Tories allowed almost £50billion of tax to go unpaid in their final year

Figures from HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) revealed the colossal amount of tax it is estimated was due, but missed
Labour has slammed the Tory government for allowing almost £50billion of tax to go unpaid in its final year in charge.
Figures from HM Revenue & Customs revealed the colossal amount of tax it is estimated was due, but missed. The biggest chunk relates to small firms and a widespread cash-in-hand economy.
‌
The data shows the 'tax gap' stood at 5.3% in the year to March 2024 - meaning around £1 in every £20 was lost. The total stood at £46.8billion. Campaigners warn the true scale of the lost tax bill could be considerably higher.
‌
The vast sum comes as the government makes tough decisions on higher taxes and spending cuts. Sources say the tax gap fell less than had been anticipated last year.
Labour has vowed to finally get a grip of the issue by ploughing more resources into tackling tax evaders, with the money used to boost public services.
Treasury Minister James Murray said the scale of lost tax was 'not good enough'. He said: ' Mirror readers will know that every pound of tax that some people do not pay puts a financial burden on everyone else who plays by the rules.
'The higher this 'tax gap', the less money the government has to invest in rebuilding the public services we all rely on. That is why this government is laser-focused on closing that tax gap, to fund our public services, invest in our infrastructure and grow the economy to put more money in people's pockets.'
The data showed corporation tax accounts for nearly half of the £46.8billion total, The corporation tax gap jumped to 15.8% - its highest for more than a decade.
‌
Rachael Griffin, tax and financial planning expert at Quilter, said the rise in the corporation tax gap is the 'standout concern' in the data. 'That's a red flag for policymakers, especially as economic uncertainty and global tax competition continue to put pressure on business revenues,' she said.
She added the rise is 'likely driven by a mix of economic strain, increased complexity in the global tax system, and perhaps a lag in HMRC enforcement capacity'.
The figures show progress in personal tax collection, with the VAT gap falling to 5% from 13.8% in 2005/06, and the income tax, national insurance and capital gains tax gap dropping to 3% from a high of 5.3% in 2013/14. HMRC said the combined share of the tax gap attributed to individuals and the wealthiest now accounts for just 10% of the overall.
‌
Mike Lewis, executive director at investigative think tank TaxWatch, said: 'It's also important to know what's not in those figures. Recent reporting by the National Audit Office suggests that there may be serious under-estimation of tax going unpaid by wealthy individuals, through offshore tax evasion, and in areas like online retail.'
Caitlin Boswell, head of advocacy and policy at Tax Justice UK, said: 'The real story here is that the UK's tax authority doesn't have the resources or backing it needs to tackle the tax gap which is likely far larger than what is published.
‌
'Evidence suggests that the level of tax non-compliance among the super-rich is far higher than estimated, with eye-watering sums of hoarded wealth being held offshore and out of sight of HMRC.
'Collecting the right tax, to invest in better healthcare, education and social security requires reliable investment and political backing in HMRC. Instead, the department has to battle fluctuations in staffing resources, has disbanded its unit dedicated to collecting tax from ultra wealthy individuals and is expected to weather real-terms cuts to budgets in the coming years.'
‌
James Murray, Exchequer Secretary to the Treasury
Labour was elected to fix the Tories' mess and to change our country for the better. When we came into office last summer, our public services – our schools, NHS, police force – were crumbling around us.
We promised to change that, and at the Spending Review last week we set out how we're investing in the things British people care about: our security, our health, and our economy.
We're seeing the progress of the choices we've made. More investment in defence and energy security. NHS waiting lists down. Wages up more in the first 10 months of this Labour government than in the first 10 years of Tory rule. But we know there's more to do.
‌
New statistics show that, in the last year of the Conservatives' time in office, £46.8billion of tax in Britain went unpaid. This is not good enough. Mirror readers will know that every pound of tax that some people do not pay puts a financial burden on everyone else who plays by the rules.
The higher this 'tax gap', the less money the government has to invest in rebuilding the public services we all rely on. That is why this government is laser-focused on closing that tax gap, to fund our public services, invest in our infrastructure and grow the economy to put more money in people's pockets.
In my role as the Minister for HMRC, I have made it this government's priority to make sure everyone pays what they owe. In our first year in office, we have set out the most ambitious package ever to close the tax gap. This will bring in an extra £7.5billion of uncollected tax – money that goes straight back into our essential public services.
‌
Let me be clear, this isn't about raising taxes. It's about making sure everyone plays by the rules and pays what they owe. HMRC are recruiting new compliance and debt officers, including those focusing on some of the wealthiest individuals who do not pay what they owe, and this new will generate far more than they cost.
We are also taking on those people who promote dodgy tax avoidance schemes, making sure ordinary people don't get sucked into them where they could risk thousands in penalties and fines. And we're making it easier to prosecute the fraudsters who want to cheat the system, whilst offering rewards to 'whistleblowers' for major tax fraud.
At the same time as going after those who don't pay what they owe, we are making it easier and less stressful for everyone else to interact with HMRC.
We are investing to improve HMRC's digital operations, including using the latest AI. New tech tools will cut down the time you need to spend on the phone, and cut the number of letters HMRC sends by three-quarters, saving £50million a year. That's how we make the tax system fairer and deliver our Plan for Change: cutting out waste, making sure everyone plays by the same rules, and putting more money in working people's pockets.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Glasgow Times

an hour ago

• Glasgow Times

'Russian roulette': Councillor speaks on Glasgow road crossings

Councillor Robert Mooney, Labour representative, said disabled Glaswegians are treated as an 'afterthought' as many crossings don't have working rotating cones — a tactile device which lets visually impaired people know when it is safe to cross — or audible signals. He has warned that someone will be killed if action isn't taken to address the problem. The council's transport convener, Angus Millar, SNP, said the council is 'committed' to replacing or installing the cones across the city. 'That will be done on an ongoing basis as the funding is available,' he added. In late 2021, it was revealed that 403 of 890 signal-controlled junctions across the city did not have a tactile cone. By July 2022, the council said 150 did not have features like rotating cones. Councillor Mooney said crossing roads in the city is 'like playing Russian roulette' for visually impaired people. 'Russian roulette': Councillor speaks on Glasgow road crossings (Image: Newsquest) READ NEXT: I tried Glasgow's newest food and drink tour - my verdict He explained: 'I was up at Cathedral Street a few months ago, I couldn't see whether the green man was on. 'The tactile cone wasn't working. I'd waited for some amount of time, there was a bus stopped at the traffic lights. "I said to myself, 'the green man must be on', I walked out and a bus came in the next lane, stopped about an inch from me. 'If I'd walked out a bit later, I wouldn't be here today. Somebody is going to get killed if this isn't addressed.' He also said the council's accessible design forum has not met since October, but the redevelopment of the city's public realm is 'moving on at a massive pace'. Millar said the forum holds talks about 'general principles around design' and lessons are fed into the design of different projects, which are then subject to consultation. He added: 'Disabled people and others are engaged with on active travel projects. "We have, on active travel projects, a really robust process of engagement with the local community and all stakeholders, including disabled people and their representative groups.'

Wales Online

an hour ago

• Wales Online

He left the country after a £50m money-laundering case. Now he has new life in sun

He left the country after a £50m money-laundering case. Now he has new life in sun The money laundering sparked a stranger-than-fiction chain of events involving a lottery winner, student houses and a bomb plot Half Moon Bay, an Auckland suburb where businessman Gregory Candy-Wallace appears to be based A man who ran companies that a court found laundered vast sums of money in Wales and England appears to have started a new life thousands of miles away. New Zealand authorities are "assessing" whether Gregory Candy-Wallace should be disqualified from managing businesses in the country after we informed them he had been operating there. It comes after the 64-year-old Brit settled a legal claim in the UK last year over his having controlled a network of firms that defrauded the taxman, HMRC, of tens of millions of pounds. There was due to be a civil trial at the High Court in London but the National Crime Agency (NCA) reached a settlement with Candy-Wallace and his companies last June, recovering assets worth £5.8m — a fraction of the more than £50m diverted from the taxman. A judge later said the money recovered was "the proceeds of crime". Now WalesOnline can reveal Candy-Wallace — a water polo enthusiast from Sussex whose companies used addresses in Cardiff for the money-laundering scheme — has more recent ventures in Auckland, where he is a majority shareholder in two companies and owns 49% of a third. We obtained court documents from the UK court case listing Candy-Wallace's address as a detached five-bedroom house in a wealthy coastal suburb of Auckland, with an outdoor pool and picturesque views onto the yacht-dotted Half Moon Bay. The home is valued at around £900,000. The Auckland-based firms are FM Group Ltd, which bills itself as a chemical wholesaler; ACM Environmental Services Ltd, an "environmental consultancy service"; and the curiously named 846361 Ltd, which says it is in the business of waterproofing buildings. Article continues below Candy-Wallace was previously a director of another Auckland company, Amoeba Investments Ltd, which classed itself as being in the "rental of residential property" industry. The firm owned a four-bedroom semi-detached house in Yorkshire, England, which the NCA applied for permission to seize before reaching a settlement. Who is Gregory Candy-Wallace? Candy-Wallace does not appear to be active on social media and — barring coverage of his court case — there is little trace of him on the internet. What can be found is mostly tied to his fondness for water polo, from refereeing in the Sussex league in 2013 to winning a tournament in Guam the same year and playing for a club in Dubai in 2022. Members of Sussex's water polo community told us they were puzzled when Candy-Wallace suddenly "disappeared" from the local scene a few years ago without explanation. Records show Candy-Wallace has been linked to civil tax fraud cases in the UK for two decades. One of his companies, described as a former "CD pressing business", was found to be "connected with fraud" as far back as 2006 in the form of invalid invoices. Another civil case dated back to 2005 when firms owned by Candy-Wallace were found to be linked to the "fraudulent evasion" of VAT by what the judge referred to as "the Malaga cell" of an illicit contra-trading network. WalesOnline's interest in his activities was first sparked last year when we investigated a network of "dormant companies" in Wales and England. There was little online to indicate what these firms actually did, beyond brief descriptions on Companies House such as "combined office administrative service activities" and "payroll services". One director, Damien Paton, was said to be a French national born in 1994. But elsewhere on Companies House his year of birth was given as 1960. In both records he was registered to a French address that was not a real place. Another of the directors was Candy-Wallace. One of the addresses used by the network was in Cranbrook Street, in Cardiff's student heartland of Cathays (Image: Conor Gogarty ) When we scanned through the many companies, a cluster of 12 stuck out. All were based at the same terraced house in Cranbrook Street in Cathays, the student heartland of Cardiff. It turned out the home was being used as a fake address for money-laundering. Landlord Nasser Nazemi told us the home started to be bombarded with letters from Companies House in 2017 after businesses had been registered there despite having no connection to the property. "The cheek of it," said Mr Nazemi. "We had to involve a solicitor to protect ourselves and it ended up costing us about £600 in legal fees." The firms in the money-laundering network were controlled by Candy-Wallace, according to the NCA, which said the "organised crime group" diverted away more than £50m of 'pay as you earn' and national insurance payments by "offering outsourcing services to third-party companies but then failing to pay the appropriate sums to HMRC". The funds were initially moved through a complex network of UK bank accounts before mostly ending up in Hong Kong and Taiwan accounts. Why wasn't he prosecuted? After last year's money-laundering settlement, we raised questions over the NCA's decision not to bring a criminal case against Candy-Wallace, particularly given that only a small portion of the £50m was recovered — on top of his decades-long links to tax fraud. As the NCA's own barrister James Laddie KC put it, the money-laundering ring was a 'deliberate and organised' fraud that featured 'inducements to secure clients'. Mr Laddie also said the settlement was a 'formal acknowledgement' that the funds were the proceeds of crime. Mr Justice Julian Knowles also described the funds in this way and said the network was part of "unlawful" payroll and money-laundering schemes. People are regularly imprisoned for fraud involving comparatively tiny sums of money. When we asked the NCA why it would not be bringing criminal proceedings, its spokeswoman said: "Civil recovery investigations are an efficient way to reclaim funds that have been acquired through unlawful conduct, and are not dependent on a criminal conviction." ‌ Jonathan Nuttall (Image: Press Association ) There was a criminal prosecution of one person involved in the network, but not for money-laundering. In 2023 one of Candy-Wallace's associates, Jonathan Nuttall, was jailed for eight years and two months after being found guilty of orchestrating a bomb plot against NCA lawyers. Nuttall had conspired to plant two explosives in London's legal district after becoming upset at the prospect of losing his stately home in Hampshire as assets were being seized in the civil case. The 51-year-old's wife, Amanda Nuttall — who once won £2.4m from her first lottery ticket — agreed to pay £1.4m and give up the stately home as part of the recent settlement. ‌ New Zealand Companies Office is now "assessing" Candy-Wallace's involvement in the Auckland firms. Its investigations team manager Vanessa Cook told us it is looking into whether his past conduct should disqualify him from directing or managing companies in New Zealand. Candy-Wallace and the Auckland companies were approached for comment. The only response we received was from a construction business whose email address was listed as a point of contact for one of Candy-Wallace's companies. The building firm said: "I don't know Mr Candy-Wallace, haven't had any dealings with him, and haven't seen him before." In the UK, registering sham addresses on Companies House has been a longstanding avenue for fraud. There is no requirement for those setting up a company to prove its legitimacy — and for those who actually live at the address, the fraud can ruin their credit rating due to the activity linked to their home. Article continues below The mass-registering of "burner companies" allows gangs to open UK bank accounts for money-laundering. However, later this year ID verification is finally due to become a requirement to start a company — after more than a decade of the system being abused — though experts have warned the scale of change needed will take time. If you know of a story we should be investigating, email us at

The Guardian

2 hours ago

• The Guardian

Ancient trees are shipped to the UK, then burned – using billions in ‘green' subsidies. Stop this madness now

How green is this? We pay billions of pounds to cut down ancient forests in the US and Canada, ship the wood across the Atlantic in diesel tankers, then burn it in a Yorkshire-based power station. Welcome to the scandal of Drax, where Britain's biggest polluter gets to play climate hero. The reality is that billions in public subsidies has enabled Drax to generate electricity by burning 300m trees. Now the government is trying to force through an extension that would grant Drax an estimated £1.8bn in public subsidies on top of the £11bn it has already pocketed, keeping this circus going until at least 2031. This isn't green energy. The mathematics alone should horrify anyone who cares about value for money or the environment. Burning wood creates 18% more CO2 emissions than coal. Even if you replant every tree Drax destroys, it takes up to a century for new growth to reabsorb the carbon released. We're supposed to reach net zero by 2050, not 2125. Yet through circus-trick accounting, all of Drax's massive emissions magically disappear from Britain's climate ledger. They've simply been wished away – counted as 'zero', while the company becomes our largest single contributor to climate breakdown. Extraordinarily, this scandal unites opposition across the political spectrum. From the Greens to Reform, from the Morning Star to the Daily Telegraph, there's rare consensus that Drax represents everything wrong with our approach to climate policy. The Labour-dominated public accounts committee condemned Drax as a 'white elephant' that's been allowed to 'mark its own homework' while claiming 'billions upon billions' in subsidies. A Lords committee agreed, saying parliament needs to see key documents before approving any more funding. I don't agree with Ed Miliband on everything – we clearly have different views on nuclear power. I respect the energy secretary's commitment to tackling climate crisis, and it is worth noting that the further subsidies are half of what was previously on offer for Drax. But that's exactly why continuing to subsidise Drax at all is so disappointing. When Miliband announced his plans to 'ramp up' biomass burning back in 2009, he was genuinely trying to find alternatives to fossil fuels. But 16 years on, this policy has gone badly astray. What was meant to be a bridge to renewable energy is actually making emissions worse. If, on Monday, the House of Lords votes to extend this unabated wood burning for another four years, what is to stop these subsidies being extended again and again? And why should the government deal with a firm as untrustworthy as Drax? Perhaps most damning is what Drax refuses to reveal. After the BBC's devastating Panorama investigation into the company's destruction of Canadian primary forests, Drax asked auditor KPMG to investigate, hoping for a clean bill of health. However, the evidence was so damning that the reports are still being hidden from the public. If Drax has nothing to hide, why not publish these reports? A former top Treasury official turned whistleblower accused it of deliberately concealing unsustainable practices to secure subsidies. The case, now settled, raises questions of dishonesty that should disqualify any company from public funding. The extra billions Drax is seeking could help build enough wind and solar capacity to power millions of homes. It could create permanent jobs in genuine renewable industries, not temporary employment destroying irreplaceable ecosystems. Every pound spent subsidising tree burning is a pound not invested in technologies that could actually deliver net zero. While other countries race ahead with wind, solar and battery storage, we're burning money on the most primitive fuel known to humanity. There's a huge loophole in the government's pledge to stop Drax burning trees from primary forest. Their restrictions on Drax only apply to subsidised electricity supplied to the grid. Drax wants to power private data centres but there is no plan that prevents it from destroying ancient forests to power 21st-century AI searches. That means Drax could be cutting down even more primary forests than it does today. MPs have lost trust in the government's ability to hold Drax to account – the criticism from parliamentary committees has been brutal. The environmental movement didn't fight to establish renewable energy so politicians could facilitate the burning of ancient forests that took millennia to grow. Real climate action means making hard choices, not hiding behind accounting tricks that make our emissions disappear on paper while making them worse in reality. It is time for Labour MPs to speak up; the fight for net zero is hard enough. More subsidies for Drax's wood burning in the name of sustainability is just more fuel on that fire. Dale Vince is a green energy industrialist and campaigner