How does Ireland's prison overcrowding crisis compare to other European countries?
EUROPE'S PRISON POPULATION is increasing, with many countries around the continent, including Ireland, experience dangerous levels of overcrowding.
According to analysis of the latest data from Eurostat, Europe's central statistics database, there was a 3.2% increase in the continent's prison population in 2023.
That year, 13 countries in Europe were experiencing overcrowding. Very high levels of incarcerations were also recorded between 1993 and 2023.
In Ireland, where prison capacity
on Friday was recorded at a level of 117%
, the issue with overcrowding has been deemed a crisis by legal experts, staff unions and senior sources within the Irish penal system.
An
increase in the number of judges
, changes to legislation and sentencing guidelines, as well as
underinvestment into the prison estate
in the country have been contributing factors to the crisis.
The Eurostat data shows, however, that this trend has been occurring across EU member states over a 30-year period. At its peak in 2012, prisons in Europe were accommodating 533,000 people.
Government has initiated an expansion plan for the construction of 1,500 new places – but industry associations like the Irish Prison Officers Association believe that 'building out' of the problem is not the solution.
Speaking at an event in May, President of the association Tony Power said that investments must be made into the existing system to provide more spaces.
Staff should not be 'expected' to work in overcrowded conditions, he added.
Mattresses on the floor in Europe
Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan has
pledged to find ways to accelerate the delivery of more prison spaces
.
Advertisement
A senior source at the service
previously told
The Journal
that building more spaces, given the timescale involved in capital projects, is not seen as an option.
This has led to
an increase in the number of people sleeping on the floor in Irish facilities
, something the Irish Penal Reform Trust deeply condemns.
These figures are so high that the service started recording them in official daily statistics this year. On Friday, 404 people were sleeping on mattresses the ground in Irish prisons.
French prison population levels reached record highs in March as a total of 82,152 people – roughly the same size of a full house at Croke Park – were in custody in French prisons that month. The official capacity is 62,539.
More than 4,500 people were sleeping on the floor at French facilities – 15 of which are at 200% capacity.
Deportations and releases
France's Justice Minister Gérald Darmanin has called for the deportation of foreign prisoners so that they can serve their sentences in their home nations.
In Ireland, however, the Irish Penal Reform Trust has
called for imprisonment to be regarded as a 'last resort' and for alternative measures
, such as community service or supervised temporary release, to be encouraged.
The Irish Prison Service has
increased the population of prisoners on temporary release
, which sees the supervised release of low-level, non-violent offenders serving sentences outside of prison under strict conditions.
The State has been criticised for allowing the temporary release scheme as a pressure valve to overcrowding, but sources in the prison management say the programme is the only way it can maintain safe population levels at facilities in the country.
In Austria, experts say prison sentences are still too common and, often, people are committed for minor offences. Facilities in the country are at 108% capacity, as of May.
Access to rehabilitative care
In Spain, the country has adopted a more rehabilitative approach. It allows prisoners a gradual transition to more open regimes, based on their behaviour and risk of re-offending.
Similar programmes are available in Ireland
. Data from Spain shows that 80% of people released from prison do not return to crime.
Related Reads
Court escorts for prisoners at risk due to overcrowding, Irish prisons boss warns
Fears within prison service that prison overcrowding increasing risk of violence and rioting
New ankle monitors could be an alternative to being held on remand, Irish prisons boss says
Overcrowding is
reducing the population's access to services in Ireland
. Sources have said that offenders placed on supervised release or short sentences are, sometimes, not provided with any rehabilitative care.
The head of the
Irish Prison Service told reporters last month
that up to 2,000 prisoners are currently on waiting lists to access psychology support services.
Director General Caron McCaffrey said there are also smaller waiting lists for other services, such as addiction therapy, education and training programmes.
She said a 'whole of government approach' is needed to boost services such as education, training and therapy in prisons.
Responding to questions by
The Journal
in May, she admitted that people are sometimes released before receiving care.
High levels of overcrowding at prisons in Austria is leading to similar issues to what is seen in Ireland, where prisoners outnumber support staff. The European Court of Auditors recently criticised Vienna's lack of investment.
Changes are being led from prison management, however, to boost rehabilitation resources in Irish prisons. Existing staff are being upskilled and trained on methods to provide and assist in the care of prisoners with mental health issues.
Additionally, a peer-led, pilot programme has been launched in Dublin's Mountjoy Prison which trains and educates prisoners on providing addiction care to others.
—
This article is part of PULSE, a European collaborative journalism project.
With reporting by
Maria Delaney
(The Journal Investigates, Ireland),
Davide Madeddu
(Il Sole 24 Ore, Italy),
Kim Son Hoang
(Der Standard, Austria) and
Ana Somavilla
(El Confidencial, Spain) as well as translation services by
Ciarán Lawless
(Voxeurop).
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
30 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Irish language signs ‘must be a part of our future' in Northern Ireland, says Michelle O'Neill
The First Minister was speaking at Sinn Fein's annual Wolfe Tone Commemoration at Bodenstown, Co Kildare, on Sunday. Sinn Fein's Stormont leader also said work on Casement Park in west Belfast must begin 'now', despite a funding shortfall in the tens of millions remaining. There has also been much recent controversy over plans to install signage in Irish in Belfast's new transport hub, with unionists heavily opposed to the idea. Ms O'Neill told republicans gathered at the final resting place of Tone, 'the father of Irish republicanism', that she was 'honoured to serve as First Minister for all, committed to power-sharing and to progress, and committed to representing all equally'. 'Acht na Gaeilge is now a reality and in the coming months the Irish Language Commissioner will be appointed,' she said. 'And in a fair and balanced way Irish language signs such as those in Grand Central Station must be part of our future. 'Additional funding was secured for Casement Park which creates renewed momentum. The work must now begin. This is a vital project not just for west Belfast, not just for the GAA, but for sports more widely in the north and across the island. 'A top class sporting stadium is a win for all. Sinn Féin is committed to investing in all sporting codes. Casement Park will be built.' Ms O'Neill also said it was time to extend voting rights in Irish presidential elections to Irish citizens in Northern Ireland. The Assembly recently passed a Sinn Féin non-binding motion to do so, although the Aontú party in the Republic had already submitted a private member's bill on the same matter in Dublin. Ms O'Neill said the vote in Stormont to extend the vote north of the border was 'something unthinkable only a short number of years ago'. 'But it is a sign of confidence in our future. A sign of things changing for the better,' she said. 'A similar motion will be debated in the Dáil this coming week. 'It is a decade since a bill was first passed in the Dáil, but it has been blocked by successive governments. 'Now is the time to act. Now is the time to extend voting rights to Irish citizens in the north.' Ms O'Neill also condemned recent racially-motivated rioting in Ballymena, Portadown and elsewhere as 'raw, unadulterated racism, fuelled by sectarian, supremacist loyalism, involving, in many cases, paramilitary elements, much of which was mirroring ultra-right English nationalism'. She also described the Northern Ireland government's Legacy Act as 'fundamentally flawed and it is a cynical piece of legislation' and called for an immediate public inquiry into the murder of GAA official Sean Brown, who was murdered by loyalists in 1997.
RTÉ News
44 minutes ago
- RTÉ News
EU foreign ministers to meet over Middle East, Ukraine
EU foreign ministers are meeting in Brussels at the start of a week of high-level diplomacy on the Middle East and Ukraine, with the NATO summit in The Hague tomorrow and a summit of EU leaders on Thursday. Foreign ministers will give their initial response to an EU report which holds that Israel is in breach of its obligations under its trade arrangements with Europe due the conduct of its war in Gaza and its activities in the occupied West Bank. Ministers are also expected to reiterate calls for a de-escalation of the Israel-Iran crisis following the US bombing of key Iranian nuclear sites. Foreign ministers will begin with a briefing from the EU intelligence and situation centre on the unfolding crisis over Israel's attack on Iran, which has now been joined by the United States. In a statement, Tánaiste Simon Harris said he was deeply concerned by the very real risk of an extremely dangerous spiral of escalation in the Middle East following the US military action. He said the EU had a role in spearheading a diplomatic solution to the crisis. However, US President Donald Trump has made it clear he does not see any role for the European Union. Separately, foreign ministers will give their first assessment of a searing indictment of Israel's policy on Gaza and the West Bank in a report produced by the EU's Special Representative for Human Rights. The review, circulated to member states on Friday, held that Israel is in violation of Article 2 of the EU Israel Association Agreement, which binds both sides to human rights and international humanitarian law obligations. Last night, Israel dismissed the report as a "moral and methodological failure," saying it should be dismissed entirely. EU chief diplomat Kaja Kallas will take stock of how foreign ministers view the findings before briefing EU leaders later in the week. It seems likely that a menu of options to hold Israel to account - possibly including trade sanctions - will not be presented to foreign ministers until their next meeting in July.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Developers are bluffing when they say lower prices would undermine viability of house building
With full employment and buoyant public finances, Ireland has never been wealthier. Affluence, rather than insufficient home building, is the true source of our housing challenges . Recognising this, and adopting more appropriate policies, is crucial to avoiding a deeper housing crisis. In the popular debate, housing demand simply equals population growth. However, the economic definition of demand is the quantity of housing that society is willing and able to consume at each price. Population growth is relevant to this. It creates competition that influences consumers' willingness to pay. But willingness does not translate into demand unless there is also an ability to pay. This explains why the world's most densely populated cities , which are in countries such as Bangladesh and Somalia, do not have the highest house prices. READ MORE Further emphasising the imperfect relationship between demography and housing demand, Bulgaria and Poland had the EU's hottest housing markets last year, despite contracting headcounts. [ Residential construction fell 10% in first quarter of 2025 compared with last year, says CSO Opens in new window ] In Ireland, rising prices and rents signify that housing demand currently exceeds supply. Contrary to the mainstream view, this does not stem from demographic growth outstripping housing supply. Between 2011 and 2022 the number of households in Ireland rose by 187,000. The housing stock only rose by 117,000, but the perception that this left a backlog of unmet housing need is mistaken, because 67,000 vacant homes were also reoccupied over the same period. Together, these sources provided 184,000 units of accommodation – closely matching the growth in household numbers. Our economic definition helps explain how demand can exceed supply even when we are building enough homes for everyone. This is possible because multiple factors, besides the number of bodies seeking beds, influence a society's willingness and ability to pay for housing. These include consumer preferences and wealth, with rich societies typically preferring, and having the resources, to live in smaller households. All of this suggests that excess capital, rather than insufficient building, is the source of Ireland's housing challenges. This raises fundamental questions about the Government's fixation with increasing housing output. Rather than striving to boost supply, Government should desist from fanning the flames of demand with subsidies such as Help to Buy and the First Home Scheme. The unspoken purpose of these is to incentivise building by driving up property values. This is unnecessary and self-defeating. The State should subtract capital from the market by tightening credit conditions. The Local Authority Home Loan is a flawed concept, while the Central Bank of Ireland 's 2023 decision to relax mortgage rules unnecessarily fuelled demand. As a dominant buyer and renter of property, the State should also exercise its market power to pay less. Government is frightened of flexing this muscle by the tacit threat of a developers' strike. Industry's trump card - which it recently played to have rent controls relaxed – is to scare up a panic that suppressing property values would undermine construction viability, causing the Government to miss its housing targets. This is bluff. Developers only earn when they build, and development costs would adjust to reduced sales price expectations if the Government called it out. Moreover, as outlined above, we are already constructing enough homes – regardless of what the industry-led targets say. Six months ago, nobody was contemplating a global recession or plunging corporation tax receipts. But both are now clearly possible Unfortunately, given the powerful interests that profit from housing development, none of this is likely. For now, the subsidies will remain and the State will continue competing against private households in the property market. Consequently, house prices and rents will rise further. This is clearly negative for consumers. But higher rents and prices will draw out more supply and, somehow, this has become a greater political priority than providing affordable homes. With population growth now slowing, increased housing output will unfold in one of two ways. If the economy remains strong, the additional homes will be occupied. By making sacrifices and taking on bigger mortgages, wealthier tenants and buyers will manage to fund themselves. For the growing remainder, the State will simply increase the subsidies. The cost of this, and the environmental costs associated with excessive building, mean everyone will face higher taxes. In this best-case scenario, the average household size will fall. Ireland currently has the EU's third-biggest households, and some consider this incongruous with our prosperity. [ Median value of homes bought by first-time buyers has risen to nearly €372,000 Opens in new window ] However, while Ireland's citizens aspire to small households like those in other wealthy countries, we also have the EU's highest proportion of children and teens. This makes larger households natural for us. A salutary lesson can be learned from the last time affluence and ambition seduced us into overruling this reality. Between 1996 and 2011, the average household size plunged from 3.14 to 2.73 persons. This was funded by prolific mortgage lending that facilitated a sharply reduced proportion of 18- to 34-year-olds living with their parents. However, the debt proved unsustainable when the economy turned, the banks failed, vacancy surged, the housing market crashed, the boomerang kids returned home and the average household size abruptly stopped falling. We are in danger of repeating this mistake. This time, however, the State, rather than the commercial banks, is bankrolling the appetite for smaller households with its subsidies and schemes. Six months ago, nobody was contemplating a global recession or plunging corporation tax receipts. But both are now clearly possible. In this scenario, the State would be unable to underwrite the occupancy of homes produced by excessive building targets – and we should know what follows. Dr John McCartney is a lecturer in property economics at TU Dublin and adjunct associate professor at UCD
