WE'RE WATCHING YOU: Rangers warn SFA they will monitor rival clubs' TV broadcasts after accusing them of making stronger comments than John Brown's 'corrupt' jibe

Rangers have warned the SFA they will be monitoring the club TV broadcasts of rival teams after they were fined £3,000 for a remark made by former Ibrox player John Brown.
A co-commentator at Easter Road on May 17, Brown was incensed when Rangers were denied a seemingly legitimate goal after Hibs defender Rocky Bushiri scrambled to clear Nico Raskin's net-bound effort.
With Rangers' interim boss Barry Ferguson adamant the ball had crossed the line, Hibs went up the park and equalised in a match which ended 2-2.
Neither referee Nick Walsh, his assistants or VAR Andrew Dallas were able to conclude if the Belgian's effort should have stood, and Brown said on air: 'I would say it is corrupt.' Commentator Tom Miller said: 'Well, I'm not sure we can actually say that.' But Brown replied: 'Well, I am saying it'.
Rangers were yesterday hit with a financial penalty for Brown's words, but claimed other clubs had made 'stronger comments on offical platforms without consequence' and accused the SFA of being selective with their punishments.
Found to be in breach of Disciplinary Rule 38 by a judicial panel, the Ibrox club have vowed to monitor all such broadcasts going forward.
A strongly worded statement read: 'We feel it is necessary to highlight the broader concerns this outcome raises and the wider implications this has for clarity and confidence in their (the SFA's) regulatory processes.
'John Brown spoke emotionally and spontaneously as someone who cares deeply about the club.
'His words were not scripted and they were not an official club comment.
'The ruling, however, sets a precedent where even spontaneous, corrected remarks made during live coverage of a clear refereeing error are enough to trigger a formal sanction.
'That is neither proportionate nor consistent, especially when other clubs have made stronger comments on official platforms without consequence.
'As part of our defence today, we flagged numerous examples of similar incidents on club channels.
'These incidents raise legitimate questions about Scottish FA rules and how consistently they are enforced. To our knowledge, none of these cases appear to have resulted in charges against the respective clubs.
'The lack of consistency with the Scottish FA's policing of similar incidents leaves more questions than answers.
'That is why we will be contacting the Scottish FA chief executive and president to seek clarity on what policies and processes the compliance officer has in place, if any, to ensure a consistent and proportionate approach to enforcement and the equal treatment of member clubs.
'We shall also be asking the Scottish FA whether they accept that a rule that cannot be applied consistently across all clubs and all platforms risks losing credibility as a fair and enforceable regulation.
'Our aim here is to understand the rationale behind the differing outcomes. A lack of consistency, or the perception of it, undermines confidence in the disciplinary process and exposes all member clubs to uncertainty about what is and is not allowed.
'There remains no clear guidance on how clubs are expected to manage live broadcast content, though we note the panel acknowledged that the club's internal editorial guidelines may serve as a constructive step for others going forward.
'To be clear, we referenced these other examples not to suggest they should have resulted in sanctions, but to highlight the clear inconsistency in how similar incidents have been handled.
'Club media channels are, by nature, passionate and partisan. Informal, tongue-in-cheek and emotional commentary comes with the territory, especially in live settings.
'But, in choosing to pursue this case, the Scottish FA has opened the door to closer scrutiny of how similar situations are handled going forward. If this is now the standard, they will be watched closely to ensure it is applied across the board, consistently, without exception and without favour.'
Rangers had denied any breach of the SFA's rules and had claimed the verdict of the Key Match Incident Panel highlighted the injustice of no goal being awarded.
By way of defence, Collum pointed to a disallowed goal for Celtic against Hibs which had also led to criticism of officials
Four out of five KMI panel members - individuals with experience from across the game - retrospectively felt a goal should have been awarded to the visitors.
Despite that, Hampden head of referees Willie Collum backed the match officials.
Speaking on his VAR Review Show, he pointed to criticism of officials after they ruled out a Daizen Maeda against Hibs earlier in the season, when the ball was judged to have gone out of play before Alistair Johnston crossed to set up Maeda's 'goal'.
'Let's go back to two incidents this season first - Hibs vs Celtic, possible ball over the line, and Dundee United vs Hibs, possible handball before it goes into the goal,' said Collum.
'We were criticised for both of those decisions, and rightly so, because ultimately there was no conclusive evidence.
'I know people who would look at this decision and say: 'That camera angle, for me, is conclusive'. But the reality is, that camera angle is at an angle looking in the way, there's nothing directly in line there.
'I've quoted before, in a World Cup match, there was a similar angle shown in a Japan game (against Spain in 2022) where, if you'd used that angle, you would say the ball was over the line.
'Then when you line it up directly in line, it only needs a slight part of the ball to be touching that line.
'Can the VAR and the AVAR there categorically, 100 per cent, say the ball was over the line? Not for us.
'Do I think it crossed the line? I think there's a good chance it did.
'But can I be absolutely certain of that? No.
'We've been criticised previously, we've now moved to say we'll only give a decision like that if we've got 100 per cent conclusive evidence, so the VAR and AVAR are correct to say there that they don't have that evidence.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

BBC News

9 minutes ago

• BBC News

Scotland end T20 series with win over Nepal

T20 Tri-Series, GlasgowScotland 193-5: Munsey 78, McMullen 42; Bhurtel 2-20Nepal 159 : Singh 43*, Airee 34; Greaves 3-27Scotland win by 34 runsScorecard Scotland signed off the T20 Tri-Series with a comfortable 34-run victory over Nepal to move into next month's World Cup qualifiers in more confident Munsey starred with the bat, whacking 78 from 39 balls to help the Scots set an imposing target of 194 at a sweltering Clydesdale in who had enjoyed two wins from their three matches in the series with Scotland and the Netherlands, never really looked like chasing who hit an associate-record 191 in a recent ODI against the Dutch, resumed that form as he managed six sixes before being caught chasing another boundary."Everyone mucked in and got the job done," Munsey told BBC Scotland."I really enjoy getting going when I can especially in front of a home crowd. I just love hitting sixes."I've just got to get myself in and be smart and enjoy the moment, thankfully it happened today."When Munsey departed he and Brandon McMullen had steered Scotland to 134-2, but when McMullen was bowled by Sandeep Lamichhane four balls later Doug Watson's side briefly struggled as Finlay McCreath and Richie Berrington were caught before reaching double figures. But Matthew Cross and and Michael Leask steadied the ship and shared an unbeaten partnership of 48 to see Scotland close to 200 chase started in erratic fashion after Kushal Bhurtel's ramp shot from McMullen's delivery in the first over was smartly taken by Finlay McCreath on the the time captain Rohit Paudel chipped one from Mark Watt to Chris Greaves, the tourists were 82-5 in the 11th Singh Airee lead the fightback with an effective 34 from 33 balls, but up stepped Greaves to bowl him, and then Lamichhane in consecutive deliveries to leave Nepal 117-8 and their hopes of victory looking grabbed his third of the day when he had Rijan Dhakal caught, and despite Rupesh Singh lasting until the end with a haul of 43, Nepal's resistance ended when Lalit Rajbanshi was run will now look to next month's qualifiers in the Netherlands when they face the Dutch, Italy, Jersey, and Guernsey for a place at the World Cup in India and Sri Lanka next ended with two wins and two losses in the three-way series, as did Nepal and the Netherlands."The key takeaways for me is the squad is growing now," head coach Watson told BBC Scotland. "We have 15 guys here who played with their heart on their sleeve for Scotland. They're developing nicely but it's a young group. "We've had some really tough and close games which bodes well for the future."

Scottish Sun

11 minutes ago

• Scottish Sun

Rangers ‘agree deal for key target' as Russell Martin closes in on first signing

Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) RANGERS are one step closer to signing Max Aarons from Bournemouth, according to a report. SunSport were first to reveal that Russell Martin was set to land his former Norwich City team-mate on loan for the season, along with Peterborough winger Kwame Poku on a permanent deal. Sign up for the Rangers newsletter Sign up 2 Max Aarons is set to join Rangers Credit: Getty 2 Russell Martin is set to land his first Rangers signing Credit: PA Fixtures will come thick and fast for the new Ibrox gaffer with his baptism of fire against Panathinaikos now less than five weeks away. He will welcome his players back for pre-season on Monday and is hoping to have some new signings in the door before the big Champions League qualifier next month. And it looks like Bournemouth full-back Aarons could very well be his first arrival at Ibrox. Sky Sports have issued an update on the potential transfer, claiming it's now pretty much a done deal. It's stated that both clubs have now reached an official agreement that will see Aarons head to Scotland for the season, but there WON'T be a buy-out clause to make the move permanent next year. The 25-year-old has fallen out of favour down south and was sent out on loan to Valencia for the second half of last season. He's now looking to revive his career in Glasgow with his old mentor Martin, who he recently described as being a "father figure" for him when he was a youth player at Norwich. Speaking to Talk Norwich City podcast last month, Aarons said: "When he came and trained with us, he had an aura. "You have to be training well every single day and I could feel that when he was training with us. "I always knew he would go on to be a manager. I think players that played with him always knew that as well. Rangers captain James Tavernier spotted training with ex-team-mate and old Premiership rival Ryan Porteous who branded him 'bad loser' "I knew we had to be on it when he was training with us, giving 110 per cent because if not, Russ will tell you and I loved that. "He pushed every single training session. "When he was training with us it almost gave me a feel that I was ready to go and make the jump with the senior players. "And as soon as Russ came in and trained with us, the advice he would give and the relationship we built from there, he was almost like a father figure." Keep up to date with ALL the latest news and transfers at the Scottish Sun football page

The National

12 minutes ago

• The National

Rangers agree deal for Max Aarons Bournemouth loan

The defender will head to Glasgow on loan in a deal running until the end of the 2025/26 season. As per the Rangers Review, it's understood that an agreement is in place between the two clubs for the right-back to move to Ibrox. New head coach Russell Martin played with Aarons during his time at Norwich City. Aarons earned a £7m transfer to Bournemouth in the summer of 2023. He spent time out on loan at La Liga giants Valencia last season. Rangers' players are due back for pre-season training at Auchenowie on Monday. And it's thought that Aarons could arrive in time to hit the ground running from day one. Asked about the aims of pre-season, which will include matches with Club Brugge and Middlesbrough, Martin said: '[The aim is] to work them physically, tactically, to get them to understand what we are demanding very early on and what the team will look like, and hopefully over the next couple of weeks to add a few players to the group, and I think we're all expecting that.