been the case for some time. In 2024, there were more people treated for problem drug use in Ireland than ever before, according to the Health Research Board . Cocaine was the most common drug used by those in treatment, up 7 per cent from 2023. Since 2017, there has been a 426 per cent increase in women receiving cocaine treatment. Figures for 2023 for people contacting the Health Service Executive 's drug and alcohol helpline also showed a record increase. Twenty-one per cent of calls were related to cocaine. In 2009, cocaine was mentioned by 2 per cent of callers. This is a huge jump. For all the progress made around alcohol, there is a major youth public-health issue regarding cocaine use. This is not being addressed in anything approaching an effective way. It demands and requires a non-judgmental public-health response, and education and awareness, all of which appears to be lacking relative to the level of consumption in Ireland. We are in a situation where there are signs that one public-health issue – excessive alcohol consumption – is being at least partly replaced by another. If we have the stats, where's the action?
