Is R700 million for a national dialogue worth it?
Before the government spends R700 million on a(nother) national dialogue, it is reasonable to ask what the dialogue promises to deliver, is this worth more than R700 million and what are the chances the stated objectives will be achieved, ask the author.
Before the government spends R700 million on a(nother) national dialogue, it is reasonable to ask what the dialogue promises to deliver, is this worth more than R700 million and what are the chances the stated objectives will be achieved. Dr Oyama Mabandla, a member of the national dialogue preparatory task team, asks us to give the national dialogue a chance, reminding us that '[t]he national dialogue is an attempt to reinvigorate and fix a dangerously adrift democracy. It will involve the entire populace, instead of the self-selecting and incestuous elites, who have been producing one after another failed plan, while the rest of us have been spectators.'
But of course it won't involve the entire populace and the outcome will be a big report that no one reads. How can it be anything other than this? Even if you could speak to everyone. What then? Which ideas do you implement and which do you ignore? No member of the task team can do anything other than talk and although conversations matter, you need executive power to change things and you get executive power through lots of votes.
The reason we have elections is that you can't involve the whole populace of 63 million people in any dialogue, no matter how important. So we compromise and although they are very far from perfect, elections are the only way we have to get a sense of what citizens want.
South Africans didn't decide to give the ANC 40% of the vote in the last election to teach anyone a lesson, as experts love to tell us. A gogo voted for the DA because she believed they would give her grandchildren the best future and a young, first-time voter put their X next to Juju's face because they believe the EFF will give them the best opportunities, but most didn't even do that. Voting is the only opportunity you have to not get the government all the other idiots deserve. It is only in those few minutes in a cubicle where you can actually get something changed.
The national dialogue is not even that. You can say as much as you want in conversations and you will be ignored. This is not personal. It is the very heart of how democracy works. No one vote counts for anything unless millions of others agree with you and then that vote really counts. I have no idea why President Cyril Ramaphosa feels like a(nother) national dialogue will yield anything positive (aside from the events' organisers who will no doubt be skimming their 25%) or why borrowing R700m to fund this will yield more in value than the R700m, plus interest, that will be spent. (We currently borrow around R1 billion per day, so the national dialogue is an extra 17 hours or so of borrowing, which somehow doesn't feel that bad. But it is).
It's all about social compacting, we are told. But what is this magical phrase loved by many and understood by few? Does Ramaphosa love social compacting more than Trump loves tariffs? Will the national dialogue make more people less poor or will everyone just be R700mn poorer?
Social compacting would pop up in masterplans in the Department of Trade Industry and Competition for example, and mostly seemed to mean that a small number of dominant companies could meet with the government, without minutes or recordings, to determine how the rest of the industry should work. It failed even with the full power of government and the largest companies in the country behind it. South Africans, when you ignore the loudest and emptiest vessels, talk with each other just fine (even if that is mostly to complain about the government). The problem is that South Africans are getting poorer and most citizens don't believe the government, irrespective of which party is in charge, can fix that. That is why so many people don't bother voting.
The most important first step to economic transformation is to make it easier for more people not to be poor. The three great social ills in South Africa of poverty, unemployment and inequality, leaves out the fourth great ill which is lack of economic freedom. The EFF hijacked this term for their version of communism, but economic freedom allows people to solve their own problems.
Not another pile of the Master's Plans, pushed down onto South Africans, but allowing them more freedom to do what they believe is important for them. But the government doesn't trust its own citizens, so you can be "given" a free house shitty house after waiting decades but you can't sell it, because the government doesn't believe you can be trusted with your own money. You wait for decades because with free stuff, the demand always outstrips the supply and no one has an incentive to increase the supply. We know poor people will pay for houses if they can own them, because poor people currently pay for houses they cannot own. Rich people have economic freedom and poor people are not allowed to make their own economic decisions and so remain poor.
We have the only national dialogue that matters, which are the conversations which happen in parliament. Have your say and vote and you are part of the dialogue. Spending R700m so you can be told by a(nother) group of people how they can lift you from poverty, as long as you do as you are told, is a terrible idea.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
27 minutes ago
- IOL News
ANC to reshuffle its leaders in ailing Msunduzi Municipality
Msunduzi Municipality mayor Mzimkhulu Thebolla's political future is uncertain after being excluded from the reginal task team list in the Moses Mabhida region. Image: Supplied The embattled ANC-led Msunduzi Local Municipality in Pietermaritzburg is likely to have new political supervisors by the end of week following the exclusion of both regional chairperson Mzimkhulu Thebolla and regional secretary Samora Ndlovu from the leaked regional task team list. According to the unconfirmed list, Thebolla who is also Msunduzi mayor did not make it to the top five positions allocated to the task team which will oversee the work of the ANC deployees in the six municipalities under the party's Moses Mabhida region. His secretary, Ndlovu is also exempt from the list. The region encompasses Msunduzi, Umshwathi (New Hanover), Umkhambathi (Camperdown), Mooi Mpofana (Mooi River), Umngeni ( Howick) and Richmond municipalities. On top of the list appears the name of Nathi Mdladla who is said to be in the leadership of Umkhonto weSizwe Military Veterans Associations and former Msunduzi mayor Chris Ndlela. Attempts to get Thebolla and Ndlovu to respond were unsuccessful. The municipality under these two leaders has been besieged by administrative and poor service delivery problems which led to Premier Thami Ntuli's intervention with the appointment of a team led by former Human Public Works MEC Ravi Pillay. The municipality and the region are one of the strategic centres of the ANC, it has the second biggest budget after eThekwini and the region also is the second largest in the province. There is talk that the municipality will be merged with the other five smaller municipalities to form a metro. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading The ANC held a service delivery summit in Durban on Sunday and the provincial task team coordinator Mike Mabuyakhulu said the process to appoint a new regional task team had been completed but the party will publicly announce the names next week after formally informing branches. 'In line with the ANC protocols, we are not going to announce the names of the people that will lead our regions as task teams before informing our branches first. Next week we will begin that process and announce the names,' said Mabuyakhulu. Despite the ANC's insistence that regional task teams are an opportunity for renewal, others view the move as a strategic decision by Luthuli House to have direct control over branches in the province ahead of the party's elective conference in 2027.
Eyewitness News
an hour ago
- Eyewitness News
Ramaphosa believes democratic order in SA still in 'good health' despite various challenges
Babalo Ndenze 23 June 2025 | 9:56 Cyril Ramaphosa Constitutional Court Democracy President Cyril Ramaphosa delivered the keynote address at the 30th anniversary of the establishment of the Constitutional Court on 20 June 2025. Picture: @OCJ_RSA/X CAPE TOWN - President Cyril Ramaphosa believes the democratic order is still in "good health" in the country despite various challenges being faced. Ramaphosa said this year marks a bold new chapter in the country's journey from apartheid to a democracy, as it's been 30 years since the Constitutional Court convened for the first time. READ: Ramaphosa: The Constitution is a guardian watching over SA's legal health He was writing in his weekly newsletter, where he said the apex court's "humanistic" approach to law over the last three decades should be a source of pride. Ramaphosa emphasised the importance of the establishment of a specialised Constitutional Court, describing it as a key facet of the multiparty negotiations which preceded the country's transition to a fully-fledged democracy. He said that whilst some believed that existing structures, such as the Supreme Court, could perform this task, the African National Congress (ANC) advocated for a new court that was "untainted by the past". In the letter, he wrote that in March 2025, the United Nations (UN) Human Rights Council reflected on how the world was facing "a moment of profound instability", characterised by "conflict, democratic backsliding, right-wing populism with judicial independence being undermined". The council stressed the need for countries to strengthen democratic institutions "charged with safeguarding fundamental rights and freedoms". Ramaphosa said South Africans can be proud that they continue to strive to live up to this obligation.
Eyewitness News
an hour ago
- Eyewitness News
ActionSA launches campaign for 2026 local govt elections in Alex, aims to boost financial support for municipalities
JOHANNESBURG - ActionSA has kicked off its campaign for next year's local government elections, with a key focus on boosting financial support for municipalities. While the party acknowledged the issues facing local government, it said that increased funding was essential for municipalities to function effectively. ActionSA's leadership launched the campaign on Monday morning in Alexandra. Along London Road in Johannesburg's Alexandra township, several homes were surrounded by sewage flowing down the street. Potholes were hard to see as they're filled with sewage water, and in some cases, filled with sand to cover them up. A strong and overpowering stench also filled the air. ActionSA national chairperson, Michael Beaumont, said these issues were precisely what the party aimed to tackle if elected to govern. "It is so appropriate that ActionSA is here today [on Monday] to launch this campaign in Alexandra, in a community where you can see service delivery issues of many kinds have not been attended to for many years." Next year will be the second time that ActionSA runs for municipal elections. The party said it was born to address failures in local government. ALSO READ: Most South Africans favour coalition politics ahead of 2026 local elections - survey
