Former MKP leader, officials challenge dismissals over R588m Covid-19 hospital renovations
Former Gauteng premier David Makhura at the opening of AngloGold Ashanti Hospital in Carletonville. Officials involved in the procurement of renovations of the facility, that skyrocketed from R50 million to R588m, are now challenging their dismissals.
Image: Supplied
FORMER uMkhonto weSizwe Party (MKP) secretary-general Dr. Sifiso Maseko and several other senior Gauteng provincial government officials are challenging their dismissals for renovations to a Covid-19 hospital, where costs ballooned from R50 million to R588m.
Maseko, who was the provincial department of health's chief director responsible for infrastructure management, was asked to return to work from suspension in October last year following the conclusion of his disciplinary hearing and while awaiting its findings.
In February, the provincial government announced that five of the nine officials, who were suspended in 2022 facing charges of financial misconduct and gross financial misconduct, had been dismissed and two received written warnings, one was acquitted while another could not be subjected to disciplinary action after leaving the public service.
They were held responsible for the costs of the skyrocketing project, from the initial estimate of R50m to R588m, without having received approval from the provincial health department.
The action taken against the officials followed Special Investigation Unit (SIU) recommendations that premier Panyaza Lesufi's office institute disciplinary action against them over irregularities in the awarding of contracts for the refurbishment of the Western Deep Levels Hospital (also known as the AngloGold Ashanti Hospital) in Carletonville on Gauteng's West Rand - at the height of the Covid-19 pandemic.
According to the SIU, a dozen professional service providers and contractors appointed for the project were not on the departments' approved panel and were telephonically advised of their appointments but overcharged the provincial government.
Maseko is now among the four officials challenging their dismissals alongside Mokhele Raseboka, Sipho Makhumisani and Trevor Tabane, who were employed by the Gauteng department of infrastructure development.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Next
Stay
Close ✕
The former MKP leader has hauled the provincial department of health before the Public Health and Social Development Sectoral Bargaining Council (PHSDSBC), where the provincial department of health wanted the matter to be heard as a stated case.
A stated case is arbitration without the need for a formal hearing or presentation of evidence and involves parties agreeing on specific relevant facts stating legal questions at issue.
Parties then submit their written arguments and submissions for consideration and a decision is made based solely on the agreed facts and the legal arguments presented in the submissions.
Both departments also wanted an order for the joint and consolidated arbitration disputes to be dealt with by way of a stated case to save time and money since it will be repetition of the same facts and testimonies about the same or similar acts of misconduct.
Maseko objected to the matter being heard as a stated case as he felt it would be prejudicial to him.
He also wanted his application to be consolidated with the one brought by Raseboka, Makhumisani and Tabane at the General Public Service Sector Bargaining Council.
Maseko told the PHSDSBC that all four affected employees seek relief based on the same cause of action arising from a joint disciplinary enquiry presided by the same presiding officer.
PHSDSBC commissioner Advocate Ronnie Bracks declined to consolidate the disputes on May 5, saying the bargaining council did not have the jurisdiction to do so.
Bracks also declined the provincial health department's bid to have the matter heard by way of a stated case but granted application for the appointment of a senior commissioner.
On Tuesday, Maseko said no date has been set for hearing the matter.
Maseko was the MKP secretary-general between June and October last year, when he resigned and was replaced by former EFF deputy president Floyd Shivambu.
loyiso.sidimba@inl.co.za
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
4 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Enterprising pupils from Cape Town school turn R1m in virtual capital into real-world win
Armed with R1m in virtual capital, learners worked in teams to build investment portfolios and respond to a series of fictional market scenarios. Each scenario challenged them to apply critical thinking and adapt to local and global economic developments as depicted. What began as a fun challenge at investor events has evolved into a financial literacy exercise introducing school learners to the world of investing in the form of the Coronation Top Investor Challenge: Schools Edition. Reuben Rietoff and Mbali Nhuku, from Parklands College in Cape Town, competing as the Cashflow Co-Pilots, outperformed hundreds of teams to win R25,000 each in Coronation unit trust vouchers, while their school has been awarded a R50,000 cash prize. A total of 292 teams representing 79 schools registered for the competition, with a minimum of two and a maximum of five learners per team. Of those, 191 teams from 58 schools completed the competition (submitted results for all three rounds). Armed with R1-million in virtual capital, learners worked in teams to build investment portfolios and respond to a series of fictional market scenarios. Each scenario challenged them to apply critical thinking and adapt to local and global economic developments as depicted. 'This was the first time many of these learners encountered the world of investing — and they rose to the challenge with remarkable insight and enthusiasm,' said Kirshni Totaram, a senior executive at Coronation. The competitors receive a beginner-friendly guide to investment fundamentals, to help them develop a working understanding of financial markets and portfolio construction. 'This challenge was a brilliant way for learners to apply their classroom theory in a real-world setting. Opportunities like this show them that what they're learning isn't just for exams. It's equipping them to make good decisions in life,' said Totaram. 'When I was told that Parklands College had won, I was surprised but not surprised. The competition is tough, but I know the calibre of our learners,' said Craig Fortuin, subject leader in Economics at Parklands College. The two enterprising scholars on the college's investing team said the competition felt like a great new opportunity to try something different. 'I think what surprised us most was how well gold performed — it ended up being one of our best investments. If I won money like this in real life, I think I'd actually invest it and see how I can grow it over time. It's made me want to keep learning and improve my skills,' said Nhuku. Rietoff said he has always been interested in commerce, and knowing that Nhuku was also keen on commerce, the pair decided, 'This was a great chance to see how our minds could work together. It was tricky at first, especially deciding which sectors to invest in. But, over time, we learned from each other, and that really helped us in the end.' 'We know that talent is everywhere, but opportunity is not,' said Totaram. 'That's why our programmes start as early as high school and extend all the way to the professional level — helping to build a pipeline of skilled, confident young people ready to thrive in the financial sector.' The initiative is not Coronation's first foray into supporting young people. The Coronation Exceptional Student Bursary Programme, launched in 1993, supports academically strong learners from under-resourced communities through their tertiary studies. Many go on to intern at the firm, gaining real-world exposure to the workplace. Post-graduation, Coronation offers the Catapult Programme, a 23-month structured experience developed in partnership with stockbroking firms. The asset manager also backs the Asisa Academy's Fezeka Investment Management Programme, which supports high-potential black female graduates when they enter the industry. DM
Daily Maverick
4 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
After the Bell: No, you're not alone; the world is a mess
As the world teeters on the brink of chaos, with everything from geopolitical conflicts to the unpredictable whims of Donald Trump stirring the pot, one can't help but wonder if we've traded a pandemic for a global financial cocktail of uncertainty that feels even more volatile than before. I hope I'm not the only one who feels the world is incredibly uncertain at the moment. And in fact I almost feel less certain than I did during Covid. At least then I felt that we were all facing the same problem. It would appear that some senior figures in the South African Reserve Bank agree. On Friday the head of the bank's financial stability project, Nicola Brink, stated during a Monetary Policy Review that 'During the review period, the global financial system e xperienced a degree of uncertainty and volatility that is similar to and in some respects worse than… at the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic'. President Cyril Ramaphosa seems to agree with the bank. He said today at the Constitutional Court that 'the world has become a very dangerous place now, with all of these conflicts that are flaring up'. It may seem strange to compare anything in recent times with Covid. I mean, during that time it felt like we were facing financial Armageddon. Stock markets around the world fell dramatically, at one point the oil prices turned negative (because oil tanks were full, people were paying customers to take the stuff). But actually, the bank is probably right. This is because the sheer number of elements that lead to instability is so high now. Then it was just one thing. And the whole world was facing it at the same time, if not exactly united. Also, it was clear pretty early on that Covid was not going to last. It was not going to be with us for a decade, it was going to end. Covid is a great example of another dynamic in global markets. That in real terms, nothing ever happens. Considering how much time, thought and sheer energy is put into trying to work out how markets will react to global events, this is incredibly surprising. But it does appear to be true. Research shows that actually while markets do react to shocks in the short-term, they tend to recover quite quickly. There is an important reason for this. As The Economist put it, 'The momentum of markets can be relentless. Shares tend to grind higher over time as consumers spend, entrepreneurs innovate and companies grow.' It would take something messing with this dynamic to stop this growth from continuing. But until around 10 years ago, I had also been told that property prices always went up. That if I bought a house it would become more valuable over time. That has not been my experience. Instead, because I bought in Joburg, values are going backwards. So the same can happen to markets. And I do worry that the sheer number of elements that are creating instability in our world may be taking us closer to some kind of greater life-changing market event than at any time since World War 2. Consider the sheer number of ingredients we are dealing with. In South Africa, the biggest variable is probably still whether the coalition government survives after Ramaphosa goes. But the rest of the world is a disaster. Israel is bombing Iran, which may or may not have nuclear weapons; Iran is responding. Meanwhile Israel is using tanks to shoot crowds of people who are starving in Gaza, creating more trouble for the region. Russia has invaded Ukraine and may well threaten other countries in Europe. China now has a leader who has almost absolute power and does not appear to have groomed a successor. Sudan's civil war continues with no sign of an end, and hundreds of thousands of people are running out of food. But the biggest agent of instability is, of course, Donald Trump. Because of his position and the power of both the weapons and the economy he commands, he is easily the most important ingredient in this toxic cocktail. But this also underscores how quickly the world has changed in the last six years. Before Covid the global economy felt like it was doing okay, and we expected our economy to grow as we put State Capture behind us. Instead the world feels like it is on fire. I do think we have to be conscious of our own journey through time though. As I have got older, so the world in which I grew up has receded. As it becomes more and more different to what I grew up in (so often for the better), so it may be harder to understand. A friend said to me once that he gets really irritated that the rugby authorities change the laws every season because that makes it more and more different from the game that many people now watching used to play when they were younger. I think that's a good way of understanding how the world changes us. It also means that probably everyone around you feels the same way. But for the moment, I think there is good reason to feel uncertain.
Daily Maverick
16 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Newly planted indigenous trees rise against bark stripping in Cape Town
A new seedling planting initiative is revitalising Newlands Forest in Cape Town, bringing together traditional healers, SANParks and conservation groups to tackle illegal bark stripping. Thousands of centuries-old indigenous trees in the Newlands Forest have been dying from pervasive, illegal and unsustainable bark stripping. Stripped bark is typically used for rope, dyes and paints, canoes, and by traditional healers for cultural and medicinal purposes. On its ancient trees you can see the scars with patches of missing bark, sometimes circling the entire trunk, a practice known as ring-barking that serves as a death sentence. This illegal bark stripping, driven by a market where a single piece can sell for between R100 and R200, is killing 100-year-old, seed-bearing indigenous trees and disrupting the forest's natural regeneration. The problem has become so widespread that, according to Niel Williamson, co-founder of the Newlands Forest Conservation Group, 'there's actually no part of the forest that hasn't been affected'. Williamson told Daily Maverick they have been concerned about the bark stripping and the impact on the forest for years and that it seemed to increase around the Covid-19 pandemic. While acknowledging the need for traditional medicines and bark for cultural uses, Table Mountain National Park (TMNP) manager Megan Taplin told Daily Maverick that responsible harvesting was needed to prevent the demise of the trees and the long-term health of the forest. When too much bark is removed, particularly through 'ring barking,' the tree dies, impacting potentially hundred-year-old, seed-bearing trees and disrupting the forest's natural regeneration. For years, the response focused on enforcement, but the demand for bark for traditional medicine persisted. Now, SANParks is using an integrated strategy to try to heal the forest from the ground up, with those who might be using the bark. 'There is no point just doing the law enforcement actions when the demand is still going to be there,' explained Taplin. 'We have to make sure that we deal with it in an integrated way.' TMNP approached various stakeholders including the Sugarbird Trust, Newlands Forest Conservation Group and the City of Cape Town to begin conversations about collecting seeds, germinating those seeds and replanting them in areas that had been most affected by bark stripping. Now it's got to this point where seeds have been collected in the forest, which were propagated in nurseries, and planted in the areas which have been most affected by bark stripping. The first planting began on Friday, 20 June 2025 along the Woodcutter's Trail. Donovan Antonie, section ranger for Newlands Forest, told Daily Maverick: 'They remove up to 90% and in some cases 100% of the bark, stripping from the bottom up… That's the crucial part of the tree and kills the trees at the end of the day.' Antonie said they have been trying to put proactive measures in place to reduce the loss of these trees. This includes raising awareness of the problem, painting trees with watered-down PVA paint to deter bark strippers, and law enforcement to apprehend bark strippers. In the past three months there have been four arrests in Newlands. The seedling planting on Friday indicated a stronger shift in SANParks' multipronged approach that moves beyond mere law enforcement – including intelligence gathering and proactive solutions such as painting mature trees. Now they have begun seed collection and planting indigenous trees in affected areas and are working with traditional healers to create awareness and find sustainable solutions. Day of planting: A ritual of restoration The trek up to the Woodcutter's Trail in Newlands Forest on Friday for indigenous tree planting with traditional healers from the Traditional Healers Organisation (THO), SANParks and conservation organisations was a wet and muddy journey through a richly shaded forest. The trail began with a steady uphill climb, winding through indigenous forest on a well-worn path that can be rocky and uneven in places, especially after rain. The group gathered to begin the first phase of indigenous seedling planting. More than 50 seedlings were planted. But before the planting began, traditional healer Jongwa Mdumata performed a ritual to bless the day's activities. Mdumata said they came to appreciate the natural environment that surrounded them, with plants and trees that were designed to sustain humanity and the earth. 'Let us preserve the natural environment amongst us,' he said. Hipor Hlathana, coordinator of the Traditional Healers Organisation's Langa branch, was part of the tree-planting efforts and has been a traditional healer since 2008. She explained that they use tree leaves and roots to heal the nation, but that they looked forward to learning more about sustainable ways of harvesting these materials. 'Families have got trees that belong to them. Part of the trees that belong to families is the Umnquma (Wild Olive tree) at Table Mountain, you cannot do any cultural event without a branch of it. But we know it is very scarce, so they are now going to equip and empower us more on how to harvest it because from generation to generation, we are still going to do cultural ceremonies,' said Hlathana. Umnquma is still going to be needed by generations to come, so Hlathana said it was their duty to ensure that it is harvested sustainably. Hlathana said that they needed more knowledge and information on how to do the harvesting for their medicine, and that they needed to find a way to balance conservation with cultural practices. Workshops with traditional healers are planned to discuss challenges and explore sustainable harvesting methods, hopefully ensuring the forest's preservation while respecting traditional practices. The traditional healers from THO who helped in the planting with SANParks were not the ones coming to the forest to strip the bark, but Taplin said they might be using the products and not know that it was unsustainably harvested and harming the environment. Replanting and future-proofing the forest Trevor Adams, based at the Cape Research Centre, provided further insight into the seedling planting process. With a horticultural background, Adams and the Biodiversity Social Projects (BSP) team have been diligently collecting and germinating seeds. He clarified that the plants being introduced are seedlings, not mature trees, since they are taking 'baby steps' to see what works best. The seedlings, including Cape Beech, Wild Almond, Bladder Nut and Cape Olive, are strategically planted, with taller, slower-growing trees placed next to faster-growing 'pioneer trees' to provide support, structure and shade, mimicking natural forest growth patterns. Taplin said: 'This is just the first such initiative of replanting in areas where they have been affected by bark stripping, where trees have died off, and there will be more in future. 'We need to try and curb illegal activities in the park… It's not so easy to contact the bark-stripping groups, because they're aware that they're doing an illegal activity, and they'll try not to be found. 'But that's why we want to engage with more traditional healers, so that they can make sure that where they are buying the bark from, it was sustainably harvested or harvested with a permit, instead of illegally harvested.' Looking ahead, SANParks plans to initiate a 'cultural demands survey' within the park to identify the various groups using Table Mountain National Park and the purposes of their visits, encompassing cultural, religious and recreational activities. While recreational users are well understood, there is a recognised lack of information about cultural, religious or spiritual uses, and new groups are continually being identified. Taplin said that understanding these diverse uses, including specific needs such as the requirement for fire in ceremonies or the use of particular plants, was crucial. She said the gathered information will enable SANParks to develop strategies that allow these needs to be met safely and sustainably within the park, fostering a collaborative approach rather than relying solely on apprehension for illegal activities. DM
