Air India crash mystery deepens: US Navy 'Top Gun' Captain Steve points to 'RAT' that may explain what exactly went wrong
In what is now India's worst air disaster in nearly twenty years and the first fatal crash involving a
Boeing 787 Dreamliner
, aviation expert Captain Steve Scheibner has updated his assessment of the June 12
Air India crash
near Ahmedabad. Scheibner, a former U.S. Navy pilot, now says the available evidence strongly supports a dual engine failure.
Captain Steve Scheibner, a former US Navy pilot with over 20,000 hours of flying experience, is widely respected for his in-depth aviation analysis and flight safety expertise.
New footage shows critical emergency system deployed
Scheibner had earlier outlined four possible causes of the crash. These included loss of power, fuel contamination, a bird strike, or a flap setting error. However, after examining sharper video footage released after the incident, his opinion has changed.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
What Does My Family Name Mean?
beenverified
Sign Up
Undo
'In the middle of the circle, you see kind of a protrusion on the belly of the aircraft... just underneath that you see a little grey dot... that little grey dot is the RAT,' Scheibner said in a new video posted on YouTube. He was referring to the ram air turbine (RAT), a device designed to deploy automatically if both engines fail or if the aircraft loses all hydraulic or electrical systems.
'This is visual confirmation that the RAT deployed,' he said. The RAT is not meant to activate under normal flight conditions and only comes into action during extreme emergencies.
Live Events
RAT sound and survivor's account offer more clues
Scheibner also analysed audio from the crash video, identifying a distinct 'high-pitched squeal' in the background. 'It sounds like a high-pitched prop, like a little Cessna going by,' he said, linking the sound to the RAT's two-bladed turbine spinning at high speed to generate emergency power.
In addition to video and sound, he pointed to the lone survivor's statement. A passenger seated in 11A, close to an emergency exit, reportedly heard 'a loud bang' and saw the cabin lights flicker before impact. Scheibner said this description matched what typically happens during a RAT deployment.
Mayday call cited as possible fourth signal
Scheibner added that unconfirmed reports of a Mayday call by the captain indicated they were 'losing thrust or something to that effect.' Although air traffic control audio is yet to be released, this detail, if verified, would further support the engine failure theory.
Conclusion remains open
'This puts the dual engine failure theory in first place,' Scheibner said. 'But we're still at square one. We don't know why both engines on a 787 flamed out after takeoff. It's a real head-scratcher.'
The Boeing 787 involved in the crash had completed over 8,000 flights and logged 41,000 flying hours before the incident. Investigations by aviation authorities are still in progress.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
AAIB transports aircraft debris to airport premises, report likely to be out in 3-4 months, say officials
On Sunday, a somber sight unfolded on Ahmedabad's Shahibaug roads as trailer trucks transported debris from the ill-fated Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner aircraft, which crashed shortly after take off from Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport on June 12, to a secure location. The Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) started transporting the debris from the Air India flight AI 171 crash site on Saturday night, with assistance from local administration, including the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation (AMC) and the City Police. On Sunday, the tail section, which had lodged into the mess hall of the Atulyam hostel of BJP Medical College in Meghaninagar, was moved to a secure site within the airport premises as part of the ongoing investigation. Notably, several eyewitnesses and first responders have confirmed to The Indian Express that no major portion of the aircraft had remained unaffected by the crash. Due to the crash, followed by subsequent explosions with the high temperature blaze caused by the aviation fuel, which burns at 1,030 degrees celsius, only the tail end of the aircraft — embedded into the mess building — was the most 'complete' part of the plane which was in one piece. The tail end was later removed from the building with the help of cranes. First responders had said that there was no fuselage left to speak of and the different parts of the aircraft had only been identified by the direction of the tail that was lodged in the hostel building. While shifting the wreckage, this part of the aircraft had purportedly gotten stuck in one of the trees that line the roads in Shahibaug area of the city, leading to a minor traffic jam till personnel from the AMC helped free the aircraft part from the branches and the convoy could reach its destination. 'The AAIB are moving the aircraft parts from the crash. Since the tail part of the plane is very large, it may have gotten stuck on a tree during transport so that was cleared immediately and the movement continued without any issues. The debris is being moved to the GUJSAIL (Gujarat State Aviation Infrastructure Company Limited) hangar, which is within the airport premises,' Jaypalsingh Rathore, the Additional Commissioner of Police ( for Sector-2, told The Indian Express. The GUJSAIL building is also acting as camp office of the AAIB investigators for the probe duration and had initially housed the aircraft's black boxes after their recovery, before they were moved out by the investigation team. The Indian Express had on June 18 reported that all parts of the London Gatwick bound aircraft, which had crashed in less than a minute after take off, would be moved to secure site after a preliminary investigation of the crash site by the AAIB and it's international partners, including the National Transport Safety Bureau (NTSB) of the US, and Air Accidents Investigation Branch (AAIB) of the British Department of Transport. Providing details about the liaising between the AAIB and the Gujarat government, Dr Rajendra Kumar, Secretary of Civil Aviation for the State, told The Indian Express, 'The AAIB has complete jurisdiction over the crash site and the debris. We know that they are moving the aircraft parts to a secure location and then (they) will conduct reconstruction and further investigation. We have provided all logistical support for the same.' When asked about the timeline of air accidents such as these, Dr Rajendra Kumar said, 'The preliminary investigation in such cases takes about 3-4 months and the final report comes after a month. We are not sure how the AAIB will be conducting their investigation in this particular case, but these are the usual timelines.' While it will likely take another day to transport all pieces of the massive passenger plane, the debris of which is spread over 500 metres, to be transported back to the secure location, the municipal corporation has provided vehicles as well as deployed an escort of firefighters with power tools and engineers to help with the process. The London-bound aircraft with 242 persons on board plunged into a medical hostel complex in Meghaninagar moments after taking off from the Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport on June 12, killing 241 on board. One passenger survived. At least 20 people lost their lives on the ground.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Iranian missile fired after US strikes causes heavy damage but few injuries in Tel Aviv
Hours after the US struck three Iranian nuclear sites, Iran launched more than 40 missiles toward Israel on Sunday, wounding 23 people and destroying apartment buildings and homes in three cities. At an impact site in Tel Aviv, the blast had sheared off the face of a multistory residential building and damaged several others - including a nursing home - in a radius of hundreds of metres. But few people were wounded, as many residents had been evacuated and others made it to bomb shelters. Deputy Mayor Haim Goren, who assisted at the scene, said it was nevertheless "miraculous" that more people were not hurt. Relatives and health aides helped residents - many with wheelchairs or walkers - to leave the nursing home, where windows were blown out up to the top on the 11th floor. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Indonesia: New Container Houses (Prices May Surprise You) Container House | Search ads Search Now Undo "It's like a typhoon came through my apartment," said Ofer Berger, who lives near the impact site on the seventh floor of a high-rise. "All of the apartments in this area are destroyed," he said. Emergency services said one person was moderately wounded by shrapnel in Sunday's missile barrage while dozens of others were lightly injured. Live Events Berger said he hoped the war with Iran would end soon. "Most of the tit-for-tat strikes like this end with a lot of tears," he said. Residents sat with their pets and suitcases outside the damaged buildings. One person sat next to a shopping cart filled with Buddha statues and a child's bicycle. Families gathered what they could and stepped gingerly around piles of glass and twisted metal. Dozens of volunteers from an organisation called "One Heart" showed up to help residents salvage their belongings. Strikes have displaced more than 9,000 people from their homes since the start of the war, according to the Israeli military. Missiles have damaged 240 residential buildings, including more than 2,000 individual apartments. Mira Goshen, 79, said her entire apartment was destroyed. "My mamad was shaking like a leaf, and I thought it was the end of the world," Goshen said, referring to the reinforced safe rooms that are required in all new construction. She said the shelter had saved her life. In some areas where entire homes were flattened, the reinforced rooms stood intact. Goshen's pet bird, Chica, survived an 11-story drop when her cage was knocked off the balcony by the explosion. A rescuer retrieved her, and she was trembling and burrowing into Goshen's neck hours later as Goshen spoke with neighbours and authorities outside her building. Hours later, municipality workers worked to sweep up the the shattered glass and remove debris, while others handed out sandwiches and water at an aid station. Several businesses on a nearby street had their windows blown out, and the stores were littered with broken glass amid baked goods, children's clothes and books. Workers at a supermarket stacked crates of fruit in front of a shattered front window and opened for shoppers, who packed the aisles. Residents appeared calm in the aftermath of Sunday's strike, but Goren said the nightly barrages, the frantic running to shelters and the close confines inside them are taking a toll. "There's a lot of stress and pressure building, lots of nerves," the deputy mayor said. Mutual aid groups are working around the clock to match families in need with shelters and support, and the municipality is working to convert parking garages, bus stations and train stations to temporary shelters. Goshen said she was more focused on where she would go next than on the US strikes on Iran and their aftermath. "I'm far away from politics, and what I think, it doesn't matter actually, because they don't listen to ordinary people," she said.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
BCD to set up centre for fire safety on IIT-Patna campus
Patna: Building construction department (BCD) is set to establish a 'Centre of Excellence for Fire Testing, Training, and Research Laboratory' on the campus of the Indian Institute of Technology-Patna. A memorandum of understanding (MoU) will soon be signed to set up the centre. The facility will assist in selecting modern equipment for fire safety in ongoing and future projects; evaluating the fire resistance of materials used; assessing damage to building structures after fires; retrofitting damaged structures, and investigating fire propagation patterns. The govt will spend around Rs 17.3 crore on this ambitious project, which was recently cleared by the state cabinet. Kumar Ravi, secretary of the BCD, said the facility will be a significant step towards ensuring fire safety in buildings. "A separate building for fire testing, training, and research centre will be constructed on the IIT-Patna campus, for which land will be allocated by the institute. All expenses related to the operation, human resources, training, equipment repair, and maintenance will be borne by the department for the first five years. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Top 5 Books Warren Buffett Wants You to Read In 2025 Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo IIT-Patna will provide expertise, faculty support, and technical leadership in research activities," he said. Discussing the objective of the facility, the secretary said it will test and inspect the fire resistance of materials and equipment used for fire safety in projects implemented or to be implemented by the BCD and other departments or corporations. "The facility will provide training to engineers on fire safety and engineering, rescue methods, assessment of damage to buildings after fires, and methods and measures for strengthening them, as well as training related to protective and rescue operations during fires. Additionally, it will also focus on the prevention of fire incidents and safety measures like sprinkler systems and smoke detection in buildings," Ravi told this reporter. Research at this facility will study the impact of fire on the structural components of buildings, the type of fire spread in multi-storey buildings, and the fire-resistant capacity of locally available construction materials. The secretary added, "The proposal for the MoU between BCD and IIT-Patna has been sent to the institute. Once it is finalised, the agency will be hired to prepare the detailed project report for the project."
