Tiger to Tendulkar? Sharmila Tagore, Sunil Gavaskar slam Pataudi Trophy renaming to honour Anderson, Tendulkar

Tiger Pataudi can arguably be the best thing that happened to Indian cricket. A name that became synonymous with the instilling of national pride and unity in the sport, which until the Tiger's entrance, was dominated by India's colonisers, England.
But the very name that scripted history is now at the centre of controversy, with Sharmila Tagore, cricketing icons Sunil Gavaskar, and Harsha Bhogle weighing in.
Earlier this month, the England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) and the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) jointly announced that the Pataudi Trophy would now be called the Tendulkar-Anderson Trophy.
The ECB and BCCI have cited the achievements of Tendulkar and Anderson as modern legends of the game, aiming to make the rivalry more relatable to younger fans and to reflect the trend of naming series after contemporary icons.
The names — Anderson, who retired in July 2024 after a record 188 Tests and 704 wickets, and Tendulkar, who bowed out in 2013 after 200 Tests and 15,921 runs — are both widely regarded as legends of the modern game.
The Pataudi Trophy was established in 2007 to mark the 75th anniversary of India's maiden Test series in England. It honoured the remarkable legacy of the Pataudi family—particularly Iftikhar Ali Khan Pataudi, the only cricketer to represent both England and India in Test matches, and his son, Mansoor Ali Khan "Tiger" Pataudi.
The 'Pataudi Trophy' was never just about silverware—it was a tribute to cricket's complex colonial inheritance. Named after Iftikhar Ali Khan Pataudi, the only man to play Tests for both England and India, it honoured a legacy of defiance and dignity.
Seasoned cricket broadcaster Harsha Bhogle took to X to reflect that although Tendulkar and Anderson are legends, the Pataudi name 'misses the deep connect that Pataudi had with our countries'.
He added: "Both father and son played for Sussex, Sr played for both England and India, Jr set schoolboy batting records in England. There was a very nice ring to the Pataudi Trophy.'
The same trophy, which now has a new name, was traditionally awarded to the winner of India's Test tours of England, while in India, the corresponding series has long been played for the Anthony de Mello Trophy, named after one of the BCCI's founding architects.
More than mere tokenism, the nomenclature honoured a man whose legacy ran deeper than the scoreboard. During the notorious Bodyline series of 1932-33, he defied his captain, Douglas Jardine, by refusing to field on the leg-side—a stance of integrity that cost him his place in the team. In him, the complex, post-colonial cricketing bond between the two nations found a fitting emblem.
The renaming drew sharp backlash, from the late Tiger Pataudi's wife Sharmila Tagore to his daughter Soha Ali Khan and cricket veteran Sunil Gavaskar.
Sharmila Tagore called it insensitive and said the family wasn't consulted. 'Whether the BCCI wants to preserve Tiger's legacy is for them to decide," she said in an interview with Hindustan Times.
In his column in Sportstar, Sunil Gavaskar said the move was 'disturbing indeed', and argued that 'this is the first time one has heard of a trophy named after individual players being retired, though the decision is entirely the ECB's, and the BCCI may well have been informed.'
The newly named trophy is set to be unveiled at Lord's during the World Test Championship final, which begins on June 11.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Indian Express

14 minutes ago

• Indian Express

It's a handspring, not a somersault – let's get our Rishabh Pant acrobatics pat

It's not Wingardium Levio-saar. It's Wingardium Levio-sah. As pedantic and irritating as it may be to point out, what Spiderman Rishabh Pant does on the field is a handspring, not a somersault. When Rishabh Pant took flight, and transported those watching into magical glee with his 'Headingley over heels' acrobatic celebrations, what the Indian wicketkeeper had pulled off was in gymnastics-speak, a Handspring. Not a somersault. Simone Biles or Dipa Karmakar might be too sweet to say 'Duh', but India's most entertaining batsman-meets-keeper-meets-human ribbon, pulled off a grand celebration after his century. Except, it got mis-labelled a somersault. Somersaults technically are rolls with tucked in limbs on the floor or in the air. To the gymnastics-leaning reader, a somersault is what Dipa does after pushing off the vaulting table, albeit aerially. What Pant did on the ground and what Biles or Karmakar do before launching into the vault is the Handspring. A somersault implies tucked limbs so hands don't hit the floor, while a Handspring demands that the force to take off aerially and flip in the air comes using hands as a spring off the floor. Pant has wowed the English crowd not only because of his comeback from a near-fatal accident. But his falling paddle off Shoaib Bashir also points to ultra-agility where imbalanced strokes translate to no-look, one-hand-off-the-bat scoop pulled off while crumbling to the ground entertainingly. It's like the French describing a flake toppling off a croissant giving a coffee rush to those watching. It's also not the first time the crowds guffawed, though he had a sliced six over long off two balls later. In the last series against England with Jonny Bairstow batting, Pant had fallen back while keeping, carrying a fast moving bounce and was on his back, with Virat Kohli in the slips. Next thing – he sprung up, arching with a foot stomp, like Hrithik Roshan or Tiger Shroff or India's finest vaulter & floor exercise medallist, Ashish Kumar. Just last month, he ensured his 27 crore price tag in the IPL delivered a memorable ROI, when he celebrated a long due century with another handspring. The awestruck watching RCB wicketkeeper equivalent could only freeze in his tracks and fold his hands behind his back. Former India head coach Ravi Shastri, who coined the 'falling paddle', told Sky Sports: 'Outrageous. He plays the numbers game beautifully, plays the way he wants. He will block for a bit and then shift gears.' It's what flipped the 'stupid, stupid, stupid' to 'superb, superb, superb' as he melted Jonty Rhodes into ABdV in batting. Shastri said Pant has his distinct USP, and apparently a UPS too. 'He has his own computer and only he knows how it works,' Shastri told Sky. 'That's his USP. That's what puts bowlers under pressure and makes him box office, a real entertainer and a match winner.' Recovering from the accident and hitting elite cricket once more too brought glee to the tale. Shastri added to Sky: 'That's why there was that celebration. Thanking the man upstairs for giving him the opportunity. I think his recovery from that accident had a lot to do with the frame of his body and being mid-20s.' He recalled meeting him in hospital. 'When I saw him in hospital, it wasn't a pretty sight. Knee in a mess, scars all over the place, bruises all over the place.' But with the Handspring – and perhaps cartwheels and somersaults to follow who knows – Rishabh Pant might be the greatest comeback to the top level, with centuries and falling paddle scoops. And his ability to make those watching, happy.

Business Standard

20 minutes ago

• Business Standard

ENG vs IND: Ganguly urges India to capitalize on strong start at Headingley

Former Indian captain Sourav Ganguly emphasized the importance of capitalizing on the commanding position India has established in the opening Test against England at Headingley, stating that such opportunities are rare and must be converted into victories. 'India must win the 1st Test vs England' India posted a formidable 471 in their first innings after being put in to bat, with centuries from Yashasvi Jaiswal, captain Shubman Gill, and Rishabh Pant laying the foundation. Reflecting on the performance, Ganguly expressed that the team had a realistic chance to reach the 600-run mark after ending Day 1 at a dominant 359 for three. 'No one expected the Headingley surface to be this dry. But if India can push towards 600, the pitch could start showing variable bounce, making things difficult for the batting side. India must win this Test. These kinds of chances don't come often,' Ganguly told PTI. 'I would've picked Arshdeep Singh' The team management's decision to exclude leg-spinner Kuldeep Yadav and left-arm seamer Arshdeep Singh from the playing 11 raised some eyebrows. Ganguly admitted he would have gone with Arshdeep over Prasidh Krishna due to the variety a left-arm bowler brings. 'Kuldeep will get his chance later. It's a long series. I'd have picked Arshdeep for the different angle he offers. But it's okay, the selected bowlers are talented,' he remarked. He also stressed the importance of Ravindra Jadeja stepping up with the ball, noting that the all-rounder hasn't been as effective in overseas conditions compared to home games. Ganguly on England's bowling unit Turning his attention to England's bowling unit, Ganguly observed a noticeable change from previous years. With experienced names like James Anderson and Stuart Broad absent, the attack is now led by Chris Woakes, Brydon Carse, Josh Tongue, and skipper Ben Stokes. Ganguly felt England's bowlers were lacking precision in their strategy. 'They were bowling too short, especially to Shubman Gill. At one point, all they did was pepper him with short balls. It's early days, and they will learn, but their current approach lacks the sharpness we've seen from England in the past,' Ganguly commented. When asked about India's chances of winning the series 3-1, Ganguly was cautious. 'It's too early to make such predictions,' he said, choosing to focus on the immediate challenge rather than looking too far ahead.

Time of India

20 minutes ago

• Time of India

Rishabh Pant is unique in many ways, let him be: Ex-players after his somersault goes viral

Swashbuckling India batter Rishabh Pant 's perfect somersault after smashing a breathtaking century in the first Test against England has caught the fancy of his legion of fans, while former players felt the acrobatic act that has since gone viral was a statement of his "unique" ways. Pant hit an entertaining 178-ball 134, his seventh Test ton, as India amassed 471 against England under new skipper Shubman Gill on Day 2 of the opening Test here on Saturday. Former India head coach Ravi Shastri said Pant probably had been doing gymnastics from a very young age. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Book 3 & 4 BHK apartments from 4.65 Cr* in Sec 22, Gurugram Ambience Creacions, Gurugram Learn More Undo "Nothing wrong in that. That's him. Let him be. You know, he's different. At a very young age, he did a lot of gymnastics," said the cricketer-turned-commentator. "Even if I might have tried it, I think I might have... (but) it would have been to go into the pool," Shastri joked in a video posted by BCCI. Live Events Pant was involved in a horrific car accident in 2022, which left him grievously injured and his return to professional cricket is one of the most heartwarming stories in sport. To perform a somersault like that after undergoing several surgeries is indeed awe-inspiring. "Rishabh being Rishabh, he does something unique. He does it really well. I think it was unique. No one expected him to do that. I've never tried it. I'll need a lot of practice because that is something if you haven't tried, you can't do it," said India batter Cheteshwar Pujara. Former India cricketer Dinesh Karthik said he was in awe of Pant, as the wicketkeeper-batter was made of a different stuff. "Neither could I do the somersault like him, nor can I bat like him. I think on both fronts (keeping and batting) he has exceeded expectations. It's quite an effort to do that, actually. And he does it consistently," said Karthik, himself a wicketkeeper-batter. "When I was very young, my parents did make me participate in gymnastics and I did try and I was an utter failure at that. So, let's just leave it there because he (Pant) is doing it so much nicer when he celebrates it," added Karthik. "I think I've never seen anything like that in my life. With pads on as well. Amazing," said an English fan.