U.S. Supreme Court rejects Ed Sheeran copyright appeal
WASHINGTON: The U.S. Supreme Court turned away on Monday a bid to revive a copyright infringement lawsuit accusing pop star Ed Sheeran of unlawfully copying from the late singer Marvin Gaye's 1973 classic "Let's Get It On" in his 2014 hit song "Thinking Out Loud."
The justices declined to hear an appeal by Structured Asset Sales, a company owned by investment banker David Pullman that has a copyright interest in Gaye's song, of a judge's decision to dismiss the case.
The company had sued Sheeran, his record label Warner Music and music publisher Sony Music Publishing, seeking monetary damages over alleged similarities between the two songs.
Gaye, who died in 1984, collaborated with singer-songwriter Ed Townsend, who died in 2003, to write "Let's Get It On," which topped the Billboard charts.
Sheeran's "Thinking Out Loud" peaked at No. 2 on the Billboard Hot 100 in 2015.
Structured Asset Sales owns a share of the rights to "Let's Get It On" that previously belonged to Townsend.
Its lawsuit accused Sheeran of misusing copyrighted elements of "Let's Get It On" including its melody, harmony and rhythm.
U.S. District Judge Louis Stanton decided in 2023 that the musical elements that Sheeran was accused of copying were too common to merit copyright protection.
The New York-based 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the decision last year.
The 2nd Circuit also rejected the Structured Asset Sales argument that Stanton should have considered elements of "Let's Get It On" that were not found in the "deposit copy" of the song's sheet music submitted to the U.S. Copyright Office.
In a 2023 trial in a separate copyright lawsuit over the same issue filed by Townsend's heirs, a jury in Manhattan federal court ruled in favor of Sheeran.
"It's devastating to be accused of stealing someone else's song when we've put so much work into our livelihoods," Sheeran said outside the courthouse following that verdict.
Structured Asset Sales has filed another lawsuit against Sheeran based on its rights to the audio recording of "Let's Get It On." That case is currently on hold.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
3 hours ago
- Malay Mail
‘Freak Offs' and trauma bonds: Sean Combs's trial hinges on abuse vs. consent claims
Defence argues hip-hop mogul's ex-girlfriends consented to 'Freak Offs' Prosecutors argue Combs used coercion and threats against ex-girlfriends Expert testimony on 'trauma bonds' challenges defence's consent argument NEW YORK, June 23 — Prosecutors at Sean 'Diddy' Combs' sex trafficking trial showed over the past six weeks ample evidence the hip-hop mogul physically abused his former girlfriends and directed them to have sex with paid male escorts, but Combs' defence is likely to highlight instances where the women participated willingly in making its own case to the jury, legal experts said. Prosecutors are expected to rest their case against Combs, who founded Bad Boy Records and is credited with popularising hip-hop in American culture, on Monday in Manhattan federal court. The defence is expected to call witnesses of its own this week. Combs, 55, has pleaded not guilty to two counts of sex trafficking as well as charges of racketeering conspiracy and transportation to engage in prostitution. The sex trafficking counts carry the highest potential prison sentence if convicted — a mandatory minimum of 15 years, and a possible life sentence. To convict Combs of sex trafficking, prosecutors must prove the sex acts were commercial in nature, and that Combs used force, threats, fraud or coercion to compel his girlfriends to take part. The defence argues that both former girlfriends, the rhythm and blues singer Casandra Ventura and a woman known in court by the pseudonym Jane, were willing participants in the sex acts. 'There's got to be a linkage between the force, fraud and coercion and the participation in the sex act,' said Sarah Krissoff, a former federal prosecutor in Manhattan. 'There is some murky testimony and evidence in there regarding that, and the defence is certainly going to hammer that.' Prosecutors say that for nearly two decades, Combs forced two of his ex-girlfriends into ecstasy-fuelled, days-long sexual performances, sometimes known as 'Freak Offs' with male prostitutes in hotel rooms while he watched, masturbated and sometimes filmed. His defence lawyers do not deny that the sex acts took place, and acknowledge that Combs was abusive in domestic relationships. But during cross-examination of the government's witnesses, the defence brought jurors' attention to sexually explicit text messages in which the women expressed affection for Combs. Both women testified that they at times took part in the sexual performances to make Combs happy, and that they participated well after brutal beatings by Combs, who was also known during his career as Puff Daddy and P. Diddy. Defence lawyers will likely use that evidence to try to convince even a single juror that Ventura and Jane took part consensually, said Krissoff, now a partner at law firm Cozen O'Connor. To convict Combs on any of the five counts he faces, the 12-member panel must unanimously conclude that prosecutors proved their allegations beyond a reasonable doubt. 'Trauma bonds' Prosecutors argue the longevity of Ventura's and Jane's relationships with Combs does not mean they consented to take part in the sex acts. Both women testified that Combs beat them, threatened to cut off financial support, or publicly release explicit videos he had taken of them. Experts who said the testimony from forensic psychologist Dawn Hughes could be key in undermining the defence argument that Ventura and Jane took part in the 'Freak Offs' consensually. Testifying as an expert witness on May 21, Hughes said victims of sexual violence can form a 'trauma bond' with their perpetrators that can make it difficult for the victims to leave an abusive relationship. 'Such compelling testimony from the victims, corroborated by the other evidence in the case of Combs' abuse and control, will be very difficult for the defence to try to overcome,' said Stephen Reynolds, a former federal prosecutor and current partner at law firm Day Pitney. — Reuters
The Star
3 hours ago
- The Star
Malaysian doctor highlights Semporna's stateless kids in London photo exhibit
An avid photographer, Dr Byron Mohammad Hamzah is hoping to make a difference by holding a photo exhibition in London on the lives of stateless children in Semporna, Sabah. The Britain-based award-winning lensman says the exhibition is a celebration of the culture, spirit and determination of the displaced youth of Semporna. "I have always been intrigued by the lives of those on the margins, and stateless people in Malaysia are no exception. "The struggles faced by stateless communities have long been a concern to me, and I felt that reading about them in newspapers wasn't enough. I wanted to understand the situation on the ground. "As I have always believed in the power of photography in telling a story and its ability to encourage engagement, I decided to use it as a tool to explore their narrative and share what I learned with a wider audience," says the Nottingham-based Dr Byron, 42, in an email interview. 'I have always believed in the power of photography in telling a story and its ability to encourage engagement,' says Dr Byron. Titled Bunga dan Tembok – Pemuda-Pemuda Tanpa Warganegara Semporna (The Flower and the Wall – Stateless Youths of Semporna), the exhibition runs from June 26-28 (6pm-10pm) at the Photofusion Gallery in Brixton, London. Featuring about 40 images and a self-made photobook, the exhibition is the result of nearly two years of work. The free exhibition is part of a final graduate showcase at the University of the Arts London, where Dr Byron has been pursuing his studies in photography. There will be seven other photographers from Britain and across Europe participating in the exhibition. A powerful tool Photography has been Dr Byron's passion for decades. To him, it is a way to capture the true essence of people and communities. In 2020, he was selected as one of the winners of the British Journal of Photography's Portrait of Britain competition. In 2022, he launched his first documentary photography project, Salam Malaya (Hello Malaya), driven by a desire to reconnect with his homeland. The exhibition merges documentary storytelling, underlining the power of photography to educate and inspire. The following year (2023), his other documentary photography project Yang Tinggal Hanya Kita (All That Is Left Is Us) was selected as a finalist in the 2023 Taylor Wessing Photo Portrait Prize, one of the biggest international documentary portrait awards organised by London's National Portrait Gallery. While his earlier works focused on understanding his identity as a Malaysian, his current project shifts the focus outward - into the lives of others. "I always assumed photography to be a solitary and sometimes lonely pursuit, but this project proved it doesn't have to be. I have learned that photography can build friendships and enrich lives - especially in this case, with the children and youth," says Dr Byron, who has been living in Britain for 20 years. Dr Byron collaborated with stateless youth from Semporna for the project, encouraging their participation in shaping how they were portrayed. "As a result, the experience involved working with people, negotiating and a whole lot more planning. I truly enjoyed the collaborative aspect and the new connections it brought," says the KL-born medical practitioner, who worked closely with students from a free school run by Borneo Komrad – a grassroots non-governmental organisation that provides education for stateless communities – through four extended trips to Semporna. Survival and resilienceBunga dan Tembok carries the theme of civil rights and injustice. Dr Byron explains that the project title comes from a poem by Indonesian poet, Wiji Thukul. "In class, the marginalised youth are also taught literature and I remember sitting in on a class discussion on the poem. I had never heard of that poem, let alone of Wiji Thukul, and I went on to research his work. "It was a beautiful poem and a great allegory for the lives of the children there. Hence, I thought it was a fitting name for the project," shares Dr Byron, who will be discussing his project on June 28 (8pm, local time) as part of the the project, he chose to focus on the positive aspects of Semporna's stateless youth, and involved the marginalised kids in the creative process. "Many photographers, especially from the West, have documented this community, but often with a focus on deprivation and hardship. While relevant, the images tend to lean towards misery and exploit poverty. Dr Byron's aim through the exhibition is to shed light on the resilience of marginalised communities. "I wanted to shift the narrative. I focused on the students' lives at a more personal level. "As an outsider, I was initially unsure about gaining their trust, so I took a collaborative approach. I invited them to participate in how they wanted to be represented. Over time, that involvement helped build trust, and allowed their personalities to shine," says Dr Byron, who shares his photos on his Instagram. Working with these children for two years was indeed an eye-opener for Dr Byron. Over the years, he has forged close relationships with many of them. He also praises the amazing teachers who continue to guide these displaced youth. Above all, he has also learned the true meaning of resilience and survival. " These two words have resonated a lot with me throughout this experience and I have observed this so much in the children I have worked with, which has really inspired me. "It has also given me a new perspective on life, helped me readjust my priorities, and changed how I manage my own tribulations. "In the end, all I see are little children living in crisis, so it is hard not to be affected by it, or to keep it from becoming a matter that is close to your heart."In an ideal world, I want them to achieve the justice and equality they truly deserve. I will always support their fight. "With the knowledge and skills they've gained from the free school, I hope they'll continue to support themselves and advocate for their rights," he says.
Daily Express
15 hours ago
- Daily Express
Ministry backs film on endangered pygmy elephants
Published on: Monday, June 23, 2025 Published on: Mon, Jun 23, 2025 Text Size: Liew (centre), flanked by Mohd Soffian (right) and Chong. Kota Kinabalu: Support from the Ministry of Tourism, Culture and Environment (KePKAS) is crucial for the success of the upcoming film 'Agatis : A Borneo Story' (AABS) set to start filming between August and September this year. Its Minister Datuk Seri Christina Liew said her Ministry has every reason to lend a hand, given the film's potential as a wildlife tourism booster. 'We will render the necessary assistance through our agency, Sabah Wildlife Department (JHL). Firstly, it is a feature film to protect and raise awareness about the endangered Bornean Pygmy Elephants. Secondly, it would be the first ever film in Malaysia filming in close proximity to these majestic animals under supervision,' she said after a presentation on the film project by the Director of Mondo Ab Films Sdn Bhd (MABF), Jeanette Chong Tze Ling, recently. MABF is a KK-based production company in Sabah. Present was the Director of JHL Mohd Soffian Abu Bakar. Chong, a Sabahan scriptwriter, film director and producer, concurred that the Ministry's support is the key to success of AABS, a 90-minute movie featuring Agatis, a four-year-old female Pygmy Elephant and Aki, a two-year-old male Pygmy Elephant, from the Borneo Elephant Sanctuary (BES) within the Lower Kinabatangan Wildlife Sanctuary. Advertisement 'I thank the Minister for her personal assistance. The support from the Ministry and Sabah Wildlife Department will bolster the confidence of potential funders and sponsors to come forward to contribute within their capacity. 'This film, my fourth screenplay, is intended not only to be screened in cinemas but also to make its debut at some film festivals,' she said, adding that the move will attract potential local and international filmmakers to produce films in Sabah. Briefing the Minister, the lawyer-turned film producer who is also a martial artist, said 'Agatis : A Borneo Story' is created with the collaboration of more than 50 years of combined experience in storytelling, wildlife cinematography, and high-quality film-making with very experienced and established production teams. 'This is the logline of the film. Both orphaned children - a young lost boy (Dhiren) and a baby Pygmy Elephant (Agatis) from two different worlds - found each other in the magical Borneo jungle where they bonded and became entangled in a battle to protect Agatis's species from greedy poachers,' explained Chong who has a passion for filmmaking. On her rationale behind 'Agatis : A Borneo Story', the film producer stressed that there is a pressing need to raise the level of awareness of the existence of the Bornean Pygmy Elephant, and emphasise the importance of coexistence through the film production. 'I met Jibius Dausip (the Elephant Whisperer) in 2023 to learn more about the Bornean Elephant and encountered baby Agatis for the very first time,' Chong recalled. Asked why Sandakan is given the priority for casting (choosing of actors), she attributed this to the location (Kinabatangan), saying it is ideal for the main cast and baby Bornean Pygmy Elephant to bond before filming starts, together with supervision from BES and their caretakers living in Kinabatangan. 'In July, we are going to do an open casting for the children in Sandakan. We are open to more NGO groups being involved as well as the local people in Kinabatangan.' Once we have successfully secured the funding needed, we hope to commence filming in mid-August or September, Chong added. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available. Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia
