Nicky English: The rules that hurling could, and should, steal from football immediately
It's never a good thing when the referee
becomes a major talking point after a big match
. I'm always reluctant to make a ref the centre of attention because everyone makes mistakes and that's part of the deal when players take to the field. You accept decisions, right or wrong. Otherwise, it's impossible.
Thomas Walsh was stepping into
a maelstrom last weekend
: a capacity crowd, the Munster title on the line and an unbelievably tight contest between
Cork
and
Limerick
.
It's a very hard job at the best of times and we don't have enough referees, so I'm slow to criticise, especially as he is usually very good. But it's extraordinary to hear so much talk about 'letting the play flow' and how great the refereeing was, when so much was let go.
Fouls are fouls and when they're not penalised, that is unfair on the hurler who has been prevented from playing by an opponent breaking the rules.
READ MORE
You will regularly have situations that are too close or very hard to call but last week went beyond that. There were clear fouls that went unpunished. Frees are frees as well. They're not an eyesore. They're a fair penalty for breaking rules and there is a skill involved in putting them over the bar.
The 'contract' for everyone on the pitch is the rule book. That's what is agreed as the basis of the contest. 'Letting it flow' is always at someone's expense and that creates frustration and confusion.
What's a player meant to do when his hurley or arm is being held? If he doesn't get his free, he's under pressure from the threat of being done for over-carrying. He then has to drop the ball and often ends up wrestling and jostling with the fellah who has been fouling him. What does that add to the game?
We had a flashpoint at half-time during the Munster final when the two management teams wanted to confront the referee. They had already been barracking him – and each other – throughout the first half. His relaxed approach to enforcing rules meant that neither side knew what was going to be penalised and that was bound to create uncertainty at best, and anarchy at worst.
What happened on the sideline at half-time is arguably the direct result of not enforcing the rule book during the match.
The
Football Review Committee
(FRC) rules have transformed football. Last year, I took the unusual decision not to go to the All-Ireland football final. The game had become unwatchable and was neither enjoyable nor interesting.
Thomas Walsh was stepping into a maelstrom last weekend. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho
Yet, a year later football is flourishing and has arguably been more entertaining than hurling for the first time in years.
I believe a good few of those rule amendments have relevance to hurling and should be introduced. It is only the evidence of a partial championship and things might change, but equally there have been innovations that have irrefutably improved football.
I'll start with sideline behaviour. What happened in the Gaelic Grounds isn't unique. Tensions regularly surface on the sideline, even if this was an extreme example.
When
Armagh
played
Tyrone
in the Ulster semi-final in April,
Kieran McGeeney
kicked a flag on the line and
was yellow carded with Tyrone being awarded a 20m free
. The Armagh manager then had to watch as Darren McCurry opted to bring the ball outside the 40m arc, kicking a two-point free.
Dissent by players when a free is awarded against their team is punishable by bringing it 50 metres forward. Footballers have to hand the ball back to opponents when a free is given. Despite a lot of pushback, this has worked well.
[
Cian Lynch: 'Hurling is so instinctive, it's an art form, it's an expression'
Opens in new window
]
These sanctions have had a radical impact and referees have spoken about how much easier is to get on with officiating when there's not a constant chorus of complaint, at times verging on verbal abuse from players and the sideline. I would introduce it immediately.
The same applies to gamesmanship when obstructing opponents from taking the free or delaying your own restarts.
I mentioned last week that the hooter/clock would be a great introduction because it would take timekeeping away from referees and so remove their discretion.
John Kiely
queried the time added on at the end of the match but I had no issue with that. There had been plenty of other stoppages after the one minute was flagged by James Owens.
I was surprised that Kiely didn't focus more on the single minute played in the first half of extra time when they had the wind behind them and the referee had to be replaced.
The hooter would address the situation where we're here a week later debating whether or not the correct time was played.
Cork's Shane Barrett scored despite efforts by Limerick goalkeeper Nickie Quaid. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho
Cork had paid their dues on this. There's a photo of Dr Con Murphy and
Jimmy Barry-Murphy on the line in the 2013 final
. Time is clearly up on the big screen, and the two boys are more or less ready to embrace before play continues and
Clare's
Domhnall O'Donovan equalises.
Anyway, Limerick had total control over that passage of play. Peter Casey over-carried the ball in their last attack when even if he had moved it on, the time was up. From the free, Nickie Quaid fumbled the ball out for a 65, which must be taken according to the rules. It's a general point but players' mistakes cost teams far more than referees' mistakes.
Many of the FRC changes don't apply to hurling but there are a couple that could be adopted. There's no need to require a puckout to go a minimum distance but I would follow the example of banning passes back to the goalkeeper. This would cut out short, one-two puckouts with the nearest back and put much greater pressure on receiving defenders. This would facilitate a high press and with it, jeopardy potentially leading to goal chances.
In my view there is also a place for the 'solo-and-go'. This would allow a player to tap a free to himself and set off on a run, which the opposition couldn't challenge for 4m. I would regulate it by stipulating that anyone availing of this would not be allowed to handpass the ball.
This would broaden the range of penalties and encourage attacking movement.
There's no obvious argument for incentivising scores from distance because we have enough of those already. But I would revisit the FRC's parallel recommendation – later withdrawn – that a goal be revalued to four and maybe even five points.
In my lifetime, rugby has revised the try from three to four to five points to maintain some sort of balance. Hurling needs to reorientate towards committing more players to attack and drawing them away from the middle third, which is almost too congested to referee properly.
Limerick's Diarmaid Byrnes and Diarmuid Healy of Cork during the Munster hurling final. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho
We see a lot of contesting in that middle third but fewer goals than used to be the case. I'm not saying go back to 14 one-on-ones but try to stretch the play a bit more.
Do we need this tactical change? We need to consider it, as I'm not sure I'm happy with the direction of the game.
Maybe it's time for an HRC to look at all of this as a package. I don't know if William Maher's role as national head of hurling would include something like this given all of his developmental responsibilities. If not, I would appoint a committee similar to the FRC with a remit broader than just rules.
It could also look at whether the current condensed season has been in the game's best interest.
The game is still a lot better than it was when I played it but that doesn't mean it shouldn't be regularly monitored – and modified – for potential improvement.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
31 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Anthony Daly: Can Galway bring enough anger to derail what is now a Liam Cahill team?
During my six years as Dublin manager, I only had a handful of rows with John Costello, then Dublin secretary and CEO, but one of the biggest arguments I had with John was before the 2014 All-Ireland quarter-final against Tipperary. We had just been beaten by Kilkenny in the Leinster final when I got a call from John the following day to inform me that the likely venue for our quarter-final was Thurles. I lost the head. 'What the hell are we going down there for, into their backyard? No way. Tell them to clear off.' John wasn't having it, saying that Tipp were arguing the decision on the basis that they had played us in Croke Park in the All-Ireland semi-final three years earlier. 'Is this a joke John?' I asked him. 'Sure every All-Ireland semi-final is in Croke Park. What did they want us to do – play it in Portlaoise? Tell them not a hope are we going to Thurles.' I was bull thick but I ended up banging my head off a brick wall. When I couldn't get around Costello, I tried to sweet talk the late Andy Kettle, who was then chairman. When Andy couldn't do anything to change the decision, I got Ciaran 'Hedgo' Heatherton, one of my selectors, to ring Seán Shanley, who was vice-chairman and very sympathetic and supportive towards the hurlers. I was raging when we seemed to be talking to the wall, especially when I was already seething with our performance in the Leinster final. I felt we needed every advantage going to try and beat Tipp – and now we had to go into their own patch. In my own head, I just felt it was all very unfair. I remember going into Parnell Park the Tuesday night before that quarter-final and the grass wasn't even cut. Even at the best of times, the pitch in Parnell had a ropey surface and I was picturing Tipp below in Thurles training on the carpet they were now going to play on. That Tipp game was my last match as Dublin manager. We were well beaten. It wasn't the way I wanted my six-year tenure to end, but the whole frustration almost encapsulated my attitude towards All-Ireland quarter-finals. I just didn't like them. And I still kind of don't. Maybe it's just my experience with Dublin that has clouded my judgement because I had a lot of good days in quarter-finals as a player and manager with Clare, beating Galway in 1999 (after a replay) and overcoming Wexford twice (as a manager) in 2005 and 2006. The only blip was the quarter-final defeat to Kilkenny in 2004 after a replay but the drawn game was a magical day, when we looked dead and buried before Jamesie O'Connor nailed the equaliser with the last puck. My first quarter-final with the Dubs was in 2009 when we lost to Limerick in a match we should have won. We had a good year and had made great progress, which was very satisfying, but it was still a missed opportunity that gnawed away at me over the winter. In 2011, we had won the league before losing the Leinster final to Kilkenny, but it wasn't that hard to lift the lads ahead of the quarter-final against Limerick. We'd had a good year. The league final gave us great confidence and the Kilkenny defeat didn't drain a lot of that out of us. I felt we'd beat Limerick, which we did. That was the one high-point but I have never warmed to quarter-finals since. Even though Clare won their last three quarter-finals, I found them frustrating experiences even as a supporter. Maybe it's just the hurling fanatic in me but I always get the impression that half the stadium doesn't care when there is a double-header. Whichever crowd loses the curtain-raiser is gone by the final whistle, while the winners' supporters are out the gap by half-time of the second match. And the whole sense of occasion just collapses like a deck of cards. Cork are a different animal again, win or lose. After they lost the 2022 curtain-raiser to Galway, the rebel hordes emptied Semple Stadium. After they beat Dublin in the curtain-raiser last year, the red wave just swept out of Thurles like a tide washing out to sea. Having the games early on a Saturday afternoon twice in the last three years certainly didn't help, but I have long felt that the double-header just doesn't work and that there should be standalone fixtures. Circumstances have dictated as much now, which I think will certainly make a difference around the atmosphere and appeal of the matches. The Dubs may be part of a double-header with the footballers but at least they'll get a decent crowd in early, while Limerick will arrive to the capital in enough numbers to make it feel like an occasion. I'm glad that Galway-Tipp is in Limerick but I'd have preferred if it was on in Ennis – and not just out of comfort for me. I'm not sure what kind of a crowd will be in the Gaelic Grounds but it certainly won't be a sellout, whereas Ennis would have been. I just felt they should have gone with Cusack Park and made it an all-ticket game. The vast majority of people who will go today would have got a ticket but the scramble would have also drummed up more hype and discussion around the occasion, which, to be honest, has been fairly low-key this week. Much of that is down to the GAA not promoting the quarter-finals enough but it's also probably a result of the distrust around Galway and what team may actually turn up. Galway haven't liked Tipp since the 1980s but they're so Jekyll and Hyde that even their own supporters can't trust them to bring enough anger into this match to make it into the kind of spectacle that their public deserves. Galway were a joke in their opening game in Nowlan Park and, while they recovered well in their next four matches, they were back to their old bad habits in the Leinster final. Aside from a seven or eight minute burst late on, Kilkenny rode roughshod over them. Galway need to cut loose again now because I'd be fairly confident that Tipp will. They're back in a quarter-final when a lot of people – including their own – wouldn't have expected Tipp to have reached this stage at the outset of the championship. They have improved as the championship has gone on, but I also think they're in a far better physical – and mental – state than they were when Tipp were last on this stage in 2023. That year, their form was slowly draining away as the championship progressed and they effectively bottomed out against Galway that afternoon in Limerick. I'm not sure if all the older brigade had bought into the Liam Cahill project in that first year whereas this is definitely Cahill's team now. Tipp almost seemed stuck in neutral on that mid-June evening in 2023 whereas this is a team on the move now. This has all the makings of a cracker but I really think it's down to Galway to make sure that it is. Is there enough badness in them to win a game like this? Everybody is already talking about Cork and Tipp in the semi-final. That's dangerous talk for Tipp but it's music to Galway's ears. Tipp have to block out all that outside noise. They're capable of beating any team on any given day, but can they step up and take down a Galway team now that, on paper, they are better than? I just think that you can trust Tipp more so I fancy them by about three points. When the option of going to Croke Park to take on Dublin was put to Limerick, I'm sure it wasn't even a discussion for John Kiely. As well as Limerick loving the venue, only losing there under Kiely in championship for the second time last year, it's also an ideal opportunity for Limerick to flush that bad memory out of their system before stretching their legs at Headquarters ahead of an expected match-up there with Kilkenny in two weeks. Limerick are too professional to be looking that far down the tracks without focusing on the job in hand, but I can't see Dublin being able to contain a wounded animal hell-bent on retribution since the Munster final defeat. Losing that game on penalties again underlined just how hard Limerick are to beat and, aside from the deficit in physicality and hurling ability, I don't think Dublin can be in the right frame of mind to take down Limerick either. If they had beaten one of Galway or Kilkenny in Leinster, it would have at least given them the confidence to think that they can live with Limerick. But I can't see it. Limerick won't be concerned about putting on a show. They will only be focused on getting the job done, which Limerick will. Kilkenny will come in their own good time.
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Dangerous Down almost ready to mark their territory
THE soon to be dormant, if not extinct, All-Ireland group stages have generally followed the rule of law. Table-toppers generally beat preliminary quarter-final winners - six out of eight times - and the two All-Ireland winners under the system, Dublin and Armagh, have topped their group. In a format not above criticism, the layered reward for where you finish in your group generally holds true. If there is one anomaly, and something that provides hope to a quartet of teams this weekend, it's that in the eight preliminary quarter-finals played, the third-placed team has travelled to the home of their rivals and won on four of seven occasions, while Monaghan also edged out Kildare in neutral Tullamore in 2023 with Newbridge out of action. Last Monday's preliminary quarter-final draw, containing more heavyweights than anticipated, resulted in three lop-sided pairings and one tie that just carries a whiff of, well if not cordite, enough propellant to provide a potentially combustible situation for Galway's All-Ireland hopes. Donegal v Louth, Kerry v Cavan and Dublin v Cork all look like foregone conclusions no matter how it's spun – and maybe the shock will come in amongst those – but Galway travel to Newry to face a Down team that seem best placed to upset the odds. That's true for two reasons. Firstly, Down have made unarguable progress under manager Conor Laverty while Galway, All-Ireland finalists in two of the last three seasons, just haven't settled into this championship since their successful Connacht run – although they will hope that their stirring second-half comeback against Armagh will offer the spark. Sunday in the Marshes will tell us more. Reigning Tailteann Cup champions Down are preparing for their biggest home match since the visit of Mayo in 2019. There have been Ulster clashes since, but nothing to match the level of excitement in the border town this week – or parts of it anyway. Back in 1994, Armagh's pre-season started prior to the All-Ireland final between Down and Dublin meaning that some of their players made the trips to training via a red and black bedecked Newry, seething inside as they passed every good luck flag and piece of bunting. They stayed up for months as Down raised Sam for a fifth time, but 31 years later there hasn't been as much as an Ulster title. Last year's Tailteann Cup was as much about ending a long wait for silverware as the trophy itself. Drive through Newry today and it's the orange and white bunting hanging from lampposts, a hangover from Armagh's All-Ireland triumph 12 months ago. The car flags driving in and out of a city that will always be referred to as 'town' by locals, are Orchard County ones. Except McCoy's Bar on the way to the ground and Páirc Esler itself, Down haven't braved marking their territory – yet. But there is belief, genuine belief, that they are ascending. Results are results but relegation to Division 3 this year was undeserved, subsequent championship displays have reinforced that feeling that they can compete with the best. When Laverty was appointed manager in August 2022, he took on a county in disarray. James McCartan oversaw a winless season beforehand and had been close to stepping down after a serious breach of discipline by players at a training camp in Dublin before being convinced to see the campaign out. 'Players have accepted responsibility and have rectified the situation," Down secretary Sean Óg McAteer told Ulster publication Gaelic Life at the time. Five players, including NFL player Charlie Smyth and current panellist Caolan Mooney, departed the panel before the Tailteann Cup with the latter lashing out at McCartan in an interview with the Smaller Fish podcast. Sources close to the camp suggested that the training block for the Tailteann Cup was the most enjoyable of the year while there was considerable anger that a Mourne legend like McCartan had been treated so poorly. Three seasons on, and of the 20 players who featured in Down's 2022 Tailteann Cup loss to Cavan, McCartan's last game in charge, only Peter Fegan, Ryan Magill, Daniel Guinness, Odhrán Murdock, Pierce Laverty and Patrick McCarthy were on the field against Monaghan last week. McCarthy, Magill and Murdock all won a pair of Ulster U20 crowns under Conor Laverty, Pierce Laverty was a long-time captain and Daniel Guinness has been Down's most consistent player over the last five years. Burren corner-back Fegan comes highly rated. Kilcoo man Laverty has 13 county medals in his pocket – and an All-Ireland too – from playing with the Magpies. He has crafted a Down team that shares so many of their attributes. Physically smaller than many opponents – as Down will be against Galway – they have an extraordinary handle on the basics and operate a running game that is maybe only bettered by Donegal currently. It's not the size of the dog in the fight, after all. He's also managed to rub out one of the black marks that had been hanging over the side – the lack of a marquee forward. On Sunday, barring any unfortunate injury, Pat Havern will move from 0-99 for the season to over the 100-point mark. Shane Walsh may have edged him out in the National League as the two-point king, but Havern is now the current heir to the throne with 21 to Walsh's 18 – although the latter did miss the Connacht championship. Havern, who looked destined to be one of Ulster's top handballers before giving it up at a young age, has previously been accused of not doing it against the top teams. Such notions have been swept away this season, Galway be warned. The men and red and black aren't back just yet, but a visit to the last eight of the All-Ireland for the first time since 2012, and at the expense of one of the favourites for Sam, and that Down bunting will start to be unfurled.
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Sam Mulroy: 'Families, lives, work and holidays need to count. We're not paid for this thing'
Sam Mulroy got a message from his clubmate JP Rooney earlier this week. It was a picture of the former Louth player's son playing football in the backyard. Before Louth's victory in last month's Leinster final, which sealed their first senior provincial title in 68 years, it seemed the apple had fallen far from the tree. 'His young lad John was never in love with football until he came and watched Louth playing in a Leinster final a few weeks back,' explained Mulroy at the All-Ireland knockout stages launch. 'It was very nice to see that you're inspiring the next generation of players. 'Louth is a small county with two massive towns and two massive soccer clubs in Dundalk and Drogheda. It's been a battle over the last while, especially with Dundalk's success in recent years in Europe. There's definitely more Louth jerseys floating around on kids these days.' Three years ago, Mulroy appeared on the BBC's The GAA Social podcast and said winning a Leinster title in the next five or six years was a realistic ambition for Louth. He took flak for his comments. To some, it seemed fanciful. Dublin's All-Ireland juggernaut might have been halted the previous year, but they still looked unstoppable in the province. After losing the Leinster finals of 2023 and 2024 to Dublin, Mulroy's prophecy came through. He had stopped just short of saying 'why not?' when asked on that podcast if Louth could win the All-Ireland. Now he's edging closer towards it. 'Last week Meath beat Kerry, and they've beaten Dublin, and there's games, there's results that you wouldn't be calling, maybe last year, that are happening this year,' said Mulroy, top scorer in the championship with 4-34. He believes Gaelic football's new rules have made the game more open. That's not to say he loves every one of them. He doesn't like that the kickout has to go beyond the 40m arc or having to hand the ball to an opposition player after a foul is committed, but what annoys him most is the altering of the rules during the season. 'It's 11 v 11 instead of 15 v 15, there's space to get shots off; players are expressing themselves a little bit more because the game's so fast, and there seems to be a lot more plays happening,' he said. 'Each play doesn't seem to be as important, whereas last year, if you turned the ball over, you could go without the ball for three, four, five minutes.' Louth face Donegal in a preliminary quarter-final on Sunday in Ballybofey. Mulroy knows Donegal manager Jim McGuinness well. McGuinness was involved with Mulroy's club when they won the Louth SFC in 2020 and 2021, the former being the first time Naomh Mairtín claimed the senior title. 'Jim was immense when he was with us, and a gentleman, and always very good with his time,' said Mulroy. 'I've got an awful lot of respect for Jim and what he's done for the game, for Donegal and our club. That was our first ever senior title in the club, so it was very special. I'll never forget that and the help he gave us. 'I was captain in 2021. He was very big on leadership and driving the group on. He would have spoken to me individually. I learned an awful lot. Just on the training pitch, how he spoke to players and got us to bring up our levels - you can see why he's been so successful.' GAA president Jarlath Burns said earlier this month that moving the All-Ireland finals to August from 2027 on would have his support. It would not have the support of Mulroy, who enjoys the split season as it stands. 'It gives a bit more time for those county players to get a little bit of a rest before they go back to the club,' he said. 'Taking into consideration the players' downtime is massively important. If you bring the All-Ireland final back to August and then they're still playing their club finals in November, December, when are they going to stop? That has to be a key consideration for everyone that's making that decision: when do the players get time off? Families and lives and work and holidays need to count. We're not paid for this thing, so I think that definitely has to be the big consideration. 'Even if you got a few more weeks between games… It's not as if you get to go and live your life for a few weeks. You're still training like a professional athlete, you're still in the camp, you're still going away on training weekends. If you push the weeks out, you don't get the time off. It's not as if we're going to be let go and go sun ourselves for a few weeks. 'Prolonging the thing adds more volume of training for players. I know it's tight between games right now, but like, Jesus, I love it. I played last weekend, I get to play again this weekend, I'd rather that than having to go train.' The possibilities for Louth in Monday's draw were all tough. It was Kerry in Killarney, Dublin in Croke Park or Donegal in Ballybofey. They would have been underdogs in the first two, and also will be on Sunday, but it's not outlandish to think they could pull off an upset. 'That's my belief, and I'll definitely be putting that message to the players when we go to training, that we're not going up to Ballybofey for the craic, or to fulfil a fixture, we're in a preliminary quarter-final of the All-Ireland Series,' said Mulroy. 'We played in a quarter-final here (in Croke Park against Donegal) last year, so it's a case of, 'let's try to go better again this year, and try to progress as a team.''
