High Court allows McGregor whiskey dispute to proceed
The hearing of a High Court dispute over an alleged oral agreement giving 5 per cent of a Conor McGregor-founded whiskey brand to his former MMA sparring partner will go ahead later this year after a judge approved moves to amend the date of the original claim.
Ms Justice Nessa Cahill, on Wednesday, granted Artem Lobov permission to amend his pleadings in the case in which he claims Mr McGregor made an oral agreement with him for a 5 per cent share, made in a gym in 2017.
The court heard Mr Lobov is now saying the meeting at which the oral agreement was made took place on October 9th, 2017, not September 2017 as originally claimed. It arose after Mr Lobov, while preparing for the hearing, found an old mobile phone which clarified the meeting was not in September 2017.
It was also in circumstances where Mr Lobov knew Mr McGregor had been defeated in a boxing match with Floyd Mayweather in August 2017. The court heard Mr McGregor was in Ibiza in September and said he could not have been present on the date Mr Lobov originally claimed.
READ MORE
Russia-born Mr Lobov claims he was involved in the creation of, and working on setting up, the 'Proper Number Twelve' Irish whiskey brand which was reported to be sold for US$600 million (€530 million) to Proximo Spirits in 2021. Mr McGregor was reported to have received $130 million from the sale.
Proximo cut ties with Mr McGregor and the brand following last year's separate High Court action in which a civil jury found he should pay almost €250,000 for raping a woman, Nikita Hand, in a Dublin hotel in December 2018. That decision is being appealed.
The hearing of the whiskey claim was due to go ahead this week but was postponed to allow Mr Lobov, who lives in Mulhuddart, Dublin, apply to amend his case after he had discovered the old phone with information alerting him to the October date.
The McGregor side, who denied there was any oral agreement, opposed the amendment.
On Wednesday, after hearing arguments from lawyers for both sides, Ms Justice Cahill said she was satisfied to allow the amendment. She approved directions for the progress of the case to hearing but noted it is unlikely to get a date until after the long courts vacation.
Earlier Andrew Walker SC said Mr Lobov had told his solicitor Dermot McNamara that he discovered the old phone in March.
While his side accepted it would have been far better if the amendment to the claim had been made sooner, the law was clear that a litigant can bring an application to amend at any time and the court has a wide ranging discretion to grant it.
This was not a case where there was irredeemable prejudice to the defendant and it was also not bound to fail, which are the only two barriers to an amendment, he said.
He accepted the defence was going to have to meet its three witnesses who were to give evidence on behalf of Mr McGregor so they can now have to deal with where they were in the relevant week of October 2017. This was not insurmountable but it would take more time, he said.
Mr Walker also accepted the amendment will have cost implications for his client.
Remy Farrell SC, for Mr McGregor, agreed there was no irredeemable prejudice or that the case was bound to fail.
'But those who receive absolution have to admit the sin or at least provide an explanation as to how this occurred', he said.
There was 'no interest' on the part of the Lobov side to address that, he said. 'The reason was to secure a litigious advantage as something that could be dealt with on the day of the trial', he said.
It arose in circumstances where after Mr Lobov told his lawyer about the new phone, a decision was taken not to reveal this until the eleventh hour, he said.
The court would, in those circumstances, be entitled to not grant permission to amend the case but could otherwise have been granted, he said.
Ms Justice Cahill said she would give reasons in a written judgment in due course for her decision to allow the amendment along with dealing with the question of costs.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
20 minutes ago
- Extra.ie
Thousands march in Dublin protests but Gardai keep rival groups apart
Thousands took part in an anti-immigration protest in Dublin yesterday, as a counter-demonstration was also held in the city centre. The anti-immigration march made its way from the Garden of Remembrance to Custom House Quay. Many attendees wore hats with the slogan 'Make Ireland Great Again', or held banners reading 'Ireland is Full'. Thousands took part in an anti-immigration protest in Dublin yesterday, as a counter-demonstration was also held in the city centre. A counter-demonstration organised by the United Against Racism group gathered on Dame Street from 1.30pm. O'Connell Bridge was closed for a time as gardaí erected barriers to separate the two crowds. The United Against Racism rally began at the Central Plaza on Dame Street, marching through the city to O'Connell Bridge at around 2pm. Several protesters carried signs saying 'Blame the Government, not migrants' and: 'Dublin stands against racism'. A counter-demonstration organised by the United Against Racism group gathered on Dame Street from 1.30pm. They also chanted: 'Say it loud, say it clear, refugees are welcome here.' The anti-immigration protest marched down O'Connell Street and turned left at O'Connell Bridge before continuing along the quays. Participants from both sides shouted and gestured towards each other across the barriers. At one point, the anti-racism rally chanted: 'You say protect women, that's a lie', and referenced a photo being carried by one person of Conor McGregor, who lost a civil trial in which a woman accused him of raping her in a Dublin hotel. The anti-immigration march made its way from the Garden of Remembrance to Custom House Quay. The anti-immigration group, which was the larger of the two, chanted: 'Whose streets? Our streets.' Several people were seen holding US or 'Trump' flags, and signs critical of RTE. The Garda Mounted Support Unit, the Public Order Unit and Garda members from outside the Dublin Metropolitan Region were in attendance.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Michael Gaine murder: Gardaí visit Michael Kelley's ex-partner in Maine
Gardaí investigating the murder of Kerry farmer Mike Gaine travelled to the United States last weekend to speak with the former partner of a man arrested about the killing. Investigators visited Waldo County in the northeastern state of Maine where Michael Kelley, the man detained and questioned last month over Mr Gaine's murder, lived before he moved to Ireland. Mr Kelley's former partner Alicia Snow said she met investigators on Saturday and that they were looking for any clues to explain what might have happened to Mr Gaine. A Garda source confirmed a detective had travelled to the US as part of the investigation to seek a statement from Ms Snow. READ MORE The Garda Press Office declined to comment on the visit. 'An Garda Síochána does not comment on, confirm or deny queries on specific operational details of ongoing criminal investigations.' A native of Maine, Mr Kelley lived and worked on Mr Gaine's farm near Kenmare, and has denied any involvement in his murder. Mr Gaine was last seen alive on March 20th. His partial remains were discovered on his land on May 17th. Michael Kelley lived and worked on Michael Gaine's farm near Kenmare, and has denied any involvement in his murder. Photograph: Barry Roche [ Who is Michael Kelley, the man questioned over the murder of Michael Gaine? Opens in new window ] Mr Kelley was arrested on May 18th on suspicion of murder and was released without charge 24 hours later. Mr Kelley, a musician, has claimed in media interviews that he is being framed for the murder by people involved in 'organised crime'. He is now living in Tralee, where he can be seen regularly busking on the streets. [ American man questioned in Michael Gaine murder inquiry addresses his Garda complaint Opens in new window ] Ms Snow, who was Mr Kelley's partner for three years and has two children with him, has fond memories of their time together living simply in a yurt on his mother's farm in the small town of Swanville in Maine. She said Mr Kelley did a variety of jobs over the years. He installed ductwork for heating and cooling systems, and worked as a farmhand on a neighbour's dairy farm, as a breakfast cook and as a butcher in a small country grocery store. In 2001, the couple had a commitment ceremony on the farm in Swanville with a group of family and friends. Ms Snow grew the flowers for the ceremony, a bagpiper played and Mr Kelley wore a kilt, she said. She described Mr Kelley as 'strong, capable, hardworking, sober homesteader' who played the Uilleann pipes and a bagpipe. Ms Snow said he was 'funny and smart and responsible and cooked well, and worked real hard like an Irish farm boy'. Their relationship subsequently broke down and they separated in 2001. After their separation, Ms Snow earned a nursing degree and began working as a nurse. Mr Kelley claimed in an interview with The Irish Times earlier this month that he had been threatened by the Ku Klux Klan in Maine because he was a Catholic and it was anti-Catholic. He claimed they poisoned and killed his dog near his home outside Swanville and, fearing for his life, he moved to Ireland. After his separation from Ms Snow, Mr Kelley brought a legal action seeking right of access to their children, who were living with her. Court papers from the legal case in Maine in 2009 show that Mr Kelley accused Ms Snow of witchcraft, and of casting spells on her children. The courts sided with Ms Snow, who was granted full custody of their children. [ Michael Gaine funeral hears of 'idyllic' community struck by 'something terrible' Opens in new window ] The judge in the case, in which Mr Kelley represented himself, concluded that Mr Kelley's ability to determine fact from fiction was 'questionable'. Ms Snow said the latest time she spoke to Mr Kelley was about 10 years ago. She said he went to Arizona about seven years ago to visit his father, who bought him a one-way ticket to Ireland.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Galway hotel fire ‘pulled our community together to help other newcomers', says professor
On Saturday, December 16th, 2023, the former Ross Lake House Hotel in Rosscahill near Oughterard, Co Galway, was set on fire in a suspected arson attack. The previous week, protesters had gathered outside the building after it was announced it would be used as temporary accommodation for asylum seekers. Frustrated by the spreading misinformation about migrants , local Rosscahill resident Prof Afshin Samali, a leading cancer specialist from the University of Galway who came here as a refugee in the 1980s, decided to speak out. He posted a thread of messages on X about why Irish people should be 'open-minded and compassionate' towards refugees. In the days that followed, after nearly four decades living in Ireland, he experienced racism for the first time in this country. After posting the online thread, he received a 'barrage of hate speech and racist comments'. READ MORE A year and a half on, Prof Samali still feels saddened when he recalls this anti-migrant incident. However, those attacking him 'were a very small minority', he clarifies. Most messages he received in the wake of his post were words of 'kindness and support'. Prof Samali arrived in Ireland in December 1985 aged 15 with his parents and siblings as part of a small group of Bahá'í refugees who were resettled in Ireland. His family had fled Iran where members of the Baháʼí faith experienced persecution, exclusion and sometimes imprisonment or execution. Before the fire in December 2023, Prof Samali and his wife and colleague, Prof Adrienne Gorman, were preparing to launch an NGO dedicated to removing barriers to education for refugees and asylum seekers in Ireland. [ On Sanctuary Sunday, we share a responsibility to oppose hostility towards migrants and asylum seekers Opens in new window ] 'We did register the foundation in 2024 but some serious threats were made against myself and my family, so I felt we needed to regroup.' Almost exactly 18 months on, on June 17th, Prof Samali and Prof Gorman gathered at the Royal Irish Academy with friends, colleagues and supporters, including Minister of State for Migration Colm Brophy, to launch the Samali Foundation. The non-profit is dedicated to advancing access to third-level education for minorities who face systematic and structural barriers to participation, he told attendees. 'The foundation's primary focus is to research, identify and remove barriers to education that hinder refugees and asylum seekers from accessing education,' says Prof Samali. This will include mentorship programmes and the development of a postgraduate access programme. 'I could see there was a gap – we'd started seeing larger numbers of refugees coming here who had studied in their own home countries but when they came here with those qualifications, they were being forced into low-paid jobs and [to] start from scratch,' Prof Samali told The Irish Times. 'This pushes these people into a vicious cycle of poverty. I felt I could do something unique by bringing my own personal experience as a refugee, and professional experience in academia, together. 'I felt a moral obligation and duty to help with the integration of refugees. The better the integration, the better it is for the country. And education is key in that process.' [ Prof Afshin Samali: 'We need to think of refugees as people who have a lot of potential' Opens in new window ] The foundation recently secured financial backing from the highly sought-after UN High Commissioner for Refugees-led innovation fund to develop a pilot postgraduate access programme for migrant groups. It was one of just 14 groups selected out of 3,500 international applications for the support. The pilot will formally begin later this year, with a goal of enrolling its first students in September 2026. The foundation is working directly with the University of Galway and is also collaborating with the University of Limerick and Maynooth University. In recent years, Prof Samali and his family have hosted a number of Afghan refugees in their home, some of them students. He was also part of a community sponsorship group in Rosscahill that formed in the wake of the Ross Lake House Hotel fire. 'The fire at Rosscahill actually pulled our community together to help other newcomers. After I spoke out, a lot of our neighbours rallied around us and were very supportive. That was the positive outcome from a sad incident – before we just lived in Rosscahill, but now we really feel we're an integral part of the community.' [ The idea that immigration fuels Ireland's housing crisis is wrong Opens in new window ] Later this year, Prof Samali will mark 40 years living in Ireland. However, he still feels a strong link to Iran and is concerned the Israel-Iran conflict will prompt a new wave of refugees into Europe. 'It upsets me to see what is happening there, I see my family and friends living in fear of what's going to happen next,' he says. 'And it's not only Iranians. Almost 10 per cent of the population is made up of displaced Afghans. I also have friends and colleagues in Israel who fear being attacked by neighbouring countries. And I'm also concerned about the plight of the Palestinians. 'At the end of the day, we should want the same safety for newcomers coming here from war and conflict as we want for our own families. We need to help them build their lives here again.'
