Nuvama downgrades Coal India stock to ‘Reduce'; cuts target price to Rs 367 on weak volumes, rising costs
Nuvama Institutional Equities has downgraded Coal India Ltd (CIL) to 'Reduce' from 'Hold', citing continued earnings pressure due to weak power demand, lower e-auction prices, and rising competition from captive coal miners. By Markets Desk Published on June 12, 2025, 07:55 IST
Nuvama Institutional Equities has downgraded Coal India Ltd (CIL) to 'Reduce' from 'Hold' , citing continued earnings pressure due to weak power demand, lower e-auction prices, and rising competition from captive coal miners. The brokerage has revised its target price to ₹367 from ₹405 earlier, valuing the stock at 5x FY27E EV/EBITDA.
Coal India has started FY26 on a soft note, with sales volume declining ~4.7% year-on-year during April–May 2025. Nuvama expects this trend to continue through June, as overall power demand fell 1.6% YoY during the pre-monsoon period, and captive coal players continue to gain share.
Data from the Ministry of Coal shows that volume from captive and commercial mines rose 14.5% YoY to ~35 million tonnes in April–May 2025, capturing ~20% of demand, up from 17.5% in the same period last year. During FY25, captive players consumed 197 million tonnes, growing 31% YoY. With captive mine capacity peaking at 575 mtpa, Nuvama sees even Coal India's 2–3% volume CAGR target at risk.
Nuvama has trimmed its volume estimates by 2% for both FY26 and FY27 to 770 mt and 793 mt, respectively — implying just 2% CAGR over FY25–27. High inventory, rising costs to impact margins
Coal India's coal inventory at end-May 2025 stood at ~112 million tonnes, significantly above the five-year average of 83 million tonnes, restricting any meaningful production increase. Management has guided for a rise in the stripping ratio to 2.67x in FY26 (vs 2.58x in FY25), which will push cost of production (CoP) higher due to increased overburden removal without corresponding volume growth.
Nuvama expects CoP to grow at 4% CAGR to ₹1,422 per tonne by FY27, factoring in wage revision-related cost increases in FY27. Limited operating leverage from stagnant production will further weigh on earnings. Lower e-auction realisations add to pressure
Adding to the challenges is the continued decline in e-auction realisations. Benchmark Indonesia thermal coal (6323 kcal) prices have dropped to USD 115/t, down from earlier highs, and Nuvama believes further downside is possible.
Coal India's e-auction prices have dropped from ₹2,615/t in Q4FY25 to ₹2,200–2,300/t currently. The brokerage now factors in an average realisation of ₹2,200/t in FY26 and ₹2,100/t in FY27.
Despite these headwinds, Coal India's high dividend yield (~6%) remains its only bright spot. However, Nuvama noted that it prefers growth-focused opportunities, which are currently lacking for Coal India. The brokerage expects EBITDA to fall at a 2% CAGR over FY25–27, reinforcing its cautious stance.
Disclaimer: The views and target prices mentioned are as stated by Nuvama and do not represent the opinions or recommendations of this publication. Investors are advised to consult their financial advisors before making any investment decisions.
Markets Desk at BusinessUpturn.com
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Wire
an hour ago
- Business Wire
Monumental Energy Announces Completion of Workover and Resumption of Commercial Production at the Copper Moki-2 Oil and Gas Well in New Zealand
VANCOUVER, British Columbia--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Monumental Energy Corp. (' Monumental ' or the ' Company ') (TSX-V: MNRG; FSE: ZA6; OTCQB: MNMRF) is pleased to announce the successful workover and resumption of commercial production at the Copper Moki-2 (CM-2) well, located in the Taranaki Basin, New Zealand. The primary objective of the CM-2 workover was to restore oil and associated gas production from the Mt. Messenger sands and to address flow restrictions identified during prior operations. Additionally, the program included perforating and testing previously untapped hydrocarbon zones. At CM-2, three new intervals have been perforated, which are expected to contribute to significant flush production rates and increase overall output. Early indications confirm the new pump is functioning as expected, with approximately 300 barrels of brine—previously used to maintain pressure—successfully pumped out of the well. The Copper Moki-1 (CM-1) workover is expected to take approximately 10 days. If successful, the well will be placed on continuous production alongside CM-2. Monumental Energy and NZEC anticipate significant flush production rates from both wells. At the time of the original drill program at Copper Moki, New Zealand faced a gas surplus, and the field remained isolated from the gas network. Today, the field has been fully integrated into the gas infrastructure, presenting a meaningful revenue opportunity that was previously unavailable. CM-1 and CM-2 were originally shut-in due to mechanical issues over time, rather than any reservoir-related concerns. The wells required only standard maintenance, and equipment upgrades to resume production. In late 2024, Monumental Energy entered into an agreement with NZEC to bring the wells back online, as NZEC shifted its focus to a gas storage business model. Under the terms of the agreement, Monumental Energy will receive a 25% royalty on all oil and gas production from the Copper Moki site, following full recovery of its 75% initial capital contribution. Oil produced in the Taranaki Basin typically receives a modest discount to Brent Crude (USD $77.39 as of June 20), while natural gas sells at a premium, with current prices ranging between USD $11.00 and $15.00 per MCF—significantly higher than North American market levels. Cumulative production data, measured in barrels of oil equivalent (BOE), will be released in the coming weeks. Max Sali, Vice President of Corporate Development and Director, commented: 'The Copper Moki wells have demonstrated exceptional reservoir performance, with cumulative production approaching one million barrels of oil to date. The successful recompletion of CM-2—including the perforation of three new intervals—is expected to significantly enhance output. We anticipate strong flush volumes and reservoir recharge, further validating the productivity of the Mt. Messenger formation. This positions us for meaningful near-term cash flow while supporting the long-term value proposition for our shareholders.' About Monumental Energy Corp. Monumental Energy Corp. is an exploration company focused on the acquisition, exploration, and development of properties in the critical and clean energy sector, as well as investing in oil and gas projects. The Company owns securities of New Zealand Energy Corp. and entered into a call option and royalty agreement on the Copper Moki wells with New Zealand Energy Corp. The Company also has an option to acquire a 75% interest and title to the Laguna cesium-lithium brine project located in Chile. The Company holds a 2% net smelter return royalty on Summit Nanotech's share of any future lithium production from the Salar de Turi Project. On behalf of the Board of Directors, /s/ 'Michelle DeCecco' Michelle DeCecco, CEO Neither the TSX Venture Exchange nor its Regulation Services Provider (as that term is defined in the policies of the TSX Venture Exchange) accepts responsibility for the adequacy or accuracy of this news release. Forward Looking Information This news release contains 'forward‐looking information or statements' within the meaning of applicable securities laws, which may include, without limitation, completing the Copper Moki 1 & 2 workovers and the expected results, the expected timeline to complete the workovers of Copper Moki 1 & 2 wells, and commencement of production of CM 1 & 2, potential oil and gas transactions, other statements relating to the technical, financial and business prospects of the Company, its projects, its goals and other matters. All statements in this news release, other than statements of historical facts, that address events or developments that the Company expects to occur, are forward-looking statements. Although the Company believes the expectations expressed in such forward-looking statements are based on reasonable assumptions, such statements are not guarantees of future performance and actual results may differ materially from those in the forward-looking statements. Such statements are based on numerous assumptions regarding present and future business strategies and the environment in which the Company will operate in the future, including the price of metals and the price of oil and gas, the ability to achieve its goals, that general business and economic conditions will not change in a material adverse manner and that financing will be available if and when needed and on reasonable terms. Such forward-looking information reflects the Company's views with respect to future events and is subject to risks, uncertainties and assumptions, including the risks and uncertainties relating to the interpretation of exploration results, risks related to the inherent uncertainty of exploration and cost estimates and the potential for unexpected costs and expenses and those other risks filed under the Company's profile on SEDAR+ at While such estimates and assumptions are considered reasonable by the management of the Company, they are inherently subject to significant business, economic, competitive and regulatory uncertainties and risks. Factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from those in forward looking statements include, but are not limited to, continued availability of capital and financing and general economic, market or business conditions, failure to secure personnel and equipment for work programs, adverse weather and climate conditions, risks relating to unanticipated operational difficulties (including failure of equipment or processes to operate in accordance with specifications or expectations, cost escalation, unavailability of materials and equipment, government action or delays in the receipt of government approvals, industrial disturbances or other job action, and unanticipated events related to health, safety and environmental matters), risks relating to inaccurate geological assumptions, failure to maintain or obtain all necessary government permits, approvals and authorizations, failure to obtain or maintain surface access agreements or understandings from local communities, land owners or Indigenous groups, fluctuation in exchange rates, the impact of viruses and diseases on the Company's ability to operate, capital market conditions, restriction on labour and international travel and supply chains, decrease in the price of lithium, cesium and other metals, decrease in the price of oil and gas, loss of key employees, consultants, or directors, failure to maintain or obtain community acceptance (including from the Indigenous communities), increase in costs, litigation, and failure of counterparties to perform their contractual obligations. The Company does not undertake to update forward‐looking statements or forward‐looking information, except as required by law.
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Sterling set for weekly loss as Middle East conflict overshadows domestic data
By Linda Pasquini (Reuters) -Sterling gained slightly against the dollar on Friday but was set for a loss on the week as uncertainty over the Israel-Iran conflict fuelled demand for traditional safe havens such as the greenback. Weak UK retail data earlier in the session and the Bank of England's decision on Thursday to keep rates unchanged had little effect on the pound. Sterling was 0.2% higher at $1.3495 but eased 0.6% against the dollar on the week, after two consecutive weeks of gains. The dollar was set for its biggest weekly rise in more than a month on Friday. The BoE said it was monitoring risks from a weaker labour market and higher energy prices on the back of the conflict as it held interest rates at 4.25% as expected on Thursday, sending the pound down briefly against the U.S. dollar. "The pound was only lightly touched by a consensus Bank of England hold yesterday," ING FX Strategist Francesco Pesole wrote in a note to clients. "Yesterday's 6-3 vote split for a cut can be interpreted marginally on the dovish side and is allowing markets to reinforce their conviction call on an August cut." Markets now priced in a near-60% chance for a quarter-point cut at the BoE's next policy meeting. The euro was marginally up to 85.43 pence on Friday, set for its second week of gains in a row. Sterling briefly pared some earlier gains against the U.S. dollar after weak British retail sales data, which saw volumes recording their sharpest drop since December 2023 last month, as demand fell after shoppers splurged on food, summer clothes and home improvements the month before. "Retail sales in May brought significant payback" after a "hard to explain" strength in the previous four months, Allan Monks, chief U.K. economist at J.P. Morgan, said. The figures came alongside government borrowing figures which showed a slightly larger than expected budget deficit of 17.7 billion pounds ($23.88 billion) for May. Britain's economy grew at a faster-than-expected pace in the first quarter of 2025 but shrank in April, as a property tax break ended and U.S. tariffs started to sting. The BoE forecasts overall growth of 1% for 2025. ($1 = 0.7413 pounds) Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Wall Street Journal
5 hours ago
- Wall Street Journal
Philippine Peso, Korean Won, Thai Baht More Vulnerable to Further Oil-Price Spikes
0217 GMT — The Philippine peso, Korean won and Thai baht are more vulnerable in Asia to further oil-price spikes, four members of MUFG Bank's Global Markets Research say in a note. They cite the bank's analysis of how oil-price increases could affect Asia's foreign-exchange markets. MUFG Bank's scenario analysis shows an oil-price increase of $10/bbl would reduce Asia's current account positions by 0.2% to 0.9% of GDP. The scenario analysis also shows that Asia's CPI will likely rise by 0.1 to 0.8 percentage point for every $10/bbl increase in oil prices. USD/PHP rises 0.8% to 57.56, USD/KRW adds 0.6% to 1,380.73 and USD/THB is 0.5% higher at 32.95, LSEG data show. ( 0125 GMT — The dollar strengthens against most other G-10 and Asian currencies in the morning session after the U.S. strikes on Iran's nuclear sites over the weekend. 'The USD lifts because the USD is a safe haven and the U.S. is a net energy exporter,' CBA's Global Economic & Markets Research team says in a note. 'How high the USD lifts is now in the hands of political and military leaders in the U.S., Israel and Iran,' the team adds. The ICE USD Index is up 0.4% to 99.06, USD/KRW adds 0.7% to 1,383.73, and AUD/USD falls 0.4% to 0.6427, according to FactSet data. (
