Watch: This innovative schoolboy try is dividing opinion – should it stand?

Who would have expected a 'try' in a New Zealand schoolboy match between Marlborough Boys' College and Nelson College to go viral, globally. But then the nature of it was so unusual it had record-breaking referees and armchair experts alike weighing in.
In the clip shared by Sky Sports NZ, you can see that with the attacking side, Marlborough, lining up a shot at goal when the kicker clips the ball off the tee to the far left of the field, where a team-mate is waiting on the wing. With the ball rolling into the in-goal area, the Marlborough attacker can touch down while the opposition try to scramble out from under their own posts.
The try was given by the match officials.
Try or No Try? 🤔
Gotta love schoolboy rugby!
First XV Rugby LIVE with #SkySportNZ pic.twitter.com/T2fcvayRhN
— Sky Sport NZ (@skysportnz) May 29, 2025
Debate has raged since, on the validity of the score. Former international referee Nigel Owens – who has overseen 100 Test matches – waded in online, posting on X: 'No try. You must make a genuine attempt to kick at goal before the try can be allowed to stand. This clearly wasn't.'
Owens then added, in response to another user querying what the sanction should be, he replied 'PK [penalty kick] void scrum.'
The point continually raised is whether once indicating to shoot for the posts, you must go for the posts. According to World Rugby's law book, under rule 8.20, it says: 'If the team indicates to the referee the intention to kick at goal, they must kick at goal. The intention to kick can be communicated to the referee or signalled by the arrival of the kicking tee or sand, or when the player makes a mark on the ground.'
Some have hailed the ingenuity of the play, however.
You may see echoes of the moment at the 2007 World Cup, when England were playing Tonga. Jonny Wilkinson had the ball on the spot where the referee signalled a penalty, when he spotted space in front of Paul Sackey. Kicking crossfield, the winger raced to touch down and earn England another try.
Back then, however, Wilkinson had not told the officials he would go for goal and there was no signal.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Scottish Sun

an hour ago

• Scottish Sun

Helen Skelton sells off one of her homes she shares with ex husband amid Gethin Jones romance

She was recently spotted on a Cheshire spa trip with her co-star LAST OFFER Helen Skelton sells off one of her homes she shares with ex husband amid Gethin Jones romance Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) HELEN Skelton has apparently sold off one of her homes that she shared with ex husband, Richie Myler. This comes as she continues to become close to her BBC Morning Live co-star Gethin Jones. Sign up for the Entertainment newsletter Sign up 9 Helen Skelton is apparently selling off her properties that she used to share with her ex-husband Credit: Splash 9 She previously split from Rugby star Richie Myler after nine years of marriage Credit: Getty 9 The Sun previously reported that she continues to grow close to her BBC Morning Live co-star Gethin Jones Credit: Instagram 9 Helen and her ex have sold the first home they bought in January 2020 for £500,000 despite its original listing of offers over £895,000 Credit: right move The former Blue Peter face previously announced her split from rugby league ace in April 2022 as she revealed he left the family home. Just four months after Helen gave birth to her third child Elsie, he walked out of their nine-year marriage. The duo turned two adjacent houses into a lavish eight bedroom dream home just months before their relationship came to an end. However, the property was put on the market for £1.8million just weeks after the split. The MailOnline reported that Helen hoped to make £500,000 from the sale. Now, the publication reports that the former couple have divided up their properties once again, amid her new romance. They sold the first home they bought in January 2020 for half a million pounds, despite the fact it was listed at nearly £900,000. It is described as a 'link detached house' with four bedrooms that was given a modern makeover by the pair. This was after the duo moved into the period house, which reported to have been sold, subject to contract. Other features include a modern open-plan kitchen and living room that contain exposed beams and vaulted ceilings. Gethin Jones and Helen Skelton's romance heats up as they're seen at spa The spacious room - which comes with a log burner - has plentiful access to south facing gardens. On the ground floor, other rooms include a snug, a dining room for guests and a bedroom with its own ensuite toilet. The two bedrooms on the first floor provide ample space, as the master suite has its own ensuite bathroom and large dressing area. Outdoors, the property boasts a heated swimming pool as well as an annexe with its own bathroom, which could serve as either a guest house or a 'summer entertainment space' Who hosts BBC Morning Live? Morning Live has been a staple of BBC One's daytime schedule offering for the last four years and airs directly after BBC Breakfast each weekday at 9.30am. But who presents the show? Gethin Jones Helen Skelton Michelle Ackerley Kym Marsh Sara Cox Gaby Roslin Rav Wilding Kimberley Walsh The outlet also reports that the couple still own a second property they bought in 2021 for £635,000. This comes after we reported that the relationship of Helen, 41, relationship with co-star Gethin, 47, continued to heat up in recent weeks as they grew ever closer off screen. The duo were spotted looking loved up as they headed to a country club and spa. He reportedly took his alleged new partner to a wellness venue near his home as he surprised onlookers with their flirty antics. An insider told The Sun: "Gethin and Helen were all over each other. "They are clearly super comfortable with each other and it wasn't just like two friends hanging out." Our mole added: "Helen was really laughing and smiling as they spent time together before heading off in the late afternoon." 9 The period home was given a modern makeover by the former couple Credit: right move 9 It features a huge open-plan kitchen and living area with exposed beams and vaulted ceilings Credit: right move 9 Helen was recently spotted on a spa retreat with her alleged new man near his Cheshire home Credit: BBC 9 Richie moved out of the sprawling eight bedroom family home after their split Credit: Instagram

The Sun

an hour ago

• The Sun

Gemma Owen's ex Jacques O'Neill posts snap from hospital bed amid ‘setback' three years after Love Island stint

JACQUES O'Neill has posted from a hospital bed after undergoing an operation following a rugby-related injury. Gemma Owen 's ex took the opportunity to open up about his dream of being back in the rugby league after - four years after he went on Love Island. 4 However, he has since been ruled out playing for the forseeable after being forced to go under the knife. He wrote on Instagram: "Operation done.. Just as I was starting to get my confidence back and enjoy rugby league again, it's taken away, but that's life." Admitting regrets over quitting rugby to follow his ex into Love Island in 2022, Jacques said: "Four years I stupidly had out the game, being an idiot chasing a life that wasn't for me. "The result of that was that I ended up in a pretty dark place and losing myself. "I was putting off returning to play because of the comments from others saying I had no chance to play again, saying \he's had too long out' etc, comments about where I was at mentally & physically. "The truth is, I doubted myself too. At first I didn't think I would have ever been able to play again the state I got myself in to. "I remember the first couple of months back driving home from training questioning myself if I still had it in me or not but as soon as I got a good team behind me, got rid of all distractions my mindset started to change. "Even though my first season back hasn't gone to plan, I'm grateful for the life lessons I've had the last few years. "Every setback has taught me something valuable. It's built me up. Not just as a player, but as a person "I'll be back hungrier than ever." Love Island's Jacques O'Neill parties with Stephen Bear's ex girlfriend in Ibiza after confirming romance Jacques, 26, coupled up with Paige Thorne on the show but quit on day 37 after she started getting to know bombshell Adam Collard. He admitted struggling with his mental health and in an interview with The Sun when out of the villa, opene up about his diagnosis with ADHD, which he says impacted his experience on the show. Paige ended up coupling up with Adam, but they didn't last long on the outside. Jacques is currently believed to be dating Norwegian influencer Isabel Raad after being linked to Stephen Bear 's ex Ellie O'Donnell. 4 4

Times

2 hours ago

• Times

David ‘Syd' Lawrence obituary, fearsome fast bowler

It was one of the most horrific sounds ever heard at a cricket ground. When David Lawrence fell horribly in the middle of his delivery stride as he was about to bowl on the last day of the Third Test between England and New Zealand at the Basin Reserve in Wellington on February 10, 1992, those present claim that the noise of his left kneecap shattering rang out 'like a pistol shot'. Lawrence echoed the analogy, recalling that it 'felt like a sniper had shot me in the knee'. The sound of his screams of pain was even louder as he was stretchered from the field, consoled by his team-mate Ian Botham, who was playing in is 100th Test. The medics were unanimous that it was a career-ending injury and Lawrence — known to one and all as 'Syd' after the bandleader — never played for England again. Yet it was typical of his bravery that he attempted a comeback for Gloucestershire in county cricket not once but twice. On the first occasion, after more than a year of rehab, his knee cracked again while working in the gym. Yet with grim determination he tried again and after missing five whole seasons, he took the field for Gloucestershire in four matches in 1997. His speed was down and eight wickets at a cost of 45 runs apiece was a meagre return, and he accepted defeat. In later life fate was later to deliver him an even crueller blow but that his obituary should begin with the moment that effectively ended his career is indicative of what a tragedy his injury was. At the time he was on the point of establishing himself in the England side as a powerfully-built quick bowler with genuine pace and endless stamina. He was, as Michael Atherton put it, 'a genuinely fast bowler in presence, heart and mind', and with Courtney Walsh as his new ball partner at Gloucestershire there was perhaps no quicker pair of opening bowlers on the county circuit. Lawrence ran in with arms and legs flailing everywhere. His direction early in his career had sometimes been erratic, but by the time of his accident he had started to add a degree of control to the speed that had made him such a fearsome opponent in county cricket. He was also the first British-born black cricketer to play for England. Others who had preceded him, including Roland Butcher, Wilf Slack, Norman Cowans, Gladstone Small and Phil DeFreitas, had been born in the Caribbean. Having made his Test debut against Sri Lanka in 1988, he was made to wait three summers before he appeared in an England shirt again, when he played two Tests in 1991 against a West Indian side led by Viv Richards and containing his county team-mate Walsh. In the final game of the series at the Oval he took seven wickets, including Richards, in his final Test innings, Desmond Haynes and Richie Richardson, to help England to a victory that enabled them to level the series. It was the sweetest moment of his cricketing career on the ground where as a 12-year-old he had watched in awe as Michael Holding, 'Whispering Death', took 14 English wickets. It was one of the greatest displays of sustained and hostile pace bowling and the moment when Lawrence decided that he, too, was going to be a fast bowler. He followed his triumph at the Oval with four further wickets in a one-off Test at the end of the season against Sri Lanka at Lords and was a shoe-in for the winter tour of New Zealand. He turned 28 during the tour and with five Tests behind him was reaching his peak. He was looking forward to many more, with an Ashes series in 1993 in his sights followed by his first tour of the West Indies. As the son of Jamaican immigrants who had arrived as part of the Windrush generation, it was his greatest ambition to play for England in a Test series in the Caribbean. He did make it to a Test match in Jamaica when England toured the West Indies in early 1998, but as a spectator. He wrote in his 2025 autobiography In Syd's Voice: 'I went out on my own as a supporter and stepped onto Jamaican soil for the very first time. Sitting in the stands and watching a game unfold in the sunshine, with the noise of the crowd, and with an ice-cold Red Stripe in my hand. Doesn't that sound like bliss?' Yet even then, bad luck dogged him. He had just settled into his seat on the first morning with his beer when, after ten overs, the umpires abandoned the game due to a dangerous pitch. After his injury, Lawrence struggled to accept how his Test match career had been cut short. 'I went through a bout of depression,' he said in 2014. 'It was a dark place. I got very low and was left wondering, 'what do I do'.' What he did was to build a new life — and a new body. In his playing days he had weighed in at over 16 stone and his barrel-chested frame grew even bulkier in the gym when he took up body building. He became the National Amateur Body Building Association's West of England champion first for the over-40s and then for the over-50s. He came eighth in the British body building finals and narrowly missed qualification for the world championship. All of his resilience was required once more when in 2024, after feeling a tingling in his toes and right leg, he had motor neurone disease diagnosed. 'You're given a diagnosis for something that has no treatment, and you know that no matter how hard you fight and no matter how hard you stay positive, you can't win… With those three words my heart hit the floor and then it seemed like my body fell with it,' he wrote in his memoir, which he dictated to his ghost writer, Dean Wilson. By the time the book was finished his voice was almost gone and he learnt to speak through a computer. He was supported in his illness by his wife, Gaynor, and son, Buster, a former professional rugby union player who brought forward the date of his wedding to allow his father to speak at the celebration. It was one of the last times his voice was heard without mechanical assistance. His final weeks were strewn with honours. He was appointed MBE in the King's Birthday Honours and was made one of six inaugural honorary life vice-presidents of the ECB. 'I am feeling hopeful that I still have enough time to enjoy this summer because the cricket season has just started and it has brought the weather I love,' he said shortly before he died. David Valentine Lawrence was born in Gloucester in 1961, the son of Joseph and Joyce Lawrence. His father had played club cricket in Jamaica and encouraged his son to take up the game. His success at Linden School attracted the attention of Gloucestershire, which gave him his first-team debut in 1981 at the age of 17. As a teenager, music and the beat of northern soul offered a rival attraction and he recalled hitching from Gloucester to Wigan Casino with a bag containing a change of clothes for a life beginning at midnight. An early encounter with his hero Viv Richards put him right. 'You only get one chance; don't waste it,' the West Indian legend told him. It was enough to persuade him to focus single-mindedly on his cricket, although he never lost his love of dancing. In later years he owned the Dojo nightclub in Bristol, often acting as the bouncer at the door of his own venue. Prior to his England debut in 1988 he spent several winters playing grade cricket in Australia and by the time he was forced to hang up his bowling boots he had taken 515 first-class wickets and another 155 in one-day cricket. Although he bowled at a fearsome pace, he was a gentle giant and when he struck the West Indian batsman Phil Simmons on the head during a game in Bristol in 1988, he described it as one of the worst moments of his life. Simmons underwent emergency brain surgery in hospital, where Lawrence visited him. 'I went into the room where he was lying down and his fiancée was sat there next to him and I just broke down in tears,' he recalled. In a 2021 Sky Sports documentary he revealed the racism he had suffered during his career, including a team-mate leaving a banana skin outside his hotel room door during his first away match. His county, Gloucestershire, issued an apology and the following year he was invited to become the club's first black president. 'I'm not going to be a gin and tonic person with a blazer on,' he said of his new office. 'I want to invite people of colour to the ground who may not have come to cricket before. There will be black poets up there, friends I have from Massive Attack. You want the camera to pan into that president's room and see a different crowd.' He was present in his wheelchair in September 2024 when Gloucestershire won the T20 Blast final, only the county's second piece of silverware in 20 years. When the Gloucestershire players handed him the trophy in the dressing room afterwards, there were tears in his eyes — and in the eyes of most of those looking on, too. David 'Syd' Lawrence, cricketer, was born on Janaury 28, 1964. He died of motor neurone disease on June 21, 2025, aged 61