Top 10 most reliable older cars from just £2,800… and the risky buys you MUST avoid
Dominating the list are hybrid cars, scroll to see which fuel type is worst for reliability
GOLDEN OLDIES Top 10 most reliable older cars from just £2,800… and the risky buys you MUST avoid
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window)
Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
DRIVERS looking to buy an affordable but reliable older motor should consider one of these top 10 picks from the Which? annual car survey.
The consumer group has revealed a list of cars it recommends with five-star reliability ratings between 10-15 years old, some for less than £3,000.
Sign up for Scottish Sun
newsletter
Sign up
From nippy city cars to big family SUVs, there are options for all drivers hunting for a bargain buy that doesn't scrimp on quality.
Michael Passingham, senior researcher at Which?, told thisismoney that hybrid cars have come to dominate the list of most reliable, older vehicles.
He said: "Why do these cars perform so well? One reason could be that the hardest part of a car's life – starting and pulling away – are mostly handled by the small electric motor.
"These motors have fewer moving parts than combustion engines and, along with sturdy main battery packs, really don't have to work all that hard.
"The downside is that our data shows a much higher failure rate of the 12V battery (the small battery all cars have) on full hybrids; this component is worked hard so it pays to buy a quality one and get it replaced every five years or so."
In good news for consumers, so called 'full' hybrids' have been removed from the 2030 ban on sales of new petrol and diesel cars planned by the government.
Micheal warned against opting for a plug-in hybrid, saying that this type of car has "one of the least reliable engine types according to our data".
Here is the full list of the 10 best buys for the most reliable older cars...
10. Toyota Auris (2012-2019)
Average used price: £4,650
10
The Toyota Auris is a great option for those wanting a green car that boasts impressive reliability especially for the price
Credit: Alamy
Faults: 28% Breakdowns: 7% Days off the road: 5.3
The predecessor to the Toyota Corolla, the Auris served as the brands family hatchback offering for almost two decades until it was replaced in 2019.
The second generation Auris, sold between 2012-2019, boasts impressive reliability with less than three in ten owners reporting faults in the last year, and only seven per cent saying their vehicle broke down.
The average price of £4,650 makes this a competitive option when looking for a family, and environment, friendly hatchback.
The only caveat is that the Auris took an average of 5.3 days to get back on the road after a breakdown, which is higher than other cars on this list.
Princess Andre hits back at money-shaming trolls who claim 'Peter and Katie Price bought her £10k motor as first car'
9. Suzuki Alto (2009-2014)
Average used price: £2,800
10
The Suzuki Alto is a small city-friendly car that is simple enough to get repaired cheaply and get back on the road quickly
Credit: Alamy
Faults: 25% Breakdowns: 1% Days off the road: 2.6
The Suzuki Alto, released in 2009, is still living up to its promise of being a cheap, compact and reliable supermini.
It was first offered for £6,000-£7,000 and now can be snapped up for less than three grand, the cheapest buy on this list.
The simplicity of the Alto makes it a particularly reliable option, with just 1 per cent reporting breakdowns in the last 12 months, and a quarter saying they had to deal with faults.
If it does need a repair, the Alto's simplicity means it gets back to you in an average of only 2.6 days.
8. Toyota Yaris (2011-2020)
Average used price: £3,100
10
The Toyota Yaris has a great track record of reliability, making it one of the most popular hatchbacks of the last 25 years
Credit: Handout
Faults: 23% Breakdowns: 6% Days off the road: 3.1
The go-to small, dependable car for many in the last 25 years, the Yaris, is still making recommendation lists for its affordability and reliability.
With less than a quarter reporting faults and only 6 per cent dealing with a breakdown in the last 12 months, the Yaris still holds up remarkably well after all this time.
This is the 2011-2020 model with a hybrid drivetrain, an addition which makes it economical to drive as well as to buy, averaging just over £3,000.
7. Suzuki Swift (2010-2016)
Average used price: £3,500
10
Suzuki Swift is considered by some an overlooked gem of the supermini class
Credit: Getty
Faults: 27% Breakdowns: 8% Days off the road: 1.4
Suzuki appears again on this list with the 2010-2016 Swift supermini, a compact, simple vehicle at a compelling price.
Received positively upon release, the Swift was praised for being fun to drive with a competitive blend of efficiency and performance.
Now on sale for only around three and a half grand, this might be a great option for those looking for a small but fiery little motor.
Although it scores a little worse on breakdowns, with 8 per cent being the highest on this list, it does only spend a brief 1.4 days in the shop when things do go wrong.
Couple this with a good score of 27 per cent reporting faults, and this characterful car is still a good buy in 2025.
6. BMW X1 (2009-2015)
Average used price: £5,200
10
The BMW X1 is surprisingly reliable for a big luxury SUV
Credit: handout
Faults: 35% Breakdowns: 7% Days off the road: 2.1
In a shock entry to this list, the BMW X1 is an outlier for luxury SUVs, which are often unreliable and costly to repair.
On the contrary, the X1 competes with other, much smaller, simpler cars with a respectable record of just 7 per cent reporting breakdowns last year and only 2.1 days taken to fix on average.
Consumers may be able to take advantage of typically low SUV resale prices, generally due to reliability and repair cost concerns, to pick up this hidden gem for a very reasonable price of around £5,000.
That said, the X1 does rank low on this list in terms of faults, with over a third experiencing issues in the last 12 months.
5. Skoda CitiGo (2009-2019)
Average used price: £4,500
10
The Skoda Citigo is mechanically identical to the popular VW Up! making it a great choice for a small car on a budget that also boasts good reliability
Credit: Getty
Faults: 22% Breakdowns: 5% Days off the road: 2.8
Mechanically identical to the VW Up!, the Skoda CitiGo was meant for squeezing into tight parking spaces and down narrow streets while keeping your fuel costs and insurance premiums to a minimum.
After being discontinued five years ago, the CitiGo now makes for a tempting prospect on the second-hand market.
It was initially praised for being surprisingly roomy for being so small, and for being the cheaper alternative to the Up! while essentially being the same car.
It boasts impressive reliability, with only 22 per cent reporting faults and 5 per cent experiencing a break down.
The CitiGo is fairly quick to repair as well, only spending 2.8 days at the garage before being ready for more.
4. Honda Jazz (2008-2015)
Average used price: £3,800
10
The Honda Jazz is popular among older drivers, but this doesn't mean it's not a great option for a convenient and reliable motor
Credit: handout
Faults: 25% Breakdowns: 4% Days off the road: 2.7
Almost exclusively driven by those of a certain age, the Honda Jazz is popular amongst the older demographic for a reason: its convenient, reliable and easy to drive.
These attributes might get Grandma excited, but they should also make the Jazz an attractive option for anyone looking for a solid vehicle at a bargain price.
One in four owners reported a fault with their cars and the average time in the garage was 2.7 days being fixed by mechanics.
Your Jazz shouldn't be seeing the inside of a garage too often though, with only 4 per cent breaking down in the last year.
3. Lexus RX 450h (2009-2015)
Average used price: £6,400
10
The Lexus RX 450h is a very reliable option for a big family motor, breakdowns are very rare according to Which?
Credit: Handout
Faults: 16% Breakdowns: 0% Days off the road: 2
This chunky SUV was voted the most satisfying car to own in 2024 in a Which? survey.
A glance at the cars record quickly confirms that one of the factors that make it so popular must be its excellent reliability.
Looking at the hybrid-powered models here, only 16 per cent reported a fault in the last year and none had their RX break down on them.
For the times that the RX was sent into the garage, it only spent 2 days on average being worked on.
The price is a little higher than some others on this list, but buyers are getting both space, comfort and relatively good fuel efficiency.
2. Mazda MX-5 (2005-2015)
Average used price: £3,800
10
The Mazda MX5 Roadster Coupe is a British icon, and could be yours for less than £4,000 if you opt for an older model
Credit: Getty
Faults: 26% Breakdowns: 0% Days off the road: 1.7
The iconic MX-5 speeds into the number two spot for good reason, bucking the trend of unreliable sports car to still deliver thrilling driving with solid build quality at a good price.
Hailing originally from the late 1980's, this example of the world's best selling roadster is the third generation MX-5, it debuted in 2005 and still holds up today.
The record from Which?'s data is flawless when it comes to breakdowns, and shows that this classic is quick to fix only spending 1.7 days in the shop.
Just over a quarter reported faults, but that's not a huge figure when it comes to second-hand sports cars.
1. Lexus CT 200h (2011-2020)
Average used price: £7,300
10
The Lexus CT 200h is the number one car according to the Which? car survey for reliability
Credit: PR handout
Faults: 13% Breakdowns: 0% Days off the road: 1.2
Topping the list as the most reliable 10 to 15 year-old car comes the Lexus CT 200h, a full hybrid hatchback which served as the brands answer to the Ford Focus and VW Golf until 2020.
CT 200h owners surveyed by Which? delivered glowing reviews, reporting zero breakdowns and only 13 per cent experiencing a fault with their car.
Drivers praised the vehicles comfort and, of course, reliability, only pointing to a small boot and clunky infotainment system as critiques, as reported by thisismoney.
The car sells for around £7,000, the priciest offering so far, but its near spotless record should mean your investment pays off with a dependable motor that is good for years to come.
The ones to steer clear of
Which? puts the diesel powered Vauxhall Zafira (2005-2014) and Nissan Qashqai (2007-20013) as two of the least reliable vehicles that consumers should steer well clear of if dependability is their aim.
The Zafira has become known for catching fires in recent years due to issues with its heater blower motor and regulator. This usually happens when owners replace parts with cheaper, aftermarket components.
It is hardly a wonder that drivers are turning to cut-price alternatives when the Zafira breaks down on three in ten owners, with more than half reporting faults in the last year.
The car also takes a whopping 14 days on average for repairs to be made.
The first generation Nissan Qashqai also from suffers reliability issues, and needs almost a week in the garage on average before it is road-ready after a malfunction.
Both these cars use diesel fuel, and Which? has found that this is by far the worst fuel type for reliability, with an average fault rate of 48 per cent, compared to 39 per cent for petrol and 23 per cent for hybrids.
Least reliable older cars aged 10-15 years Vauxhall Zafira DIESEL (2005 - 2014)
Nissan Qashqai DIESEL (2007 - 2013)
Mercedes-Benz C-Class (2007 - 2014)
Skoda Octavia Estate (2005 - 2013)
Audi A4 (2008 - 2015)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
9 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Ten family car favourites from 70s to 90s and their value today – from iconic Ford worth THOUSANDS to budget Vauxhall
Read on to see if you have had one of these motors HIT THE ROAD Ten family car favourites from 70s to 90s and their value today – from iconic Ford worth THOUSANDS to budget Vauxhall Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) SEVERAL iconic family favourite vehicles from the last three decades have a new worth today. From the Ford to Vauxhall, these cars that were once common among British families in the 1970s, '80s and '90s still have value in 2025. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 9 The Austin Allegro was a popular family motor in the 1970s and early '80s 9 British families also favoured a generation of the Ford Escort, like this blue Mk2 model 9 The Reliant Scimitar GTE came as a two door coupe classic motor car for the 70s Credit: Alamy Austin Allegro (1973-1982) Value today: £1,200 (Allegro 1.0 saloon) to £7,600 (Allegro Equipe, concours condition) The Allegro was one of the popular vehicle choices for car buyers with families, as well as being company vehicles for employers. In typical shades of Russet brown and Applejack green of the seventies, the Allegro brings a nostalgia. This is despite its known maladies as a vehicle in the contemporary world, and even back in the day. They have been justified to be a worthy classic car and collector item, due not only to the Austin brand, but also its unique Hydragas suspension and style. Editor of the UK Hagerty Price Guide, John Mayhead, has witnessed the steady rise in value of all Austin Allegro variants over the past decade whilst monitoring the value of classic cars in auction prices and policyholder quotes. He said: "Last year, only 7 per cent of all models in the Hagerty Price Guide rose in value." Ford Escort Mk2 - Mk4 (1974 - 1990) Value today: £600 (Mk 4 Escort L) to £93,600 (Escort Mk 2 RS1800, concours) From the late 1960s up to the 2000s, families in Britain were likely to have one of the five generations of Ford Escorts. Children could enjoy riding in the back of these vehicles, whether in the lower trimmed Mk2 or more spacious and utilitarian third and fourth generations. Classic car graveyard found in field where a 1960s classic with rare feature worth up to $150K has been left to rot The Mk3 and Mk4 had a transverse engine layout, with a hatchback style rather than saloon. Models ranged from three and five-door hatches, as well as cabrio or sport versions with the XR3, XR3i, and RS1600i variants. To this day, there's still a lot to admire about the Escort, particularly with the Fast Ford racing and performance versions. They are highly collectable with a thriving club scene, and base models can still be found for cheap at around £3,000. Reliant Scimitar (1975 - 1986) Value today: £3,300 to £9,000 (GTE SE5a) The Reliant Scimitar GTE was an attractive choice of vehicle for those wanting something more exciting than a saloon or estate, but also looking for practicality. It became a performance motor offering a four-seat layout to appear as a family car too. In addition to the layout, the GTE provides a glass hatchback and proper boot, fibreglass body more durable against rust and well-proven Ford mechanics. Cost around £2,300 in 1973, the GTE became a viable cheaper alternative to something like an Audi 100 or 3.0-litre Granada GXL. Since last year, the Scimitar GTE has seen a slight dip in value, but remained relatively stagnant since 2016. John adds that some have been restored to a very high standard: "Lots of very cheap restoration cases available, but not for the faint-hearted." Austin Montego (1984 - 1995) Value today: £800 (Montego 1.3 saloon) to £11,000 (MG Montego Turbo, concours) Montegos have been considered the "most ordinary" of vehicles, but were certainly among the most popular of its time. A solid family car by Austin that had built its reputation for decades, Specifically, as a blue saloon built in 1989, they could regularly be seen parked in driveways or out on roads. Whilst they where just about everywhere in the 1980s, they became almost extinct by the 1990s. The Montego has increased in value as a vehicle model in 2025, following a flat period. 9 2.3 million Citroen BXs were built during its 12-year history between 1982 and 1994 Credit: Getty 9 Renault Espace Mk1 was an MPV perfect for large families in the '90s Credit: Renault 9 The Volkswagen Golf Mk 2 has been a classic German car in Britain Credit: Alamy Citroen BX (1982 - 1994) Value today: £900 (S1 1.4 hatchback) to £10,100 (BX Sport, concours) This French saloon spanned the years of 1982 to 1994, with a styling that became a major success. The BX's lineup of XUD four-cylinders were among the best frugal diesels of the '80s. Whilst demand for the Citroen BX was not exceptionally high in the UK, the model reached great heights in France. A well-preserved 1992 BX 16S even sold for over €47,000 in 2021. Renault Espace Mk1 (1984 - 1991) Value today: £1,100 to £12,400 (Turbo D) Despite famously being a flop when first released for sale in 1984, the Espace soon became a European favourite as parents recognised its value. With several back seats, it was one of the easiest cars for loading kids in the back, who were able to thereby see through the vehicle's large glass windows. Families warmed up to this Renault's bold box shape, following 12 months of struggle for sales of this multi-purpose vehicle. John suggested: "Early versions of this groundbreaking vehicle are beginning to become very collectable. "Now rare in any configuration, they are not expensive cars and if you can find one, a fair runner could be under £2,000." Best used cars for family holidays £5,000 to £9,999 - Suzuki S-Cross (2013 to 2020) £10,000 to £14,999 - Toyota RAV4 (2012 to 2018) £15,000 to £19,999 - Kia XCeed (2019 to present) £20,000 to £24,999 - Hyundai Tucson (2021 to present) £25,000 to £29,999 - Citroen C5 Aircross (2018 to present) £30,000 to £34,999 - BMW X1 (2022 to present) £35,000 and upwards - Skoda Kodiaq (2024 to present) Volkswagen Golf GTI Mk2 (1983 - 1992) Value today: £900 (Driver) to £23,800 (GTI 16v) The VW Golf GTI Mk2 was an exciting release for car-loving families, coming with five doors and more space for practical and better riding. It was a reliable car too with its Volkswagen reputation, better fuel economy and improved comfort. It was also capable of reaching more than 130mph. John said: "For a long time, Mk 2 Golf values lagged far behind their Mk 1 predecessors, especially in the iconic GTI configuration, but in the last couple of years, they have gained ground. "There's a lot of love for this model, and although prices are down a little from their 2023 high, the general trend has been growth for the past 12 years." Ford Mondeo Mk1 (1993 - 2000) Value today: £800 (first-generation 1.6) to £8,500 (ST220) After their release in 1993, Mondeos became a common sight on roads through the mid-90s. They served as private motors, company vehicles, police cars, trade workhorses, and even appeared in the British Touring Car Championship. "Excluding motorsport variants, the Mondeo is a very affordable classic with even performance versions being available for under £5,000," John said. They are likely to become increasingly collectable as first generation cars that are more of a rarity. Rover 75 (1999 - 2005) Value today: £900 (2.0 CDTi) to £16,100 (MG ZT, concours) The Rover 75 featured a retro design both internally and externally, providing class and comfort, more than image or rock-hard suspension. Popular particularly among the older enthusiasts, the 75 has not seen a major decline in customers since first releasing in 1999. It is a car that is greatly designed for the pothole-riddled roads of Britain, known for its toughness and rarity. The model has therefore not seen much of a change to its value, holding their price as many other classics are dropping. Vauxhall Zafira A (1999 - 2005) Value today: £550 (1.6 Base) to £7000 (1.8 Elegance, concours) Sales of this smaller MPV skyrocketed after being put on the market. As a seven-seater hatchback, it was a clever car with fine driving characteristics, and based on the Astra G platform. Today, they are rare to find in good condition. 9 Austin Montegos where almost everywhere in the '80s Credit: Getty 9 The Rover 75 model took a top award as Car of the Year for 1999 Credit: PA:Press Association
Scottish Sun
15 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Dartford Crossing charge to rise by 40 per cent in September – check how much you'll now have to pay
It has been nine years since the toll prices were last raised TAKING ITS TOLL Dartford Crossing charge to rise by 40 per cent in September – check how much you'll now have to pay Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) THE Dartford Crossing is set to become more expensive to use in just a couple of months time. The crossing - which was known as the Dartford Tunnel until 1991 - is made up of two tunnels and the Queen Elizabeth II Bridge and carries a charge for many who use it. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 3 The cost of using the Dartford Crossing is set to rise in a matter of weeks Credit: PA Used by around 180,000 cars every day the cost of using the crossing will rise from £2.50 to £3.50 on September 1, marking the first price increase since 2014. Transport Secretary, Lilian Greenwood, explained the toll increase was necessary in order to manage the almost 200,000 vehicles that use it everyday. "I am aware that these necessary changes to the charges will be unwelcome news for users of the crossing," she said in a statement to parliament. "These traffic levels are well in excess of the crossing's design capacity, causing delays for drivers." Buses, coaches, vans and other commercial vehicles with two axles will pay up to £4.20 when the new fees kick in, while vehicles with more than two axles will have to pay up to £8.40. The Transport Minister promised "significant" discounts on the tolls for people living locally and car drivers with prepaid accounts. "I am aware that these necessary changes to the charges will be unwelcome news for users of the Crossing," Greenwood said in her stament. "I have been determined to keep the nominal fee paid by local people as low as possible, as many rely on the Crossing to get around their local area." She added that drivers who live in Dartford or Thurrock and who have signed up to the Scheme will pay £25 for unlimited annual crossings from September 1, which is a small increase from the current annual fee. Greenwood argued: "The new charges will be significantly lower than if they had increased in line with inflation since the tariff was last fully revised in 2014." Traffic chaos as 'protesters' climb bridge with warnings of huge delays during morning rush hour The charges at the Dartford Crossing vary depending on the type of vehicle being driven and if the driver already has an account set up on the website. The fees are often referred to as the Dart Charge. Since the tollbooths at the Dartford Crossing have been removed, the charge can be paid on the website. 3 Charges must be settled by midnight the day after crossing but can also be paid in advance. The government website can be used to pay the Dart Charge and to set up an account to make future payments easier and cheaper. Users can also use the service to pay or challenge a fine, as well as check which crossings they have paid for.
Scottish Sun
15 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Inside minuscule EV with top speed of 56mph that costs just £21k – it's the perfect travel companion for summer
It could also be upgraded to a special package with extra perks POCKET ROCKET Inside minuscule EV with top speed of 56mph that costs just £21k – it's the perfect travel companion for summer Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A FOUR-WHEELED electric bubble car manufactured by a Swiss company makes the perfect companion for a seaside trip. Micro, the maker of the adorable quadricycles, has unveiled a new Spiaggina version last year. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 4 Spiaggina can reach a top speed of 56mph Credit: Top Gear 4 The car comes in two colours Credit: Top Gear 4 It sports vegan leather seats inside which are moisture-resistant Credit: Top Gear Spiaggina is the latest version of Microlino, a tiny battery-powered bubble car introduced in 2022. The microcar sports a 17bhp e-motor and can reach a top speed of 56mph. Spiaggina comes in two colours, reminiscent of Italian seaside towns - Portofino Blue and Sardinia Sage. If you'd like to enjoy a sea breeze during your drive, the quadricycle can lose its rear and side windows while the canvas roof can be removed entirely. The minuscule EV is equipped with a front-opening door and externally mounted headlights as well as a trunk. Inside, it features a simplistic but elegant design with vegan leather seats in a two-tone colour. The seat material is the same as the one often used in sailing yachts which means it's moisture-resistant too. With a 10.5kWh battery, the Spiaggina can survive up to 110 miles without recharge. Once out of juice, it only takes four hours at a home socket to regain its battery entirely. Microlino will also offer Cool and Connect package which includes a climate control system, a smartphone holder and a Bluetooth speaker. Iconic 90s Ferrari Jeremy Clarkson dubbed the 'greatest car in the world, ever' up for sale for eye-watering price The price for the Cool and Connect package is yet to be revealed. But The Spaggiana in its mid-range spec is currently available for £21,377. It comes after the Swiss firm's micro motors hit the UK streets last year. The manufacturer also plans to partner with major city authorities such as Transport for London to bring entire fleets of Microlinos to be hired, just like electric scooters and bicycles. Swiss inventor Wim Ouboter started creating Micro Scooters 25 years ago and transformed the way people get around. Since 1997, Ouboter's family-owned Micro Mobility Systems business has sold more than 50 million scooters in 30 varying models and generated over £600m.
