The hurt that dripped from Michael O'Brien and others has to be part of Pope Francis's legacy
Born a few years before
Pope Francis
,
Michael O'Brien, who also died this week
, will be remembered for his appearance on
RTÉ
's Questions and Answers current affairs programme in May 2009. As an audience member, he spoke powerfully and agonisingly of the physical and sexual abuse he experienced in Ferryhouse industrial school near Clonmel, Co Tipperary, run by the Rosminians. The hurt dripped from him as his testimony detailed a family torn apart, a childhood ruined and a life haunted by nightmares.
One of 13 children, after O'Brien's mother died in 1942 he was taken by the Irish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children 'on a scut truck' to court in Clonmel. The siblings were sent to different institutions and 'there was nothing my father could do'. Two nights after he arrived in Ferryhouse, he was raped. 'Our only crime against the State was that we were poor and had no mother,' he recalled.
Although O'Brien met his wife Mary when he was aged 18, he did not tell her about the abuse until 1999. He also spoke of a suicide attempt after spending five days at the Ryan Commission inquiry into child abuse, a stark reminder of the renewed trauma that reliving these experiences could spark.
As an elected politician and Fianna Fáil mayor of Clonmel from 1993-1994, O'Brien's was an unusual victim's voice, but his demand was a consistent one from many victims: 'the government and the religious orders must not do anything now without consulting us'.
READ MORE
Amid the tributes paid to the late pope, it is fitting that O'Brien is remembered generously too. The personal experience he outlined was part of the reason Pope Francis's visit to Ireland in 2018 was so different from the previous Irish papal visit in 1979. Thousands turned out for a 'Stand 4 Truth' protest in the Garden of Remembrance in 2018 to coincide with the pope's Phoenix Park Mass.
[
'I couldn't believe the bravery': Abuse survivors pay tribute to Michael O'Brien and his 'powerful' RTÉ testimony on child sex abuse
Opens in new window
]
When speaking at the outset of the papal visit, then-taoiseach
Leo Varadkar
eschewed the fawning tone of 1979 while Francis looked on. Varadkar referred to 'failures of both church and State, and wider society' that 'created a bitter and broken heritage for so many, leaving a legacy of pain and suffering. It is a history of sorrow and shame ... stains on our State, our society and also the Catholic church.'
The warm glow around the Francis obsequies this week should not obliterate those stains or the enduring relevance of O'Brien's experiences and the trauma abuse victims continue to endure. Varadkar insisted in 2018 there was still 'much to be done to bring about justice and truth and healing for victims and survivors ... We must now ensure that from words flow actions.' That speech remains relevant for Ireland and the Vatican.
O'Brien's insistence in 2009 that victims be made central has hardly been honoured to anything like the extent required. Shortly before the death of Francis, for example, the report compiled by Sheila Nunan, the independent negotiator appointed by government to liaise with religious organisations over financial redress, revealed that only two of eight religious bodies linked to mother and baby homes have offered to contribute to a survivor redress scheme.
[
Pope in Ireland: Francis speaks of Church's failure to tackle clerical abuse 'scandal'
Opens in new window
]
What went on in Ferryhouse was known before O'Brien bared his trauma. In 1990, the Rosminian provincial Fr James Flynn was unambiguous: 'The greatest guilt has to be borne by those of us who utilised or condoned or ignored the extreme severity, even brutality which characterised at times the regime at Ferryhouse.'
Yet even a quarter of a century later during the pontificate of Francis, and after an avalanche of evidence of abuse, the Vatican prized its power over its responsibilities and culpability. True, Francis met victims, listened to them, and appealed for forgiveness. He summoned bishops to tell them survivors deserved 'concrete and efficient measures'. But the self-serving bureaucracy was still allowed to choke transparency.
Marie Collins, a victim of clerical sex abuse in Ireland in 1960, and appointed a member of the
Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors
established by Francis in 2014, resigned in 2017 over what she regarded as a 'shameful' lack of co-operation. The commission was incorporated into the Roman Curia, the Holy See's all-too-powerful government. In 2022, Francis was still pleading for a 'reliable account on what is presently being done and what needs to change' in relation to child abuse and its survivors.
O'Brien railed against the non-disclosure agreements victims were faced with as part of the redress process and decried the indemnities given to religious orders in return for patently inadequate contributions. Ultimately, what he was looking for was reflected in the name of the group he chaired: 'Right to Peace'. That finding such peace was made so difficult for so many should also be recorded as part of the legacy of Francis's pontificate.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
an hour ago
- The Journal
How does Ireland's prison overcrowding crisis compare to other European countries?
EUROPE'S PRISON POPULATION is increasing, with many countries around the continent, including Ireland, experience dangerous levels of overcrowding. According to analysis of the latest data from Eurostat, Europe's central statistics database, there was a 3.2% increase in the continent's prison population in 2023. That year, 13 countries in Europe were experiencing overcrowding. Very high levels of incarcerations were also recorded between 1993 and 2023. In Ireland, where prison capacity on Friday was recorded at a level of 117% , the issue with overcrowding has been deemed a crisis by legal experts, staff unions and senior sources within the Irish penal system. An increase in the number of judges , changes to legislation and sentencing guidelines, as well as underinvestment into the prison estate in the country have been contributing factors to the crisis. The Eurostat data shows, however, that this trend has been occurring across EU member states over a 30-year period. At its peak in 2012, prisons in Europe were accommodating 533,000 people. Government has initiated an expansion plan for the construction of 1,500 new places – but industry associations like the Irish Prison Officers Association believe that 'building out' of the problem is not the solution. Speaking at an event in May, President of the association Tony Power said that investments must be made into the existing system to provide more spaces. Staff should not be 'expected' to work in overcrowded conditions, he added. Mattresses on the floor in Europe Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan has pledged to find ways to accelerate the delivery of more prison spaces . Advertisement A senior source at the service previously told The Journal that building more spaces, given the timescale involved in capital projects, is not seen as an option. This has led to an increase in the number of people sleeping on the floor in Irish facilities , something the Irish Penal Reform Trust deeply condemns. These figures are so high that the service started recording them in official daily statistics this year. On Friday, 404 people were sleeping on mattresses the ground in Irish prisons. French prison population levels reached record highs in March as a total of 82,152 people – roughly the same size of a full house at Croke Park – were in custody in French prisons that month. The official capacity is 62,539. More than 4,500 people were sleeping on the floor at French facilities – 15 of which are at 200% capacity. Deportations and releases France's Justice Minister Gérald Darmanin has called for the deportation of foreign prisoners so that they can serve their sentences in their home nations. In Ireland, however, the Irish Penal Reform Trust has called for imprisonment to be regarded as a 'last resort' and for alternative measures , such as community service or supervised temporary release, to be encouraged. The Irish Prison Service has increased the population of prisoners on temporary release , which sees the supervised release of low-level, non-violent offenders serving sentences outside of prison under strict conditions. The State has been criticised for allowing the temporary release scheme as a pressure valve to overcrowding, but sources in the prison management say the programme is the only way it can maintain safe population levels at facilities in the country. In Austria, experts say prison sentences are still too common and, often, people are committed for minor offences. Facilities in the country are at 108% capacity, as of May. Access to rehabilitative care In Spain, the country has adopted a more rehabilitative approach. It allows prisoners a gradual transition to more open regimes, based on their behaviour and risk of re-offending. Similar programmes are available in Ireland . Data from Spain shows that 80% of people released from prison do not return to crime. Related Reads Court escorts for prisoners at risk due to overcrowding, Irish prisons boss warns Fears within prison service that prison overcrowding increasing risk of violence and rioting New ankle monitors could be an alternative to being held on remand, Irish prisons boss says Overcrowding is reducing the population's access to services in Ireland . Sources have said that offenders placed on supervised release or short sentences are, sometimes, not provided with any rehabilitative care. The head of the Irish Prison Service told reporters last month that up to 2,000 prisoners are currently on waiting lists to access psychology support services. Director General Caron McCaffrey said there are also smaller waiting lists for other services, such as addiction therapy, education and training programmes. She said a 'whole of government approach' is needed to boost services such as education, training and therapy in prisons. Responding to questions by The Journal in May, she admitted that people are sometimes released before receiving care. High levels of overcrowding at prisons in Austria is leading to similar issues to what is seen in Ireland, where prisoners outnumber support staff. The European Court of Auditors recently criticised Vienna's lack of investment. Changes are being led from prison management, however, to boost rehabilitation resources in Irish prisons. Existing staff are being upskilled and trained on methods to provide and assist in the care of prisoners with mental health issues. Additionally, a peer-led, pilot programme has been launched in Dublin's Mountjoy Prison which trains and educates prisoners on providing addiction care to others. — This article is part of PULSE, a European collaborative journalism project. With reporting by Maria Delaney (The Journal Investigates, Ireland), Davide Madeddu (Il Sole 24 Ore, Italy), Kim Son Hoang (Der Standard, Austria) and Ana Somavilla (El Confidencial, Spain) as well as translation services by Ciarán Lawless (Voxeurop). Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
The Journal
2 hours ago
- The Journal
Tánaiste says efforts are being made to evacuate 15 Irish citizens from Israel
EFFORTS ARE UNDERWAY to evacuate 15 Irish citizens from Israel as the conflict between the country and its neighbour and longtime foe Iran has soured further. Last night, it was announced by US President Donald Trump that t he US had bombed three nuclear enrichment sites in Iran after Israel had earlier launched attacks on Iran over a week ago. There has been discussion in recent days regarding the potential evacuation of Irish passport holders who are residing in either country. Today, Harris said that his Foreign Affairs Department is also working with a smaller number of citizens in Iran who had requested an evacuation. Around 29 Irish citizens in Iran had registered with the Irish embassy and around 200 in Israel. The government remains in contact with embassies in Israel and Iran. Staff in Tehran left the country on Friday and have since been working remotely. Speaking to RTÉ Radio One this afternoon, Harris confirmed that a civil protection operation with EU member states is taking place in order to extract European citizens from the region. He said while it is an ongoing operation, with further and more significant updates pending, only a small number of Irish citizens are seeking assistance from the joint mission currently. Advertisement Harris said he spoke to Iran's deputy foreign minister today, at their request, who was 'full of anger'. 'He did say to me that it was the view of Iran that the aggressors would have to learn lessons and pay a price,' he told reporters at Government Buildings. 'Of course I articulated in the strongest possible terms that Ireland and the European Union doesn't want to see that, we want to see people step back from the brink and engage in dialogue.' Harris said the US strikes on Iran had made a 'volatile situation even more dangerous' and added an 'extra layer of complexity' to what was already a 'tinderbox'. When asked whether he supported Trump's strikes on Iran, Harris said: 'I think it's resulted in an extraordinarily dangerous escalation of a conflict that already best be described as a tinderbox. 'We're now entering a moment of particular danger, because I think the chances now of a spiral of escalation are more likely than ever before, and there is a real prospect now of the international community losing all control of this very, very volatile conflict.' He said there was only a 'very small' number of Irish citizens, many dual nationals, seeking an evacuation, and they were working with European counterparts. A significant update on this would be available in the hours ahead, he said. With reporting by Press Association Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
‘You won't be out of our reach', warns top cops in vow to hunt Irish crime gangs across borders after extradition deal
IRELAND'S extradition treaty with the UAE is 'very significant' in the ongoing fight against organised crime, says a senior Garda officer. Assistant Commissioner Angela Willis - who has responsibility for the Advertisement 5 Assistant Commissioner Angela Willis vowed to hunt Irish crime gangs regardless of where they are based. Credit: Gary Ashe 5 Angela told our Crime Editor Stephen Breen that a number of Irish gangs have an 'international reach' Credit: Gary Ashe But a formal extradition treaty between the two countries was signed on May 18. AC Willis - who has over 34 years policing experience - told how international cooperation was 'essential' to combating Ireland's transnational crime gangs. Advertisement She also revealed how there is a 'significant number' of criminal organisations operating in Ireland with an 'international reach'. They include mobs involved in murder, Other gangs involved in child sexual exploitation, firearms, economic crime and intimidation are also in the sights of the Gardai's Organised and Serious Crime. In recent times, The Family, the Kinahan cartel and The Black Axe gangs are just some of the criminal organisations who have been targeted in major operations. AC Willis said: 'All of the top level Advertisement 'Global criminal networks are operating in unison and impacting very locally in Ireland, causing harm in our communities. 'Organised crime has also become increasingly complex and dynamic over the last few decades and that is why international cooperation is of critical importance in our investigations. Sean McGovern arrives at Dublin court after extradition 'We have seen the value of our 'The extradition treaty with the UAE has strengthened our ability to target those who continue to impact our society, but who are based in the UAE. "The treaty is very significant when it comes to combating organised crime. We had our first ever extradition from the UAE and that shows regardless of where you go you won't be out of our reach.' Advertisement The Garda National Bureau of Criminal Investigation, which includes the Garda Serious Crime Review Team and the Garda Extradition Unit, is one of the specialist units under Organised and Serious Crime. LIVE INVESTIGATIONS The GNBCI is currently involved in 39 major live investigations. In 2024, they were involved in assisting other Garda divisions in 24 major investigations that included 15 for murder. The others were for organised crime and serious sexual offences. Just last week, they also provided support to investigators investigating the disappearance of So far this year, they have also investigated 94 incidents of people fraudulently applying for passports. Advertisement 'INTERNATIONAL REACH' AC Willis added: 'There are significant crime gangs in Ireland who have an international reach and it's not just in the drugs area. 'We will continue to pursue all of the top level criminal organisations who have a footprint in other countries. 'Organised and serious crime doesn't know any borders and neither does our response.' 5 Sean McGovern was extradited to Ireland on May 29 Credit: Crispin Rodwell - The Sun Dublin 5 A huge bounty has been put on the head of cartel boss Daniel Kinahan Advertisement 'None of our successes against serious and organised crime groups in recent years would have been possible without the courage, dedication and commitment of the people who make up the bureaus. 'We have strong partnerships with international law enforcement and will continue to pursue those that threaten our communities.' AC Willis also told how international cooperation was 'vital' as part of ongoing efforts to target cyber crime. 'TECH IS EVOLVING' She said: 'International liaison is very important and we are at the forefront of investigations into cyber crime. 'We have already significant outcomes when it comes to the identification of victims and offenders, especially in the area of child exploitation. Advertisement 'Technology is constantly evolving, so we have to evolve our capabilities to ensure we are positioned to respond.' In one cyber crime investigation, Gardai seized €13million in crypto currency and €600,000 worth of luxury goods. AC Willis, who was appointed to the Organised and Serious Crime in October, told of her concerns over ongoing feuds in the capital among 'mid-level' crime gangs. "The treaty is very significant when it comes to combating organised crime. We had our first ever extradition from the UAE and that shows regardless of where you go you won't be out of our reach.' Assistant Commissioner Angela Willis In recent months, there have been shots fired at homes, petrol bomb attacks and assaults in the Bluebell, Ballyfermot and Dolphin House areas of Dublin. Willis said: 'Criminality that impacts communities is a concern and there are crime groups engaged in violence at various levels. While we have seen a significant reduction over recent years in gangland murders, mid-level groups are causing fear in some communities. Advertisement 'This is an area of focus primarily for the Gardai's Dublin Metropolitan Region and all of the divisions, supported by the 'A LOT OF CHAOS' 'Some prominent offenders who were causing a lot of chaos - people who were at the mid-level and not on a national level - are now imprisoned. 'We continue to support our colleagues on investigations and it's a collective effort across the Garda organisation. We have a capacity to target the top level, which we do, and also the mid-level to prevent those groups from increasing their criminal networks.' The Gardai also work closely with Revenue, Customs, the Irish Navy, the Air Corps and the Irish Defence Forces with Willis adding: 'such cooperation and collaboration is key to achieving success.' And across Advertisement The bureaus working under the Gardai's Organised and Serious Crime include The Garda National Cyber Crime Bureau (GNCCB), the Garda National Drugs and Organised Crime Bureau (GNDOCB) and the Garda National Protective Services Bureau (GNPSB). 5 Weapons seized by cops
