CRL Commission chair opens case against Forsa leader for 'repeated insults'
The chair of the CRL Commission wants the courts to decide the fate of Michael Swain, leader of Freedom of Religion South Africa (Forsa), who she believes is repeatedly insulting her and the commission for its stance on the monitoring of churches.
Thoko Mkhwanazi-Xaluva addressed a media briefing on Thursday with Cheryl Zondi, a witness in the Nigerian televangelist Timothy Omotoso rape case, before she proceeded to Hillbrow police station to open a case of crimen injuria.
Mkhwanazi-Xaluva alleged that NGO Forsa had been persistently using various social media platforms to spread misinformation about the work of the commission.
'This misinformation has been sustained despite us having met them to provide clarity on why the commission has resolved to undertake particular projects or programmes.
'However, the most crucial issue that necessitated this briefing today is the malicious lies that they have been spreading about me as the chair of the commission, as well as Cheryl Zondi,' she said.
In April this year, the Commission for the Protection of the Rights of Cultural, Religious and Linguistic Communities (CRL Rights Commission) raised concerns about the absence of effective oversight mechanisms for religious leaders in churches
Mkhwanazi-Xaluva at the time questioned who was responsible for monitoring and preventing inappropriate behaviour in churches.
'There are behaviours that are unbecoming, inappropriate, unsuitable, sometimes even indecent, in churches,' she said in April. 'Who is monitoring that? Who is making sure that those things don't happen?'
On Thursday, she said Forsa, an organisation of religious leaders representing more than 12-million people, had appealed to the president not to reappoint her in 2019. She said they claimed to have highlighted irregularities and bias of the CRL's investigation and the conflict and division this had created among the faith communities, which CRL had a statutory and constitutional duty to protect and defend.
'While Forsa raises a bias on the part of the commission, they go ahead to single me out. The investigation into abuses taking place in the religious sector and in different religious communities was launched by the members of the commission, not by myself as an individual,' she said.
She said the commission seemed to have started a war with some of the religious leaders when they spoke about monitoring.
'We seem to have started a war with that because people don't want to be held accountable. People who say they're fighting for freedom of religion have literally declared a war on the commission, but specifically on me and then dragged in Cheryl, because they think this is easy to do. You can't just insult people in whatever way you like,' she said.
She added that the commission needed to send a strong message to all the people who were trying to run away from being held accountable as religious leaders.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
TimesLIVE
a day ago
- TimesLIVE
CRL chair's claims against its executive director are 'defamatory', Forsa says
Freedom of Religion South Africa (Forsa) has strongly denied what it termed false and defamatory allegations made by chairperson of the CRL Rights Commission Thoko Mkhwanazi-Xaluva on Thursday. During a media briefing convened by the commission, Mkhwanazi-Xaluva alleged Forsa and its executive director Michael Swain had accused her, Cheryl Zondi and/or the Cheryl Zondi Foundation of receiving R1.5m from the National Lotteries Commission. Zondi was a witness in the rape trial of Nigerian televangelist Timothy Omotoso. Forsa said this donation was reported widely in the media. It said a press release from the National Lotteries Commission of December 13 2018 stated the Cheryl Zondi Foundation had partnered with the Izimvo 447 NPC and received R1.5m to aid their work for those exploited in sacred spaces. 'Neither Michael Swain, nor Forsa, has ever alleged financial misconduct of any kind. Such claims are false and wholly without any factual basis at all,' the organisation said in a statement. Forsa said it was disappointed that Mkhwanazi-Xaluva did not first seek clarity or engage with it before making public accusations and threatening legal action. 'Her subsequent laying of criminal charges against Michael Swain and Forsa is seen as vexatious and unfounded. It appears to be a personally motivated attack designed to intimidate and deter Forsa (or others) from opposing the chair's agenda to push again for state regulation of religion.' Forsa said it reserved all legal rights in its response to this matter and was considering appropriate legal remedies in response to these false and harmful allegations. 'These include a formal demand for retraction as well as amending its extant damages claim for defamation.' Forsa said it was not against any person or institution, including Mkhwanazi-Xaluva or the commission. 'On the contrary, Forsa supports all of its legitimate and constitutional objectives. However, our singular focus is the protection and advancement of religious freedom and related constitutional rights in South Africa.' Forsa said a letter from more than 20 senior religious leaders representing about 12-million South Africans was sent to President Cyril Ramaphosa in 2019, raising several concerns, including that Mkhwanazi-Xaluva simultaneously served as CRL chairperson and deputy chair of the Cheryl Zondi Foundation. The commission was a Chapter 9 institution, created to be independent and impartial, accountable only to parliament, Forsa said. 'Thus, its chair must avoid bias, preferential treatment and dual loyalties. Arguably, this includes keeping clear boundaries when interacting with organisations, especially advocacy organisations, linked to matters before the commission.' Forsa said under Mkhwanazi-Xaluva's leadership at the time, the CRL strongly pushed for state regulation of religion. 'A wide diversity of faith communities strongly opposed the CRL's proposal. The 'conflict of interest' concern arose because the CRL chair cited the Omotoso case as a high-profile example to justify the CRL's proposed regulation model (via peer review councils, licensing of religious leaders, etc).' Her appointment as the deputy chair of the Cheryl Zondi Foundation, therefore, created a strong impression of an overlap of interest and influence. 'On the one hand, the chair of the CRL is tasked with impartial interaction with faith communities, constitutional compliance, and safeguarding diverse religious rights. Acting as deputy chair of the Cheryl Zondi Foundation is an advocacy-aligned — not neutral — position.' This raised legitimate concerns about a conflict of interest on the part of the chairperson, Forsa said. 'It must be stressed that this in no way raises any concern or casts any suspicion on Cheryl Zondi or the Cheryl Zondi Foundation.' Since being reappointed, Mkhwanazi-Xaluva has continued promoting proposals for state regulation of religion, including the introduction of peer review mechanisms, Forsa said. It said it had consistently opposed this course of action, repeatedly warning that state regulation of religion was unnecessary, unconstitutional, unworkable and unaffordable. 'In Forsa's public education efforts to point out the dangers to religious freedom of state regulation of religion, we gave the historical background to the current context. One part of this extensive presentation referenced the 2019 letter to the president in good faith and with full transparency.' Forsa said the 2019 letter did not accuse Mkhwanazi-Xaluva of theft or corruption of any kind and did not contain any accusations against Zondi or the Cheryl Zondi Foundation at all.
Daily Maverick
2 days ago
- Daily Maverick
‘A refuge for the connected' — ActionSA slams NPA, calls for Batohi's removal
NPA boss Shamila Batohi continues to face criticism over her leadership, with ActionSA protesting in Tshwane on Thursday, calling for her removal. While the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) continues to face criticism over its failure to lead successful prosecutions in several high-profile cases, ActionSA staged a protest outside the justice minister's offices in Tshwane on Thursday, 19 June, calling for the removal of NPA boss Shamila Batohi. 'Worryingly, the NPA has become a refuge for the politically connected, a place where accountability is avoided, justice is delayed and prosecutions collapse with alarming regularity,' said ActionSA president Herman Mashaba and the party's parliamentary head Athol Trollip in a joint statement after submitting a memorandum. 'Supported by victims of the NPA's failure to ensure that our criminal justice system protects the public and tackles rampant lawlessness, ActionSA's demand for the removal of advocate Batohi rests on the lived experiences of those who have been failed by a prosecuting body clearly incapable of fulfilling its mandate.' Batohi has faced criticism after several State Capture cases have been thrown out of court. ActionSA supporters emphasised the Timothy Omotoso case, with the Nigerian televangelist walking free in April after being cleared of all 32 charges – including rape and human trafficking. Hlengiwe Zondi, 23, an ActionSA supporter who arrived from Johannesburg, told Daily Maverick that she attended Thursday's protest because she was concerned about what the Omotoso case meant for her own safety. 'I am very scared. I am very scared for myself, for my younger sisters. I am scared for every single girl. 'The release of Omotoso after so much clear evidence against him, for me, was an indication that not a single woman or girl is safe under the current leadership of the NPA … What angers me most is that the leader of the NPA is a woman herself,' Zondi said. Sibongile Msomi, 48, said, 'These are the cases you want to use and set an example to intruders like Omotoso, whose actions amounted to peeing on our sovereignty. He needs to be brought back. 'There will be no shame in the NPA in doing that, failed as they have. In fact, many South Africans would be delighted to see Omotoso brought back to face the music. I did not trust the NPA at all since the Zuma years, but now I hate them for their conduct in the Omotoso and many State Capture cases,' said. Msomi, who said she was not a supporter of ActionSA, urged all South Africans to voice their displeasure with the criminal justice system. 'It only benefits the rich and corners ordinary South Africans,' Msomi said. Omotoso left the country in May and was declared a prohibited person for overstaying his visa and entering SA on a false permit. 'Batohi must go. We need somebody new, hopefully with a much clearer vision and guts,' Tisietso Mofokeng, 39, from the East Rand, said on Thursday. The ActionSA leaders said that while Batohi's 2018 appointment was met with hope that the NPA would move past an era defined by State Capture, 'that hope has curdled into deep public disillusionment'. 'The institution remains directionless, riven by internal factionalism, and wholly unable, or unwilling, to act decisively against either high-level corruption or pervasive violent crime. 'From troubling vacancy rates across provinces and key units within the NPA, to the failure to prosecute any high-profile cases arising from the Zondo Commission, to botched cases involving Timothy Omotoso, Ace Magashule, Moroadi Cholota and Zizi Kodwa, and the apparent laissez-faire approach to consequence management within the institution, the case for the removal of the NDPP is made by her own widely evident failures as the head of the institution. Batohi refuses to step aside Batohi has repeatedly denied that the NPA is in crisis. 'I want to say that, as the NDPP, I will not be stepping down because I believe that we are doing a really good job to serve the people of this country – as we have been – and, particularly, the victims of crime,' Batohi told MPs in Parliament this week. Batohi conceded there were '10 to 12 cases… that the NPA is coming for a lot of flak on'. 'There are legal processes and I urge that we consider these cases individually and consider where is the actual problem. And once we understand the actual problem, make sure we put in place solutions which address the problem,' she said. 'There are huge systemic problems in the criminal justice system. And I want to say that as the national director, I will not be [stepping] down because I believe that we are doing a really good job. And I will continue with my really good team to serve the people of this country,' said Batohi. In a recent SABC interview, Batohi said, 'There certainly have been setbacks and I don't want to underplay that. There've been major setbacks for the institution. But we're dealing with them.' During her presentation to the parliamentary justice committee on Tuesday, Justice Minister Mmamoloko Kubayi said one of the problems facing the NPA was corruption. She said lifestyle audits could help address this. 'With lifestyle audits, we are able to see the patterns. We have agreed that this work will be done and we have committed that it will be started in this financial year,' she said. Batohi's term is set to expire in January 2026, and civil society groups have called on President Cyril Ramaphosa to make the appointment process of her successor public, in a similar fashion to the public interviews Batohi faced before she was appointed. DM
TimesLIVE
2 days ago
- TimesLIVE
CRL Commission chair opens case against Forsa leader for 'repeated insults'
The chair of the CRL Commission wants the courts to decide the fate of Michael Swain, leader of Freedom of Religion South Africa (Forsa), who she believes is repeatedly insulting her and the commission for its stance on the monitoring of churches. Thoko Mkhwanazi-Xaluva addressed a media briefing on Thursday with Cheryl Zondi, a witness in the Nigerian televangelist Timothy Omotoso rape case, before she proceeded to Hillbrow police station to open a case of crimen injuria. Mkhwanazi-Xaluva alleged that NGO Forsa had been persistently using various social media platforms to spread misinformation about the work of the commission. 'This misinformation has been sustained despite us having met them to provide clarity on why the commission has resolved to undertake particular projects or programmes. 'However, the most crucial issue that necessitated this briefing today is the malicious lies that they have been spreading about me as the chair of the commission, as well as Cheryl Zondi,' she said. In April this year, the Commission for the Protection of the Rights of Cultural, Religious and Linguistic Communities (CRL Rights Commission) raised concerns about the absence of effective oversight mechanisms for religious leaders in churches Mkhwanazi-Xaluva at the time questioned who was responsible for monitoring and preventing inappropriate behaviour in churches. 'There are behaviours that are unbecoming, inappropriate, unsuitable, sometimes even indecent, in churches,' she said in April. 'Who is monitoring that? Who is making sure that those things don't happen?' On Thursday, she said Forsa, an organisation of religious leaders representing more than 12-million people, had appealed to the president not to reappoint her in 2019. She said they claimed to have highlighted irregularities and bias of the CRL's investigation and the conflict and division this had created among the faith communities, which CRL had a statutory and constitutional duty to protect and defend. 'While Forsa raises a bias on the part of the commission, they go ahead to single me out. The investigation into abuses taking place in the religious sector and in different religious communities was launched by the members of the commission, not by myself as an individual,' she said. She said the commission seemed to have started a war with some of the religious leaders when they spoke about monitoring. 'We seem to have started a war with that because people don't want to be held accountable. People who say they're fighting for freedom of religion have literally declared a war on the commission, but specifically on me and then dragged in Cheryl, because they think this is easy to do. You can't just insult people in whatever way you like,' she said. She added that the commission needed to send a strong message to all the people who were trying to run away from being held accountable as religious leaders.
